More advice wanted

Richard

Muse
Joined
Aug 1, 2001
Messages
960
You know, this is a great place to get good advice. So here I go again. I'm trying to line up a radio debate or something like that with this man:

http://www.afterlifenews.com/a/266.html
Mike Agostini.

I called into a radio show yesterday that was giving him a free run. When I talked about Randi's offer, he dismissed it as fake. Then he tried this tact, he asked me if I have ever been in love to which I answered yes. He then said prove it!

You see, his main line is that so many people have experiences (paranormal) that they cannot all be wrong, so there must be something in it. He also said that we could never agree on what reality was!

Another tact of his is to say that there is a mountain of scientific research that backs his claims. Even though this is false, it is very hard to dismiss on the spot.

So, over to you my dear JREF posting friends.
 
Don't waste your breath. There is no common ground to stand on for an intelligent exchange.

He also said that we could never agree on what reality was!

You will just be giving him publicity. He's views appeal more to the masses.
 
From Mike Agostini's web site:
A graduate in Economics (University of California at Fresno, 1958)

My psychic abilities cannot detect UC Fresno.

Berkeley
Davis
Irvine
Los Angeles
Merced
Riverside
San Diego
San Francisco
Santa Barbara
Santa Cruz

Nope, no Fresno.:confused:
 
Maybe it's the California State University, Fresno?

Almost inevitably. But the man says "University of California".

I had a similar case with quack Sandra Cabot (the liver cleanser). She had a web site which said that she graduated from the University of South Australia. This was done because she assumed that the rubes who would buy her crap would be confused if she put University of Adelaide as they might not know where Adelaide is. The wonderful thing is that the University of South Australia doesn't have a medical school.

I am always suspicious of people who offer qualifications from places that they didn't attend. Agostini might have received a very good degree from Fresno State, but he didn't attend the University of California, just as Cabot had a very legitimate MB,BS from somewhere other than the institution she mentioned.
 
Try asking him what the magic number is that turns belief into fact. If 10 people believe it? 100? 1000?
 
What, exactly, are your claims?

Why do you treat unverifiable anecdotes as scientific evidence?

How do you distinguish between e.g. a death bed visitation and a hallucination?

How do you distinguish between a real paranormal phenomenon and someone lying/fantasizing/hallucinating?

A little background information on Agostini:

Source

Source

On his website, he mentions winning a "Helm's World Trophy". I haven't found any references to one such.
 
You know, this is a great place to get good advice. So here I go again. I'm trying to line up a radio debate or something like that with this man:

http://www.afterlifenews.com/a/266.html
Mike Agostini.

I called into a radio show yesterday that was giving him a free run. When I talked about Randi's offer, he dismissed it as fake. Then he tried this tact, he asked me if I have ever been in love to which I answered yes. He then said prove it!

You see, his main line is that so many people have experiences (paranormal) that they cannot all be wrong, so there must be something in it. He also said that we could never agree on what reality was!

Another tact of his is to say that there is a mountain of scientific research that backs his claims. Even though this is false, it is very hard to dismiss on the spot.

So, over to you my dear JREF posting friends.

This probably doesn't solve your problem, but a strategy I recommend is fostering specialists in particular subjects. In some circumstances, they can volunteer to debate people that operate within their specialization. Skeptics also need to bone up on our rhetoric.

In this case, I'd reply with "How would you like me to prove it?" If he says "I don't know," then just continue, "OK, I'm happy to answer the question, but the ball's in your court until you can figure out what exactly you're asking me to do, but in the meantime I know how I would like you to prove these events are caused by what you describe..." (see list of questions above re: distinguishing between 'experiences' that are personal experiences that don't exist outside the mind, versus those that *do* exist outside the mind, ie: in the real world).

However, in this case, your debating opponent is doing the Gish Gallop, which is to say, he's generating lies faster than they can be absorbed much less refuted. This is a difficult debater, because he's not debating at all: he's lying his ass off and you are under the misapprehension that he is even remotely interested in discussion.

There is debate within the skeptical community as to whether we should be engaging these people in public, in debate format, as it may just fuel their scam. Eugenie Scott of the NCSE has put her opinion forward that this should be policy, and will scold biologists who give creationists a public forum in the form of debates.
 
This is a difficult debater, because he's not debating at all: he's lying his ass off and you are under the misapprehension that he is even remotely interested in discussion.

And what proof do you have that he's "lying his ass off", or that he's "not interested in discussion"?

There is debate within the skeptical community as to whether we should be engaging these people in public, in debate format, as it may just fuel their scam. Eugenie Scott of the NCSE has put her opinion forward that this should be policy, and will scold biologists who give creationists a public forum in the form of debates.

In the skeptical community, or in the closed-minded community? Many people with solid reputations have taken paranormal phenomena seriously. Do the skeptics have a corner on truth? Do they know for sure that paranormal phenomena do not, and cannot occur?
 
And what proof do you have that he's "lying his ass off", or that he's "not interested in discussion"?

In the skeptical community, or in the closed-minded community? Many people with solid reputations have taken paranormal phenomena seriously. Do the skeptics have a corner on truth? Do they know for sure that paranormal phenomena do not, and cannot occur?


The funny thing is that you respond with exactly the same tact that he was accusing you of.

What about that degree Mr. Agostini?
 
The funny thing is that you respond with exactly the same tact that he was accusing you of.

I asked for proof that Mike was "lying his ass off", and not really interested in discussion. Mike often publishes skeptical views on his website, in the daily news section. But it's the "lying" charge I'm interested in. What is he lying about in regard to paranormal phenomena?

What about that degree Mr. Agostini?

Technicalities can be changed if necessary, so as not to offend the suspicious, but Fresno State College later became Fresno State University, which is a university in California. Not the same as UC, admittedly. But Mike has a legitimate degree, from a legitimate university in California. We are talking about the 1950s, and some name changes have occurred since then.

This is what Mike's degree states:

“The Trustees of the California State Colleges….On the Reccomendation of the Faculty of FRESNO STATE COLLEGE…have conferred upon….. Michael G. Agostini

In the 1970s Wollongong University (in Australia) was known as "Teacher's College", and it later became the University of Wollongong. So if someone graduated from "Teacher's College" in the 1970s, would they be lying to say to a contemporary audience that they attended the University of Wollongong?
Everyone who graduated from Teacher's College says that they graduated from the University of Wollongong, because that's how you speak to a contemporary audience, in terms they understand.

On the other hand, I guess you can't please pedants.

Also of interest is that Mike's degree was signed by Ronald Reagan ten years after he graduated. When he was awarded the degree Reagan was only a B grade actor in 1958, but when he applied for the certificate ten years later Reagan was the governor of California. I suppose he could mention all of these technicalities, but it would be quite laborious, wouldn't it?
 
Last edited:
And what proof do you have that he's "lying his ass off", or that he's "not interested in discussion"?

In the skeptical community, or in the closed-minded community? Many people with solid reputations have taken paranormal phenomena seriously. Do the skeptics have a corner on truth? Do they know for sure that paranormal phenomena do not, and cannot occur?

You have point on the college/university name-change thing. I've run into this, too.

However, it's your last shriek here that's telling: it's not up to "the skeptics" to prove that what ever snake oil this guy (your brother?) is selling is NOT real, it's up to him to prove it is--when challened.

Can he prove that he is speaking to the dead or whatever by something other than skilled cold reading? I know this site offers a whole battery of tests and anyone with an IQ above that of an orange knows that James Randi has been making this same offer for, it's gotta be going on at least 30 years and possibly 40 by now. I can remember when it was a paltry $10,000...nobody won it then (though many falsely claimed they did...some I believe were sued by Randi and made to stop making that claim, lest they could [ahem] prove they'd won the prize). Today the amount is a cool $million$.

If I were an Amazing Psychic, and my powers were real, I'd scoop that up in a heartbeat.

Why doesn't this guy?

Tokie
 
However, it's your last shriek here that's telling: it's not up to "the skeptics" to prove that what ever snake oil this guy (your brother?) is selling is NOT real, it's up to him to prove it is--when challened.

Can he prove that he is speaking to the dead or whatever by something other than skilled cold reading? I know this site offers a whole battery of tests and anyone with an IQ above that of an orange knows that James Randi has been making this same offer for, it's gotta be going on at least 30 years and possibly 40 by now. I can remember when it was a paltry $10,000...nobody won it then (though many falsely claimed they did...some I believe were sued by Randi and made to stop making that claim, lest they could [ahem] prove they'd won the prize). Today the amount is a cool $million$.

If I were an Amazing Psychic, and my powers were real, I'd scoop that up in a heartbeat.

Why doesn't this guy?

Proof, as in laboratory proof, isn't always possible. Just look at Dr. Susan Blackmore's debates with the scientific community who study NDEs. She admitted that she could not prove NDEs to be false, or entirely brain-generated. She believed they were, and offered her evidence, generated mostly from her own OBE, which is not the same as an NDE. She never experienced a proper NDE. Also in regard to psi:

Susan Blackmore has recently confessed that her prior conclusions about the probability of psi and metaphysical consciousness existing being close to none, were not as conclusive as she thought and that she was NOT justified in ruling out psi after all. Therefore, she has taken an honest "don't know" stance and left the issue at that.

(I was going to post the URL but a note says I can't do this until I've made 15 posts.)
 
Ray, just prove on thing.. just one small paranormal thing. A simple test. If you are unable to do that, then you must take a hard look at your claims. We here at Australian Skeptics will help out. How hard can it be?
 
However, it's your last shriek here that's telling: it's not up to "the skeptics" to prove that what ever snake oil this guy (your brother?) is selling is NOT real, it's up to him to prove it is--when challened.

Yes, he is my brother. I've done research for him in the past, and I started out quite skeptical of some things, but like Blackmore I have adopted a healthy "don't know" in regard to some phenomena. I don't refer to this as "snake oil", because the evidences are sometimes quite complex. Raymond Moody started out as a total skeptic, as did many others who eventually changed their minds upon looking at the evidences. How you "prove" this to someone else is not cut-and-dried. Scientists can look at the same evidences and come to totally different conclusions - there is no mathematical precision in regard to metaphysical phenomena. We know things about the atomic and sub-atomic world that could not even be dreamed of before. I do think there may come a time when science may be able to determine if phenomena, such as NDEs, are real or not. In the meantime you're entitled to your personal view, but putting these phenomena into the "snake oil" compartment is a bit premature.

Sure, we do not accept any and every report. Mike is basically a storyteller, he relates his own and other's experiences. He's not a scientist, doesn't claim to be one, and is not interested in pedantry and method. He entertains his readership and listeners with stories, not made up stories, but stories from people who have had experiences which science does not currently have answers for, at least among the more open-minded scientists.

(I keep getting logged out and don't know why. Glitch or something?)
 
Ray, just prove on thing.. just one small paranormal thing. A simple test. If you are unable to do that, then you must take a hard look at your claims. We here at Australian Skeptics will help out. How hard can it be?

Richard, I'll post some things I find of much interest, later. Not dodging your question, but I am on my day off work and have a lot of domestic work to do. We are in the same time zone (basically), and I will have more time about mid-afternoon. I'm off work until Wednesday, so I'll eventually get around to replying properly.

I always look hard at my assumptions/beliefs. If I didn't, I would be closed-minded. So while I have some strong beliefs, based on evidences I see, and things I have experienced as well, I'm open to the possibility my interpretations, current understandings, may be wrong. I feel one can, however, go too far into unjustified skepticism.
 
...I called into a radio show yesterday that was giving him a free run. When I talked about Randi's offer, he dismissed it as fake. Then he tried this tact, he asked me if I have ever been in love to which I answered yes. He then said prove it! ...

First, to really make the comparison fair, both tests (love, paranormal) need to move out of past claims anyway, and into a future test. So as long as he would be willing to set up an agreed upon definition of what his ability is, and an agreed upon test, then you would also agree to a common definition of 'being in love', and determine a future test to prove it. So the question is no long "Have you been in love", but "Can you fall in love?", or perhaps "Are you in love?", or even "Can people love?". That would mirror "Can you tell the future"?

Second, obviously the domains of test here are quite different. A common definition of the paranormal is "Beyond the range of normal experience or scientific explanation". Love is common experience. Telling the future, or other paranormal claims, are by definition not common experience, and so require proving where love really doesn't (by definition).

And third, I think he just got this from the movie Contact: ("Did you love your father?" "Yes". "Prove it.")
 
Ray, just prove on thing.. just one small paranormal thing. A simple test. If you are unable to do that, then you must take a hard look at your claims. We here at Australian Skeptics will help out. How hard can it be?

I can give you the simple test, Richard. A very personal one. If you agree, I will email you an experience I had. I've actually had several, but the one concerned has not been explained by anyone who has read it (even Mike was somewhat skeptical at first, and may still be). I privately emailed this experience to skeptics on two different forums, and not one had an explanation. It is written out in detail, and anyone can make a judgement on the merit of this. I am not prepared to post this on an open forum because it involves a former workplace, where it occurred. One catch, this experience is recorded on my other computer which means I will have to unplug this one and email it to you from the other one after I set it up. The motherboard on that computer blew it and I had a new one put in, and I've had it back three weeks now and have not set it up yet. I'm prepared to do this just for you.

Let me know if you agree to read this experience, and if you have an answer, I will be most grateful for your help, as offered by Australian Skeptics. I guess there has to be an explanation, but since what happened defies the currently known laws of physics, I would anxiously welcome one. I will also refer you to other people who have had similar experiences. I verified this by doing some Net-searching since I wanted to make sure I was not losing my marbles.

One condition:

1) You agree not to share this publicly, at this time (I'll give my reasons in the email), and in future only with my permission.

I need your preferred email address, if you agree to read this.
 
On his website, he mentions winning a "Helm's World Trophy". I haven't found any references to one such.

Where did you search?

Here is one example easily obtainable:

Los Angeles, March 2, 1965 – Mohamed Gammoudi of Tunisia. Runner-up in
the 1964 Olympic 10,000 meters run, was selected for the Helms World Trophy Award.
Instituted in 1949, the Award recognizes the six foremost amateur athletes of the
six continents.
Mr. Gammoudi was the choice to represent Africa. The selections are
made by the Helms Athletic Foundation of Los Angeles.
William Schroeder, Helms Athletic Foundation manager, will fly to Tunisia in
may to present the award to Mr. Gammoudi.
 
Ray, there is a difference between the CSU system and the UC; what that difference is, I don't know. I could claim that I got a degree from Western Wyoming, but what I really have is a degree from Western Wyoming Community College. It would be best that your brother correctly states the school from where he got his dipolma from. (FSU or CSUF, either one would be fine)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom