Is this a serious position? Abused people are abused because they consent to domination?
In part, yes. An abuser is unlikely to stop dominating on his own as he (and I'm using "he" generally, not as a gender-specific term, mind) reaps the benefits, and the victim wishing or praying for someone else to stop it is abdicating responsibility for one's own self determination.
My god, that's shocking and horrific.
yes it is. Doesn't make it any less true.
So women in the Middle East are subjugated and humiliated because they want to be.
Not entirely, no. Most of them were born into it and taught that lifestyle before they knew any better. But that does not absolve them from personal responsibility for what happens to them.
If they simply stood against their oppressors they would be free?
Not "simply", but they won't ever be free if they do not, will they?
There is such a massive disparity of power in Somalia that the subjugated groups cannot fight back.
Such is your assertion. Why can't the same be said for the American colonists? The French peasants of 1789? Hell, any of
these?
What would you suggest they do?
Stand up for themselves. Or leave.
The warlords will just slaughter them without conscious.
So you claim. Funny thing about warlords, the more people they kill, the fewer people there are to rob and steal from. Killing one person to scare the others works great- when it works. Killing everybody bacause they aren't afraid anymore is self-destructive to the warlord.
And notcie that the only way to "break their addiction" will be through violence. Sit-ins don't work against Somali warlords.
How do you know? Worked for Ghandi.
And how about the Kosovars? They were in the process of being exterminated. They fought back desperately, but their enemy was happy to wipe them from the face of the Earth. What were they supposed to do? I guess the genocide was their fault because they didn't want to live badly enough.
Being the target of a campaign of extermination is a different subject than willingly living under oppression.
That's true, and a great many rebeillions have failed miserably and their response led to complete devistation. In recent history the Kurds tried to rebell against Saddam Hussein and were nearly gassed into extinction. How many thousand of slave revolts in the history of the planet resulted in more death and destruction to the rebels?
And your point is...? Are you saying that they would have been better off living in misery and squalor until someone came to deliver them? Violence is only wisely used when one has a superior force?
There is no guarantee anywhere that standing up for one's self is going to be successful at gaining one's freedom- but it is guaranteed that
not standing up for one's self will fail to bring freedom. Deliverance by a foreign hand is just changing masters.
A rebellion, in the least, requires some organization. The Somalis are so devastated by the violence that they cannot muster the necessary groups.
That's an assertion. Care to back that up? I just know that they aren't mustering, and if it is not their responsibility to do so, why is it ours to "save" them?
Honestly, you're one of the ones advocating violence as a political solution in this thread- or is that only an option for rich white folk?
I find it unbelievable that you blame the Somalis for their suffering at the hand of warlords.
Where should the blame lie?
Yes, I'm sure Polish Jews were "content" to be rounded up and tossed into ovens.
Not all of them.
Sometimes, often, the power differential is so great that rebellion cannot occur.
So you assert. Where in history has that been the case?
This completely misses the point.
It is the point. If violence is a valid political solution then it is a solution available to everyone, not just the people with the biggest guns.
I would love for you to explain how you would have kept the Kosovars from extinction with Pacifism. Please, lay it out.
Where in the world did I say that it was possible?