Ray Agostini
Thinker
- Joined
- Sep 16, 2007
- Messages
- 134
To put all people in the same boat for anything is a bad idea. It breeds things like racism, sexism, and stereotypes.
Ray, based on your posts you seem to lack a sufficient understanding as to why you get the responses you do.
The skeptics do have an agenda. We are tired. We are tired of people passing off lies as truth. We are tired of people making claims of special abilities, yet are unable to demonstrate them under proper scientific conditions. We are tired of people selling items that do not do what they claim. These things are detrimental to society as a whole. It results in people losing money to frauds, receiving bogus medical treatments instead of real ones, and can even result in a person breaking contact with their father because a psychic told them their dad was evil. And quite often these things are done for personal financial or popularity gain at the expense of others.
We are tired of this crap not only existing but flourishing. So our agenda is to stop it. To not just believe anything we are told, but to demand evidence which shows the claim to be true.
I can understand this point of view. In fact I have a great deal of empathy with it.
Your story is not evidence. Just as my story about how Santa Clause came and gave me presents many years ago is not evidence that Santa Clause is real. A story can be made up, exaggerated, or be mostly true with a few lies thrown in. If you had video taped evidence of whatever happened at your previous workplace, that may be different.
You also do not seem to understand that the burden of proof is upon the person making the claim. If I say that Santa is real, it is up to me to prove he is real. I do not ask you to prove that he isn't because it is impossible to prove a negative statement.
If you want anyone to take you or your paranormal beliefs seriously you will need to be able to give evidence in the form of a scientific experiment that is repeatable.
I have already acknowledged that this cannot be proved. But because something can't be proved under controlled scientific conditions, does not mean "it can't happen". Did Edmund Hilary have to prove he reached the summit of Everest? Even photos can deceive. Apparently, some don't even believe the moon landing occurred. It was a "grand deception" by NASA. I saw the moon landing in 1969 live, at any rate I believed it was live (could have been a replay or delayed telecast, for all I know, or just pure fabrication). I watched Neil Armstrong step down from the Lunar module (well, we were told it was Armstrong, but I've never met Armstrong, and behind the spacesuit I wouldn't recognise him from a bar of oatmeal soap), and utter the words "One small step for man....", or was it "one small step for a man.....". How does anyone know this was not doctored? So what of the skeptics (or should we call them "skeptics"?) who disbelieve the moon landing? What evidence do you have that all of what you saw, if you saw it, was not doctored by some magnificent collaboration between a Steven Spielberg and NASA?
My question is, where does skepticism stop, or at least, are there any boundaries? Do you agree that everyone, including skeptics, have to exercise a certain amount of faith, or trust, in what they see or hear?
Don't get me wrong, I'm not saying people should not be skeptical, but is there a boundary to skepticism?
Did Earnest Shackleton really go to the South Pole? How do we know this? Do I have to prove that Shackleton went there before I believe it? How would I prove it?
What evidence would you ask of Shackleton?

