More advice wanted

Athon, I'm afraid this concept has been discussed already and Ray gave this excuse:

And I agree with him; science needs to remain open to any explanations. That's why it is 'self-correcting' - it adopts a position with a view that if and when contrary evidence is discovered, it must change.

Ray doesn't quite get the fact that it's this need for strong evidence to contradict the standing position which is the key. Is it a fallible brain or a dimensional portal? Well, it could be either, yet the former has evidence which supports the possibility over the latter. If sufficient evidence comes to light that the latter is more likely, science shifts.

I know you understand this, yair, and I know that Ray struggles with the idea. I'm restating it simply to put it on the record.

Athon
 
You can get a good idea of what happened to me from this link (I said others have had similar experiences, and I checked it on the Net):

http://amasci.com/weird/unusual/objs.html

Only the object concerned was very large, containing about 500-600 kilos of matter.

That's all I will say for now, and I'm soon off to another working week anyway.

(Hey, I'm a scholar - in 3 days!)

Thanks for the info.

I must admit though I was hoping for something slightly more impressive. Given a choice between anecdotal accounts of the spontaneous modification of material reality and faulty memory, you can understand why one would choose the latter.

(congratulations!?)
 
To anyone desperate to hear the full story, if you ask Ray nicely he may email it to you like he did to me. Just PM him your email address (apologies Ray if you have decided not to send it out anymore).
 
Ray doesn't quite get the fact that it's this need for strong evidence to contradict the standing position which is the key. Is it a fallible brain or a dimensional portal? Well, it could be either, yet the former has evidence which supports the possibility over the latter. If sufficient evidence comes to light that the latter is more likely, science shifts.

I have no problem with that. If someone else had told me this experience, I would likely have great trouble believing it. I had read like phenomena before, but it never really "sunk" in until I had this experience. I don't blame anyone for not believing me, or putting it down to some kind of "brain trick". That's fine with me. I'm not even going to argue with that. I just put myself in the position of one hearing this to understand the skepticism. I have accompanying material evidences, which both Richard and Dan know about, and that is what persuaded me I was not hallucinating. I also had witnesses, and recorded times and facts, but because it was in the workplace it became a Catch 22. There was no way I could call them as official witnesses, because it may have jeopardized my job.

For two years now I have refused to place this in the public arena, and I have, very uncomfortably, revealed more on this board than anywhere else. I might even get to the stage where I no longer want to discuss it. You really cannot make a proper assessment of this until you read the details, and I'm not going to be emailing this out to all and sundry. What I can say is that the usual reaction from most who have read it, including hardcore skeptics elsewhere, is something like "I'm stumped". Others, who believe me, express utter amazement. I've even had people who believe in the paranormal say they've never read anything that so confronts their sense of reality, mainly because it comes from someone they know personally, not just "a story" on the Web. Most refuse to discuss it at length because they don't have explanations, and it bothers them.

You can be as hypothetical as you want, but the facts are in two places: 1) In my head, as I experienced it, 2) Recorded in great detail.

I agree with Richard that this cannot be tested, at least not now, maybe immediately after it happened, and if I had asked the witnesses to give statements, I know those statements would have been consistent with what I saw, because it was recorded at two different locations. I got the confirmation of that the next day.

Just adding this footnote, because I don't usually post on forums during the working week as I work long hours.
 
"You can't say anything about my experience without me telling you about it, but I'm not going to tell you about it." Got it.
 
Not having seen the account of Ray's experience, I can't give a specific commentary. Here are some thoughts about experiences of this nature:

The choice of explanations is not necessarily just between "a trick of the mind" and "paranormal". Maybe somebody actually played a joke on you. Maybe something has been stolen by a very cunning thief. Here it pays to be really open-minded and creative, considering all sorts of explanations that fit in with a standard scientific view of reality, however improbable they may seem. Even if you're sure you have exhausted all the possible ideas, there still may be a rational explanation you haven't thought of. I personally have no idea how Paul Daniels could make an elephant disappear or appear, but I'm convinced there is a perfectly simple explanation involving known technology: I'm just not clever enough to think of what it could be.

I've looked through the "similar experiences" at http://amasci.com/weird/unusual/objs.html. It's a mixed bag of stories and there is no reason to suppose that there is just one explanation for all these events. In some cases people were probably not remembering correctly, in other cases there might have been an optical illusion, in other cases there could be a physical reason (even an improbable one, like the eraser that bounced into the inside of a tube), in other cases someone may have played a practical joke, in other cases people were drunk or otherwise drugged (should we be surprised by the "miraculous" disappearance of a marijuana joint that the storyteller had just been smoking?) and of course some people may have just made up a story.

Of course it's more fun to think that the object was taken by aliens or that it fell into a parallel world, but that doesn't make these explanations more likely. I agree that a scientific mind should remain open to all possible explanations until there is enough evidence to prove a specific one: the important word here is all. We shouldn't just pounce on the paranormal explanations and discard the other ones. Indeed we should keep racking our brains for other possible reasons. And we should remember that we are not perfect witnesses, even if we think we are.
 
Maybe somebody actually played a joke on you. Maybe something has been stolen by a very cunning thief.

Not a scintilla of the written evidence supports this. If a thief is this cunning, then he must be the invisible man with more paranormal power than any human alive.

This commentary is only wild speculation by people who have not read the account. I would estimate that about a dozen to 20 people have read it, assuming, that is, they have not shared it with others without my knowledge.

They have not provided me with any reasonable answers. If they do so, then it would have to be quite convincing, without baseless speculation, or "perhaps", "maybe", "I think". I provided concrete evidences. If there is an explanation, then I expect good reasoning, and equally good evidences in that/those explanations. If I can find a believable one, I will accept it. But "joke" doesn't fit into this scenario. And any thief that would steal the objects concerned, while leaving all the others untouched, would have need of a frontal lobotomy, because it makes no sense at all. It would be like robbing a bank to steal the toilet paper.
 
You can get a good idea of what happened to me from this link (I said others have had similar experiences, and I checked it on the Net):

As long as you've decided not to consider conventional explanations, why limit yourself to parallel universes? Why not consider the possibility that elves came out, faster that the blink of an eye, and stole your object? Or that a time traveler from the future came into the past and took it? Or that God made it vanish? Or that it never really existed, and you just imagined that it did? If you are going to consider strange explanations, then you need to give equal weight to all strange explanations. If not, you need to explain why you are giving more weight to one than the others.

Only the object concerned was very large, containing about 500-600 kilos of matter.


Here's a true anecdote. It happened to me, and I don't mind telling it. I drive a long way to work (2 hours), and I park my car in a different parking lot depending on the day. Most of the time, I park in one particular lot (Lot A), but every Wednesday I have to park in a different lot (Lot B). So, last week I drove to work and parked. After 9 hours at work, I came out to Lot B, only to find my car was gone. It wasn't in the parking space that I absolutely knew I parked it in. I had a very clear memory of parking it there just 9 hours ago, this being Wednesday, and it simply wasn't there. After much time, I finally found it...in the other lot.

The whole way home, I wondered about this. I questioned my sanity, but I figure that if you are able to do that, you must be sane. I questioned my memory, but as I said, my memory was absolutely clear. I thought perhaps it was a practical joke, but couldn't think of anyone with the desire and means to pull it off. For two hours I wondered.

It was my wife who set me straight. I told her the story, and she said, "But, dear, today's Thursday."

The weird part is, I even debated that! For 10 minutes, we argued over what day it was! Were I religious, I would have sworn on a stack of bibles that it was Wednesday. Turns out, she was right, and I had spent the entire day dating my reports wrong.

And that absolutely clear memory I had? Must have been last week's.

So it just goes to show, you can vanish a 600kg item with nothing more than a faulty memory.
 
As long as you've decided not to consider conventional explanations, why limit yourself to parallel universes? Why not consider the possibility that elves came out, faster that the blink of an eye, and stole your object? Or that a time traveler from the future came into the past and took it? Or that God made it vanish? Or that it never really existed, and you just imagined that it did? If you are going to consider strange explanations, then you need to give equal weight to all strange explanations. If not, you need to explain why you are giving more weight to one than the others.

I have considered other explanations, but none have been satisfactory, so far. Furthermore, I have allowed others the opportunity to offer possible explanations. The parallel universe theory, which was offered to me by one correspondent, I find "interesting", but do I believe it. I really can't say so. How could I even prove this? This is something you cannot know, but only speculate on. I am in fact looking for concrete, down to earth explanations by people who can scrutinise the evidence and show me an explanation, not theories from metaphysics. Interesting as they are, they do not explain.


Here's a true anecdote. It happened to me, and I don't mind telling it. I drive a long way to work (2 hours), and I park my car in a different parking lot depending on the day. Most of the time, I park in one particular lot (Lot A), but every Wednesday I have to park in a different lot (Lot B). So, last week I drove to work and parked. After 9 hours at work, I came out to Lot B, only to find my car was gone. It wasn't in the parking space that I absolutely knew I parked it in. I had a very clear memory of parking it there just 9 hours ago, this being Wednesday, and it simply wasn't there. After much time, I finally found it...in the other lot.

The whole way home, I wondered about this. I questioned my sanity, but I figure that if you are able to do that, you must be sane. I questioned my memory, but as I said, my memory was absolutely clear. I thought perhaps it was a practical joke, but couldn't think of anyone with the desire and means to pull it off. For two hours I wondered.

It was my wife who set me straight. I told her the story, and she said, "But, dear, today's Thursday."

The weird part is, I even debated that! For 10 minutes, we argued over what day it was! Were I religious, I would have sworn on a stack of bibles that it was Wednesday. Turns out, she was right, and I had spent the entire day dating my reports wrong.

And that absolutely clear memory I had? Must have been last week's.

So it just goes to show, you can vanish a 600kg item with nothing more than a faulty memory.

Apples and oranges. If not for the recorded evidence, at the time, and independent eyewitness reports to back up what happened, this was no mixing up days, or even times.

Two things you show by this post. Having not read the report you're willing to speculate wildly with parallels which have no comparison to a report you have not read. Not very objective. Your "conclusion" is therefore based on a false premise, about an event you know nothing about, but factor in your conclusion because of your assumptions about the nature of the universe. "If it 'can't happen', according my understanding, then it must be 'faulty memory'". "There is no other explanation." Or, perhaps, you believe scientists know everything about the universe, and how it works. There is nothing left to understand.
 
Ray, Just out of interest are you able to answer these questions for me?

Your brother and yourself are obviously huge advocates for paranormal phenomena. Did this happen after this amazing event as a result, or were you already believers in the paranormal?

Is your family background one of paranormal beliefs, e.g your Mother consults/is a psychic medium etc?

I think how a persons brain is pre-prepared for what they accept/beleive, factors hugely in how they perceive different events.
 
Last edited:
And with that attitude, you most certainly ain't going to see it. Rest assured of that.

Since you refuse to tell us anyway, I fail to see how refusing to tell me is any different. If you want to discuss possible explanations, give us something to discuss. If you don't, why the hell are you here?
 
Ray, Just out of interest are you able to answer these questions for me?

Your brother and yourself are obviously huge advocates for paranormal phenomena. Did this happen after this amazing event as a result, or were you already believers in the paranormal?

My brother has had an interest in NDEs and the paranormal for longer than I can remember, probably before I was born. This event had nothing whatsoever to do with it. The only time we discussed it was when I informed him of what happened. We have never discussed it since. He, too, has not offered any explanation. His interest is more along the lines of NDEs, not paranormal phenomena. I think he is in fact skeptical to much of it. He's more interested in scientific research into NDEs, and NDE reports, and afterlife studies. I think he's quite skeptical of much of what he reads, but is not dogmatic about it one way or the other. His aim is to provide information, and relate stories. I have never heard him say anything is proven. He has only pointed to what he feels are interesting evidences for things like life after death, and always lets readers/listeners decide for themselves.

Is your family background one of paranormal beliefs, e.g your Mother consults/is a psychic medium etc?

My mother has been dead since 1991. She read cards, and believed that card-reading was accurate to some degree. She did this for family and close friends, and never charged for it. I would say it was a hobby, certainly not an obsession. My father was far more skeptical. He refused to go to the movies when he learned how movies were made (in the '50s, I presume), because after that he believed they were all fake. They were practical, down to earth people, first and foremost.


I think how a persons brain is pre-prepared for what they accept/beleive, factors hugely in how they perceive different events.

This may be true, and maybe genetic/biological factors have some influence. I am quite open to this. I do notice that many in my family have a leaning towards "mystical" things. However, my children are total skeptics, all of them, with the possible exception of one, so I'm not sure of the extent of the possible influence. On the other hand, maybe some families are genetically influenced to skepticism - like my ex-wife's?

But all of this aside - what does any of this have to do with the evidences I have recorded? Is it even relevant? We are looking at hard core evidence here, not "family influence", not "disposition", not "genetic factors", but evidences that need explaining. Are you going to explain this event by inquiring if my great grandmother believed in Leprechauns? I see what you are getting at, but it's way, way off track. Almost like trying to discredit the reporter as a hallucinatory because of what others in his family believed.

Do you know the saying, "play the ball, not the man"? If you can't explain, or accept something, then don't try to discredit it by discrediting the reporter. Deal with the facts. If a man or woman is on trial, do lawyers factor in his whole family history? Or do they deal with the evidence at hand? A judge would throw this out faster than the speed of light.

So what do any of your questions have to do with the subject?
 
Since you refuse to tell us anyway, I fail to see how refusing to tell me is any different. If you want to discuss possible explanations, give us something to discuss. If you don't, why the hell are you here?

My working week is finally over, for three days anyway, so I'll answer this. I have given private correspondents from this board much to discuss, and explain.

Do you feel left out?

I am here to be a bit skeptical about the skeptics. Is that a crime? Or does skepticism go only one way? You like skeptics? Then you'll love me!

Here is my question: Are you skeptics, and do you examine all phenomena with an open mind? Or are you true believers in the Hoffer sense?

Propaganda does not deceive people; it merely helps them to deceive themselves.

However different the holy causes people die for, they perhaps die basically for the same thing.

The opposite of the religious fanatic is not the fanatical atheist but the gentle cynic who cares not whether there is a god or not.
 
Really? My mother graduated from the Teacher's College.

If asksed, she says that she attended the Teacher's College which later became the University of Woollongong.sic

It is simple and no one can accuse her of having graduated from a University a decade before it existed.

Well, the truth is that Wollongong (I don't know any "Woollongong") University was incorporated in the 1950s. The Teacher's College was an addition to the university, but they later merged for practical reasons.

Tell your mum she can say she graduated from the University of Wollongong. If she wants to explain the historical bit about the merger, that's fine. But I doubt the average person would be interested in the fine print.
 
Are you skeptics, and do you examine all phenomena with an open mind?

Skepticism is an approach, not a sect or cult with a rule book

However, there are some (in)famous skeptics whose published thoughts can help focus attention on keeping an open mind

I would never die for my beliefs because I might be wrong.
Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970)

Admission is free and all are welcome :)
 
Given a choice between anecdotal accounts of the spontaneous modification of material reality and faulty memory, you can understand why one would choose the latter.

(congratulations!?)

I can, especially if one decides this without having read the account. See my Hoffer quotes above.
 
My brother has had an interest in NDEs and the paranormal for longer than I can remember, probably before I was born. This event had nothing whatsoever to do with it. The only time we discussed it was when I informed him of what happened. We have never discussed it since. He, too, has not offered any explanation. His interest is more along the lines of NDEs, not paranormal phenomena. I think he is in fact skeptical to much of it. He's more interested in scientific research into NDEs, and NDE reports, and afterlife studies. I think he's quite skeptical of much of what he reads, but is not dogmatic about it one way or the other. His aim is to provide information, and relate stories. I have never heard him say anything is proven. He has only pointed to what he feels are interesting evidences for things like life after death, and always lets readers/listeners decide for themselves.



My mother has been dead since 1991. She read cards, and believed that card-reading was accurate to some degree. She did this for family and close friends, and never charged for it. I would say it was a hobby, certainly not an obsession. My father was far more skeptical. He refused to go to the movies when he learned how movies were made (in the '50s, I presume), because after that he believed they were all fake. They were practical, down to earth people, first and foremost.




This may be true, and maybe genetic/biological factors have some influence. I am quite open to this. I do notice that many in my family have a leaning towards "mystical" things. However, my children are total skeptics, all of them, with the possible exception of one, so I'm not sure of the extent of the possible influence. On the other hand, maybe some families are genetically influenced to skepticism - like my ex-wife's?

But all of this aside - what does any of this have to do with the evidences I have recorded? Is it even relevant? We are looking at hard core evidence here, not "family influence", not "disposition", not "genetic factors", but evidences that need explaining. Are you going to explain this event by inquiring if my great grandmother believed in Leprechauns? I see what you are getting at, but it's way, way off track. Almost like trying to discredit the reporter as a hallucinatory because of what others in his family believed.

Do you know the saying, "play the ball, not the man"? If you can't explain, or accept something, then don't try to discredit it by discrediting the reporter. Deal with the facts. If a man or woman is on trial, do lawyers factor in his whole family history? Or do they deal with the evidence at hand? A judge would throw this out faster than the speed of light.

So what do any of your questions have to do with the subject?

No, i have no more questions for you. And thankyou for answering my questions honestly. They are very insightful for my personal opinion (and im sure for others reading), which i will not bother you with.
 
Last edited:
Skepticism is an approach, not a sect or cult with a rule book........

I would never die for my beliefs because I might be wrong.
Bertrand Russell (1872 - 1970)

I wouldn't die for my beliefs either.

But someone might, perchance, murder me because they don't like them.
 
No, i have no more questions for you. And thankyou for answering my questions honestly. They are very insightful for my personal opinion (and im sure for others reading), which i will not bother you with.

I don't mind being bothered. I can't say I don't like skeptics, because if I did, I would loathe myself.

I am open to all questions. Sorry if I came across harshly. A soft answer doesn't turn away wrath, it just makes you look like a little pussy. And we all know it's big pussies we should be afraid of.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom