More advice wanted

Ray, there is a difference between the CSU system and the UC; what that difference is, I don't know. I could claim that I got a degree from Western Wyoming, but what I really have is a degree from Western Wyoming Community College. It would be best that your brother correctly states the school from where he got his dipolma from. (FSU or CSUF, either one would be fine)

I think some clarifications will be made. At least this is what I understand from Mike.
 
1) You agree not to share this publicly, at this time (I'll give my reasons in the email), and in future only with my permission.

Nope.. it does not work like that. I have very little interest in what you think may have happened in the past. We get stories like this all the time.

Can you design a simple test to prove whatever claim you are making? If not, why not? If so, we'll test you.
 
Tell you what... I'll pass on your request to our chief investigator. He may well like to read your report.

Nope.. it does not work like that. I have very little interest in what you think may have happened in the past. We get stories like this all the time.

Can you design a simple test to prove whatever claim you are making? If not, why not? If so, we'll test you.
 
Second, obviously the domains of test here are quite different. A common definition of the paranormal is "Beyond the range of normal experience or scientific explanation". Love is common experience. Telling the future, or other paranormal claims, are by definition not common experience, and so require proving where love really doesn't (by definition).

I dunno. I would say that "true love" is beyond the range of normal experience. How do you distinguish between "true lust" and "true love"? How many teenagers say "I am in love", when in fact they are "in lust"? The latter is common. Was Tom Cruise in "true love" with Nicole Kidman? Or was it some kind of mega-infatuation that eventually wore out? How about Liz Burton-Taylor? How about any Hollywood mega-star? So how do you define it?

And third, I think he just got this from the movie Contact: ("Did you love your father?" "Yes". "Prove it.")

I doubt he's even seen the movie. The UFO/ alien abduction/contact phenomenon holds little interest for him. At least not on the level that afterlife experiences do.
 
Nope.. it does not work like that. I have very little interest in what you think may have happened in the past. We get stories like this all the time.

I don't "think" Richard, I know what happened, and it's recorded. I would not have believed it myself if I didn't have the material evidence. "Chief investigator" sounds ominous. Does he come to this "investigation" with pre-determined conclusions? This is what I have found with so many skeptics.
 
I don't "think" Richard, I know what happened, and it's recorded. I would not have believed it myself if I didn't have the material evidence. "Chief investigator" sounds ominous. Does he come to this "investigation" with pre-determined conclusions? This is what I have found with so many skeptics.

You 'know' and you cannot make up a simple test???

Ian Bryce has an open mind unlike true believers in the paranormal who 'know' they are right and cannot be wrong. Surely you are not one of those close-minded believers? I mean, you are open to the chance that you might be wrong?
 
Surely you are not one of those close-minded believers? I mean, you are open to the chance that you might be wrong?

Of course I am. But I want you to prove me wrong, or deluded, privately, first. When, and if you do, I will publicly announce that I finally have an explanation for what I experienced. But as I said, Richard, my main reason for doing this privately is because of possible legal implications, as it involved my former workplace. What happened was real, and I have the evidence. You may not fully understand until you hear my full explanation, privately, which I am more than willing to share with you. When you understand the circumstances, you'll understand why I prefer it to remain private, at this stage. If there is an explanation, then I will have no fear of revealing it publicly.

You have my guarantee, Richard. Explain it, and I will publicly reveal what happened, with your added explanation.
 
Proof, as in laboratory proof, isn't always possible. Just look at Dr. Susan Blackmore's debates with the scientific community who study NDEs. She admitted that she could not prove NDEs to be false, or entirely brain-generated. She believed they were, and offered her evidence, generated mostly from her own OBE, which is not the same as an NDE. She never experienced a proper NDE. Also in regard to psi:

Proof is a mathematical term, not a scientific one, and is often abused by all manner of people. Science works on the back of evaluating evidence for its worth and then accumulating enough so it satisfies some personal threshold. Once that is achieved, it is treated as useful, and one can say they 'believe' in the claim.

That is more or less how a personal belief is developed. When you state given claim has merit, you're asked to present evidence. Skeptics are people who evaluate that evidence critically with an effort to limit socially-weighted reasoning (such as appealing to popularity or emotion).

In short, 'proof' is not necessarily something that is produced in the laboratory. It is the pointing out of an observation that needs no judging, that could only be observed if the claim were true. If a claim cannot produce this, it is the same as any speculation, and as such carries no more worth than any speculation.

I can give you the simple test, Richard. A very personal one. If you agree, I will email you an experience I had. I've actually had several, but the one concerned has not been explained by anyone who has read it

This doesn't constitute evidence. How is it distinguishable from an invented experience? How would another's speculation (or lack of) on its cause contribute in any way to demonstrating that said claim was factual?

Science strives to remove itself from personal points of views and speculations. This is where its strength lies - in an attempt to be objective.

I dunno. I would say that "true love" is beyond the range of normal experience. How do you distinguish between "true lust" and "true love"?

Your 'love' comparison is a poor analogy. 'Love' is the description of a sensation which occurs in a situation. 'Near Death Experiences' are hypothetical descriptions of a process. When a person experiences a sensation of closeness, they personally convey that emotion as a description of love. Emotions are described in such terms. They have a known chemical basis in physiological expression, and result in observable behaviours. This amounts to sound evidence that 'love' is a sensation many individuals feel.

Near Death Experiences attempt to describe a sensation as a process. This requires more than a labelling of a sensation or a behaviour, but demands a mechanism (such as providing evidence that the mind can exist externally to the biology, for example).

Therefore your analogy is bunk.

How many teenagers say "I am in love", when in fact they are "in lust"?

This is a matter of semantics and word games. Teenagers describe the novel intensity of this sensation in different terms. It bears no comparison to the hypothetical process of a NDE in any form.

I don't "think" Richard, I know what happened, and it's recorded. I would not have believed it myself if I didn't have the material evidence.

This 'material evidence' is obviously enough to satisfy your belief threshold. Could any other phenomena account for this phenomena? Why not agree to a test (describe a possible observation) which could only be accounted for by your claim? If your claim has merit, such an observation would be easy to collect. If it doesn't, then your material evidence could be accounted for using other rationalisations.

"Chief investigator" sounds ominous. Does he come to this "investigation" with pre-determined conclusions? This is what I have found with so many skeptics.

And yet you seem to have your conclusions formed as well, which gets us nowhere. And yet if you were to propose a situation which could occur only if your claim is true, and we observe that to happen, then you'd be putting said skeptics to shame.

It's not difficult.

Athon
 
Proof is a mathematical term, not a scientific one, and is often abused by all manner of people. Science works on the back of evaluating evidence for its worth and then accumulating enough so it satisfies some personal threshold. Once that is achieved, it is treated as useful, and one can say they 'believe' in the claim.

Science does not have the answers for all claims. To remain open-minded, and to evaluate evidence as it comes to hand, and to be prepared to change opinions and ideas, is the hallmark of science. To be dogmatic is anti-science. No scientific "conclusion" is beyond debate or dispute. That, in theory, is how science works.

That is more or less how a personal belief is developed. When you state given claim has merit, you're asked to present evidence. Skeptics are people who evaluate that evidence critically with an effort to limit socially-weighted reasoning (such as appealing to popularity or emotion).

And I have offered to give my evidence privately, first. If it is proved to be wrong, I will go public in acknowledging the answer to what I thought was a mystery. Simple as that.

In short, 'proof' is not necessarily something that is produced in the laboratory. It is the pointing out of an observation that needs no judging, that could only be observed if the claim were true. If a claim cannot produce this, it is the same as any speculation, and as such carries no more worth than any speculation.

"True" by which standards? Currently observable science? True science looks at phenomena, even inexplicable phenomena, and leaves itself open for future investigation for what is not currently understood.


This doesn't constitute evidence. How is it distinguishable from an invented experience? How would another's speculation (or lack of) on its cause contribute in any way to demonstrating that said claim was factual?

Simple: read the evidence. Judge its merit, or demerit. But if you have predetermined ideas, you are not using the scientific method. You are using the dogmatic method, which often belies a set worldview, not amenable to change, which is what science is about - the revision of ideas based on evidence, no matter how contrary to the current worldview it may be.

Science strives to remove itself from personal points of views and speculations. This is where its strength lies - in an attempt to be objective.

Every scientist has personal views. Even gravity was developed from a personal view.


Your 'love' comparison is a poor analogy. 'Love' is the description of a sensation which occurs in a situation. 'Near Death Experiences' are hypothetical descriptions of a process.

They are not "hypothetical" to experiencees. They are real. If it's an illusion, then it should be easily demonstrable, but so far it isn't. Unless some kind of "mass illusion" is occurring. Quite possible, but where is the evidence of "mass illusion"? Has it been documented? Proved?


When a person experiences a sensation of closeness, they personally convey that emotion as a description of love. Emotions are described in such terms. They have a known chemical basis in physiological expression, and result in observable behaviours. This amounts to sound evidence that 'love' is a sensation many individuals feel.

So you don't believe in love? It's all a "chemical reaction"? Definable by bodily functions, such as the need for sex, disguised as "love"? Please clarify.

Near Death Experiences attempt to describe a sensation as a process. This requires more than a labelling of a sensation or a behaviour, but demands a mechanism (such as providing evidence that the mind can exist externally to the biology, for example).

And how do you "prove" that? Through a mechanistic worldview of reductionism? We are cells and robots subject to biological whim? Nothing else, and when we die, that's it?

Therefore your analogy is bunk.

So is history, according to Henry Ford.


This is a matter of semantics and word games. Teenagers describe the novel intensity of this sensation in different terms. It bears no comparison to the hypothetical process of a NDE in any form.

And I never said it did. The "love" comparison was to illustrate subjectivity in judgement.



This 'material evidence' is obviously enough to satisfy your belief threshold. Could any other phenomena account for this phenomena? Why not agree to a test (describe a possible observation) which could only be accounted for by your claim? If your claim has merit, such an observation would be easy to collect. If it doesn't, then your material evidence could be accounted for using other rationalisations.

Speculative when you have not read my experience. If it is "rationalisation", then I welcome your assessment. But read it first, then tell me if it's "rationalisation". You know, the scientific method. Examine all things, and don't assume you have all the facts.


And yet you seem to have your conclusions formed as well, which gets us nowhere. And yet if you were to propose a situation which could occur only if your claim is true, and we observe that to happen, then you'd be putting said skeptics to shame.

It's not difficult.

Athon

I do not want to "put the skeptics to shame". I simply want them to explain what I experienced. Is that too hard?
 
Ray Agostini said:
I do not want to "put the skeptics to shame". I simply want them to explain what I experienced. Is that too hard?
Hello, welcome to the forum.
As far as I understand your comments so far:
1. You are saying you believe in the paranormal because you have a story which you cannot explain. I hope you know that coincidence is an explanation of things which are statistically improbable like dreaming of a set of numbers and then filling out a lottery ticket with those numbers and winning. That is coincidence and not paranormal ability unless you can reproduce it again and again.

2. You say that
True science looks at phenomena, even inexplicable phenomena, and leaves itself open for future investigation for what is not currently understood.
so basically you are right and science is wrong because it is not advanced enough to detect your claims which are not repeatable and rely solely on anecdotal evidence.

3. You are a romantic/fantacizing person at heart:
We are cells and robots subject to biological whim? Nothing else, and when we die, that's it?
You wish to believe that there is more to life than just the boring old "being born, living life, dying and becoming worm food" (that does sound yucky and boring so let's believe there is more out there).

"Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary proof" - Carl Sagan

Now you can think of Sagan as a fool for being a scientist and relying only on actual hardcore evidence but what Sagan and other scientists have prooven to be facts, you are prooving them to be right with your everyday activities like typing on your computer, driving your car, heating up your food, lighting up your house and talking with people over vast distances while walking to the grocery or sitting in the restroom.

It's always funny to me to know on one hand that the human race spends billions of dollars each year for so long on improving our understanding of science and coming up with concrete results in all its branches (biology, physics, chemistry etc.). But then on the other hand there are those who come and say "well, your science is nice but it's nothing compared to what I know. I'll tell you what's true and i know it because I've got this amazing story to tell you. Oh yeah and I don't want to hear explanations for it like coincidence or other boring speculations. It must be something really exciting."

Regards,
Yair
 
Last edited:
No, it does not work like that. It is up to you to prove your claim to be true.

I have offered to prove it. Which email address would you like me to send the evidence to?

Provide an explanation for this email information, Richard, and I promise to join the skeptics, if you can explain it. I really mean that.

I'm all for truth. Even if it makes me look like a savant for stupidity in my utter imaginary delusion of wishful thinking. I'll gladly believe we are nothing but "chemical reactions" if you can show my ignorance. I have nothing to lose. Except a vivid imagination.
 
3. You are a romantic/faing person at heart: You wish to believe that there is more to life than just the boring old "being born, living life, dying and becoming worm food" (that does sound yucky and boring so let's believe there is more out there).

I do not "wish" to believe anything. I just "wish" that agendas would cease.

"Extraordinary claims demand extraordinary proof" - Carl Sagan

Yawn. Seriously. Sagan is in line for the Fifth Gospel.

Now you can think of Sagan as a fool for being a scientist and relying only on actual hardcore evidence but what Sagan and other scientists have prooven to be facts, you are prooving them to be right with your everyday activities like typing on your computer, driving your car, heating up your food, lighting up your house and talking with people over vast distances while walking to the grocery or sitting in the restroom.

I am all for "prooving" them right in this regard. Whenever I turn on my PC, I think of "Karl Sagan". Seriously, any better arguments? This argument is just a worn out cliche. "He made my toaster, so he must know the answers to ALL the universe!!" Toasters and metaphysics blend harmoniously.

It's always funny to me to know on one hand that the human race spends billions of dollars each year for so long on improving our understanding of science and coming up with concrete results in all its branches (biology, physics, chemistry etc.). But then on the other hand there are those who come and say "well, your science is nice but it's nothing compared to what I know. I'll tell you what's true and i know it because I've got this amazing story to tell you. Oh yeah and I don't want to hear explanations for it like coincidence or other boring speculations. It must be something really exciting."

Regards,
Yair

Regards to you too, Yair. I'd rebut this if it was my argument, but it's not. You're barking up a tree I wouldn't even piss on.
 
Thanks for clarifying the degree issue.

I have to admit I am rather curious about that "proof" now, and especially what legal ramifications it entails. ;)
 
I am all for "prooving" them right in this regard. Whenever I turn on my PC, I think of "Karl Sagan". Seriously, any better arguments? This argument is just a worn out cliche. "He made my toaster, so he must know the answers to ALL the universe!!" Toasters and metaphysics blend harmoniously.

Come an getcher genuine 'Karl Sagan' Toasters! Gets your bread toasty hot! Great with a cup of tea if you happen to be orbiting between Earth and Mars. Order today, and we'll bundle you a handcrafted 'Karl Sagan' computer!

To put it another way:
I see lots of this: :words:
But no evidence.
 
Last edited:
Science does not have the answers for all claims. To remain open-minded, and to evaluate evidence as it comes to hand, and to be prepared to change opinions and ideas, is the hallmark of science. To be dogmatic is anti-science. No scientific "conclusion" is beyond debate or dispute. That, in theory, is how science works.

Correction; science makes no claim to have answers, as it is a process used to arrive at a point of confidence. Indeed, one must remain open minded, yet this amounts to considering evidence as having weight, not that all speculations are equally possible.

Am I open to the observations associated with Near Death Experiences equating the transfer of a soul? Hell yeah. It would be amazing to investigate such a novel field in science. However for me to have confidence in it existing in spite of my opinion of it, so magnificent would such a discovery be, I would need strong evidence which could not be explained through any other means.

"True" by which standards? Currently observable science? True science looks at phenomena, even inexplicable phenomena, and leaves itself open for future investigation for what is not currently understood.

'True' as a statement of confidence in the fact that nothing else could explain it. That is as close as we can hope to get in defining reality.

Simple: read the evidence. Judge its merit, or demerit. But if you have predetermined ideas, you are not using the scientific method. You are using the dogmatic method, which often belies a set worldview, not amenable to change, which is what science is about - the revision of ideas based on evidence, no matter how contrary to the current worldview it may be.

You didn't read what I said, either by choice or mistake. So I'll ask again - what makes this evidence (regardless of what it constitutes) unexplicable through any other explanation, including complete fabrication, bias or misperception? Assuming I have a completely unbiased mind (indeed, impossible, however bear in mind I would actually want NDE to represent an actual phenomena, for the potential understanding of the universe we could get from it), how would I distinguish your evidence as having strength while any other anecdote might not?

Every scientist has personal views. Even gravity was developed from a personal view.

Again, you missed what I said. Science strives to be objective. It is a goal, however much we might miss it. Therefore we must ensure we put into action certain methods which circumvent our own hopes, biases and expectations. That way it doesn't matter what I beleive - if the test results in a given observation, then we have good evidence in support of a claim.

They are not "hypothetical" to experiencees. They are real.

The observations are real, I grant you that. The phenomena might well not be explained through mechanisms other than illusion, neurology and chemistry.

If it's an illusion, then it should be easily demonstrable, but so far it isn't.

Explain.

Unless some kind of "mass illusion" is occurring. Quite possible, but where is the evidence of "mass illusion"? Has it been documented? Proved?

Why would it need to be a 'mass illusion'? If it results from one's physiology, it would be possible for many people to experience similar phenomena. It need not be chance, but the result of something already explainable.

So you don't believe in love? It's all a "chemical reaction"? Definable by bodily functions, such as the need for sex, disguised as "love"? Please clarify.

I'm not sure how you arrive at the conclusion that I don't believe in love. I've felt that closeness, the empathy for another person. I have a fiancee I adore. I believe in the sense. I believe in the poetry of it, the need to express it. I believe her when she tells me she loves me, as it is evidenced in her actions.

The fact it can be explained through chemistry and biology makes it only more amazing. To think this computer I'm writing on is electrical pulses and circuits, yet it is capable of producing the most beautiful sounds and images. Being able to feel might result from nothing more than chemical mechanics, but that doesn't diminish its beauty. Not one spot.

There need not be a 'ghost in the machine' - afterall, were we to find it, we'd only go in search of the 'machine in the ghost'. All ghosts are essentially machines. And there is nothing more beautiful than that thought.

And how do you "prove" that? Through a mechanistic worldview of reductionism? We are cells and robots subject to biological whim? Nothing else, and when we die, that's it?

Yes. Until I have reason to believe otherwise. We exist at the whim of rules and laws; science is based on the very notion that all actions are relatively consistent with time and space. If you don't believe that, we have no discussion, as science is built on that very tenet.

If all things are rules and laws, all fragments of that can be expressed as a consistent set of rules. Those we define by physics in order to keep track of them, and to make sensible predictions. It sounds very mechanical, however to not define all things in terms of consistent descriptions means we have no means of describing anything. Oddly enough, it's yet to be seen as wrong. The universe does seem to be made of consistent rules. If we have souls, they too must be consistent, must interact with the physics of reality, and must be subject to those consistent rules. Souls too would have a set of mechanics.

Are some things more than the sum of their parts? Of course. Yet that doesn't make them less consistent or mechanical - it simply means they have a more complex set of definitions.

Speculative when you have not read my experience. If it is "rationalisation", then I welcome your assessment. But read it first, then tell me if it's "rationalisation". You know, the scientific method. Examine all things, and don't assume you have all the facts.

It is an anecdote of an experience, yes? Or have I missed something? It will appear as text in my email box (should I agree to reading it), hence have an author...and therefore is an anecdotal account? I would be forced to make assumptions, such as the anecdote having factual merit, and therefore would be speculating. Again, how would this contribute anything? How would this speculation contain any more merit than if it were based on an anecdote that was totally fabricated?

I do not want to "put the skeptics to shame". I simply want them to explain what I experienced. Is that too hard?

You're more than welcome to explain what you experienced, either here or privately. However I fail to see what it offers. How would I distinguish it from a fabrication of an event, an illusion or a misperception or an exaggeration? Bear in mind I'm not accusing you necessarily of any of these, however I am asking how I would see your evidence as having merit while these things themselves all carry possible weight explaining what I would read.

Athon
 
Thanks for clarifying the degree issue.

I have to admit I am rather curious about that "proof" now, and especially what legal ramifications it entails. ;)

That's for me to know, and you to find out. Won't be holding my breath for "skeptics" to decipher it. You want a sign? Go read the reply of Baalim's ass.
 
Ray Agostini said:
This argument is just a worn out cliche.

So funny you say that as all the evidence you have in the world for your claims is words words words and worn out cliches about stories we've all heard hundreds of times from hundreds of people with your kind or other kinds of claims.

"He made my toaster, so he must know the answers to ALL the universe!!" Toasters and metaphysics blend harmoniously.
You're proving my points again and again.
You mock the scientists who enable you to have the way of life that you're living and that have made almost all of human kind's wildest imaginations come true.
I never said science has all the answers to the universe but it's getting closer and closer and there is nothing you can do about it (unfortunately for you and your kind).

Ray Gostini said:
Toasters and metaphysics blend harmoniously
And you're talking about worn out cliches? Too funny.
Randi has your current and future arguments in all of his lectures.
Soon you'll be talking about "quantum" effects, "energies" of all sorts, and other vocabulary you know nothing of. But you do want your arguments to have those scientific vocabulary because science is the strongest set of arguments there is. You know it and I know it and so does everybody else. Why? because it prooves itself over and over again each second of our lives.

But you, you have your stories. Magnificant stories of powers beyond our wildest imaginations and mocking of science. That's very arrogant of you don't you think?

Regards,
Yair
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom