More advice wanted

That's not true Ray. If the caveman was an open minded person and we'd show him that again and again we can perform what we claim with pure physics and proven evidence than he'd not think it was paranormal.

Regards,
Yair

How? Algebra can be traced back to the Babylonians, but was only perfected by Arabic scholars in the 9th century. And you expect a cave man to even begin to grasp this? You might as well try teaching your cat Portuguese.
 
That's not true Ray. If the caveman was an open minded person and we'd show him that again and again we can perform what we claim with pure physics and proven evidence than he'd not think it was paranormal.

Regards,
Yair

That's exactly the case. The caveman might say 'if that amazing thing is true, I would observe X. Show me X, and I'll believe it is true'. You could then show him X, demonstrating to him that your explanation for the phemomena he observed was true. That stands then as it does now. Anecdotes have no place in demonstrating the validity of a claim. None at all.

Which brings us to this. We've all asked how an anecdote could provide any strong evidence at all. You avoid this point as you know it is the weakness in your argument. This anecdote has zero strength.

Athon
 
I am not trying to "convince" anyone. I know it happened, and I want some explanations, even if they are only opinions.

And there we go - more evidence that it's not skeptics which are the closed minded ones...

Athon
 
Which brings us to this. We've all asked how an anecdote could provide any strong evidence at all. You avoid this point as you know it is the weakness in your argument. This anecdote has zero strength.

Athon

Fine by me, but as far as my experience goes, "I know the earth revolves around the sun", and I don't care what "the Church" says. The Church of the Scholars, or the Church of the Skeptics.
 
Well I have read Ray's account. I will, as I try to be a man of my word, not give out the details as I can see that could harm Ray. I will say that I have suggested to Ray that I think it was not supernatural. I have no firm answer as to what really happened as I was not there and am relying 100% on Ray's account. It is also something that we cannot really test, as it boils down to a 'the is what happened to me' account and not a repeatable event.

Here is part of my letter to Ray, not giving away any of his letter me to..

----

I am far from leaping to the supernatural as an answer. In fact
something like this once happened to me years ago. A fax popped out of
my fax machine one day and before I could catch it, it fell off the
machine and onto the floor.... so I thought. When I bent down to pick
it up, it was gone. It was about 2 seconds after it fell off the
machine, yet it had just gone and I mean not on the floor, not on the
machine... nowhere. At last I found out that it had slipped as it fell
and fluttered down into the tiny paper-thin gap between the draws
under the fax machine. A one in a million chance but nevertheless, it
happened. If I had never looked in the gap, I might to this day never
know.

-----

But, thanks Ray for being open-minded enough to look for the possibility of a rational answer.
 
Ray Agostini said:
How? Algebra can be traced back to the Babylonians, but was only perfected by Arabic scholars in the 9th century. And you expect a cave man to even begin to grasp this? You might as well try teaching your cat Portuguese.
No Ray, the caveman does not need to know the theory behind what I show him the same as the JREF challenge does not need to know the theory behind paranormal claims in order for them to win the $1M.
If a person is open minded and is shown time and again that some phenomenon is predictable or that a claim is backed up with hardcore evidence that are repeatable than there's no need for him to assume that the claim is paranormal. Why assume the paranormal when other more reasonable explanations exist? Optical illusions are in the realm of reasonable explanations as they happen all the time all over the world.

Regards,
Yair
 
Fine by me, but as far as my experience goes, "I know the earth revolves around the sun", and I don't care what "the Church" says. The Church of the Scholars, or the Church of the Skeptics.

Then again, why bother? You've closed your mind completely to concepts of evidence and of science, choosing to villify anything which conflicts with your view. You are satisfied with your answer, regardless of whether it may or may not reflect reality. So why feign the process of discussion, when it isn't what you're interested in doing at all?

The irony of your accusing us of being dogmatic and closed minded is overflowing.

Athon
 
Ray, this is a short part of Rober Park's "Science In The Courts" article found here: http://www.nesl.edu/lawrev/vol36/3/park.pdf
It tells you just how open minded science is which is the main reason that science is so powerful and has so many credits in our everyday life. I think everybody should adapt this method in order to stay in the realms of reality.

"...Now if I come up with a discovery, the first thing that I am
going to do is talk to my colleagues and see if they can point to a mistake
in my measurements or reasoning. I will then probably present my work
at a departmental colloquium. And, if nobody in the department jumps on
me, I will probably give a paper on my new discovery at a scientific conference and if I get away with that, I will probably submit my discovery to a scientific journal which will send it out to a bunch of anonymous reviewers who would like nothing better than to tear me apart, and I go all the way through the process. We rely on our colleagues to keep us straight in science, and this is very important."

Regards,
Yair​
 
I am not trying to "convince" anyone. I know it happened, and I want some explanations, even if they are only opinions.

I will not set myself up to ridicule for an experience which had a very traumatic on me.


Ray, it starts when boys get to a certain age, a state in their development called 'puberty'.

The simplest thing is to change your own bedding.

We already know about it.
 
Ray, it starts when boys get to a certain age, a state in their development called 'puberty'.

The simplest thing is to change your own bedding.

We already know about it.

Sounds like an insult, to me. Then the mods wonder why I traded insults. Is there some kind of moderation bias here?
 
Optical illusions are in the realm of reasonable explanations as they happen all the time all over the world.

It was not an "optical illusion". You haven't even read the experience, yet you have drawn this conclusion. So much for "objectivity". There are skeptics, and there are skeptics. One looks for the truth, the other dictates truth.
 
Last edited:
Ray, this is a short part of Rober Park's "Science In The Courts" article found here: http://www.nesl.edu/lawrev/vol36/3/park.pdf
It tells you just how open minded science is which is the main reason that science is so powerful and has so many credits in our everyday life. I think everybody should adapt this method in order to stay in the realms of reality.

"...Now if I come up with a discovery, the first thing that I am
going to do is talk to my colleagues and see if they can point to a mistake
in my measurements or reasoning. I will then probably present my work
at a departmental colloquium. And, if nobody in the department jumps on
me, I will probably give a paper on my new discovery at a scientific conference and if I get away with that, I will probably submit my discovery to a scientific journal which will send it out to a bunch of anonymous reviewers who would like nothing better than to tear me apart, and I go all the way through the process. We rely on our colleagues to keep us straight in science, and this is very important."

Regards,
Yair​

I agree. I am perfectly willing to be "torn apart". But just make sure you have all the facts before you have me for lunch.
 
It was not an "optical illusion". You haven't even read the experience, yet you drawn this conclusion. So much for "objectivity". There are skeptics, and there are skeptics. One looks for the truth, the other dictates truth.

There are observers and there are observers:
  • one draws closer and closer, mesmerised by the colours and shapes that PROOVE its magic
  • one stands back and sees a $5 kaleidoscope
 
Give me a break. I am willing to pay for the best delusions, and FULL price. Why would I look into an El Cheapo when I can delude myself with the best?


Retail isn't my field, but I am familair with the maxim that states "no-one has ever won an argument with a customer"

Cetainly sir! We have this model from Zeiss... a mere trifle at $42k... would you like it gift wrapped?

Would you like fries with that?
 
Last edited:
Retail isn't my field, but I am familair with the maxim that states "no-one has ever won an argument with a customer"

Cetainly sir! We have this model from Zeiss... a mere trifle at $42k... would you like it gift wrapped?

Would you like fries with that?

The customer is always right. But in my job, I can kick customers out, if I want, because it's an "essential service". I love these liberties. Just inflates my ego and sense of importance, and, of course, my gross delusions of grandeur. But I go home feeling fine, thank you. A boost to a deflated ego is charity for the poor in spirit.
 
Well Ray I just read your story and you've convinced me. The paranormal exists. I hereby renounce scepticism and I solemnly swear to start trolling these message boards as a sign of my new faith............

Just kidding but I will admit that it is a very strange story and I cannot immediately think of a rational explanation other than 'you're lying/delusional'

man i bet everyone who hasn't read Ray's story is going nuts with curiousity by now! :D
 
Well Ray I just read your story and you've convinced me. The paranormal exists. I hereby renounce scepticism and I solemnly swear to start trolling these message boards as a sign of my new faith............

Just kidding but I will admit that it is a very strange story and I cannot immediately think of a rational explanation other than 'you're lying/delusional'

man i bet everyone who hasn't read Ray's story is going nuts with curiousity by now! :D

Thank you, Dan. I'm a pathetic liar, and delusional. As you can so clearly see, I invented all of this. I could outdo Harry Potter, if I could get off my lazy, lying ass.

Just kidding, too. :D
 
Well I have read Ray's account...<snip/>
It is also something that we cannot really test...<snip/>
I am far from leaping to the supernatural as an answer...<snip/>
But, thanks Ray for being open-minded enough to look for the possibility of a rational answer.

...just make sure you have all the facts <snip/>

So... what happens next?

Are there other options for testing the claim?
 
So... what happens next?

Are there other options for testing the claim?

What happens next? Absolutely nothing. The world turns, Ray continues to preserve his beliefs from being questioned, and science, again, comes out the winner.

You didn't think anything different would occur this time, did you?

Athon
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom