More advice wanted

Think? No... nothing lead me to think anything significant would transpire

Although that doesn't preclude that faint glimmer of naive hope that one day, someone will find something...

Dreams are free
 
So... what happens next?

Are there other options for testing the claim?

Lick finger = place to wind. Determine where blowing crap. Avoid it.

:jaw-dropp Like the plague.

But the question is: Why do you want to "test" the claim? If from predetermined dogmatic conclusions, forget it.

We are all in this "sea of complexity" together. What we don't understand now may be considered "paranormal". In the future it may be nothing but child's play.

We criticise, and reject, what we don't understand, and only because we don't understand it. In the future we will only have to think of which TV channel we want to watch, and it will appear. No? There may, in fact, be no "paranormal" - only what we don't yet understand.
 
But the question is: Why do you want to "test" the claim? If from predetermined dogmatic conclusions, forget it.

Whether a claim is true or not should not be affected by the beliefs of the person testing it though. If you're claim were testable, which anyone who knows the details would say it is not, then it shouldn't matter whether the person testing it believes it to be false. The evidence should speak for itself.

The point of science is to try as hard as you can to prove a theory is false before accepting its true. If you find that you cannot prove it false then its probably true. That's why a sceptic will always start from the position of not believing something without evidence.
 
This is not a claim we can test. It was a story of a memory of something Ray cannot explain. I can see little point in this now.
 
I will let Richard judge that. If he has an explanation I can believe, I will accept it. So far, I have had none. The problem, too, is that what we think is paranormal today, may actually have a "natural" explanation in the future. What would a cave man think of modern computers? They would have to be paranormal, as far as he's concerned. Remember that film about the Kalahari?

Something we do not understand today may indeed be explained by the science of tomorrow. It does not follow that this will be the case for all "paranormal" experiences. Indeed, we can already explain the majority of so-called paranormal experiences with the science of today - the only problem is that some people don't want to accept these explanations. They prefer imagining that there are mysterious, unearthly or magical reasons.

Certainly a cave man would be likely to consider a computer to be paranormal (assuming he was sufficiently advanced to have concepts of "normal" versus "paranormal"). If we could show David Copperfield's flying act to the cave man, he'd probably think that David is some sort of god, or at least that he possesses magical powers. If, however, you were to assert that you could read his destiny in the stars, it probably wouldn't surprise him, and if you said to the cave man "I can talk with dead people", he might well reply "So can I".

Today we know that computers aren't driven by magic, we know that David Copperfield is supported by solid technology when he's apparently flying, but we consider astrology or talking with dead people to be in the realms of the paranormal. The continuing lack of hard evidence, coupled with advances in scientific knowledge, makes these things seem less likely to be true than they might have seemed a few thousand years ago. Our knowledge of science not only makes us doubt that these phenomena exist, it also helps us to understand why astrology may seem to work, or why people may be convinced that they have been in contact with a dead relative even though there is no evidence that this has really happened.

Through advances in science we create technology that previous generations could not have imagined and and we come to understand more and more of the mysteries of our universe. These same advances also permit us to become better and better at detecting superstition, hallucination or simple fraud. When we hit on something we don't understand, the way forward is not to say "wow, that must be paranormal!". The way forward is to look for a scientific explanation.
 
In the 1970s Wollongong University (in Australia) was known as "Teacher's College", and it later became the University of Wollongong. So if someone graduated from "Teacher's College" in the 1970s, would they be lying to say to a contemporary audience that they attended the University of Wollongong?
Everyone who graduated from Teacher's College says that they graduated from the University of Wollongong, because that's how you speak to a contemporary audience, in terms they understand.

Really? My mother graduated from the Teacher's College.

If asksed, she says that she attended the Teacher's College which later became the University of Woollongong.

It is simple and no one can accuse her of having graduated from a University a decade before it existed.
 
This is going to drive me nuts - Ray/Richard is it possible to formulate the account in an abstract fashion such that we at least know what the claimed paranormal phenomenon actually is?
 
This is going to drive me nuts - Ray/Richard is it possible to formulate the account in an abstract fashion such that we at least know what the claimed paranormal phenomenon actually is?

That is up to Ray. I will not give the details but it was along the lines of something seeming to vanish.
 
This is going to drive me nuts - Ray/Richard is it possible to formulate the account in an abstract fashion such that we at least know what the claimed paranormal phenomenon actually is?

You can get a good idea of what happened to me from this link (I said others have had similar experiences, and I checked it on the Net):

http://amasci.com/weird/unusual/objs.html

Only the object concerned was very large, containing about 500-600 kilos of matter.

That's all I will say for now, and I'm soon off to another working week anyway.

(Hey, I'm a scholar - in 3 days!)
 
Last edited:
While I'm no longer surprised by people's need for convoluted explanations to avoid acknowledging that the human mind has certain fallabilities, I still find it remarkable.

From Ray's link:

I lived in the same house for over 30 years. I spent my whole childhood there and new every inch of the local area. Climbed every tree, hid in every bush... you get the idea.
One day I left for work and drove round the corner to the T junction at the end of my road. Same as I had done for the previous several thousand days. But this day something wasn't the same. I stopped the car, put it in nuetral, pulled the hand brake and stared. straight ahead in front of the house where a friend of mine used to live was a tree, a tree that had never been there before.
It was about 15 foot high, so quite a few years old. I got out and looked around it, The ground was undisturbed and grass, moss etc were growing right up to it. No sign that it had been a new addition....

...I asked people about the tree and the door and was surprised that people's memory was 'kinda foggy' they remembered the same as I did, but no one could remeber when these things had changed.

I'm curious to know the line of questioning. After all, if this was a brand new tree in the front yard which I had never seen before, I wouldn't be 'kinda foggy' on how long it had been there for. Even if I wasn't sure if it had been there yesterday, 'foggy' is not a response. 'Foggy' is 'I think it might have been there for about twenty, maybe twenty five years. I'm not sure'.

These 'am i loosing it?' events started me thinking about the whole issue of stuff that changes, vanishes etc and I have come to the following conclusion.

This 'going crazy' or 'losing it' response is the common fallback - either it happened just as so or I'm insane. Since I'm not insane, it must have happened that way. The fact that the human brain works in a particular way, and is fully capable of a range errors which make a mockery of our perceptions of reality, seems to escape them. Any deviation from their expectation of how their brain should work is met with fears of being called mad or insane.

The parallel universes or multiverse theory is pretty much established and excepted by most rational scientists. I believe that if true, then there must be some sort of interaction and even intersection between these universes. Each one is just a little different from the next. very occassionally, things or even people in one universe slip into a parallel plane, without even knowing it.
It could be that we are all just skipping from one to the next, backwards forewards here there and everywhere without ever knowing it. Each one has so little difference that it is virtually imposible to percieve, however every now and then there is something different enough to prick up our ears.
If you think about it, you could have skipped a thousand times today. People and things all round the world could have changed, moved, vanished and unless it was something close to you, you would never know about it.

And hence the invention of a fantastical explanation to avoid considering the (more reasonable) cause of a human brain working as it does.

Athon
 
While I'm no longer surprised by people's need for convoluted explanations to avoid acknowledging that the human mind has certain fallabilities, I still find it remarkable.

If you'd like to look at the theory of parallel universes this might be a good start:

http://www.manyuniverses.com/

It has also been discussed in Scientific American.

http://holtz.org/Library/Philosophy/Scientific American Parallel Universes - Tegmark 2003.htm

Short extract:

By this very definition of "universe," one might expect the notion of a multiverse to be forever in the domain of metaphysics. Yet the borderline between physics and metaphysics is defined by whether a theory is experimentally testable, not by whether it is weird or involves unobservable entities. The frontiers of physics have gradually expanded to incorporate ever more abstract (and once metaphysical) concepts such as a round Earth, invisible electromagnetic fields, time slowdown at high speeds, quantum superpositions, curved space, and black holes. Over the past several years the concept of a multiverse has joined this list. It is grounded in well-tested theories such as relativity and quantum mechanics, and it fulfills both of the basic criteria of an empirical science: it makes predictions, and it can be falsified. Scientists have discussed as many as four distinct types of parallel universes. The key question is not whether the multiverse exists but rather how many levels it has.

So it may not all be "all in the brain". How about looking at more evidences and information before you jump to conclusions? Is this not what skeptics are supposed to do? Or just express "amazement" at something they don't understand?
 
Last edited:
I too have had similar experinces of things not being the way I remembered them. For example there was a canal next to my childhood home. We moved, but returned a couple of months later to get the house ready for sale. At that time I noticed the canal that I had remembered as contining straight had a bend.

Another example in my adult life involved a poster we had been using at the school where I was teaching as an instructional aid. One day I was searching the teacher's resource room for it and couldn't find it. When I asked the other teachers who I knew had used it themselves and described what was on it, none of them knew what I was talking about or remembered having used any such poster for the purposes we had that one.

I chalk both of these up to faulty memory on my part. The second one happened after I was knifed in a mugging and had to undergo surgery. I suspect the trama at the time jiggled some things about in me.

As for childhood memories, they are quite unreliable.
 
If you'd like to look at the theory of parallel universes this might be a good start

Ummm... how about, before jumping to the conclusion that the 'right answer' MUST lie in the realm of the paranormal/irrational/etc, we consider that we might be asking the 'wrong question(s)'

Just a thought




Anyhoo...

A bit of light reading:

Proving The Existence of Parallel Universes (with the Added Bonus of Immortality)

If someone told you that there was a simple way of making sure you live forever, you would consider them crazy. If this person then went on to tell you that the very same method of doing this – which is incredibly easy to do – would allow you to prove to yourself that an infinite number of universes exist at the same time all around us, you would surely laugh nervously and walk away swiftly in the opposite direction.

But suppose you stayed and listened. Suppose the apparent madman told you that performing this remarkably cheap and easy experiment would be the biggest gamble of your life as well as the most controversial of all possible activities. Would you do it? Would you do it if you knew the man telling you about it was a physicist?

The man's name is Max Tegmark1. He is a physicist – at the University of Pennsylvania to be more precise. Below is the practical guide to performing his controversial experiment, but first, an explanation, and then, a dire warning.
<snip/>

Source: www.bbc.co.uk/dna/h2g2
 
Ummm... how about, before jumping to the conclusion that the 'right answer' MUST lie in the realm of the paranormal/irrational/etc, we consider that we might be asking the 'wrong question(s)'

Just a thought




Anyhoo...

A bit of light reading:

I'm not sure you're reading this correctly. You stop your quotation at the "dire warning" bit, but read on what the dire warning is:

The Warning

Like all typical insurance deals, the experiment proposed by Max Tegmark comes with a catch. It is purely a gamble. Nobody, including Tegmark, can assure you that it will go smoothly, because nobody has actually attempted it yet. There are two possibilities for the outcome of this experiment: either you live forever and you are satisfied that parallel universes exist, or - and this is the controversial part - you die.

Don't give up reading yet. This experiment is as grounded in scientific fact as any other modern theory of physics. It may sound like temptation from the devil, but it is an investigation in quantum mechanics like no other. Understand that if the experiment succeeds, you would have a hard time convincing your friends that parallel universes exist. So without further ado, we present...

Footnote 1 also says:

Actually, the idea is not just Max Tegmark's. It was proposed independently by Hans Moravec in 1987 and Bruno Marchal in 1988.
 
What a goofball article. I was going to cu tit some slack being form the bbc until it went crazy-woo with the definitions of observation and information at the end.
 
If you'd like to look at the theory of parallel universes this might be a good start:

I'm actually quite familiar with the parallel universe hypothesis (and please note, while many articles love to use the word theory, it is nothing more than an interesting speculation based on theoretical mathematics). It is untestable as the very concept itself says no energy (therefore no information) can be exchanged between universes. If they could, it would no longer be distinct universes. Hence the concept - even if taken seriously - cannot account for any happenings here.

So it may not all be "all in the brain". How about looking at more evidences and information before you jump to conclusions? Is this not what skeptics are supposed to do? Or just express "amazement" at something they don't understand?

You have no idea how this works, do you? All concepts and claims have equal weight in your mind. That's not how science works - ideas have an increased chance of providing useful information if they have a greater amount of supporting evidence. Hence in order to explain an observation (such as an account of a gentleman claiming he saw a tree where he had never seen one before) that idea which has the most support is the one which remains the most likely.

There is no support, other than some theoretical mathematics, for parallel universes existing. There is absolutely no supporting evidence for anything - energy or matter - transferring between them. Hence the theory is dead in the water until such evidence appears. There is, however, plenty of evidence suggesting that the brain is capable of making such errors. For a rather enlightening read, I might recommend Oliver Sacks' book 'The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat', which demonstrates that people who are otherwise quite sane, and themselves would argue that they are completely normal in the head, are capable of making some grave mistakes in perception.

Athon
 
Athon said:
You have no idea how this works, do you? All concepts and claims have equal weight in your mind. That's not how science works - ideas have an increased chance of providing useful information if they have a greater amount of supporting evidence. Hence in order to explain an observation (such as an account of a gentleman claiming he saw a tree where he had never seen one before) that idea which has the most support is the one which remains the most likely.

There is no support, other than some theoretical mathematics, for parallel universes existing. There is absolutely no supporting evidence for anything - energy or matter - transferring between them. Hence the theory is dead in the water until such evidence appears.
Athon, I'm afraid this concept has been discussed already and Ray gave this excuse:

Ray Agostini said:
True science looks at phenomena, even inexplicable phenomena, and leaves itself open for future investigation for what is not currently understood.
Basically, evidence or lack of them has no impact on Ray's theories. He avoids the lack of evidence by saying the above or in other words that science does not know everything (which he also said in one of his posts) and when science matures enough (say in 150 years) then it will maybe have the tools to cope with his phenomena.

Regards,
Yair
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom