More advice wanted

Hi again Ray,
I would like to ask you how has this unexplained experience of yours affected your life?
Do you spend many hours a day contemplating about it? Have you become active in many forums discussing this? etc.

Thank you,
Yair
 
Hi again Ray,
I would like to ask you how has this unexplained experience of yours affected your life?
Do you spend many hours a day contemplating about it? Have you become active in many forums discussing this? etc.

Thank you,
Yair

Actually, no. This is the first forum I've discussed it at any length. I mentioned it in passing on two other forums, in the course of debate, and several people asked me to read about what happened to me. This is, in fact, the first time it's gone on this long, and never has this much been told publicly. I always dropped the matter on other forums. Kind of ironic that this much would be discussed on a skeptics forum. But this is a good thing, because that way I will know how skeptics feel, and I can get more critical feedback.

How has this (experience) affected me? To this very day I go over the event in my mind, and I know that it was real, and not imagined, although I have to "prove" it to others. If I could find a rational explanation I would accept it, but so far I haven't. I do not like this thought at all - that something can just vanish out of sight. It's scary, and one would hope that it's a very infrequent event, because we would be paranoid at wondering what else in our lives could just vanish. Fortunately, this is a rare event. Or so it appears (no pun intended).

I don't dwell on it very often, thankfully, and, so far, my car has been there every morning I walked out to it (though immediately after this experience I wondered if it would be). "Reality" seems to prevail.

I still believe that eventually there will be an explanation for this, but I don't foresee it happening soon. I think we live in an incredibly interesting and unpredictable universe, and that's what makes life so interesting. There is supreme order in what at times seems like chaos. I am glad that what I experienced happens to so very few, and I am glad it has not happened to me since then. Since the event I've lived a normal life. People don't realise, though, how disconcerting this experience can be. You first wonder about your own sanity, and then you wonder how you can possibly tell this to others. I have, at the risk of looking like a moron. If I didn't have the concrete evidences, I would not have believed this myself. And I don't blame anyone for not believing me. Not one.
 
Hi Ray,

interesting thread. I completely agree with you on the way some self professed 'skeptics' can be dogmatic, closed-minded and unscientific in their approach. Like you, I've pointed this out, and the reaction has been almost unanimously negative. I wouldn't worry too much about such reactions - it's pretty much par for the course.
There are few people here questioning the general consensus, so I hope you stick around.

As to objects vanishing.
The current consensus (please anyone correct me if I'm wrong on it being the current consensus,..maybe I am)... among 'rational, scientific' people, including most 'skeptics', is that the whole of space and time appeared in an instant out of nothing.
If the theory is true then every object we experience ultimately just appeared out of nothing and nowhere.
In such a scenario I, personally, don't find it totally out of the question that it may be possible for objects to suddenly vanish.
In other words, if they can appear out of nothing, why should the reverse process - of them vanishing (returning to nothing) - be automatically dismissed as impossible?
 
Hi Ray,

As to objects vanishing.
The current consensus (please anyone correct me if I'm wrong on it being the current consensus,..maybe I am)... among 'rational, scientific' people, including most 'skeptics', is that the whole of space and time appeared in an instant out of nothing.
If the theory is true then every object we experience ultimately just appeared out of nothing and nowhere.
In such a scenario I, personally, don't find it totally out of the question that it may be possible for objects to suddenly vanish.
In other words, if they can appear out of nothing, why should the reverse process - of them vanishing (returning to nothing) - be automatically dismissed as impossible?


If you're referring to the Big Bang theory, it doesn't say the universe was created out of nothing. I.e., "The Big Bang is the cosmological model of the universe whose primary assertion is that the universe has expanded into its current state from a primordial condition of enormous density and temperature." (see wikipedia, for example).

So that doesn't parallel the idea of an object returning to nothing.
 
Hi Ray,

interesting thread. I completely agree with you on the way some self professed 'skeptics' can be dogmatic, closed-minded and unscientific in their approach. Like you, I've pointed this out, and the reaction has been almost unanimously negative.
Given your near constant demonstration of your own ignorance of scientific methodology it seems unlikely that you could point out its lack.

As to objects vanishing.
The current consensus (please anyone correct me if I'm wrong on it being the current consensus,..maybe I am)... among 'rational, scientific' people, including most 'skeptics', is that the whole of space and time appeared in an instant out of nothing.
You are wrong. This is not the consensus.
 
"The whole of space and time emerged in an instant out of nothing"? Statements like this - along with "quantum physics proves that weird stuff is real" and "we are made of energy" - make me despair of the educational system.
 
Hi Ray,

interesting thread. I completely agree with you on the way some self professed 'skeptics' can be dogmatic, closed-minded and unscientific in their approach. Like you, I've pointed this out, and the reaction has been almost unanimously negative. I wouldn't worry too much about such reactions - it's pretty much par for the course.
There are few people here questioning the general consensus, so I hope you stick around.

Perhaps I will stick around, but I might have to buy some expensive cat chow.

I posted on Mormon discussion forums (pro and anti) for seven years and I decided to stop posting on them. I'm sort of tired of long and detailed debates on Mormonism after seven years of that, but I'll check out the scenery here anyway.
 
If you're referring to the Big Bang theory, it doesn't say the universe was created out of nothing. I.e., "The Big Bang is the cosmological model of the universe whose primary assertion is that the universe has expanded into its current state from a primordial condition of enormous density and temperature." (see wikipedia, for example).

So that doesn't parallel the idea of an object returning to nothing.

Wikipedia:
"The term is also used in a narrower sense to describe the fundamental "fireball" that erupted at or close to an initial timepoint in the history of our observed spacetime."

So, if spacetime didn't appear out of nothing I guess the only alternative is that, running time backwards, the "primordial condition of enormous density and temperature" gets smaller and smaller for infinity.

This would mean that spacetime, and hence our universe, is infinitely old... in other words it had NO starting point.
Is this what you're arguing?

Or maybe the primordial condition stayed the same size ...kind of hanging around.. until it decided to start expanding.
Even with this scenario, unless it was created out of nothing, the universe must be infinitely old.
 
"The whole of space and time emerged in an instant out of nothing"? Statements like this - along with "quantum physics proves that weird stuff is real" and "we are made of energy" - make me despair of the educational system.

see my reply to Denver, and please correct if you can
 
Wikipedia:
"The term is also used in a narrower sense to describe the fundamental "fireball" that erupted at or close to an initial timepoint in the history of our observed spacetime."

So, if spacetime didn't appear out of nothing I guess the only alternative is that, running time backwards, the "primordial condition of enormous density and temperature" gets smaller and smaller for infinity.

This would mean that spacetime, and hence our universe, is infinitely old... in other words it had NO starting point.
Is this what you're arguing?

Or maybe the primordial condition stayed the same size ...kind of hanging around.. until it decided to start expanding.
Even with this scenario, unless it was created out of nothing, the universe must be infinitely old.

No, it doesn't follow that the universe must be infinitely old. The sum of an infinite series can be finite (1 + 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + 1/16 + 1/32 + 1/64 + .... and so on ad infinitum = 2). See also Xeno's paradoxes.

For some detailed information about the Big Bang see http://www.talkorigins.org/faqs/astronomy/bigbang.html
 
plumjam - The "big bang" theory postulates that our universe started as a hot, dense ball of gas. We don't really KNOW what was going on "before that" - where the gas came from, what caused it to start expanding, and so on - because our empirical laws start to break down when applied to such a really ridiculously pressurized system. In other words: scientists are working on it, but right now the answer to "what happened immediately before the big bang?" is "We don't really know".

That's about as open-minded as a person can be, eh?
 
Kind'a relevant to this thread, here in the UK this weeks New Scientist magazine has a good article on aspects of (mis)perception with some fun links.

Sadly the website's subscription: New Scientist
 
scientists are working on it, but right now the answer to "what happened immediately before the big bang?" is "We don't really know"
"and we don't really see the point in pursuing notions that its all down to magick. If anyone can illustrate demonstrate any errors in this logic, please do leave a concise message after the tone"
 
Ray, I'm starting to believe you on what you wrote in this thread.
I'm at work now and have had a piece of paper in which I kept track of my measurements. I am the only one with a key to the lab and this paper was on the desk for several days and I filled it up as I went along with the measurements. I leave the room (although unlocked) and then come back. I didn't notice the paper because there was a long measurement running. When it was finished I looked for the paper but it was gone. Just vanished. There is no reason for anyone to enter the lab and this paper has no meaning to someone else. I've looked everywhere for this paper but it's just gone. Damn it...I need it now.
 
Breaking news...nevermind, I found it. It fell somewhere really unpredictable. Under a desk behind the one I was using which has a flat 'floating' leg. The paper was hiding underneath it. Strange place to be hiding.
 
I have considered other explanations, but none have been satisfactory, so far. Furthermore, I have allowed others the opportunity to offer possible explanations. The parallel universe theory, which was offered to me by one correspondent, I find "interesting", but do I believe it. I really can't say so. How could I even prove this? This is something you cannot know, but only speculate on. I am in fact looking for concrete, down to earth explanations by people who can scrutinise the evidence and show me an explanation, not theories from metaphysics. Interesting as they are, they do not explain.

What makes the "parallel universe" theory more satisfying than the "invisible unicorns stole it" theory? I'm not trying to be smug. It's an honest question, looking for an honest answer.




Two things you show by this post. Having not read the report you're willing to speculate wildly with parallels which have no comparison to a report you have not read. Not very objective. Your "conclusion" is therefore based on a false premise, about an event you know nothing about, but factor in your conclusion because of your assumptions about the nature of the universe. "If it 'can't happen', according my understanding, then it must be 'faulty memory'". "There is no other explanation." Or, perhaps, you believe scientists know everything about the universe, and how it works. There is nothing left to understand.

Actually, I'm being as scientifically objective as I can. I'm working with what (very little) information I have to develop a theory that explains what was observed while also being in tune with everything we already know about the world around us. Should there be more information available, I'd be happy to revise my theory. However, considering the definitive lack of information you're willing to divulge, I thought I was doing pretty well.

Besides, it wasn't supposed to be a direct comparison. I wasn't suggesting you mixed up the days. I was pointing out that a very, very strange occurance can result from a very, very simple explanation.
 
Besides, it wasn't supposed to be a direct comparison. I wasn't suggesting you mixed up the days. I was pointing out that a very, very strange occurance can result from a very, very simple explanation.

So far none of the correspondents has provided a "very, very simple" explanation. Some have not even attempted to. If there is a "simple explanation" it would be able to be explained quite easily. That has not been the case. If people want to believe the world "works in a certain way", and no other way, that's their choice. I am not so certain that I know everything about "how the world works".
 
But Ray, it is not up to us to prove it did not happen. You have to prove it did and you cannot do that.

No, I couldn't prove it in a court now. I couldn't make a report for the reasons outlined in the account I sent you. I have been having quite detailed email discussions with another correspondent, which I'm finding interesting. I accept there cannot be proof at this late stage, but so far I'm not satisfied with the explanations given, and neither what I saw, nor the physical evidences accompanying, have been sufficiently explained. This has all been outlined in detail.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom