Science does not have the answers for all claims. To remain open-minded, and to evaluate evidence as it comes to hand, and to be prepared to change opinions and ideas, is the hallmark of science. To be dogmatic is anti-science. No scientific "conclusion" is beyond debate or dispute. That, in theory, is how science works.
Correction; science makes no claim to have answers, as it is a process used to arrive at a point of confidence. Indeed, one must remain open minded, yet this amounts to considering evidence as having weight, not that all speculations are equally possible.
Am I open to the observations associated with Near Death Experiences equating the transfer of a soul? Hell yeah. It would be amazing to investigate such a novel field in science. However for me to have confidence in it existing in spite of my opinion of it, so magnificent would such a discovery be, I would need strong evidence which could not be explained through any other means.
"True" by which standards? Currently observable science? True science looks at phenomena, even inexplicable phenomena, and leaves itself open for future investigation for what is not currently understood.
'True' as a statement of confidence in the fact that nothing else could explain it. That is as close as we can hope to get in defining reality.
Simple: read the evidence. Judge its merit, or demerit. But if you have predetermined ideas, you are not using the scientific method. You are using the dogmatic method, which often belies a set worldview, not amenable to change, which is what science is about - the revision of ideas based on evidence, no matter how contrary to the current worldview it may be.
You didn't read what I said, either by choice or mistake. So I'll ask again - what makes this evidence (regardless of what it constitutes) unexplicable through any other explanation, including complete fabrication, bias or misperception? Assuming I have a completely unbiased mind (indeed, impossible, however bear in mind I would actually want NDE to represent an actual phenomena, for the potential understanding of the universe we could get from it), how would I distinguish your evidence as having strength while any other anecdote might not?
Every scientist has personal views. Even gravity was developed from a personal view.
Again, you missed what I said. Science
strives to be objective. It is a goal, however much we might miss it. Therefore we must ensure we put into action certain methods which circumvent our own hopes, biases and expectations. That way it doesn't matter what I beleive - if the test results in a given observation, then we have good evidence in support of a claim.
They are not "hypothetical" to experiencees. They are real.
The observations are real, I grant you that. The phenomena might well not be explained through mechanisms other than illusion, neurology and chemistry.
If it's an illusion, then it should be easily demonstrable, but so far it isn't.
Explain.
Unless some kind of "mass illusion" is occurring. Quite possible, but where is the evidence of "mass illusion"? Has it been documented? Proved?
Why would it need to be a 'mass illusion'? If it results from one's physiology, it would be possible for many people to experience similar phenomena. It need not be chance, but the result of something already explainable.
So you don't believe in love? It's all a "chemical reaction"? Definable by bodily functions, such as the need for sex, disguised as "love"? Please clarify.
I'm not sure how you arrive at the conclusion that I don't believe in love. I've felt that closeness, the empathy for another person. I have a fiancee I adore. I believe in the sense. I believe in the poetry of it, the need to express it. I believe her when she tells me she loves me, as it is evidenced in her actions.
The fact it can be explained through chemistry and biology makes it only more amazing. To think this computer I'm writing on is electrical pulses and circuits, yet it is capable of producing the most beautiful sounds and images. Being able to feel might result from nothing more than chemical mechanics, but that doesn't diminish its beauty. Not one spot.
There need not be a 'ghost in the machine' - afterall, were we to find it, we'd only go in search of the 'machine in the ghost'. All ghosts are essentially machines. And there is nothing more beautiful than that thought.
And how do you "prove" that? Through a mechanistic worldview of reductionism? We are cells and robots subject to biological whim? Nothing else, and when we die, that's it?
Yes. Until I have reason to believe otherwise. We exist at the whim of rules and laws; science is based on the very notion that all actions are relatively consistent with time and space. If you don't believe that, we have no discussion, as science is built on that very tenet.
If all things are rules and laws, all fragments of that can be expressed as a consistent set of rules. Those we define by physics in order to keep track of them, and to make sensible predictions. It sounds very mechanical, however to not define all things in terms of consistent descriptions means we have no means of describing anything. Oddly enough, it's yet to be seen as wrong. The universe does seem to be made of consistent rules. If we have souls, they too must be consistent, must interact with the physics of reality, and must be subject to those consistent rules. Souls too would have a set of mechanics.
Are some things more than the sum of their parts? Of course. Yet that doesn't make them less consistent or mechanical - it simply means they have a more complex set of definitions.
Speculative when you have not read my experience. If it is "rationalisation", then I welcome your assessment. But read it first, then tell me if it's "rationalisation". You know, the scientific method. Examine all things, and don't assume you have all the facts.
It is an anecdote of an experience, yes? Or have I missed something? It will appear as text in my email box (should I agree to reading it), hence have an author...and therefore is an anecdotal account? I would be forced to make assumptions, such as the anecdote having factual merit, and therefore would be speculating. Again, how would this contribute anything? How would this speculation contain any more merit than if it were based on an anecdote that was totally fabricated?
I do not want to "put the skeptics to shame". I simply want them to explain what I experienced. Is that too hard?
You're more than welcome to explain what you experienced, either here or privately. However I fail to see what it offers. How would I distinguish it from a fabrication of an event, an illusion or a misperception or an exaggeration? Bear in mind I'm not accusing you necessarily of any of these, however I am asking how I would see your evidence as having merit while these things themselves all carry possible weight explaining what I would read.
Athon