More advice wanted

If there is an answer, I am certain now I won't find it among "the skeptics". I think, honestly, "the skeptics" are as agenda-ridden as any religion I have encountered. Come to a conclusion, then exclude anything which doesn't fit the conclusion.

Nobel-Prize material.

You're absolutely right here Ray. It would be hard to find more unanimity of belief anywhere outside of North Korea under Kim Il Sung.
 
You're absolutely right here Ray. It would be hard to find more unanimity of belief anywhere outside of North Korea under Kim Il Sung.

I kind of wonder if it's even worth it, sometimes. I think Eric Hoffer's book The True Believer is a good start to understanding why people need dogma, be they atheist, religious, or skeptic. Some people just need security, and absolute certainty. The world operates "this way", and no other way.

Warning ships: "Titanic, icebergs ahead".

Titanic: "What? And spoil our Southampton to New York record??!!"
 
I kind of wonder if it's even worth it, sometimes. I think Eric Hoffer's book The True Believer is a good start to understanding why people need dogma, be they atheist, religious, or skeptic. Some people just need security, and absolute certainty. The world operates "this way", and no other way.

Warning ships: "Titanic, icebergs ahead".

Titanic: "What? And spoil our Southampton to New York record??!!"

That's cute. But the truth is that many, if not most of the "dogmatic believers" to be found on this forum gave up security and absolute certainty when they abandoned their religious beliefs because they could no longer pretend that they weren't contradicted by the world around us.
 
I kind of wonder if it's even worth it, sometimes. I think Eric Hoffer's book The True Believer is a good start to understanding why people need dogma, be they atheist, religious, or skeptic. Some people just need security, and absolute certainty. The world operates "this way", and no other way.

Warning ships: "Titanic, icebergs ahead".

Titanic: "What? And spoil our Southampton to New York record??!!"

I know exactly what you mean.
Thanks for that, I'll look up Eric Hoffer.
 
That's cute. But the truth is that many, if not most of the "dogmatic believers" to be found on this forum gave up security and absolute certainty when they abandoned their religious beliefs because they could no longer pretend that they weren't contradicted by the world around us.

And having given up their religious beliefs, did they think that everything in the world was as wrong as their religious beliefs? Seems so to me.

Religion not true: God does not exist.

Religion not true: The paranormal cannot exist.

Makes perfect sense.
 
Ray and Plumjam,

You are both incorrect. The people on this forum, and skeptics in general do not conform to a belief system. Yes there appear to be people who accept the same things as reality, but these people have arrived at this acceptance through the process of logic and reason, completely independent of each other. The reason they have arrived at these conclusions, is because of factual evidence that reality provides.
To illustrate this for you, consider the following:
If you have one apple. You then get an additional apple. How many apples do you now have?
Given this situation, everyone is going to arrive at the same conclusion.
There are two apples.
They have arrived at this conclusion correctly, and if you argue against them, they will appear to be uniform in their belief that there are two apples.
They are not being dogmatic, and acepting anything on faith. They do not have an agenda. They simply beleive what they believe, because it is consistent with the evidence they know to be true.

Being a skeptic is not an easy default choice, it requires critical thinking, and research. It is a much harder road than accepting things on faith to satify your desires, or allay your fear of death.

Let me use myself as an example:
I grew up as a christian, for a large portion of my young years i believed in god, heaven and hell, and was comforted by the belief that i would end up in Heaven and live happily ever after.
The easiest thing for me to do for the rest of my life, would be to accept christianity on faith, and live out the rest of my life.
But i was not able to take this easy road, it was impossible.
Why? because the more i thought about christianity, the more i could see things that did not make sense. I tried to explain them away to myself, and keep up my blind faith, but i could not. So i started researching, trying to find out whether there is enough evidence for christianity so that i could justify my faith.
Unfortunately for me, i was too fair in my research, i gave fair considerations to both sides of the argument. What i ended up with, was the the realization, christianity cannot be true, it does not make sense logically, and there is no evidence for it. Many years later, i find myself as a member of this forum, discussing matters with people, trying to get to the bottom of reality, and doing so in a manner which i consider to be fair i.e. Looking at evidence, and basing conclusions on logic, and reason.

I do not have an agenda. I dont not have an unreasonable faith. I do not fit uniformly in with everyone else in this forum.
But i do however share one thing in common with a lot pf people on this forum; I have arrived independently through my own reasearch at conclusions about the paranormal, which class me as a skeptic.

So please, enough with your baseless accusations of uniformity and dogmatic faith.
 
Ray and Plumjam,

You are both incorrect. The people on this forum, and skeptics in general do not conform to a belief system. Yes there appear to be people who accept the same things as reality, but these people have arrived at this acceptance through the process of logic and reason, completely independent of each other. The reason they have arrived at these conclusions, is because of factual evidence that reality provides.

The factual evidence that reality provides? I didn't know that "reality" provided anything. So when we want answers to anything, including the mysteries of the universe ( are there any mysteries?), we just ask "reality"? I suppose scientists could find the answer to anything, including quantum theory and chaos, by just asking "reality".

To illustrate this for you, consider the following:
If you have one apple. You then get an additional apple. How many apples do you now have?
Given this situation, everyone is going to arrive at the same conclusion.
There are two apples.
They have arrived at this conclusion correctly, and if you argue against them, they will appear to be uniform in their belief that there are two apples.
They are not being dogmatic, and acepting anything on faith. They do not have an agenda. They simply beleive what they believe, because it is consistent with the evidence they know to be true.

If only it was so simple. I have one apple. I buy another apple, how many apples do I have? Who needs Einstein when Humpty Dumpty can answer such basic questions. Or even the Easter Bunny. "I have one egg, I add another egg. How many eggs do I have?" Three, of course, if I include my brain. Just joking.

Being a skeptic is not an easy default choice, it requires critical thinking, and research. It is a much harder road than accepting things on faith to satify your desires, or allay your fear of death.

Sounds like your agenda in science is driven by your former Christian beliefs. Not a good start. Reactions to dogma can be as bad as the dogma itself.

Let me use myself as an example:
I grew up as a christian, for a large portion of my young years i believed in god, heaven and hell, and was comforted by the belief that i would end up in Heaven and live happily ever after.
The easiest thing for me to do for the rest of my life, would be to accept christianity on faith, and live out the rest of my life.
But i was not able to take this easy road, it was impossible.
Why? because the more i thought about christianity, the more i could see things that did not make sense. I tried to explain them away to myself, and keep up my blind faith, but i could not. So i started researching, trying to find out whether there is enough evidence for christianity so that i could justify my faith.

You're not the first one to decide that Christianity is not a good foundation for the search for truth. But your debunking of everything else supernatural on this basis is like believing all apples are bad because you bought a rotten one in a bunch. You don't measure truth by what you reject, or because you've had bad experiences. This is like saying all women are bad because the one I was married to was bad. Or all black people are bad because one night I got mugged by a group of black men.


Unfortunately for me, i was too fair in my research, i gave fair considerations to both sides of the argument. What i ended up with, was the the realization, christianity cannot be true, it does not make sense logically, and there is no evidence for it. Many years later, i find myself as a member of this forum, discussing matters with people, trying to get to the bottom of reality, and doing so in a manner which i consider to be fair i.e. Looking at evidence, and basing conclusions on logic, and reason.

Again, what does Christianity have to do with truth? I think you are the epitome of someone driven by agenda-driven "truth". Christianity was false, so anything associated with Christianity is false. Miracles are the basis of Christianity, so there are no miracles. Supernatural phenomena are present in Christianity, so all supernatural phenomena are false. Just ask "reality". You don't even see your own bias.

I do not have an agenda. I dont not have an unreasonable faith. I do not fit uniformly in with everyone else in this forum.
But i do however share one thing in common with a lot pf people on this forum; I have arrived independently through my own reasearch at conclusions about the paranormal, which class me as a skeptic.

Aided by your experience with Christianity.

So please, enough with your baseless accusations of uniformity and dogmatic faith.

Seems "dogmatic faith" touches a chord with you. Just make sure you've not traded one dogmatic faith for another, or even as a reaction to another former faith.
 
Last edited:
And having given up their religious beliefs, did they think that everything in the world was as wrong as their religious beliefs? Seems so to me.

Religion not true: God does not exist.

Religion not true: The paranormal cannot exist.

Makes perfect sense.

How about:

Religion contradicts all known laws of nature, so it's rubbish.

The paranormal contradicts all known laws of nature, so it's rubbish as well.

Makes perfect sense.
 
Ever get the feeling you are being strung along.....?

This is where the skeptics will be really tested as to if they are skeptics. Or, just repeaters of crass dogma. Put this on your show, Richard. I might even be willing to reveal the details there. No? I will put this to the world, eventually, and seek their answers.
 
The factual evidence that reality provides? I didn't know that "reality" provided anything.
Well, reality provides evidence, something which is sorely lacking in this thread.
So when we want answers to anything, including the mysteries of the universe ( are there any mysteries?), we just ask "reality"? I suppose scientists could find the answer to anything, including quantum theory and chaos, by just asking "reality".
Which is what scientists do. What is your problem?

Sounds like your agenda in science is driven by your former Christian beliefs. Not a good start. Reactions to dogma can be as bad as the dogma itself.
You seem to have a problem with accepting critical thinking, since you classify it as a "dogma".

You're not the first one to decide that Christianity is not a good foundation for the search for truth. But your debunking of everything else supernatural on this basis is like believing all apples are bad because you bought a rotten one in a bunch.
Why this focus on Schlitt's former Christianity? He actually said "Looking at evidence, and basing conclusions on logic, and reason." You think that leads to thinking all apples are bad if you have bought a rotten one?

Miracles are the basis of Christianity, so there are no miracles. Supernatural phenomena are present in Christianity, so all supernatural phenomena are false. Just ask "reality". You don't even see your own bias.
Skeptics ask for evidence of supernatural phenomena. That must seem a horrible bias to you!

So far you have only delivered an anecdote that those who read it are not allowed to discuss. Strong evidence indeed!
 
This is where the skeptics will be really tested as to if they are skeptics. Or, just repeaters of crass dogma. Put this on your show, Richard. I might even be willing to reveal the details there. No? I will put this to the world, eventually, and seek their answers.

I have lots of strange things on my show. So, Xkg of matter vanished from our universe? And no sonic boom as the air rushed in to fill the gap. Wow.
 
How about:

Religion contradicts all known laws of nature, so it's rubbish.

The paranormal contradicts all known laws of nature, so it's rubbish as well.

Makes perfect sense.

If you're open minded you'll realise that what is known changes and expands with research and human experience.
So for you to dismiss things as 'rubbish' just because they don't fit into current knowledge is closed minded, and yes, dogmatic.
 
You are quite right to correct me plumjam.

Obviously, I was referring to the "unknown laws of nature" in my message, and you are perspicacious in the extreme to have been able to identify that fact.
 
You are quite right to correct me plumjam.

Obviously, I was referring to the "unknown laws of nature" in my message, and you are perspicacious in the extreme to have been able to identify that fact.

Good on you. Very gracious of you. :)
 
You'll have to start a thread telling us all what life is now like, having experienced the full ironyectomy.
 
If you're open minded you'll realise that what is known changes and expands with research and human experience.
So for you to dismiss things as 'rubbish' just because they don't fit into current knowledge is closed minded, and yes, dogmatic.
What exactly does not fit into current knowledge? The problem with your paranormal phenomenas is that they only live in the world of anecdotes. For some reason they shun away from controlled circumstances. There really is nothing to indicate a revision of the physical laws.
 
It really seems that you are clutching at straws to defensively cling to your position, or that you are incapable of logical thought.

You post is so off the mark it is almost funny.


The factual evidence that reality provides? I didn't know that "reality" provided anything. So when we want answers to anything, including the mysteries of the universe ( are there any mysteries?), we just ask "reality"? I suppose scientists could find the answer to anything, including quantum theory and chaos, by just asking "reality".

Im not sure whether you are intentionally missing the point here and trying to look like you lack general comprehension skills, or you really do. Either way, you comments are comical.
Of cause scientists do not "ask reality". they STUDY reality, looking for evidence, for which to logically base conclusions on. If different scientists independently come to the same result, it means the evidence is consistent, and their conclusions are therefore verified.


If only it was so simple. I have one apple. I buy another apple, how many apples do I have? Who needs Einstein when Humpty Dumpty can answer such basic questions. Or even the Easter Bunny. "I have one egg, I add another egg. How many eggs do I have?" Three, of course, if I include my brain. Just joking.


This is an analogy, not a comparison.
Go back to school if you do not understand the difference.

Sounds like your agenda in science is driven by your former Christian beliefs. Not a good start. Reactions to dogma can be as bad as the dogma itself.



You're not the first one to decide that Christianity is not a good foundation for the search for truth. But your debunking of everything else supernatural on this basis is like believing all apples are bad because you bought a rotten one in a bunch. You don't measure truth by what you reject, or because you've had bad experiences. This is like saying all women are bad because the one I was married to was bad. Or all black people are bad because one night I got mugged by a group of black men.




Again, what does Christianity have to do with truth? I think you are the epitome of someone driven by agenda-driven "truth". Christianity was false, so anything associated with Christianity is false. Miracles are the basis of Christianity, so there are no miracles. Supernatural phenomena are present in Christianity, so all supernatural phenomena are false. Just ask "reality". You don't even see your own bias.



Aided by your experience with Christianity.



Seems "dogmatic faith" touches a chord with you. Just make sure you've not traded one dogmatic faith for another, or even as a reaction to another former faith.

You are making things up here.
At no point have i indicated that because i do not accept christianity, i therefore discount anything paranormal.
I did however make it clear that while trying to reach a decision regarding christianity, i did my very best to give equal weighting to both sides of the argument, to try and reach an objective decision.
It seems you are purposely choosing to misunderstand my words.

Ray, I have no way to know whether what happened to you was paranormal or not (I do not even know what happened to you). I therefore cannot rule out the possibility that it was a paranormal event. However, to beleive that it was paranormal, i would require evidence that can be verified.
I do not see why you would class someone who is taking my position as "agenda ridden" or "dogmatic", it just does not make sense.
 
What exactly does not fit into current knowledge?
all experiential evidence currently dismissed because it doesn't fit into the current paradigm


The problem with your paranormal phenomenas is that they only live in the world of anecdotes.
all experience, when reported, is anecdote. Including laboratory science.


For some reason they shun away from controlled circumstances.
they are, by nature, rare phenomena.
falling in love is a rare phenomenon, but we accept that it exists because it happens to most of us at least once in our lives. try to replicate falling in love in a laboratory experiment.


There really is nothing to indicate a revision of the physical laws.
neither was there for Einsteins relativity, neither was there in the 19th century when the "experts" ridiculed the notion of electromagnetic waves.

knowledge grows and expands, telling us more about reality.. if you want to shut off the possibility of radical future changes in our understanding, do so. Just please be aware that history indicates you'll be completely wrong.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom