That's a personal decision each person makes. No one is morally or legally obligated to save this person from herself, especially if she repeats this behaviour.
That simply isn't true. You are 100% incorrect about this.
We as taxpayers fund police and other law enforcement officials to make sure someone is taking care of such victims. As a society we have agreed to devote ourselves to a system of laws that mandate protecting that woman no matter how many times she puts herself in bad situations.
You neither understand the concept of making an argument nor the doctrine of contributory negligence. It isn't simply a colloquial phrase, it has specific rules and criteria.
If you want to make the argument you have to consciously explain how the doctrine applies. You have done nothing of the sort. You have simply made barely intelligle single sentence utterances that never have any argumentative support.
That's not what the agreement is. The agreement is that the police officer is agreeing to respond to criminal activity and we compensate them for this beahvior.
You consented to this agreement by not leaving the jurisdiction of the police officer when you reached the age of personal responsibility.
You have said that we shouldn't help people who don't try to help themselves. If my car is stolen I expect the police to look for it, even if I do not. Why does your criteria not apply to me?
And why is geography relevant? If I am wronged in another country our foreign embassy will take up my cause. The rights and privelages of my citizenship follow me even if I do leave the jurisdiction.
We elect senators to sign treaties. The treaties they've signed obligate us to international action. We pay troops to execute those duties. How is that different?
Exactly the point, and why the police officer analogy you offered does not apply. There are no humanitarian missions which are compulsory. A police officer that does not perform his duty can be fired or jailed. A humanitarian that does not complete his mission answers to no one but his own conscience.
This is manifestly false. It betrays an ignorance of our international treaty obligations that is frankly frightening.
Never said there was. The police office does have a contractual obligation, however, thet the humanitarian does not.
So contracts are more binding that international treaties? Please cite either the legal or constitutional source that supports this claim.
International agreements, UN resolutions, and good intentions are not laws.
This is a terrible misunderstanding of how treaties operate. Please read the Constitution before you spew more of this tripe.
Article 6:
"This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof;
and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land."
If those created actual obligations (as opposed to meaningless paper declarations of good intentions) why are we not interfering in Africa?
We do a great deal in Africa. You are making the wholly unwarranted assumption that our obligation to intervene in humanitarian crisis can only be satisfied by sending troops.
"The G-8 agreed to double foreign aid to Africa, from $25 billion a year to $50 billion..."
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02/12/AR2006021201150.html
Only there is nothing enforcing our "international obligations". If there are, what punishment can we expect for not interfering in Africa?
We do "interfere" in Africa, so this point is moot.
As for the enforcement mechanisms of international law, this is a complicated subject. If you want to start a new thread I would gladly write about it, but these posts are becoming long enough as is.
And by the way, you are now contradicting yourself:
And what happens when the abused spouse doesn't want "intervention"?
You're childish little single line responses are doing nothing for you. Where is the contradiction? We didn't have to send troops to Rwanda. None of the treaty obligations we held required that of us. At the same time, a small military force
could have helped a great deal.
There is nothing remotely contradictory there, and whatever you think BWS has to do with needs a great deal more explanation than your typical empty line.
Legally, when a woman is abused the husband is arrested regardless of what the woman wants. The crime of beating a woman stands alone, it doesn't need a cooperative victim.
Good thing I did not assert that. I said (and showed) it can happen, as counter to your fallacious assertion that abused or oppressed people are "helpless".
Jews in concentration camps were helpless. The 800,000 Kosovar refugees were helpless against the Serbian army. Slaves in the South were helpless.
My claim is that there exist groups of people who we should help because they can't help themselves.
You have time and time again said that
all people can revolt, and because of that we have no obligation to them if they don't want to help themselves.
Not only is this primitive and barbaric, it's fallacious. I am not making a universal claim, you are, so counterexamples don't bother my position, but they destroy yours.
Which is it? If we are "bound to act" why are we not doing so in Africa?
For the millionth time, bound to act does not mean military intervention.
So some people cannot rebel, and some can? Is that what you are saying now?
Uh, yeah, have I ever said otherwise?
Show me where I said that. Or how on earth it is "self-serving".
I went over your posts looking for quotes and was once again startled by their absolute emptiness and lack of thought. Here are a few that are on point.
"One is only terrorised by one's own consent. A warlord only has the power that those around him grant him."
When asked about people's options: "Stand up for themselves. Or leave."
I gathered from your writing that you think people always have the option of revolt. This is why you say that it is their duty to "stand up for themselves." If there are people who cannot muster the necessary resistence, who are they? You tell me?
And it's self-serving because it allows you to pretend like victims are to blame for their state. You said it yourself, "one is only terrorised by one's own consent." Why help people who are responsible for their abuse?
And by the way, this is just a disgusting world view, and one, incidently, that is obviously false. Are children "responsible" for their molestation? Are women in the Middle East responsible for the acid thrown in their faces? Were Jews in Poland responsible for being shoved into ovens?
And your mealy-mouthed retreat from this absurd position, holding that they are in part, not completely responsible, is baldly contradicted by that quote: "one is only terrorised by one's own consent." This is much stronger than a contibutory negligence position.
But you just said that these psychological conditions do not necessarily apply to all people. Which is it?
In any case, unless these syndroms apply to everyone in a subjucated population, they are irrelevant. They may explain why a particular individual chooses not to revolt, but not why everyone in the population doesn't- as you try to claim.
I'm not the one making universal claims. YOu said
all people could revolt, all people are responsible for being terrorized, if they didn't like it, they should leave. BWS syndrome contradicts this claim.
Your inability to follow the simplest aspects of this discussion is continually astonishing.
So then a "pacifist" may be a humanitarian and yet NOT intervene when people are being slaughtered, yes?
Sure, in fact, that's the only way any of you have come up with a pacifistic solution to Kosovo. If, however, the doctrine of pacifism is completely inable to deal with the most difficult issues (my assertion), then it fails as a reasonable approach to humanitarianism.
Read the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Pacifists were and are thrilled by the ideas contained in that document. If pacifism cannot deliver the goals advanced by that convention, then other means of humanitarianism have to be found.
You are not a humanitarian, so this bit of argument isn't aimed at you. You have to first accept the idea that we should do what we can to aid struggling people before you can discuss the best means of doing so.
You are just a weak nihilist, solving all your problems by running away.
Haha, oh man, awesome. You make this claim, "Let me offer you the only definition of “humanitarianism” that matters, when applied to states, organizations, or groups- the one that is actually practiced, by all of them:"
Then use a quote you made up. Those are some balls you've got there, speaking in the name of
all humjanitarian organizations without bothering to look at the specific founding documents of a single one.
That bit of wholesale incompetence alone suffices to dismiss you a serious thinker.
No organisation has ever acted, to my knowledge, contrary to that definition.
Show me I'm wrong.
Here's your definition: "Do what you can afford to do for other people, when it is expedient to do so, unless compelled."
Before I can move forward you have to explain who the expediency requirement applies to. Do you mean, do what you can when it's expedient (beneficial or advantageous) for the humanitarians? Or do you mean, do what you can when your operations will be advantageous to the people receiving aid?
Your definition is vague and toothless. If you actually took time to reason through your stance, instead of posting goofy quips, you might be able to develop some type of actual position.
Indeed not. However, their failure to act in Africa shows that definition to be at best merely a statement of hollow ideology and useless good intentions.
Haha, so very, very pathetic.
"There are ongoing humanitarian operations in approximately 58 countries, 40 of which are in Africa. (Statistics derived from ReliefWeb list of countries and emergencies.) One study estimated that there were a total of 214,654 aid workers as of 2005."
http://humanitarianrelief.change.org/blog/view/statistics_on_humanitarian_relief
You just have no idea what you're talking about.
I don't see anything in any of those links that contradicts anything I've said, including letting a people suffer the consequences of their own actions (or inaction). Humanitarians are not superheroes.
Either you didn't read the links, or you don't understand them:
First link, Humanitarianism: "the philosophical doctrine holding that
it is a human being's duty to improve the lives of other people."
Yes, you are obliged to help others.
Keep looking, I can't help you. I haven't made that assertion. I just disputed your assertion that because they are oppressed "modern psychology" says they can't.
What is your assertion as it applies to people's ability to revolt? Do you think all people can revolt, and if so, why?
But NOT with their actual actions. "Charters" and "voluntary agreements" aren't worth steaming gos se.
Except for the uncomfortable fact that Constitution has made those treaties the law of the land.
Well, the sanctions against Iraq in the 90's were enforced by UN forces. The treaty ending the wars in the Balkans was enforced by NATO.
There are literally hundreds of international organizations and NGOs operating throughout the world. There are a number of enforcement regimes including the World Bank and local groups of countries acting in concert.
Quote me where I said this.
I didn't answer the general question, as I am not a pacifist. And when you asked me I asked a clarifying question you declined to answer. As I have given no answer to the question "how a pacifist would have saved the kosovars and Muslims in the Balkans" claiming "you say they should have tried to save themselves" is an outright fabrication.
What was your clarifying question? I missed it.
You have said that people are responsible for whatever oppression is brought down on their heads. I quoted you saying that above.
In addition, When I pointed out that people may often make a decision that as bad as things are, revolt would make them worse, you replied, "Exactly. The Somalis have yet to do so (revolt, rise up), so why is it our right or responsibility to make that decision for them?"
I read that as saying that no obligation to help a group exists if they do not attempt to save themselves.
Again, if you have a different stance on Kosovo, please share it. So far all you've said is we have no obligation to help. Death and genocide are meaningless to you unless people try to revolt on their own.
Quote me where I said this. Your lack of intellectual integrity is not becoming.
Haha, are you serious? You want me to quote you not saying something? You've offered no solution to the problem save to let them die. This is inferred from you claim that we have no obligation to them. Thus, when I repeatedly ask you what you would do, and all you do is argue that we don't have to do anything, my conclusion is that you're perfectly happy to let them die.
Again, offer something else, I'm waiting.
This is why I suggest your reading comprehension leaves a lot to be desired. You apparently cannot comprehend ideas that do not conform to your precancieved notions. I'm not the only one in this thread to notice this.
Then what is your plan? Please share it. If you've said it before, just copy and paste.
And looking to the ropes for a tag-team partner won't save you from the beating you're taking here.
I'm not aware there was
any ongoing violence when we "intervened". The
gassing of the Kurds to which you previously referred occured
two decades prior to our "intervention".
I'm talking about right now. Iraq right now. There are millions of people that want the violence to end. That violence is the direct result of our intervention.
Once again, I'm not arguing in favor of military intervention in all cases.
Right. And neither does Somalia. That's the point.
Haha, no it isn't. The problem in Iraq is that there isn't a humanitarian intervention, there is a destabilizing military occupation. The problem in Somalia is that they have no government, no law enforcemnt, and it's utter chaos makes intervention likely to cause more problems that it saves.
The intervention in Somali has to occur on the periphery, using military force to protect ships from pirates, not from occupying the nation.
Sometimes it's better not to intervene. Once more, I'm not the one making universal claims.
Sound like a pretty toothless "obligation", don't it?
That war was started by a group of people that expressly denied any sort of humanitarian obligations. The behavior of Bush and Cheaney are not relevant to the discussion, save to point out the danger posed by a powerful country that goes rogue.
And that often times, "intervention" is not wanted, no matter what one's good intentions might be.
Yes, that has to be a calculation. For the 2087th time, I am not advocating military intevention in all circumstances. I pointed to one that stopped a massacre and asked what pacifists would do.
I don't disagree with that. I just disagree with your apparent insistance that that force must come from an external source.
Again,
sometimes allowing a nation to solve their problems is the best course of action. Iran is a good example of this. The more we intervene, the more problems we're likely to cause.
Sometimes that force has to come from external parties because the internal groups are insufficient. The Jews in concentration camps in WWII serve as the most famous such case. Kosov, Appartheid, and slavery are others.
I don't think so. I'm not the one contradicting myself and making demonstrably false statments.
Demonstrably means able to demonstrate. I can't think of a more inappropriate word for you to attempt to employ. You've only demonstrated your inability to grasp basic concepts.
beliefs and intentions are irrelevant. No organisation consistently acts on this alleged "obligation", and precious few individuals.
If that's what "humanitarianism" is to you, it is meaningless, useless idealism.
Right, all of those treaties, charters, organizations, and conventions are meaningless and useless. The thousands of workers in over 50 countries around the world are the ones that are meaningless.
I support humanitarianism in action. You want to claim the title and hide from the job.
Please offer an argument that says humanitarian acts can't make a profit. Micro loans have been one of the most successful humanitarian projects in the history of the world. They include a small amount of interest to cover the costs of the program. If they modified the interest a percentage of a point higher, they would make a profit. Explain to me how that fraction of a percent contradicts the basic tenents of humanitarianism.
Belief is irrelevant. Mission statements are irrelevant. What they do is relevant, and what humanitarian organisations do is sometimes they let people suffer and die that they could help, despite their "obligations".
Belief is all that matters. You're saying humanitarianism does not contain a duty or obligation to others. Whether or not the concept has its own ontology, all humanitarian organizations believe in that duty.
You have created a version of humanitarianism that contradicts all humanitarian organizations. It's really amusing, I do hope you continue.
Give me an example of a humanitarian organization letting "people suffer and die that they could help." Support your claim. Remember, you also have to prove that they could have helped.
What they
say is irrelevant.
Under what entity's enforcement?
Well, if you join the Peace Corps, the Peace Corps will insure that you act in accordance with their principles. If you do not, they will kick you out.
If you join any humanitarian organization and do not follow their goals, they will remove you and you will not be a humanitarian.
This is how all professions operate.
That's actually true. Buildings have burned while different departments argued over in whose jusrisdiction it was. It was common in the Nineteeth century, but happens even today, especialy between city FDs, Volunteer FDs and Rural Metro FDs. And if your house is not in an area with a tax subsidized FD and you don't pay your subscription fees, they may not put it out if it burns.
These are disputes about which department has the duty to put out the fire, not whether firefighters have a duty to put out fires.
And if they didn't put out the fire, you could sue that organization into oblivion. Weak effort.
Actually, I never claimed to be a humanitarian either. What I said was that being a humanitarian created no obligation. The way humanitarian organisations do things, this is evident, despite what they may claim.
But you're wrong. You have given no evidence to support this claim.
It is just like psychic powers. I can claim all day long I can read minds or talk to the dead, but unless I do it, I'm not a psychic.
Uh, ok.
Find me one that acts like they have an obligation to help others.
First of all, you could have actually read the Geneva Conventions that I linked. They go into great detail about signature nations and their obligations to others.
Second, international law bestows such obligations:
"States are the
duty-bearers under international human rights law and, together with other armed groups, are bound by the norms of international humanitarian law. Each State has primary responsibility to take care of the victims of natural or man-made emergencies occurring in its territory."
http://www.fao.org/DOCREP/005/Y4430E/y4430e05.htm
But finally, you wanted to know about human rights organizations, you may be interested to hear what 40 such organizations agreed to at the Global Humanitarian Platform:
"The GHP brings together NGOs Red Cross/Red Crescent
and UN agencies on an equal footing, recognising diversity as an asset,
interdependence among humanitarian organisations, and
acknowledging an ethical
obligation and accountability to the populations we work with."
Such as watching Africa destroy itself while drafting resolutions declaring good intentions, perhaps?
You really thought you found something good with that Africa example. At this point you've used it so many times that I'm starting to feel bad that you're so wrong. Here's some more information about the massive amount of humanitarian work going on in Africa:
http://doctorswithoutborders.org/news/country.cfm?id=2366
You're confusing me with the UN. And I have not insulted you.
Ok, I apologize and will try to refrain from insulting you. But where's the enforcement?