More advice wanted

To put all people in the same boat for anything is a bad idea. It breeds things like racism, sexism, and stereotypes.

Ray, based on your posts you seem to lack a sufficient understanding as to why you get the responses you do.

The skeptics do have an agenda. We are tired. We are tired of people passing off lies as truth. We are tired of people making claims of special abilities, yet are unable to demonstrate them under proper scientific conditions. We are tired of people selling items that do not do what they claim. These things are detrimental to society as a whole. It results in people losing money to frauds, receiving bogus medical treatments instead of real ones, and can even result in a person breaking contact with their father because a psychic told them their dad was evil. And quite often these things are done for personal financial or popularity gain at the expense of others.

We are tired of this crap not only existing but flourishing. So our agenda is to stop it. To not just believe anything we are told, but to demand evidence which shows the claim to be true.

I can understand this point of view. In fact I have a great deal of empathy with it.

Your story is not evidence. Just as my story about how Santa Clause came and gave me presents many years ago is not evidence that Santa Clause is real. A story can be made up, exaggerated, or be mostly true with a few lies thrown in. If you had video taped evidence of whatever happened at your previous workplace, that may be different.

You also do not seem to understand that the burden of proof is upon the person making the claim. If I say that Santa is real, it is up to me to prove he is real. I do not ask you to prove that he isn't because it is impossible to prove a negative statement.

If you want anyone to take you or your paranormal beliefs seriously you will need to be able to give evidence in the form of a scientific experiment that is repeatable.

I have already acknowledged that this cannot be proved. But because something can't be proved under controlled scientific conditions, does not mean "it can't happen". Did Edmund Hilary have to prove he reached the summit of Everest? Even photos can deceive. Apparently, some don't even believe the moon landing occurred. It was a "grand deception" by NASA. I saw the moon landing in 1969 live, at any rate I believed it was live (could have been a replay or delayed telecast, for all I know, or just pure fabrication). I watched Neil Armstrong step down from the Lunar module (well, we were told it was Armstrong, but I've never met Armstrong, and behind the spacesuit I wouldn't recognise him from a bar of oatmeal soap), and utter the words "One small step for man....", or was it "one small step for a man.....". How does anyone know this was not doctored? So what of the skeptics (or should we call them "skeptics"?) who disbelieve the moon landing? What evidence do you have that all of what you saw, if you saw it, was not doctored by some magnificent collaboration between a Steven Spielberg and NASA?

My question is, where does skepticism stop, or at least, are there any boundaries? Do you agree that everyone, including skeptics, have to exercise a certain amount of faith, or trust, in what they see or hear?

Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying people should not be skeptical, but is there a boundary to skepticism?

Did Earnest Shackleton really go to the South Pole? How do we know this? Do I have to prove that Shackleton went there before I believe it? How would I prove it?

What evidence would you ask of Shackleton?
 
Your scenario does not fit. He provides evidence of tobacco.
Furthermore, he has a verifiable way to prove what he is saying.

How? What is the "verifiable way" to prove this? Did anyone in Spain know, at the time, what tobacco was, or where it really came from? What evidence would anyone have to prove where this came from? Unless they actually went there, saw the Indians, saw the tobacco plants growing, saw them smoking it. Until the trade routes were developed, and others actually went there, how was anyone to know Columbus was not lying? So was the default position - "don't believe a word Columbus says until we can establish this ourselves"? He has no real hard evidence.

Should they have mocked Columbus? Or waited to see if others could verify this? I think, in fact, many did mock him.
 
Nope

Although he mistook N America for India, his 'discovery' (who said it was lost?) wasn't anecdotal, it was corroborative

All European navigators knew (through astronomy) that the world was round long, long before Columbus was even born

It was corroborative many years later. Columbus died believing he had reached the Far East. Obviously, he never downloaded Google Earth. Hindsight is so luxurious.
 
So far you have only delivered an anecdote that those who read it are not allowed to discuss. Strong evidence indeed!

They are freely allowed to discuss it, and ask any questions, by email. Haven't seen an email from you. You don't even know what the evidence is, though you can easily find out, yet you post on the board as if I'm some kind of "Grand Inquisitor" hiding something.

I am hiding nothing.
 
Easy. Do you hear a sonic boom when you flush your toilet? Where did it go?
I don't, no.
But I certainly flipping do a couple of minutes before flushing it. :eek:

Seriously though, Ray.. you're spot on in what you've been saying in these posts. Keep going, mate.
 
How? What is the "verifiable way" to prove this? Did anyone in Spain know, at the time, what tobacco was, or where it really came from? What evidence would anyone have to prove where this came from? Unless they actually went there, saw the Indians, saw the tobacco plants growing, saw them smoking it. Until the trade routes were developed, and others actually went there, how was anyone to know Columbus was not lying? So was the default position - "don't believe a word Columbus says until we can establish this ourselves"? He has no real hard evidence.

Should they have mocked Columbus? Or waited to see if others could verify this? I think, in fact, many did mock him.


The fact that no-one knew what tobacco was is an even stronger reason to beleive that it may come from a foreign land. It was a tangible thing which could be shown to be new.

The fact is Ray, it was verifiable, simply because it was. People could be taken there. If he were to take people there and verify it... they would beleive him.

Also, he was not claiming anything that contradicted a scientific system that has been in place for many years and brought us such things as aeroplanes, antibiotics, space travel, electricity, computers etc etc....

It is natural to disbelieve something that contradicts what we know to be true. But, if there is real evidence for it, and it can be verified, then it becomes accepted and itself becomes something we know to be true.
In the time of columbus, yes there were disbelievers, but at the end of the day, what comlumbus was saying was verifiable, and it was verified.

So, as with columbus, you have to suffer the disbelief, but if your claim is based on reality, there will be something verifiable, as there was with columbus.
So where is your verifiable evidence?
 
The fact that no-one knew what tobacco was is an even stronger reason to beleive that it may come from a foreign land. It was a tangible thing which could be shown to be new.

The fact is Ray, it was verifiable, simply because it was. People could be taken there. If he were to take people there and verify it... they would beleive him.

The question I have is, why should they disbelieve him, or mock him, or be skeptical before seeing this for themselves? Until they proved this, Columbus' account was "anecdotal". Does that mean all anecdotes are rubbish? How do you know that in the distant future something like "parallel universes" will not be proved? It has already been theorised, but totally dismissed by "skeptics". The parallel universe theory is as radical today as some of Columbus' ideas were.

But when Columbus walked onshore in the Bahamas, he encountered the beginnings of a continent that Europe had no idea existed. There were no nautical folk tales or rumours of a landmass in the middle of the Atlantic Ocean, nor was there a history of vague contact between the populations of these two continents. Quite simply, the Americas were not supposed to be there.

http://www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/eurvoya/columbus.html

Also, he was not claiming anything that contradicted a scientific system that has been in place for many years and brought us such things as aeroplanes, antibiotics, space travel, electricity, computers etc etc....

See above. Retroactive knowledge is always so obvious.

It is natural to disbelieve something that contradicts what we know to be true. But, if there is real evidence for it, and it can be verified, then it becomes accepted and itself becomes something we know to be true.
In the time of columbus, yes there were disbelievers, but at the end of the day, what comlumbus was saying was verifiable, and it was verified.

With hindsight. In Columbus' day the "skeptics" would have laughed at him until their bellies ached.

So, as with columbus, you have to suffer the disbelief, but if your claim is based on reality, there will be something verifiable, as there was with columbus.
So where is your verifiable evidence?

As far as I know, you haven't asked for it.
 
They are freely allowed to discuss it, and ask any questions, by email. Haven't seen an email from you. You don't even know what the evidence is, though you can easily find out, yet you post on the board as if I'm some kind of "Grand Inquisitor" hiding something.

I am hiding nothing.
You will not get an email from me because I would never consent a priori not to divulge the information I got. I am not accusing you of hiding something. I am accusing you of trying to present something as evidence that the persons who see it are not allowed to discuss openly. That is, your evidence can be earth-shaking, but only a few people will know (perhaps you intend to make commercial use of it later: fine with me, but I will reserve judgement till I see the application). Or your evidence could be crap, and the your correspondents have promised not to reveal its nature, thus keeping your argument alive longer than it deserves.

Mind you, that even if your tale was public, it would still be an uncorroborated anecdote. Nobody can know if you or the other witnesses have make an honest mistake, been fooled, or whatever. Anecdotes are simply not evidence, but they can form a basis for something that should be investigated.
 
The question I have is, why should they disbelieve him, or mock him, or be skeptical before seeing this for themselves? Until they proved this, Columbus' account was "anecdotal". Does that mean all anecdotes are rubbish?
Not rubbish, but also not evidence. At the time it was actually claimed that Columbus had faked his journey, and that he was just after the money. But first of all, Columbus was not the only man returning from America, and secondly, his travel could be repeated, and there was a general consensus that the Earth was indeed round, so his discovery, though exciting, was not far-fetched.

How do you know that in the distant future something like "parallel universes" will not be proved? It has already been theorised, but totally dismissed by "skeptics". The parallel universe theory is as radical today as some of Columbus' ideas were.
As far as I know, 'parallel universes" are a mathematical construction, and it is a strawman argument that "skeptics" dismiss it. In the mathematical theories I have heard about, there is no chance of interaction between the parallel universes (contrary to the sci-fi version), so I do not expect a confirmation of the theory any time soon. But if it comes, I cannot see what physical laws should have been broken by the theory, and why I should dismiss it beforehand.
 
The question I have is, why should they disbelieve him, or mock him, or be skeptical before seeing this for themselves? Until they proved this, Columbus' account was "anecdotal". Does that mean all anecdotes are rubbish? How do you know that in the distant future something like "parallel universes" will not be proved? It has already been theorised, but totally dismissed by "skeptics". The parallel universe theory is as radical today as some of Columbus' ideas were.



http://www.ucalgary.ca/applied_history/tutor/eurvoya/columbus.html




See above. Retroactive knowledge is always so obvious.



With hindsight. In Columbus' day the "skeptics" would have laughed at him until their bellies ached.



As far as I know, you haven't asked for it.


No, not all anecdotes are rubbish. But until they can be proven to be real, you have to understand that people are going to be skeptical.
You do not Believe everything that another person tells you right?
e.g if i told you that i was actually born on pluto, and came to earth when i was 19. You would not believe me, unless i was able to show you some good proof that i really did.
If you want people to believe something you are telling them, you need to provide some evidence beyond just taking your word for it.

I understand your position, you have witnessed something which to you seems paranormal, and it may well be.
But we cannot simply decide that science is wrong, just because of a story you tell which has no way to be proven.

If you have some verifiable way to prove what you saw, e.g you could visit the spot and make other things vanish. Then anyone would have to believe you.

Also Ray, keep in mind that almost everyone on this board would LOVE it if your story was true. We are not trying to be nasty, and disbelieve because we are not nice people, it is just that given what we accept about reality, we understand the likelihood of events like this.

So please, if you do have verifiable evidence, i would love to see it.
 
I have my history right, thank you.

You do not have your history right. The first post was by six7s, talking about the shape of the world.

Originally Posted by six7s
Nope

Although he mistook N America for India, his 'discovery' (who said it was lost?) wasn't anecdotal, it was corroborative

All European navigators knew (through astronomy) that the world was round long, long before Columbus was even born

You responded in kind....

They did not "know". It was a theory, first developed by the Greeks in c.600 BC, but may have gone back to the Persians long before that. If all of this was such common knowledge, why did no one believe Galileo? Or, very few? Knowledge is gained, then lost and regained. Go back to the writings of Plato, who believed in an afterlife and immortality.

So-called "near death experiences" have been recorded and discussed since Plato's time, and he believed it. Even in the Bible, Isaiah mentions "the circle of the earth", so this may have been know to the Hebrews as well. The "pillars of the earth" reference may have only been metaphor on steroids.

All silly, of course, like the "round earth" theory. The world is not actually "round", but spherical, by the way. I think you know that.

The "skeptics" fail to impress me, sadly. I still think 99% of them are nothing but agenda-driven. Hopefully, I will be proved wrong.


Again, the problem the church had with Galileo did not have to do with the shape of the earth, but rather whether it was or was not the center of the universe.

wiki said:
Galileo's championing of Copernicanism was controversial within his lifetime. The geocentric view had been dominant since the time of Aristotle, and the controversy engendered by Galileo's opposition to this view resulted in the Catholic Church's prohibiting the advocacy of heliocentrism as potentially factual, because that theory had no decisive proof and was contrary to the literal meaning of Scripture.[5] Galileo was eventually forced to recant his heliocentrism and spent the last years of his life under house arrest on orders of the Inquisition.


I have not chosen any solution. If I had a solution it would no longer be a mystery, or an "unexplained event", which it is.

Fine, I will accept your nitpick. Let me rephrase. You have proposed a particular theory to explain what you say you observed. My question is, why have you selected that particular theory as a probable one, rather than any of the others I've suggested?
 
You will not get an email from me because I would never consent a priori not to divulge the information I got.

Thanks for the tip off.

I am not accusing you of hiding something. I am accusing you of trying to present something as evidence that the persons who see it are not allowed to discuss openly. That is, your evidence can be earth-shaking, but only a few people will know (perhaps you intend to make commercial use of it later: fine with me, but I will reserve judgement till I see the application). Or your evidence could be crap, and the your correspondents have promised not to reveal its nature, thus keeping your argument alive longer than it deserves.

I am more interested in the email exchanges than board exchanges, and I'm not trying to "keep this alive". In what time I have on days off I've replied to some posts. I have lots of other things to do on days off, and because this board discussion has now become very circular (answering the same questions over and over), I envision that on my next break from work I'll be devoting myself to other things, while maintaining the email correspondence with those still interested. I find that far more interesting and stimulating.

I have no intention of gaining financially from what I've recorded, nor do I believe I can. If anything, when I feel the time is right, and possibly after legal advice, I may consider adding it to the list of "unexplained phenomena", and then anyone can attempt an explanation. Until then, it's probably pointless to keep going round the merry-go-round here.

Mind you, that even if your tale was public, it would still be an uncorroborated anecdote. Nobody can know if you or the other witnesses have make an honest mistake, been fooled, or whatever. Anecdotes are simply not evidence, but they can form a basis for something that should be investigated.

I've said this ad infinitum. And those who have chosen to email are attempting investigations/explanations. They are in a position to decide for themselves if mistakes were made, or if there are serious loopholes in the account. I appreciate the time and effort some of them have invested.
 
I have already acknowledged that this cannot be proved. But because something can't be proved under controlled scientific conditions, does not mean "it can't happen". Did Edmund Hilary have to prove he reached the summit of Everest? Even photos can deceive. Apparently, some don't even believe the moon landing occurred. It was a "grand deception" by NASA. I saw the moon landing in 1969 live, at any rate I believed it was live (could have been a replay or delayed telecast, for all I know, or just pure fabrication). I watched Neil Armstrong step down from the Lunar module (well, we were told it was Armstrong, but I've never met Armstrong, and behind the spacesuit I wouldn't recognise him from a bar of oatmeal soap), and utter the words "One small step for man....", or was it "one small step for a man.....". How does anyone know this was not doctored? So what of the skeptics (or should we call them "skeptics"?) who disbelieve the moon landing? What evidence do you have that all of what you saw, if you saw it, was not doctored by some magnificent collaboration between a Steven Spielberg and NASA?

I understand what you mean. Technically it is impossible to prove something to be 100% true.

The best we can do is to look at the quantity of evidence, and the quality of that evidence. For instance, a personal story does not have the same quality or weight to it that a scientific study does. Evidence that cannot be reproduced becomes subject to credibility issues. How can you tell if it was just a fluke, or if there was an alternate explanation if you cannot reproduce the results you saw?

I have thought about what I would do if something miraculous happened to me and I had no proof. What if aliens visited me, or suddenly a ball of multicolored light appeared in front of me and suddenly disappeared. I would have the personal experience to know that this happened to me, but I would not be able to prove it to anyone else. To everyone else it would just be a story, with no way for them to know if I'm lying, exaggerating, or am mistaken about what I saw. Even then I would have to admit that while the evidence is very strong for me because I saw it, I don't really know what I saw. There could be a logical explanation for it that I am just unaware of. I just wouldn't really know.

This is why your story may be enough evidence for you, but why it will do nothing for convincing anyone else. To convince a larger group or the masses you need a higher quantity and quality of evidence.
 
Last edited:
I've said this ad infinitum. And those who have chosen to email are attempting investigations/explanations. They are in a position to decide for themselves if mistakes were made, or if there are serious loopholes in the account. I appreciate the time and effort some of them have invested.
That is fine. But how can I actually know the truth of what you say when they are not allowed to discuss it?

Some years ago a bubble gum manufacturer sponsored an investigation into potential health benefit of his bubble gums. He claimed that the investigation gave no result, but the researchers were not allowed to speak publicly about the result of the investigation. How do you think this sat with the public?
 
You know, this is a great place to get good advice. So here I go again. I'm trying to line up a radio debate or something like that with this man:

http://www.afterlifenews.com/a/266.html
Mike Agostini.

I called into a radio show yesterday that was giving him a free run. When I talked about Randi's offer, he dismissed it as fake. Then he tried this tact, he asked me if I have ever been in love to which I answered yes. He then said prove it!

You see, his main line is that so many people have experiences (paranormal) that they cannot all be wrong, so there must be something in it. He also said that we could never agree on what reality was!

Another tact of his is to say that there is a mountain of scientific research that backs his claims. Even though this is false, it is very hard to dismiss on the spot.

So, over to you my dear JREF posting friends.

Richard, going back to your original post: What is reality?

Can you give me a definition?

Have scientists in laboratories decided what "reality" is?
 
Richard, going back to your original post: What is reality?

Can you give me a definition?

Have scientists in laboratories decided what "reality" is?

Yes. But we're not prepared to discuss it in a public forum, we'll only talk about it with a select few people via e-mail.
 
Richard, going back to your original post: What is reality?

Can you give me a definition?

Have scientists in laboratories decided what "reality" is?

Scientists in laboratories? What "reality" is?

Sorry Ray, this is not a real question and you know it. What, next your going to ask me if I have ever been in love? ( A really stupid question) and if I say 'yes' you'll ask me to prove it? Either you are interested in a real discussion or, as President Bartlett would say, 'your just yanking my chain.'
 
... You see, his main line is that so many people have experiences (paranormal) that they cannot all be wrong, so there must be something in it. ...

One counter-argument to this is modern media.

Since George Melies’ "A Trip to the Moon" in 1902, we can estimate conservatively an average of 200 films a year. Let's assume 50 hours of raw footage per film.
TV has been around since 1950 or thereabouts; assume an average of 100 series 25 episodes per per year, and 10 hours per episode.
Likewise home movie and video is about 50 years old, say around 100 million users, shooting 5 hours per year.
Finally, cellphone cameras -- 3 years old, 500 million users, 1 hour per year.

Film + TV + home video + cellphone = (100 x 200 x 50) + (50 x 100 x 25 x 10) + (50 x 100,000,000 x 5) + (3 x 500,000,000 x 1) = 1,000,000 + 1,250,000 + 25,000,000,000 + 1,000,000,000 = 26,502,250,000 hours recorded.

Average lifespan = 75 years; awake = 50 years x 365.25 x 24 = 438,300 hours.

Divide: that’s the equivalent of c. 60,000 waking lifetimes of empirical observation!

Yet, still no clear evidence of random paranormal occurrence to match the sensational anecdotes of paranormal witnesses?

This isn’t of course absolute proof either way (empirical science isn’t math) and never can be, but every second of film / video shot without clear evidence of the paranormal is further disconfirmation of the paranormal hypothesis.

And all it would take is a few seconds of clear footage to confirm it… :con2:

ETA: d-oh, forgot all about security cams!

What do you figure there are about a million of these things worldwide, running non-stop, for the past two decades maybe? That's 1,000,000 x 20 = 20,000,000 years / 50 = another 400,000 waking lifetimes!!! These should be the surest way to capture paranormal events, as security companies work to guarantee their fidelity and scan them for anomalies. Ever hear of a ghost appearing on a security tape, fairy godmother, object disappearing into thin air? Me neither. (Plus professional film -- e.g. police surveillance, corporate functions, special events, tv ads -- should tack on more than a few extra hours; other sources I may be forgetting; I'm guessing at least 500,000 waking lifetimes of moving visual records, all told; as we wait for that one clear image, and wait, and wait, and wait...) :slp:
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom