More advice wanted

But you, you have your stories. Magnificant stories of powers beyond our wildest imaginations and mocking of science. That's very arrogant of you don't you think?

The best part is that he is willing to claim that said story happened to everyone here and that it is evidence, but refuses the details. If this is a touchy subject, then why did he bring it up in the first place?
 
Correction; science makes no claim to have answers, as it is a process used to arrive at a point of confidence. Indeed, one must remain open minded, yet this amounts to considering evidence as having weight, not that all speculations are equally possible.

Am I open to the observations associated with Near Death Experiences equating the transfer of a soul? Hell yeah. It would be amazing to investigate such a novel field in science. However for me to have confidence in it existing in spite of my opinion of it, so magnificent would such a discovery be, I would need strong evidence which could not be explained through any other means.

The evidence is there. But do you want to see it? I could beat you over the head with it, but would you see it? Unlikely.


You didn't read what I said, either by choice or mistake. So I'll ask again - what makes this evidence (regardless of what it constitutes) unexplicable through any other explanation, including complete fabrication, bias or misperception? Assuming I have a completely unbiased mind (indeed, impossible, however bear in mind I would actually want NDE to represent an actual phenomena, for the potential understanding of the universe we could get from it), how would I distinguish your evidence as having strength while any other anecdote might not?

I think you meant "inexplicable". Simple: read the evidence.


Again, you missed what I said. Science strives to be objective. It is a goal, however much we might miss it. Therefore we must ensure we put into action certain methods which circumvent our own hopes, biases and expectations. That way it doesn't matter what I beleive - if the test results in a given observation, then we have good evidence in support of a claim.

You at least sound sincere. What you or I believe matters not. Only the truth matters, and that is not always easy to arrive at.



The observations are real, I grant you that. The phenomena might well not be explained through mechanisms other than illusion, neurology and chemistry.



Explain.

Indeed. I want the skeptics to explain, but it seems they prefer dogma.



Why would it need to be a 'mass illusion'? If it results from one's physiology, it would be possible for many people to experience similar phenomena. It need not be chance, but the result of something already explainable.

Which is?............I would love an explanation.



I'm not sure how you arrive at the conclusion that I don't believe in love. I've felt that closeness, the empathy for another person. I have a fiancee I adore. I believe in the sense. I believe in the poetry of it, the need to express it. I believe her when she tells me she loves me, as it is evidenced in her actions.

The fact it can be explained through chemistry and biology makes it only more amazing. To think this computer I'm writing on is electrical pulses and circuits, yet it is capable of producing the most beautiful sounds and images. Being able to feel might result from nothing more than chemical mechanics, but that doesn't diminish its beauty. Not one spot.

There need not be a 'ghost in the machine' - afterall, were we to find it, we'd only go in search of the 'machine in the ghost'. All ghosts are essentially machines. And there is nothing more beautiful than that thought.

I've heard of the "ghost in the machine". But I've never heard that "all ghosts are machines". We are all machines? Good God, who am I? I am only a machine. I only think while the machine works. I could be a washing machine.
I only feel "chemical reactions". I am nothing but sophisticated nuts and bolts. A think-tank created by Hoover. I am sophisticated metal. Nothing else. I only think when plugged in. Apart from that, there is NO reality.


Yes. Until I have reason to believe otherwise. We exist at the whim of rules and laws; science is based on the very notion that all actions are relatively consistent with time and space. If you don't believe that, we have no discussion, as science is built on that very tenet.

Sorry to disappoint, but science is built on NO "tenets". Religion is. Maybe skepticism is a religion?

If all things are rules and laws, all fragments of that can be expressed as a consistent set of rules. Those we define by physics in order to keep track of them, and to make sensible predictions. It sounds very mechanical, however to not define all things in terms of consistent descriptions means we have no means of describing anything. Oddly enough, it's yet to be seen as wrong. The universe does seem to be made of consistent rules. If we have souls, they too must be consistent, must interact with the physics of reality, and must be subject to those consistent rules. Souls too would have a set of mechanics.

If soul mechanics get better money than car mechanics, I'm all for better industrial awards. Sorry to be so cynical, but this is crap.

Are some things more than the sum of their parts? Of course. Yet that doesn't make them less consistent or mechanical - it simply means they have a more complex set of definitions.

I would say a Hoover mechanic is better than a Simpson mechanic. I could be wrong, though. Hoover's are too "mechanical" for my way of thinking. I think they should be more spiritual, like Simpson. This is, surely, where we will find the answers to the universe - in washing machine mechanics. They think like humans, they act like humans, and they love like humans. Very valid comparisons. We are all "chemical reactions". All "machines". Washing machines, car machines...who cares? Same genre. "WE think, therefore we am". And we only think when the plug is in. Pull the plug, and we are nothing but metal. Pure metal.



It is an anecdote of an experience, yes? Or have I missed something? It will appear as text in my email box (should I agree to reading it), hence have an author...and therefore is an anecdotal account? I would be forced to make assumptions, such as the anecdote having factual merit, and therefore would be speculating. Again, how would this contribute anything? How would this speculation contain any more merit than if it were based on an anecdote that was totally fabricated?

I dunno. After all, I'm just a Hoover. I only think while the clothes need washing. Pull the plug, and that is the end of me. I think no more, therefore: I am not.



You're more than welcome to explain what you experienced, either here or privately. However I fail to see what it offers. How would I distinguish it from a fabrication of an event, an illusion or a misperception or an exaggeration? Bear in mind I'm not accusing you necessarily of any of these, however I am asking how I would see your evidence as having merit while these things themselves all carry possible weight explaining what I would read.

Athon

Like I said. You don't have to believe me. I'm only a sophisticated washing machine with "chemical reactions".

Pull the plug, and I am gone forever.
 
The best part is that he is willing to claim that said story happened to everyone here and that it is evidence, but refuses the details. If this is a touchy subject, then why did he bring it up in the first place?

Huh? Which planet you on, abnormal dude? Did you read my statements, or massacre them?

Please refer to your Membership Agreement, this post in in breach of Rule 12.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So funny you say that as all the evidence you have in the world for your claims is words words words and worn out cliches about stories we've all heard hundreds of times from hundreds of people with your kind or other kinds of claims.
Yair

"Your kind...Your kind." And what is "your kind", yair? "Enlightened skeptics"? Know alls? "Your kind". If you are a truth-seeker, then I'm a Congo banana ready to be picked. I'm ripe with delusion. Yellow-ripe delusion. And you love it. Keep picking on bananas. I've gone from a Hoover washing machine to a banana...now if that isn't proof of evolution. "I think, therefore me is". Did I get DeCarty write? After all, I'm ony a wash machine. A "chemical reaction". I think until someone pulls the plug. Did I get the quote write, or is that just a chemical reaction?
 
Great. Already on to insults I see. :rolleyes:

I only insult those who think I'm a washing machine. You got a prob with that,
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Membership Agreement removed
? Did you defend my brother when he was accused of "lying his ass off"? With NO evidence.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
But you, you have your stories. Magnificant stories of powers beyond our wildest imaginations and mocking of science. That's very arrogant of you don't you think?

Regards,
Yair

I think it's very arrogant of you, since you have read NOTHING about my experiences, and know NOTHING about them. But this is what I expect from "skeptics", who are, in fact, total debunkers of anything which does not suit their worldview. Your blatant dogma is UNsuprising.
 
I only insult those who think I'm a washing machine. You got a prob with that,
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Membership Agreement removed
? Did you defend my brother when he was accused of "lying his ass off"? With NO evidence.

First off, other than the degree thing, which is now resolved, I haven't commented on your brother. Without hearing any of the program, I'm not going to comment on it. It's also not my job or responsibility to step in to defend some stranger that I've never heard of and know nothing of.

My comment on your story still stands. If you are not willing to divulge details in public, you should never have brought it up in public in the first place. If I came to you in a public place and said I knew your brother was lying, but refused to say why I knew this and that you should simply take my word for it, what would your reaction be?

You've becoming increasingly abusive and aggressive since the moment you appeared here. You are obviously emotional and not thinking clearly at the moment. I suggest you back off from the keyboard and do something else.

ETA: Edited for typos.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I think it's very arrogant of you, since you have read NOTHING about my experiences, and know NOTHING about them. But this is what I expect from "skeptics", who are, in fact, total debunkers of anything which does not suit their worldview.

How could we possibly know anything about your experiences when you refuse to tell us anything about them? How can we know if something goes against our worldview if we don't know what it is? Seriously, if you want to have a sensible debate about how your experiences could be explained you have to actually tell us what they were. As has already been pointed out, it won't prove anything since they are merely anecdotes, but even anecdote is better than nothing at all.

Incidentally, you do realise it is only possible to debunk something that is in fact bunk? By saying we are debunkers of anything that does not suit our worldview, you are in fact saying that our worldview is in fact correct and anything else, including your own, is bunk. You should probably remember in future that "debunker" is not actually an insult.
 
Ray Agostini said:
But this is what I expect from "skeptics", who are, in fact, total debunkers of anything which does not suit their worldview.
Science is subjective. It is not my worldview nor your worldview nor their worldview. It is nature's laws. We know this based on hard evidence which has been repeated over and over and over again by many scientists over many years in many different parts of the world (which limits the biasing of the observers and proposes different conditions for the tests).

How do you live with your knowing so much about nature (or think you know so much) and yet can do nothing with it because your claims are not repeatable?

Regards,
Yair
 
Last edited:
I only insult those who think I'm a washing machine. You got a prob with that,
Edited by Darat: 
Breach of Membership Agreement removed
? Did you defend my brother when he was accused of "lying his ass off"? With NO evidence.

Please do so. Who would want to agree with this codswallop?
 
I don't care much for the actual topic here, but Ray you really need to chill.
 
How could we possibly know anything about your experiences when you refuse to tell us anything about them? How can we know if something goes against our worldview if we don't know what it is? Seriously, if you want to have a sensible debate about how your experiences could be explained you have to actually tell us what they were. As has already been pointed out, it won't prove anything since they are merely anecdotes, but even anecdote is better than nothing at all.

Incidentally, you do realise it is only possible to debunk something that is in fact bunk? By saying we are debunkers of anything that does not suit our worldview, you are in fact saying that our worldview is in fact correct and anything else, including your own, is bunk. You should probably remember in future that "debunker" is not actually an insult.

Do you have a problem with PLAIN English? Read what I wrote. When you understandy, let me know.
 
First off, other than the degree thing, which is now resolved, I haven't commented on your brother. Without hearing any of the program, I'm not going to comment on it. It's also not my job or responsibility to step in to defend some stranger that I've never heard of and know nothing of.

My comment on your story still stands. If you are not willing to divulge details in public, you should never have brought it up in public in the first place. If I came to you in a public place and said I knew your brother was lying, but refused to say why I knew this and that you should simply take my word for it, what would your reaction be?

You've becoming increasingly abusive and aggressive since the moment you appeared here. You are obviously emotional and not thinking clearly at the moment. I suggest you back off from the keyboard and do something else.

ETA: Edited for typos.

I already explained why I will not divulge this publicly. My invitation was to Richard Saunders, not you. Richard has not given me any details of where I can send this too. He obviously does not want to read anything that will confront his worldview. I'm prepared to send this to the head skeptics, privately, and await their answer. If that bugs you, then go do something else.
 
I already explained why I will not divulge this publicly. My invitation was to Richard Saunders, not you. Richard has not given me any details of where I can send this too. He obviously does not want to read anything that will confront his worldview. I'm prepared to send this to the head skeptics, privately, and await their answer. If that bugs you, then go do something else.

Then why didn't you PM him about it? You bring something up in a public forum for legitimacy, expect the public to respond to it.
 
The evidence is there. But do you want to see it? I could beat you over the head with it, but would you see it? Unlikely.

This is a convenient reaction for you to have, regardless of how truthful it might be - if I agree with the evidence, you're vindicated. If I disagree, I simply don't see what you see, and you remain vindicated. Therefore your conclusion remains unchallenged. This is the very thing you've been accusing skeptics of, and yet your own conclusions remain concrete and unable to be challenged.

I think you meant "inexplicable". Simple: read the evidence.

I apologise for the typo. As for 'read the evidence', you continue to refuse to address my point. On completion of reading it, how would I distinguish your evidence as having strength where other contradictory anecdotes might not? Simply reading it will not address this.

Why is this a sticking point for you? PM me the account and I'll happily read it, however it still won't address that point, no matter what it says.

Which is?............I would love an explanation.

Notice I never said we have a complete explanation. We don't. There are numerous indicators that support it could well have a neurochemical explanation, however nothing has been concluded.

It is beside the point. The neurochemical hypothesis for the observations is far more likely to produce an explanation than one that requires evidence for a soul and an afterlife, purely on the grounds that potential mechanisms exist. To entertain the possibility of a soul as the cause for NDE observations, evidence for a soul must be produced. Evidence for the effect of neurochemistry on NDE-like experiences already has that evidence.

I've heard of the "ghost in the machine". But I've never heard that "all ghosts are machines". We are all machines? Good God, who am I? I am only a machine. I only think while the machine works. I could be a washing machine. I only feel "chemical reactions". I am nothing but sophisticated nuts and bolts. A think-tank created by Hoover. I am sophisticated metal. Nothing else. I only think when plugged in. Apart from that, there is NO reality.

Ah, so the facetious, nonsensical responses now begin. Strange how the sensible debate now disintegrates when you run out of counterpoints and feel the need to turn the discussion into something flippant. I strongly doubt that you don't see the context I use the term 'machine' in.

Sorry to disappoint, but science is built on NO "tenets". Religion is. Maybe skepticism is a religion?

As Darat said, maybe the term 'axiom' is more familiar.

If soul mechanics get better money than car mechanics, I'm all for better industrial awards. Sorry to be so cynical, but this is crap.

Why is it crap?

I dunno. After all, I'm just a Hoover. I only think while the clothes need washing. Pull the plug, and that is the end of me. I think no more, therefore: I am not.

Like I said. You don't have to believe me. I'm only a sophisticated washing machine with "chemical reactions".

Pull the plug, and I am gone forever.

Again, flippant nonsense rather than anything of substance. Why pretend to discuss something if you have no desire to consider any alternatives to your point of view?

I've been quite open to anything you've had to say, and your responses are now full of ridicule and insults. Who was accusing who of having preformed conclusions and being dogmatic and closeminded? :rolleyes:

Athon
 
Then why didn't you PM him about it? You bring something up in a public forum for legitimacy, expect the public to respond to it.

Because Richard asked me to give "one example". So I replied that I would, (to appease the lions), and I said that IF he could explain my experience in naturalistic terms, I would agree. AND, if he could do this, I would publicly recant and admit that someone has an explanation. I am fair dinkum about this. If Richard can explain it, and I see his logic - I will admit I was wrong. But only after our personal exchanges - and his explanation. He made a public challenge, I responded publicly.
 
I already explained why I will not divulge this publicly. My invitation was to Richard Saunders, not you. Richard has not given me any details of where I can send this too. He obviously does not want to read anything that will confront his worldview. I'm prepared to send this to the head skeptics, privately, and await their answer. If that bugs you, then go do something else.

Richard already said to PM him. I also offered, if you're reluctant to send it to Richard. If you're not sure how, just click on the name and a menu comes up.

However I can say up front that I can't see what difference it would make. It would not constitute evidence any more than any anecdotal account would. This is not running and hiding, or being close minded or stubborn - it would simply be that a block of text detailing an experience of some sort is an anecdote. You're yet to say how it could be shown that it would not be a complete fabrication, an exaggeration, a biased view or a misperception. If you cannot say that, how would anybody be expected to give it credibility above any other anecdote?

Athon
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom