TraneWreck
Philosopher
- Joined
- Jun 9, 2008
- Messages
- 7,929
In part, yes. An abuser is unlikely to stop dominating on his own as he (and I'm using "he" generally, not as a gender-specific term, mind) reaps the benefits, and the victim wishing or praying for someone else to stop it is abdicating responsibility for one's own self determination.
This is quite honestly insane. Not only does it completely ignore modern understanding of psychology (battered wives' syndrome, for example), it is just historically naive.
How would you propose, for example, that slaves of African heritage end their bondage without military intervention from the North? They were split into small groups completed separated from each other completely restricting their ability to communicate. They were beaten constantly and repressed to the point that they were hopeless.
Yet your claim is that it was the slaves fault that they were slaves. This is horrific and false.
Slave owners were consciously aware of the threat of rebellion so they squashed the possibility long before it could grow into anything remotely serious.
This is just one of many historical examples.
yes it is. Doesn't make it any less true.
No, you're right, it isn't wrong because it's horrific, it's wrong because it isn't supported by reality.
Not entirely, no. Most of them were born into it and taught that lifestyle before they knew any better. But that does not absolve them from personal responsibility for what happens to them.
Again, this is historically and psychologically naive. We understand why people in abusive, dependent relationships do not and can not willfully separate themselves.
http://www.heart-2-heart.ca/women/page4.html
Not "simply", but they won't ever be free if they do not, will they?
No, they can be freed when nations and groups with sufficient strength intervene on their behalf. For example, South Africa. People rebelled against apartheid for years and were summarily beaten down. It was only the intervention of the world community that brought an end to the practice.
All of the captives held in concentration camps by the Nazis were freed by Allied forces. Kosovars were freed from their oppressors by NATO intervention. Slaves in the South were freed by the military intervention of forces from the North.
Do I need to go on?
Such is your assertion. Why can't the same be said for the American colonists? The French peasants of 1789? Hell, any of these?
Those comparisons are foolhardy, in the least. The American Revolution was led by a group of highly educated rich land owners and military professionals who masterminded a brilliant tactical uprising. They worked for years to generate support in the populace.
The French revolution, after its initial uprising, was organized and supported by a great many intellectuals.
No such organization exists in Somalia. Both American and French revolutionaries rose up in advanced cultures. Laws and structure were already in place. Somalia doesn't even have a government, there is controversy about whether it actually qualifies as a nation. There is nothing to revolt against because there is not structure. It's just various groups of warlords controlling little fifedoms.
You literally could not have picked more drastically different examples.
Stand up for themselves. Or leave.
Haha, you've said a great many silly things, this is the best. Where do you propose they go? To refuge camps in neighboring countries? Remember, these people are so poor that they need international aid to survive, and most of that is stolen from them. Where and how do you propose they leave?
So you claim. Funny thing about warlords, the more people they kill, the fewer people there are to rob and steal from. Killing one person to scare the others works great- when it works. Killing everybody bacause they aren't afraid anymore is self-destructive to the warlord.
Yes, that is why they've taken to the seas as pirates and steal aid shipments. They've beaten their populace into submission.
And, by the way, who said killing was necessary to subjugation. Slaves need to be alive to serve their purpose, that doesn't mean their abusers didn't beat them down.
There are worse things than death, and Somali warlords are well aware of them. They use people's children against them, rape and beat the women, and generally thrive on terrorising the populace.
Making such absurd claims about the simplicity of standing on your own can only come from someone who has never been asked to risk their life or the lives of loved ones. It's very easy to sit in front of a computer in a life of luxury and demand a struggling populace rise up.
How do you know? Worked for Ghandi.
Yes, Ghandi was rebelling against the British Empire. THe British beat and murdered until they realized it wasn't economically feasible to try and hold on to India. A structured government made that decision.
In the United States MLK's non-violence worked primarily because more than half the nation was horrified by the gross abuses in the South. He changed the minds of people in a democracy.
No one is in control in Somalia to make a similar decision. What do you expect to happen?
Being the target of a campaign of extermination is a different subject than willingly living under oppression.
That is such insulting nonsense. "Willingly." Please. At this point I can only conclude you're a troll trying to start a fight. This is pathetic.
And your point is...? Are you saying that they would have been better off living in misery and squalor until someone came to deliver them? Violence is only wisely used when one has a superior force?
Is it really that complicated?
You're asking people to revolt when times are bad. You ignore the fact that as bad as things are, they can always be worse. People make judgments based on practical matters, like the lives of their children. A group has to decide for themselves whether they're desperate enough to raise arms against an oppressor. Sometimes it's so hopeless that you cling to what little you have rather than throw your life away.
Each group has to make that estimation for themselves, but just because they haven't revolted, that doesn't mean we can't understand a need for intervention.
Again, slaves in the US never seriously revolted, but the North was correct in fighting a war to end the practice. It was a horrific blight upon civilization that needed to end whether slaves could mobilize or not.
There is no guarantee anywhere that standing up for one's self is going to be successful at gaining one's freedom- but it is guaranteed that not standing up for one's self will fail to bring freedom. Deliverance by a foreign hand is just changing masters.
********.
You sound like a person that has never risked anything in your life. Even destitute people have loved ones. When they make a calcuation, it's of the sort, "I hate my lot in life, but I love my children. If I keep my head low and try to get by, at least they will be with me. If I revolt, we will all be tortured and killed."
Claiming that a person in that situation (which is true of every repressed group in the history of human kind) choosing to hang tightly to what little they have has now justified the brutality agains them is absurd, false, and horrific.
We can see when others are suffering and intervene.
That's an assertion. Care to back that up? I just know that they aren't mustering, and if it is not their responsibility to do so, why is it ours to "save" them?
No one said it's our "responsibility," we could happily let them be, like we did with Rwanda.
In fact, Somalia has started to turn slightly in recent years, the current government, if you can call it such, is very slowly gaining legitimacy. For a number of reasons, intervention in Somalia now is probably not a good idea.
http://bloggingheads.tv/diavlogs/19425?in=00:23:52
The reason the Somali people can't revolt, is that there isn't anything to revolt against. Up until recently, it was wholesale chaos.
Honestly, you're one of the ones advocating violence as a political solution in this thread- or is that only an option for rich white folk?
Huh? That makes no sense. Your childish little attempt to smear me with an aimless hint of racism falls well in line with your consistently lame thoughts.
Rebellion was a good idea and worked very well for Ho Chi Minh and the Vietnamese until we stuck our noses in their business. Ghandi's rebellion was a good idea, and shows that non-violence is a powerful tool.
Where should the blame lie?
Uh, with the warlords and pirates.
So only those Jews that mounted a hopeless uprising deserved to be saved? All of the rest of them deserved to die in ovens because they didn't stand against the German military machine? And more absurdly, if they didn't rebell we can conclude that they were happy with the state of affairs?
I'm just trying to get a feel for what you're arguing here. It makes no sense on the face.
So you assert. Where in history has that been the case?
Slavery in the American South. The Russian population under Stalin (he killed everyone who he thought would potentially object to his rule). Abused women in the Middle East. Jews in WWII, notice that your example of the Warsaw uprising ended in total slaughter. People seeking civil liberties in comtemporary China. North Koreans.
I can go on.
It is the point. If violence is a valid political solution then it is a solution available to everyone, not just the people with the biggest guns.
This is a childish reading of the point at hand. Violence is not always a good idea, in fact, for the most part it's a terrible idea. Yet there are times and places where it is both necessary and effective.
It is always available as an option, very rarely is it a solution. The Kurds did have the option to revolt against Hussein, but because of the massive power disparity, they were destroyed, like the Jews in Warsaw.
Where in the world did I say that it was possible?
So with the Kosovars we have a group actively fighting their oppressors but are being ethnically cleansed despite their protest.
The United States and NATO have the ability to stop the ethnic cleansing in support of the clear self-determination of those people.
We can 1) use air raids to stop the genocide, or 2) let it happen.
Which is the appropriate action according to your view?