More advice wanted

Richard already said to PM him. I also offered, if you're reluctant to send it to Richard. If you're not sure how, just click on the name and a menu comes up.

I know how to work forums, thank you. I said I don't want this to be a PM, but an email. Understand?

However I can say up front that I can't see what difference it would make. It would not constitute evidence any more than any anecdotal account would. This is not running and hiding, or being close minded or stubborn - it would simply be that a block of text detailing an experience of some sort is an anecdote. You're yet to say how it could be shown that it would not be a complete fabrication, an exaggeration, a biased view or a misperception. If you cannot say that, how would anybody be expected to give it credibility above any other anecdote?

Stop speculating. I said, and I will repeat - this is for Richard, and it will only be through email.

Got that?
 
I know how to work forums, thank you. I said I don't want this to be a PM, but an email. Understand?

I fail to see the difference. But as I said, regardless, the entire exercise is pointless unless you provide reasons as to why this account has more credibility than any other anecdote.

Stop speculating. I said, and I will repeat - this is for Richard, and it will only be through email.

Got that?
Ah, so the conversation has gone from discussing this in polite debate, through insults and flippancy on your behalf, to now closed discussion. You've now done little but show everybody that you have no real desire to discuss the topic, but rather cling tenaciously to your belief and avoid having it challenged at all, using as your sole means of argument a pointless exercise that, as you well know, would do nothing to substantiate your claim.

If Richard were to read the account and admit he could provide only limited evidence for a natural explanation, it would still offer no support to your claim, as you cannot demonstrate your anecdote is free of misperception or misinformation.

Athon
 
Ray Agostini, if you have time go to this link:
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=91751&highlight=shaman+levitation

The guy posting it has even better than anecdotal evidence of people being able to levitate using only the power of their minds. He has an actual video of it for everybody to see.
Do you think this is enough to be regarded as proof that levitation is actually possible with only the power of the mind?
I'd like to hear what you think about this. Is this kind of levitation possible relying on the evidence at hand?

Regards,
Yair
 
Last edited:
I think ray is saying. First assume that my experience happened in exactly the way i describe it then try and explain it as if that was what really happened to me. Obviously accusing him of lying (even if this was the case) wouldn't be a very satisfying explanation of it for anyone.


Ray: PM Richard already and tell him the story! If you want to send it to an email rather than a PM, PM Richard and ask for his email address.
 
I think ray is saying. First assume that my experience happened in exactly the way i describe it then try and explain it as if that was what really happened to me. Obviously accusing him of lying (even if this was the case) wouldn't be a very satisfying explanation of it for anyone.

The thing is, nobody is accusing him of lying. Nobody is making any accusation. That's not the point.

For an anecdote to be useful as an observation in support of a claim, all of the possible causes for that observation (the anecdote itself) must be considered and compared. The anecdote could have been caused by an accurate recollection of an actual observation (which says nothing of the mechanism, just of the sensing of the phenomena), or it could be a misperception (we know people misperceive things), or a lie (we know people fabricate stories) or an exaggeration (we know people are capable of exaggerating, both intentionally and accidentally).

All of these things are possible, with some more likely than others. The one thing an anecdotal recollection of an observation doesn't do is accurately describe a mechanism. The closest it does is describe the sensation resulting from the mechanism.

In the end, an anecdotal account is as close to useless as it gets. Yet Ray clings to it as he has nothing else.

Athon
 
I fail to see the difference. But as I said, regardless, the entire exercise is pointless unless you provide reasons as to why this account has more credibility than any other anecdote.

Ah, so the conversation has gone from discussing this in polite debate, through insults and flippancy on your behalf, to now closed discussion. You've now done little but show everybody that you have no real desire to discuss the topic, but rather cling tenaciously to your belief and avoid having it challenged at all, using as your sole means of argument a pointless exercise that, as you well know, would do nothing to substantiate your claim.

If Richard were to read the account and admit he could provide only limited evidence for a natural explanation, it would still offer no support to your claim, as you cannot demonstrate your anecdote is free of misperception or misinformation.

Athon

I am not, and don't intend to "demonstrate" anything to you. Stay in your closet cocoon of unbelief, for all I care.

If Richard can explain this to me, I will listen. Not to your taunts. Do your dummy spits elsewhere.
 
In the end, an anecdotal account is as close to useless as it gets. Yet Ray clings to it as he has nothing else.

Athon

Thank you for making an acute observation based on the email I sent you. Your objectivity is worthy of the Congressional Medal of Honor.
 
The thing is, nobody is accusing him of lying. Nobody is making any accusation. That's not the point.

For an anecdote to be useful as an observation in support of a claim, all of the possible causes for that observation (the anecdote itself) must be considered and compared. The anecdote could have been caused by an accurate recollection of an actual observation (which says nothing of the mechanism, just of the sensing of the phenomena), or it could be a misperception (we know people misperceive things), or a lie (we know people fabricate stories) or an exaggeration (we know people are capable of exaggerating, both intentionally and accidentally).

All of these things are possible, with some more likely than others. The one thing an anecdotal recollection of an observation doesn't do is accurately describe a mechanism. The closest it does is describe the sensation resulting from the mechanism.

In the end, an anecdotal account is as close to useless as it gets. Yet Ray clings to it as he has nothing else.

Athon

sorry i also meant, ray wants us to suspend our disbelief entirely. Assume that his story happened in exactly the way he decribes it (if he ever does get round to describing it). i.e. discount all explanations that fall under , hallucination, exagerration, mis remembering, lying etc.

The question he wants answered is IF his story happened in exactly the way he described it, how can you explain it rationally?

Obviously from a scientific stndpoint it is useless as evidence because as you athon have rightly pointed out, the question of how he can show that he wasn't lying, mis rmembering hallucinating etc still (i.e. what distinguishes his story from fiction?), in reality, stands...
 
I am not, and don't intend to "demonstrate" anything to you. Stay in your closet cocoon of unbelief, for all I care.

Huh? I ask for evidence, explanations, and seek to understand your line of reasoning by asking you to explain how your sole suggestion of evidence, an anecdote, could be considered strong...and you suggest I'm remaing in a 'closest cocoon of unbelief'? I could be more polite, or more inquisitive to your position, and still you choose to ignore everything.

If Richard can explain this to me, I will listen. Not to your taunts. Do your dummy spits elsewhere.


How is Richard your sole saviour in this? I've already pointed out how this is a pointless exercise. He either delivers you a natural explanation, and your position is forfitted, or he doesn't, yet your anecdote has no substance, so it doesn't support your position anyway...still making it forfit. Either way you end up with nothing.

As for 'dummy spits', I count zero warnings against me in this thread. How many have you received?

Thank you for making an acute observation based on the email I sent you. Your objectivity is worthy of the Congressional Medal of Honor.

Once again you ignore the content of what I say. Sadly, your brother hasn't had an opportunity to make any claims himself here, and yet you seem to be making a mockery of his position on his behalf. Maybe you should stop now before you really do some serious damage.

To be honest, I think Richard is doing the both of you a real favour by not accepting your account. You've kind of screwed either way if he does.

Athon
 
sorry i also meant, ray wants us to suspend our disbelief entirely. Assume that his story happened in exactly the way he decribes it (if he ever does get round to describing it). i.e. discount all explanations that fall under , hallucination, exagerration, mis remembering, lying etc.

The question he wants answered is IF his story happened in exactly the way he described it, how can you explain it rationally?

Obviously from a scientific stndpoint it is useless as evidence because as you athon have rightly pointed out, the question of how he can show that he wasn't lying, mis rmembering hallucinating etc still (i.e. what distinguishes his story from fiction?), in reality, stands...

I recommend you take a course in spelling. After you do that, get to some grammar school. I will even send you a check ("cheque" in Oz) to help. You really need it. Can I help? I am very humanitarian. I love people. I honestlolyy do. There, I even made a mistake to make you feel good. We are not all purrrrfect.
 
I recommend you take a course in spelling. After you do that, get to some grammar school. I will even send you a check ("cheque" in Oz) to help. You really need it. Can I help? I am very humanitarian. I love people. I honestlolyy do. There, I even made a mistake to make you feel good. We are not all purrrrfect.

Not perfect, by any means, but you are also extremely arrogant to boot. Keep in mind this is a global bulletin board, with many from non-English speaking backgrounds. I couldn't do half as good as this guy in Spanish, French, German, Chinese...or any other language.

Now that you've displayed yourself as rude, obnoxious, evasive and arrogant, I guess we can all see that the one thing you don't have is a valid argument.

Well, that was short and sweet.

Athon
 
Ray, thanks for a good laugh.
The way you failed so abysmally to answer Athlon's well conceived points, and then resorted to attacking something so irrelevant such as a few typos was really quite amusing.
Your display of evasiveness, and failure to grasp concepts was truly impressive.

Please keep posting, i am eager to see what tactic you resort to next.
 
Way to completely dodge the questions there Ray.

I've PM'd you my email address so why don't you want to tell me your story?

I wasn't even trying to be rude to you before so I don't know why you reacted so angrily. I apologise that spelling and grammar isn't my highest priority when commenting on forums whilst at work.

But if you really are willing to pay me to "get to some grammar school" whatever that means then I'll be happy to accept a cheque. :)
 
Ray, thanks for a good laugh.

Precisely the point. This is the first time I've posted on a skeptics forum, created by skeptics, and apparently at least one person has a sense of humour.


The way you failed so abysmally to answer Athlon's well conceived points, and then resorted to attacking something so irrelevant such as a few typos was really quite amusing.
Your display of evasiveness, and failure to grasp concepts was truly impressive.

Apparently your humour is limited.

Please keep posting, i am eager to see what tactic you resort to next.

So am I. I have no idea what I'll come up with next. I'll have to ask the little voice in my head. :eye-poppi
 
Not perfect, by any means, but you are also extremely arrogant to boot. Keep in mind this is a global bulletin board, with many from non-English speaking backgrounds. I couldn't do half as good as this guy in Spanish, French, German, Chinese...or any other language.

I speak two languages, English and Trinidadian, so I should really be more humble. I concede your point.

Now that you've displayed yourself as rude, obnoxious, evasive and arrogant, I guess we can all see that the one thing you don't have is a valid argument.

Arrogant is assuming that something like the paranormal "can't happen" because you never experienced the paranormal.
 
Way to completely dodge the questions there Ray.

I've PM'd you my email address so why don't you want to tell me your story?

I won't PM my experience, because mods and others can read it. It's email only. And since I'm new here I don't know who I can trust, or can't. Richard is a well known skeptic in Oz, and I trust he will abide by my conditions. They are only temporary conditions, as I said, and only because it involves possible legal implications from a former workplace. That's how real it was. If not for that possibility I'd post it openly.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom