More advice wanted

I won't PM my experience, because mods and others can read it.


...snip...

As Admin: That is not the case on this Forum. (Albeit it in principle with access to the server it could happen however that is the realms of paranoia akin to not using email because the staff at your ISP can read all of your emails or not using the postal system because the post man or woman could read your letters.)
 
Because Richard asked me to give "one example". So I replied that I would, (to appease the lions), and I said that IF he could explain my experience in naturalistic terms, I would agree. AND, if he could do this, I would publicly recant and admit that someone has an explanation. I am fair dinkum about this. If Richard can explain it, and I see his logic - I will admit I was wrong. But only after our personal exchanges - and his explanation. He made a public challenge, I responded publicly.

Ray, I have not received any message from you via the JREF 'send private message'. Do that and we can take it from there.

I have no idea if I will be able to explain whatever it is you have. There are many claims that we get that we cannot explain mainly due to the fact that they are just stories or ".. it happened to me.." type things. Or there are claims we get with a ton of paperwork 'proving' this or that in the eyes of the believer that turns out to be just a ton of paperwork. That's why we ask for a simple test, not endless explanations as to the theories behind whatever.

If I or the Skeptics cannot explain your claim it does not mean your claim is real. We cannot explain a claim of a Unicorn sighting, does that mean Unicorns are real? We need to test what we can.

Look at it this way, if you do some something you "know" is real, then we should be able to test it, yes? In fact while you are waiting, why not suggest a simple test of your claim we could try?
 
...the realms of paranoia akin to not using email because the staff at your ISP can read all of your emails or not using the postal system because the post man or woman could read your letters


​
 
I'm terrified. Big pussy looks hungry.

Seriously, why are you here? I've got no desire for you to go away, but I am bloody curious to know what your point is. You don't wish to discuss anything, you've been directed to PM Richard to take the matter further...and yet you've returned to the thread for some reason.

Please, feel free to entertain yourself. It's not like you can do any further damage. But I have no idea what your purpose is.

Athon
 
Seriously, why are you here? I've got no desire for you to go away, but I am bloody curious to know what your point is. You don't wish to discuss anything, you've been directed to PM Richard to take the matter further...and yet you've returned to the thread for some reason.

Richard has my email, not a PM. I await his reply.

Please, feel free to entertain yourself. It's not like you can do any further damage. But I have no idea what your purpose is.

Skeptics like to make fun of believers, so I'm having a little fun with the skeptics. Thank you for allowing me to entertain myself.
 
Ray Agostini said:
They are only temporary conditions, as I said, and only because it involves possible legal implications from a former workplace.

So why not just erase the name of the workplace and solve that problem?
Is the name of your former workplace so important to your claim?

Regards,
Yair
 
So why not just erase the name of the workplace and solve that problem?
Is the name of your former workplace so important to your claim?

Regards,
Yair

I don't believe for one minute Richard is a dill. He will understand why I'm keeping this private. For now anyway.
 
Oh and one more thing.
I wrote to you earlier (post #64) regarding the levitating shaman and the video to prove it. I said that this video is even better than anecdotal evidence. You can actually see the claim happening before your eyes.
In your opinion, is that sufficient evidence to prove that levitation is possible with only the power of the mind?

Regards,
Yair
 
Oh and one more thing.
I wrote to you earlier (post #64) regarding the levitating shaman and the video to prove it. I said that this video is even better than anecdotal evidence. You can actually see the claim happening before your eyes.
In your opinion, is that sufficient evidence to prove that levitation is possible with only the power of the mind?

Regards,
Yair

I'll have a look at it and get back to you. I missed that.
 
Oh and one more thing.
I wrote to you earlier (post #64) regarding the levitating shaman and the video to prove it. I said that this video is even better than anecdotal evidence. You can actually see the claim happening before your eyes.
In your opinion, is that sufficient evidence to prove that levitation is possible with only the power of the mind?

Regards,
Yair

This is not actually better than anecdotal, or written evidence. Trick photography can occur anywhere, which is why I'm also doubtful of UFO photography. I dismiss almost all of that. I would need to speak to the photographers, and, if necessary, put them under a lie detector test. A person's sincerity can often be judged by direct, eye to eye contact, so I have little faith in any kind of photography trying to prove anything through this medium. This, in particular, would be very easy to recreate on the Internet. I'm not saying it didn't, or couldn't happen, but a clip on You Tube proves absolutely nothing. You might as well watch cartoons and believe they are real.
 
Ray Agostini said:
This is not actually better than anecdotal, or written evidence. Trick photography can occur anywhere, which is why I'm also doubtful of UFO photography. I dismiss almost all of that. I would need to speak to the photographers, and, if necessary, put them under a lie detector test. A person's sincerity can often be judged by direct, eye to eye contact, so I have little faith in any kind of photography trying to prove anything through this medium. This, in particular, would be very easy to recreate on the Internet. I'm not saying it didn't, or couldn't happen, but a clip on You Tube proves absolutely nothing. You might as well watch cartoons and believe they are real.
I'm glad this is what you think. At least we can agree on something.
But now I ask you what makes your written story evidence more convincing than this case?
In the case of the levitation, the photographer could have written you the exact thing that you've watched in the video and swear that it was true plus add a video bonus. All you have is the written story and no video.
Why do you think you can convince anyone that your story is true and has a paranormal claim when you yourself don't believe other claims that are written and backed up with videos?

Regards,
Yair
 
I'm glad this is what you think. At least we can agree on something.
But now I ask you what makes your written story evidence more convincing than this case?
In the case of the levitation, the photographer could have written you the exact thing that you've watched in the video and swear that it was true plus add a video bonus. All you have is the written story and no video.
Why do you think you can convince anyone that your story is true and has a paranormal claim when you yourself don't believe other claims that are written and backed up with videos?

Regards,
Yair

I will let Richard judge that. If he has an explanation I can believe, I will accept it. So far, I have had none. The problem, too, is that what we think is paranormal today, may actually have a "natural" explanation in the future. What would a cave man think of modern computers? They would have to be paranormal, as far as he's concerned. Remember that film about the Kalahari?
 
Last edited:
But now I ask you what makes your written story evidence more convincing than this case?

SNIP

Why do you think you can convince anyone that your story is true and has a paranormal claim when you yourself don't believe other claims that are written and backed up with videos?

Regards,
Yair

I am not trying to "convince" anyone. I know it happened, and I want some explanations, even if they are only opinions.

I will not set myself up to ridicule for an experience which had a very traumatic on me.
 
Last edited:
Ray Agostini said:
The problem, too, is that what we think is paranormal today, may actually have a "natural" explanation in the future. What would a cave man think of modern computers? They would have to be paranormal, as far as he's concerned.

That's not true Ray. If the caveman was an open minded person and we'd show him that again and again we can perform what we claim with pure physics and proven evidence than he'd not think it was paranormal.

Regards,
Yair
 
Ray Agostini said:
I am not trying to "convince" anyone. I know it happened, and I want some explanations, even if they are only opinions.
You said before that we need to keep an open mind. It seems now that you are the closed minded person if you already KNOW that some paranormal phenomenon happened to you and apparently nothing will convince you otherwise.

Regards,
Yair
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom