More advice wanted

haha, keep em coming
Couldn't come up with a response refuting my observation that you show much ignorance of science, eh?

Really? What is the current consensus?
There is no "before" the Big Bang. At the point of the Big Bang the entire universe including space/time was in a state of extreme concentration. Time itself starts at the Big Bang. The current thinking is that space/time is like a giant, multi-dimensional sphere, self contained. Asking what came before the Big Bang is like asking what's further north than the North Pole.
 
So far none of the correspondents has provided a "very, very simple" explanation. Some have not even attempted to. If there is a "simple explanation" it would be able to be explained quite easily. That has not been the case. If people want to believe the world "works in a certain way", and no other way, that's their choice. I am not so certain that I know everything about "how the world works".

Another curious thing...why did you select to respond to this one small part of my post, and not the rest of it? If you'd like another chance, here's the recap:

1) What makes the parallel universe theory any more likely or believeable than other seemingly fantastic theories?

2) Considering that I'm attempting to comment on a situation for which *very* little information has been given, you have to expect that what I have to say doesn't match up exactly. If there were more information forthcoming, I could easily revise what I'd have to say about it.
 
If there were more information forthcoming, I could easily revise what I'd have to say about it.

There will be no more public information forthcoming. End of matter. I already said people could email me and discuss it. Did you miss that? Then why are you pursuing it on the board? That is why my previous reply was so short.

Simple. Logical. Just follow what I said previously.
 
Anecdotes are worthless in the first place, and keeping them secret certainly do not raise their credibility.

Is every anecdote you have told "worthless"? Is every anecdote told worthless? That's your reasoning, unless you wish to be more specific. I have already explained the reason, a million times, why this can't be made public at this time. If you can't comprehend that, that's not my problem.

How many more are going to raise this idiotic reply when I have clarified it?

I see no further point in my participation in this thread, or, for that matter, this forum. I have emailed the story to everyone who asked. NOT ONE has provided a rational explanation/rebuttal. They have been very vague and wishy-washy explanations, and have not addressed the crucial points. Some have been downright hilarious. I can't remember what I saw in late 2005, along with detailed physical evidences (none of which have been addressed directly), but I can tell you the names of almost everyone who attended my wedding in 1978, and what occurred. But that was a "natural event". No one will have trouble accepting that, but when something "unnatural" occurs, it has to be some kind of "perceptual blindness". Right. Got it.

If there is an answer, I am certain now I won't find it among "the skeptics". I think, honestly, "the skeptics" are as agenda-ridden as any religion I have encountered. Come to a conclusion, then exclude anything which doesn't fit the conclusion.

Nobel-Prize material.
 
If there is an answer, I am certain now I won't find it among "the skeptics". I think, honestly, "the skeptics" are as agenda-ridden as any religion I have encountered. Come to a conclusion, then exclude anything which doesn't fit the conclusion.

Nobel-Prize material.


This is completely untrue.
In the case of the JREF tests, which people consistently fail, the participant has agreed on the testing parameters. Therefore the person being tested and the testers are at the same conclusion, which is;
"a successful demonstration of the agreed conditions, will demonstrate paranormal activity."
The fact that people always fail the tests is not the fault of the people testing, it is because the phenomena does not exist, or the person being tested does not posses the ability they claim.

Now in the case of skepticism and science. One starts with a hypothesis, and trys to prove this wrong. This is the opposite of what you stated "Come to a conclusion, then exclude anything which doesn't fit the conclusion."

All you are doing is illustrating your ignorance of science, and inability to grasp the simple concept that an anecdote cannot be taken as concrete evidence.
 
Last edited:
NOT ONE has provided a rational explanation/rebuttal.

Well, OK.. explain this. I flew to Mars on a paper plane. I did. I mean I can write about it and everything. I cannot prove it, but it's up to you to give me an explanation of how it happened. If you cannot, then what use are you skeptic?
 
NOT ONE has provided a rational explanation/rebuttal. They have been very vague and wishy-washy explanations, and have not addressed the crucial points. Some have been downright hilarious.

If there is an answer, I am certain now I won't find it among "the skeptics". I think, honestly, "the skeptics" are as agenda-ridden as any religion I have encountered. Come to a conclusion, then exclude anything which doesn't fit the conclusion.

Nobel-Prize material.

Keep in mind, a good cook needs good ingredients. You complain of vague answers, yet most people here have only vague information to work with. Cut them a break. Consider if I told you "Something weird happened to me. I can't tell you what it was. Now, either you explain it to my satisfaction, or I'm going to ridicule your attempts."

Keep in mind the title of this thread, a title you picked.

Ray has emailed me his account of the event. Without divulging any details, and with just a few minutes of thought, I can think of several explanations for what he witnessed.

(1) Ray is unintentionally misremembering his observations.
(2) Ray is intentionally misremembering his observations.
(3) A coworker is playing a joke on him.
(4) Temporary insanity.
(5) Ray is making the whole thing up.
(6) The items in question slipped into a parallel universe.
(7) Ray has slipped into a parallel universe.
(8) People with the ability to control the flow of time stopped time, stole the items, and started time up again.
(9) Invisible unicorns stole the items.
(10) Other

My point is, Ray, that of items (6), (7), (8), and (9), one is just as likely as another, given the available evidence. I'm curious what has prompted you to choose one over the other.

Also, when it comes to probability, the explanation is more likely to be (1), (2), (3), (4), (5) or (10). What prompted you to decide not to choose from this group?
 
My point is, Ray, that of items (6), (7), (8), and (9), one is just as likely as another, given the available evidence. I'm curious what has prompted you to choose one over the other.

Also, when it comes to probability, the explanation is more likely to be (1), (2), (3), (4), (5) or (10). What prompted you to decide not to choose from this group?

You still haven't addressed the evidence. If you wish to do so, do it by email. I won't be answering in any detail on the board. Finally, one correspondent has asked for a even more detailed explanations, which I'm happy to give. I'll even try to provide photos, where possible. You can't dismiss something like this in several posts, or even emails, and I'm not afraid to provide all the evidences requested. A laundry list of choices isn't sufficient.

This almost reminds me of the Lindy Chamberlain case in the early '80s. "A dingo took my baby". No one believed her, and she was eventually jailed, but later released. It took some 8 years for this to happen. To this day some still believe she murdered her daughter, because "the dingo story is unbelievable".
I'd be interested to hear what Richard has to say about this, and I have no idea what he thinks of the Chamberlain case.
 
Well, OK.. explain this. I flew to Mars on a paper plane. I did. I mean I can write about it and everything. I cannot prove it, but it's up to you to give me an explanation of how it happened. If you cannot, then what use are you skeptic?

Well Richard, if many others had claimed this your example could be taken seriously. I don't know if anyone who has claimed to fly to Mars on a paper plane, but many have claimed the experience which I had, and I already gave the link. Are you going to dismiss all of them?

http://amasci.com/weird/unusual/objs.html

When you find a website with people claiming to have flown to Mars on paper planes, let me know.

Cheers,

Ray.
 
Well Richard, if many others had claimed this your example could be taken seriously. I don't know if anyone who has claimed to fly to Mars on a paper plane, but many have claimed the experience which I had, and I already gave the link. Are you going to dismiss all of them?

http://amasci.com/weird/unusual/objs.html

When you find a website with people claiming to have flown to Mars on paper planes, let me know.

Cheers,

Ray.

Going by this logic, one would also have to accept the following;

The world is flat

the lochness monster is real

Aliens visit us frequently

there are bigfoots all over the show

Islam is the one true faith

christianity is the one true faith

buddhism is the one true faith

etc

Just because a lot of people beleive something, doesn't make it so.

The point is, anyone can claim something outrageous, but unless there is some meaningful evidence that other people can verify, then it stays meaningless to other people.

What happened to you may be something paranormal.
what happened to you may be something perfectly explanable.
We are not in a postion to be able to tell, which one it is, because you cannot provide us any evidence.
You would like us to take your word for it, but how do we know you word is trustworthy?
And even if we knew your word was trustworthy, how could we tell your perception and recollection of the event is accurate?

surely you must understand the position we are in.
 
Is every anecdote you have told "worthless"? Is every anecdote told worthless? That's your reasoning, unless you wish to be more specific. I have already explained the reason, a million times, why this can't be made public at this time. If you can't comprehend that, that's not my problem.
Worthless as evidence. Anecdotes can still make good entertainment. In the nature of anecdotes, there is only the author's word that this is what happened. It is not possible to ensure that the author was not deceived, that the story actually happened as described. You may have lots of reasons why your experience must remain a secret, but that it makes it even less credible is your problem, not ours.
 
You still haven't addressed the evidence.

I certainly have addressed the evidence. My post gave 10 possible explanations for the evidence.

You still haven't answered my question. Why did you pick that particular explanation out of the many available?

You can't use "many others have experienced it" as a reason, because there are many who believe time travel exists. And aliens. And even invisible unicorns, I'm sure. So why pick the one you did?
 
Well Richard, if many others had claimed this your example could be taken seriously. I don't know if anyone who has claimed to fly to Mars on a paper plane, but many have claimed the experience which I had, and I already gave the link. Are you going to dismiss all of them?

http://amasci.com/weird/unusual/objs.html

It's strange that Ray gives this list to show that many others have had the experience he had: this is a mixed bag of tales, with the only common denominator being "something inexplicably vanishes". Each case certainly has it's own explanation, which could be any one, or a combination of the following:

- Faulty memory
- Inattentional blindness (google it for some interesting stuff)
- Change blindness
- Incapacity to take in several events happening at the same time
- Optical illusion
- Acoustical illusion
- Conscious or unconscious embroidering of the facts to make a story more interesting
- Just making it up
- Absent-mindedness
- Influence of drugs
- Acute tiredness
- Unnoticed narcolepsy
- Unusual but perfectly normal physical phenomenon

- - - I'm sure others can think of some more ideas. There are so many possibilities: it's funny that many believers in paranormal events treat skeptics as closed-minded, but are not prepared to open their own minds to the vast possibilities of rational explanations. It's not a case of "dismissing" the experience: it's a case of explaining how it can happen.

A very common pattern is to think something has disappeared and then to find it exactly where it ought to be, although the storyteller is convinced that it wasn't there the first time they looked. It is indeed possible to look straight in the direction of an object and not actually consciously see it. We are not the perfect witnesses we might like to be. Many people don't want to believe this, saying "there was NO WAY I could have missed it" etc. etc.

If you're not familiar with the classic demonstration devised by Daniel Simons and Christopher Chabris, this is a fun thing to do: go to this site and watch the short video clip. Here's what you're meant to do:

When viewing the video, try to count the total number of times that the people wearing white pass the basketball. Do not count the passes made by the people wearing black.

Here's the video

Afterwards, go here to see how well you've done.
 
It is indeed possible to look straight in the direction of an object and not actually consciously see it. We are not the perfect witnesses we might like to be. Many people don't want to believe this, saying "there was NO WAY I could have missed it" etc. etc.

You're forgetting on thing Michael, which is in my account. I ran my hands through the empty space, and there was nothing there. Check my account again.

As mentioned, I will email you more details tomorrow.
 
You're forgetting on thing Michael, which is in my account. I ran my hands through the empty space, and there was nothing there. Check my account again.

The point I am making is precisely that all those experiences in the link you gave are not the same. They are not all examples of one particular phenomenon: each story has it's own explanation. In some cases people missed seeing something that was really there, in others they thought they had seen something that wasn't there at all, in others there was a totally different explanation. I talked about a common pattern in many of the stories, but that doesn't mean it applies to every story, nor indeed to your particular one.
 
I thought of another possibility.

(11) Maybe this guy was in the area, looking for a little practice.

I guess he could have been, but I didn't see him. I said before that I don't trust videos/clips of paranormal phenomena, and I'm wary of most so-called "UFO photos". In fact, I don't trust anything on the Internet which claims to demonstrate something through visual clips. Cyber-space is rather sophisticated these days. I guess I'm, er, skeptical? Unless you were actually there, you have no way of knowing if this happened the way it is claimed (the magic, that is). Nor do I blame anyone for being skeptical of my account, in fact, I would think it's healthy to be skeptical, but not sarcastic.

As for the elephant trick, this goes back to Houdini. The magicians "code of honour" forbids magicians from revealing their trickery, and there's intense competition among magicians. Remember, this is pure trickery, illusion, fabricated by humans. Let's take it a step further. What if the audience was asked to set up this scenario? The magician shows the elephant, standing still. Then the audience is given the privilege to control the setting, and move the elephant to a different ground, and then ask the magician to perform his magic. Would he fail? 100% guaranteed. Because it is trickery, illusion, and the set up is completely controlled by the magician. This is entertainment, not reality.

Now in my case, the object moved before it disappeared. It was no set up, controlled by a magician. I would like to see which magician can do that. Remember, this magic is performed under controlled circumstances (the audience only watches, does not participate). Not in the course of a normal working day.

Of course, you may now say your example was tongue-in-cheek. My account is not tongue-in-cheek, and no magician would be able to perform this under uncontrolled circumstances.
 
I certainly have addressed the evidence. My post gave 10 possible explanations for the evidence.

You still haven't answered my question. Why did you pick that particular explanation out of the many available?

You can't use "many others have experienced it" as a reason, because there are many who believe time travel exists. And aliens. And even invisible unicorns, I'm sure. So why pick the one you did?

And you know for certain that "aliens" don't exist? We are the only life in the universe? Got it. I guess some thought Columbus was mad. There is no life in the universe far more advanced than we are? You know this? How? Do tell.

By the way, do you know why the West Indies is called such? Well Columbus thought he had arrived in the Indies, the "west Indies". He died without realising that he was half a globe away from the Indies, but the name "West Indies" stuck.
 
Now in the case of skepticism and science. One starts with a hypothesis, and trys to prove this wrong. This is the opposite of what you stated "Come to a conclusion, then exclude anything which doesn't fit the conclusion."

Did I say science does this, or pseudo-skeptics? I said some scientists do this, not all. If you really want to be skeptical, have a look at fraud in science. My main concern is how some use science to further their own dogmatic conclusions and preconceived ideas. This is not science, this is scientism.

All you are doing is illustrating your ignorance of science, and inability to grasp the simple concept that an anecdote cannot be taken as concrete evidence.

Not now, in a court anyway, but I have allowed anyone to look at the evidences and draw their own conclusions. Since you had a go at my "ignorance" of science, let me say your English is not the best. Does that mean you can't read and comprehend? Do you have to be a professor of English to understand basic thoughts being conveyed through the written word? What if I dismissed everything you wrote because you don't understand the difference between "trys" and "tries"?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom