Pacifism. Needs some clarifying.

Well there are many variations of what people consider a "pacifist" to be (just like all such idealogical labels).

One form of pacifism is that you cannot be coerced by violence as much as it is about you not using violence yourself. When you run with that definition as a thought experiment it is quite interesting, for example a pacifist nation could never be militarily occupied using traditional methods since such an occupation relies on the threat of violence.

Or they could just be massacred...
 
Perhaps I'm jaded by my profession, but even as a young child I learned that the best way to avoid the typical schoolyard bullying was to fight back.
Interesting. I learned when I was young that the best way to avoid the typical schoolyard bully was to avoid putting mysef in a situation where I would be a target.

Basically, this meant making myself too easy. I was hassled and teased throughout high school, but I was never physically assaulted, and never had my lunch money stolen (ETA: except perhaps once, and that was by pickpocketing, not violence). I believe that this was because I was an obvious square (modern translation: nerd) and thus seen as a target for nothing more than plain ridicule. Sure - it wasn't pleasant being teased, but it was a heck of a lot better than being beaten up, which is what I saw happening to one or two people who tried to stand up to the bullies.
 
Last edited:
I feel that pacifists are ... cowards ...
Again, you use that word as though it were a bad thing.

I need to sleep sometimes, and work (it's almost 2m right now), so I'll probably be offline for about eleven or twelve hours. I promise that I will continue this discussion tomorrow. Goodnight everyone.
 
To me, I feel that pacifists are either being cowards or lazy because they are unwilling to defend themselves or others and rely on other people to do it for them. Did I get that right?

Please define "coward". Some people decide that the lesser of two evils is to comply rather than risk their lives or that of their loved ones or those of innocent people. You might not agree with it but some come to that conclusion.
 
Well, once again this is a totally unrealistic "what if" scenario. For a start, I don't have a daughter. Secondly, a situation like this is statistically very unlikely in my region.

Arth, you are aware of a little thing called "for the sake of argument" ?

Obviously, if we're discussing what can happen to you we'll always be discussing the past. But you getting a daughter in the future is not impossible, no ? If you feel like it, maybe swap the daughter for someone you really love.

I don't think there's a doubt that I would resolve to violence in Quad's scenario. Of course, in that case it's self-defense.
 
This strikes me as strange because the difference between garbage men and the military is glaringly obvious.
It isn't to me, can you explain it?

As I stated in the other thread, there will ALWAYS be people in this world willing to commit violence against others for evil purposes. The only way evil can prevail is if good men sit by and do nothing (pacifists).
What is this "evil" of which you speak?
 
twinstead said:
Your scenario is one where violence isn't necessary. If I were alone, getting the hell out of there is job 1. But, what if the person was firing at your family, and they couldn't run?

I find that subjects like this involve an awful lot of what if... scenarios. I generally don't find considerations of hypotheticals very productive, because they tend to address idealistic, fantasy worlds rather than the real world.

Are you saying the real world doesn't have violent people, who will only stop being violent upon being confronted with greater violence, or at least the threat thereof?
 
I think there's quite a bit of room for disagreement about when violence is "necessary."

For example, if someone pulls a handgun on you and starts firing, is violence "necessary"? Some would say yes. Others would say no -- what is "necessary" is to get the hell out of there. I must admit that I incline to the latter; police stats suggest that you're more likely to get hurt or killed in this situation if you return fire, and much more likely to get hurt/killed if you try to resist but don't have a firearm yourself. (Part of the reason for that is that most people are just lousy shots and if you can get more than about 20 feet away, their chance of hitting you is almost nil. If you're facing Wyatt Earp, your statistics may vary.)

Please provide a link to these "police stats" proving you are more likely to get hurt than defending yourself.
 
Are you saying the real world doesn't have violent people, who will only stop being violent upon being confronted with greater violence, or at least the threat thereof?

Are you assuming these people have infinite reach? Because I submit that they will also stop being violent when there is no one left in range to be violent to.
 
Let me say here that I have had some training and practice in various martial arts. I believe that if it came to a one on one violent confrontation I could probably hold my own. But I would be using nonlethal techniques (joint locks and holds), and more importantly I have never tested this belief. I just don't know. I'll probably never know. I would rather not find out.

If your martial arts training is geared to competition and if you come up against a seasoned street fighter intent on doing you harm you will likely find yourself with your guts stomped out.
 
Are you assuming these people have infinite reach? Because I submit that they will also stop being violent when there is no one left in range to be violent to.

How do you propose to isolate them?

Let's say we ignore Somali pirates and never send a ship near them, they will continue to prey on their own populace. Somalia is one of the most brutal, consistently violent places in the world.

So it's ok to let groups slaughter their own people? That may technically be pacifism, but it's a version of the ethos that completely ignores it's historical humanitarian roots.

If your answer is that we should ignore the pirates, isolate them, and then help the "nation" of Somalia so the violent people have no motivation to commit evil acts, I would love to see you draw up a plan to accomplish those aims that doesn't include some type of force.

Remember, we've been sending aid to Somalia for several decades. Warlords and Pirates simply steal that aid for themselves.
 
Please provide a link to these "police stats" proving you are more likely to get hurt than defending yourself.

Department of Justice, National Crime Victimization Survey.

Your likelihood of injury if you use a gun for self-protection in a robbery, for example, is about 7.7%. If you try to run away, your likelihood of injury is about 4.9%. If you try to threaten the perp while unarmed, the chance rises to about 16%. See also this paper, although it specifically discusses the elderly.

Previous studies have suggested that victims may incur more injuries if they attempt to defend themselves. Analysis of the NCS data showed that while victims of more serious crimes were likely to be hurt, screaming, running away, and reasoning with the offender were frequently successful in preventing injury to the elderly victim.
 
How do you propose to isolate them?

I don't. I propose to run the hell away. If you want to charge in guns-ablazing,.... well, you've never claimed to be a pacifist, have you?

But don't tell me that you are required to do that. I'm still waiting for an example where violence is actually "required."
 
So it's ok to let groups slaughter their own people? That may technically be pacifism, but it's a version of the ethos that completely ignores it's historical humanitarian roots.

Since when does "humanitarian" mean "sucker", "doormat", or "nanny"? People have to want solutions to their own problems before rendering aid becomes meaningful or helpful.

It does not matter how many interventions you have for someone who just doesn't want to give up drinking.
 
Department of Justice, National Crime Victimization Survey.

Your likelihood of injury if you use a gun for self-protection in a robbery, for example, is about 7.7%. If you try to run away, your likelihood of injury is about 4.9%. If you try to threaten the perp while unarmed, the chance rises to about 16%. See also this paper, although it specifically discusses the elderly.

There are two issues being conflated here:

First, is it wise to allow free access to guns, allow citizens to carry them in public, and promote confrontation?

I think the study you provided, along with many others, proves that such behavior in a society is unwise. It escalates voilence.

A second issue asks whether anyone in a society should carry a gun and violently confront violent offenders. In other words, should law enforcement groups be allowed to use deadly force when necessary?

As a "pure" pacifist, you would have to say no, but I think we can all imagine what would happen if we took guns out of the holsters of American police officers.

Someone has to confront violent offenders. Speaking as someone who defended a great many such individuals on the Southside of Chicago, I can promise you that disarming police would simply make them drool in anticipation. It's wise to arm a well-trained police force, unwise to allow vigilanties to run around popping off and making bad situations worse.
 
I don't. I propose to run the hell away. If you want to charge in guns-ablazing,.... well, you've never claimed to be a pacifist, have you?

But don't tell me that you are required to do that. I'm still waiting for an example where violence is actually "required."

So you personally run away from Somalia and let the warlords dominate and murder their own people? I have to admit that this sounds more like cowardice than pacifism.

I'll ask you the question I asked Howard Zinn, how would you have stopped the ethnic cleansing in Kosovo? If your answer is that we should just run away and let it happen, we have unreconcileably different world views.

Now, I will agree with you that certain interventions, like Iraq, caused far more death and violence than it prevented, but not every scenario will turn out that way. One of the great forgotten tragedies of the last 20 years was the lack of intervention to stop the slaughter in Rwanda. A well-equipped military force could have saved hundreds of thousands of lives.

Nothing is ever "required" so long as you're able to rationalize the consequences. I suppose we didn't have to stop Hitler, but if you think a peaceful solution could have been reached with Stalin and Hitler, I would love to hear it.
 
There are two issues being conflated here:

Not really, no.

I was asked for stats showing that violent resistance increased the chance of the victim being injured. I provided them. I should also point out that violent resistance tends to decrease the chance of the crime being successful (although so does running-the-hell-away). Most pacifists are happy to trade a loss of the money in their wallet against the decreased risk of being hurt; that's part of what makes them pacifists.

As a "pure" pacifist, you would have to say no, but I think we can all imagine what would happen if we took guns out of the holsters of American police officers.

Yeah. Among other things, we can look to Britain for an example.

Someone has to confront violent offenders.

Still waiting for justification on that one.

Speaking as someone who defended a great many such individuals on the Southside of Chicago, I can promise you that disarming police would simply make them drool in anticipation.

So might I suggest staying-the-hell-out-of-the-Southside-of-Chicago?
 
Last edited:
Since when does "humanitarian" mean "sucker", "doormat", or "nanny"? People have to want solutions to their own problems before rendering aid becomes meaningful or helpful.

It does not matter how many interventions you have for someone who just doesn't want to give up drinking.

This is such a bizarre view I don't know where to begin.

A nation is not an individual. They can't be "alcohalic" in the sense that the entire population will unanimously behave one way or the other.

In Somalia a small group of very violent warlords have been terrorizing the population. The people being murdered and having their aid shipments stolen would love to see an end to their assailants. They very much do not want to be beaten, raped, and murdered, but they are so poor and destitute that they can't really mount a rebellion.

So I don't know how your alcoholism analogy even applies. Yes, the warlords are gleefull drunks, but that says nothing about their victims.

Of course all situations are not the same, we have to seriously analyze the amount of good we can do vs. the cost of intervention. For example, I think that our little adventure in Iraq caused far more harm to the populace, even with a brutal dictor as the other option, than it saved. And yet the actions in Kosovo were necessary and successfull. A similar intervention could have done a great deal in Rwanda.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom