More advice wanted

Religion not true: God does not exist.

Religion not true: The paranormal cannot exist.

Evidence for Religion1 not true
Evidence for Religion2 not true
Evidence for Religion3 not true
Evidence for Religionn not true
Probability of finding any evidence for any religious woo: decreasing...
keep looking though, in your spare time, cos you never know



Evidence for woo1 not true
Evidence for woo2 not true
Evidence for woo3 not true
Evidence for woon not true
Probability of finding any evidence for any woo: decreasing...
keep looking though, in your spare time, cos you never know


Observation:
Logic supporting mainstream religion seems fundamentally the same as the
logic supporting mainstream paranormal phenomenon; proceed with caution
 
Skeptics ask for evidence of supernatural phenomena. That must seem a horrible bias to you!

Maybe you should read Thomas Kuhn, then you'll understand the difference between bias and looking objectively.

Kuhn argued that science does not progress via a linear accumulation of new knowledge, but undergoes periodic revolutions that he called "paradigm shifts", in which the nature of scientific inquiry within a particular field is abruptly transformed.

The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 1962.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thomas_Kuhn

So far you have only delivered an anecdote that those who read it are not allowed to discuss. Strong evidence indeed!

I have withheld nothing from anyone. I have given the evidence and exchanged emails with posters. Anyone is free to look at the evidence, and whether it is discussed on the board, or privately, makes no difference, except that on the board posters tend to throw ridicule to show off to other posters: "Look at how silly this is." Instead of examining the evidence in detail and offering explanations. And I've explained why I don't want this public at this time (how many times I've lost count). You can discuss the nature of vanishing objects to your heart's content on the BB, but if you want to discuss my particular experience do so by email. Ask any question you like by email, and I will eventually reply. I have several replies to get to today, and a lot of domestic work to do. But everyone will get a reply.
 
Ray, I have no way to know whether what happened to you was paranormal or not (I do not even know what happened to you). I therefore cannot rule out the possibility that it was a paranormal event. However, to beleive that it was paranormal, i would require evidence that can be verified.

You do not even know what happened, yet you're making lavish comments. Isn't this working on preconceived notions? How objective is that?

I do not see why you would class someone who is taking my position as "agenda ridden" or "dogmatic", it just does not make sense.

It makes sense if you comment on something you haven't read.
 
You do not even know what happened, yet you're making lavish comments. Isn't this working on preconceived notions? How objective is that?



It makes sense if you comment on something you haven't read.

As i have said, i am unable to make a judgement on your situation. And yes, as i have said, i have not read your account.
what i am saying applies to any concept. Before beleiving it, i require solid evidence. This is just sound logic.
Unfortunately with your situation, you only have an anecdotal account.
This would not satisfy the requirement for verifiable evidence, therefore i could not make a conclusion as to whether it was a paranormal event or not, even if i had read your account.
 
Last edited:
As i have said, i am unable to make a judgement on your situation. And yes, as i have said, i have not read your account.
what i am saying applies to any concept. Before beleiving it, i require solid evidence. This is just sound logic.
Unfortunately with your situation, you only have an anecdotal account.
This would not satisfy the requirement for verifiable evidence, therefore i could not make a conclusion as to whether it was a paranormal event or not, even if i had read your account.

I think Columbus' discovery of the New World was "anecdotal".

Hypothetical scenario:

Columbus: We saw land, and at first thought it was the horizon, but it turned out to be real land, inhabited by natives.

Queen Isabella: Oh what rot! You mean the earth is not flat? You reached the Indies? Bull****

Columbus: Yep, I reached the Indies, and here's some tabacca to prove it.

Queen Isabella: Go back and get me some more. The world obviously ain't flat.
 
I think Columbus' discovery of the New World was "anecdotal"

Nope

Although he mistook N America for India, his 'discovery' (who said it was lost?) wasn't anecdotal, it was corroborative

All European navigators knew (through astronomy) that the world was round long, long before Columbus was even born
 
Nope

Although he mistook N America for India, his 'discovery' (who said it was lost?) wasn't anecdotal, it was corroborative

All European navigators knew (through astronomy) that the world was round long, long before Columbus was even born

They did not "know". It was a theory, first developed by the Greeks in c.600 BC, but may have gone back to the Persians long before that. If all of this was such common knowledge, why did no one believe Galileo? Or, very few? Knowledge is gained, then lost and regained. Go back to the writings of Plato, who believed in an afterlife and immortality.

So-called "near death experiences" have been recorded and discussed since Plato's time, and he believed it. Even in the Bible, Isaiah mentions "the circle of the earth", so this may have been know to the Hebrews as well. The "pillars of the earth" reference may have only been metaphor on steroids.

All silly, of course, like the "round earth" theory. The world is not actually "round", but spherical, by the way. I think you know that.

The "skeptics" fail to impress me, sadly. I still think 99% of them are nothing but agenda-driven. Hopefully, I will be proved wrong.
 
Last edited:
My point was that Columbus' claim wasn't accepted on anecdotal evidence

Do you have a point?

The "skeptics" fail to impress me, sadly. I still think 99% of them are nothing but agenda-driven. Hopefully, I will be proved wrong.

It seems like you simply hope to tell sceptics, on a sceptics forum, that you're not impressed with 99% of us... for being sceptical...

Who has an 'agenda'?
 
... It seems like you simply hope to tell sceptics, on a sceptics forum, that you're not impressed with 99% of us... for being sceptical... ...


Gosh, I hope I'm in the 1% that impresses Ray!
It would mean ever so much to me mum y'know, and the kiddies, especially little Tim... waa-haa-haa-haaaa :cry1

Whoops, crying's not too impressive, is it? Buck up boy, must soldier on, if only to impress Ray, mustn't let him know how much is riding on this, just play it cool, real cool and nonchalant-like...

So, ahh, Ray, how's it hangin' tarzan? Seen any 600 kilo objects disappear into another dimension lately?

There, that oughta do it. Who wouldn't be impressed with that sort of suave, yet skeptical, solicitation. Top 1% here I come! :yahoo
 
Last edited:
No sonic boom..... How do explain that Ray?

I think that if some object of 500 kilos has vanished in an instant you can safely surmise that some as yet unknown law or principle is at work..
you can't assume that this unknown law or principle definitely wouldn't interfere with what would cause a sonic boom
 
Gosh, I hope I'm in the 1% that impresses Ray!
It would mean ever so much to me mum y'know, and the kiddies, especially little Tim... waa-haa-haa-haaaa :cry1

Whoops, crying's not too impressive, is it? Buck up boy, must soldier on, if only to impress Ray, mustn't let him know how much is riding on this, just play it cool, real cool and nonchalant-like...

So, ahh, Ray, how's it hangin' tarzan? Seen any 600 kilo objects disappear into another dimension lately?

There, that oughta do it. Who wouldn't be impressed with that sort of suave, yet skeptical, solicitation. Top 1% here I come! :yahoo

very poor
 
all experiential evidence currently dismissed because it doesn't fit into the current paradigm
Isn't it rather the case that whenever this "experiental" evidence is scrutinized, it actually falls well within the current paradigm, but not in the way the woo-woos like?

all experience, when reported, is anecdote. Including laboratory science.
That is why laboratory tests need replication from other laboratories.

they are, by nature, rare phenomena.
falling in love is a rare phenomenon, but we accept that it exists because it happens to most of us at least once in our lives. try to replicate falling in love in a laboratory experiment.
As far as I know, falling in love has actually been performed under controlled circumstances, which is why many hormonal changes in the process are well known. But one bad example should not detract from your argument that paranormal phenomena are so rare that they cannot be investigated. I would have thought they were rather common because practically everybody with the right inclination seem to have experienced paranormal phenomena. Many are doing it on a regular basis. I really cannot understand this argument as anything else than trying to explain away the complete failure when put to the test.

neither was there for Einsteins relativity, neither was there in the 19th century when the "experts" ridiculed the notion of electromagnetic waves.
I believe you are wrong in both cases. There were phenomena that needed to be explained, and eventually the proper theories were formulated to do so. That there was resistance to the theories is not an argument that resistance is always wrong, and in these cases it is also clear that the resistance was overcome with evidence. In the case of ESP, we are still waiting for evidence after more than 100 years of parapsychological research.

knowledge grows and expands, telling us more about reality.. if you want to shut off the possibility of radical future changes in our understanding, do so. Just please be aware that history indicates you'll be completely wrong.
Why do you assume that skeptics think there will be no "radical" future changes in our understanding? The skeptic position is that without evidence, there will be no changes at all, and that seems to be the problem for you.
 
Maybe you should read Thomas Kuhn, then you'll understand the difference between bias and looking objectively.
Thank you. As a former member of a UFO society, I know perfectly well what this difference is.

I doubt that we will see a paradigm shift based on anecdotes alone.

I have withheld nothing from anyone.
Well, I certainly have no idea what you are talking about, and I am not going to keep quiet about fundamental evidence that I might obtain, so you are not going to tell me. In any case, I expect your story to be of the kind: "I was skeptical at first, but I experienced this, and I could not find an explanation, so it must have been true", which is basically how every anecdote goes.

And I've explained why I don't want this public at this time (how many times I've lost count).
I am not arguing that you should make it public. I am arguing that you should not use it as evidence.
 
I think Columbus' discovery of the New World was "anecdotal".

Hypothetical scenario:

Columbus: We saw land, and at first thought it was the horizon, but it turned out to be real land, inhabited by natives.

Queen Isabella: Oh what rot! You mean the earth is not flat? You reached the Indies? Bull****

Columbus: Yep, I reached the Indies, and here's some tabacca to prove it.

Queen Isabella: Go back and get me some more. The world obviously ain't flat.


Your scenario does not fit. He provides evidence of tobacco.
Furthermore, he has a verifiable way to prove what he is saying.
 
A very common pattern is to think something has disappeared and then to find it exactly where it ought to be, although the storyteller is convinced that it wasn't there the first time they looked. It is indeed possible to look straight in the direction of an object and not actually consciously see it. We are not the perfect witnesses we might like to be. Many people don't want to believe this, saying "there was NO WAY I could have missed it" etc. etc.

This happened to me this past weekend, twice. I was camping (18th century re-enactment) and I set my mug down on my ceramic plate on the table, right next to my fork and spoon. I was called away for a bit, and later in the day I came back to find out my mug was gone. No question that I had left it there..there was even a ring on the bowl showing that the mug had dried there. I certainly hadn't moved it, so someone else must have. Three hours went by searching for it. Eventually I found it. Where? At the shop across the way, where I left it. Apparantly, I got myself a drink, went for a walk to the shop, and when I pulled out my wallet, set the mug down and forgot to pick it up again. The thing was, I was thoroughly convinced that the whole shopping trip happened before I set the mug on the plate, not after. I really, really, really thought so.

Later that day, something similar happened, not worth going into the details. But the same idea...I looked right at an object, declared it missing, and later found it right where I left it.

And you know for certain that "aliens" don't exist? We are the only life in the universe? Got it. I guess some thought Columbus was mad. There is no life in the universe far more advanced than we are? You know this? How? Do tell.

I never said aliens don't exist. I highly doubt they've visited us, but that's not really the purpose of the statement. You're totally missing my point. Given that it's likely there's life in universe other than here, why wouldn't you jump to the conclusion that those alien life forms are responsible for taking your stuff, rather than it slipping into a parallel dimension? If it's prior evidence you're looking for, well, there are plenty of tales of alien abductions.

My point is, you have chosen one particular solution for your dilemma and you have not explained why you have chosen that solution to the exclusion of all others.

They did not "know". It was a theory, first developed by the Greeks in c.600 BC, but may have gone back to the Persians long before that. If all of this was such common knowledge, why did no one believe Galileo? Or, very few? Knowledge is gained, then lost and regained. Go back to the writings of Plato, who believed in an afterlife and immortality.

Er...as I recall, the church had a beef with Galileo not because he thought the earth was spherical (that was well-established). They just didn't like the idea of the heliocentric theory.

If you are going to cite historical reference to back up your arguments, make sure you get your history right.
 
This happened to me this past weekend, twice. I was camping (18th century re-enactment) and I set my mug down on my ceramic plate on the table, right next to my fork and spoon. I was called away for a bit, and later in the day I came back to find out my mug was gone. No question that I had left it there..there was even a ring on the bowl showing that the mug had dried there. I certainly hadn't moved it, so someone else must have. Three hours went by searching for it. Eventually I found it. Where? At the shop across the way, where I left it. Apparantly, I got myself a drink, went for a walk to the shop, and when I pulled out my wallet, set the mug down and forgot to pick it up again. The thing was, I was thoroughly convinced that the whole shopping trip happened before I set the mug on the plate, not after. I really, really, really thought so.

I can tell many such stories which also happened to me. This doesn't even come close to the event I'm describing. There were other witnesses, and physical evidence involved which is very difficult to explain. I'll let the correspondents who are emailing me keep trying, because they are interested in the details, and I am, and have said I would answer any and every question (by email). I'm prepared to be scrutinised inside out on this one, but facile "solutions" won't do.


My point is, you have chosen one particular solution for your dilemma and you have not explained why you have chosen that solution to the exclusion of all others.

I have not chosen any solution. If I had a solution it would no longer be a mystery, or an "unexplained event", which it is.

Er...as I recall, the church had a beef with Galileo not because he thought the earth was spherical (that was well-established). They just didn't like the idea of the heliocentric theory.

If you are going to cite historical reference to back up your arguments, make sure you get your history right.

I have my history right, thank you. Whether it be the heliocentric theory or a flat earth, the point is that they "didn't like the idea". Few like new ideas which don't fit their paradigm, or the current scientific paradigm, hence the reference to Kuhn.
 
Gosh, I hope I'm in the 1% that impresses Ray!
It would mean ever so much to me mum y'know, and the kiddies, especially little Tim... waa-haa-haa-haaaa :cry1

Whoops, crying's not too impressive, is it? Buck up boy, must soldier on, if only to impress Ray, mustn't let him know how much is riding on this, just play it cool, real cool and nonchalant-like...

So, ahh, Ray, how's it hangin' tarzan? Seen any 600 kilo objects disappear into another dimension lately?

There, that oughta do it. Who wouldn't be impressed with that sort of suave, yet skeptical, solicitation. Top 1% here I come! :yahoo

It's people like you who give me the clear impression that skeptics are closed minded. I never said "99%" were closed minded (but "agenda-driven", there is a difference), but with this post of yours, I'm moving towards that figure. Even an agenda driven person can look at evidences. A closed minded person will not even go near it, because they have already decided the "solution".

Edit: Maybe I'm am being a bit too harsh, though. I think some correspondents have not been agenda driven, but genuinely interested. I think it's therefore a bit premature of me to put all skeptics in the same boat.
 
Last edited:
To put all people in the same boat for anything is a bad idea. It breeds things like racism, sexism, and stereotypes.

Ray, based on your posts you seem to lack a sufficient understanding as to why you get the responses you do.

The skeptics do have an agenda. We are tired. We are tired of people passing off lies as truth. We are tired of people making claims of special abilities, yet are unable to demonstrate them under proper scientific conditions. We are tired of people selling items that do not do what they claim. These things are detrimental to society as a whole. It results in people losing money to frauds, receiving bogus medical treatments instead of real ones, and can even result in a person breaking contact with their father because a psychic told them their dad was evil. And quite often these things are done for personal financial or popularity gain at the expense of others.

We are tired of this crap not only existing but flourishing. So our agenda is to stop it. To not just believe anything we are told, but to demand evidence which shows the claim to be true.

Your story is not evidence. Just as my story about how Santa Clause came and gave me presents many years ago is not evidence that Santa Clause is real. A story can be made up, exaggerated, or be mostly true with a few lies thrown in. If you had video taped evidence of whatever happened at your previous workplace, that may be different.

You also do not seem to understand that the burden of proof is upon the person making the claim. If I say that Santa is real, it is up to me to prove he is real. I do not ask you to prove that he isn't because it is impossible to prove a negative statement.

If you want anyone to take you or your paranormal beliefs seriously you will need to be able to give evidence in the form of a scientific experiment that is repeatable.
 
Last edited:
...
Edit: Maybe I'm am being a bit too harsh, though. I think some correspondents have not been agenda driven, but genuinely interested. I think it's therefore a bit premature of me to put all skeptics in the same boat.


Well, your edit sounds a bit more cordial.
Your accusation that 99% are agenda-driven sounded agenda-driven, and thus fit for ridicule.
If by "agenda-driven" you mean people who dismiss evidence, that's not my typical experience on this forum, though it does happen, I'll grant you that. Everyone is guilty of clinging too much to personal belief sometimes -- human nature and all. Discussion forums like this are a good antidote.
Good luck solving the mystery...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom