Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Then you come and visit me in my place and I will treat you to a tour of my place...

Hello, Gerry!

I will answer you the same way I have many times in the past, and I hope that other posters follow my lead and answer you in this way as well:

I grant you that God, the maker of the universe, exists. I grant and agree that the universe was created by God who created the entire universe - the sun and moon and whatever else you wrote.

Such a God does exist. I agree. There is no need for you to present any further proof of the matter. Nor is there a need to define proof.

Let us grant you that such a God exists, as I have offered to do in the past.

Now what? What is the next step of your argument once we agree that the universe was created by a creator?


Well, then you come and visit me and I will treat you to a tour of my place plus a dinner.

Because we are both people who know God exists.


Now what?

Well, if you are not happy or not satisfied and still curious or still feeling empty, because you want to ask now what?

Try to do something about your knowledge of God that will keep your mind busy, that is a very most peculiar human occupation.

You can try reforming how God knowers are doing with their knowledge of God and tell them that is not the way to give credit to God, and show them the right ways -- according to you.

Okay?

Or you develop the hobby of reading the socalled classics of Christian spirituality, treatises on Christian perfection, Christian asceticism, mysticism, etc., just as Western converts to Buddhism are so enraptured with Buddha and Buddhism that they take up the study of similar subjects written on by Buddhist masters.

Or you can now write a book like Antony Flew how you are now a self-declared knower of the existence of the Christian God, though Flew did not go beyond the existence of God into like as I said the hobby of reading the classics and contemporary works on Christian spirituality, etc.

Not that I know of.



Yrreg
 
You know, I've seen this many times. Someone will come in with something to prove, but before we get to all that, we have to establish what proof is. What is evidence?

I am not an unreasonable person. I have had many, many conversations about all sorts of subjects (yes, even God!) without going through this song and dance. I have already stated simple definitions for "proof" and "evidence." I'll repeat them here:

Evidence - That which tends to prove or disprove a given conclusion.
Proof - Evidence sufficient to establish an idea as true or false.

May we move on?

I take it this is your first yrreg thread then?

Stick around, you'll learn.
 
Please give some examples of evidence and of proof.

Evidence - That which tends to prove or disprove a given conclusion.
Proof - Evidence sufficient to establish an idea as true or false.

[...]


Please give some examples of evidence and of proof.



Yrreg
 
Please give some examples of evidence and some examples of proof.


I sense us drifting off topic.

In your first post, you said:

I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​


Only after someone mentioned evidence, did you say:


Now that you bring up evidence, that's very good for you to tell us what is evidence.


In your last post, you talked about examining our own noses.

What exactly is the next step after we grant that God, the maker of the universe, exists?

Is it to look at our noses? Is it to then define evidence? Is it an unnamed third thing?

In any case, the examples of evidence sufficient to form proof are infinite. What level of certainty do you consider to be high enough to constitute proof in your case?
 
That is one example that is not relevant, please be relevant.
Yes it is.

You are into the mechanical manner that God should answer prayer, otherwise there is no God.

God is not a robot.

And prayer is not turning on a switch.
If you read carefully I only used that as an example of the kind of thing that needs to be given. I specifically said that you could name ANYTHING god does within the universe.

Once again :

If you want to present evidence of god to an atheist, you need to make a statement like "If god exists then we should observe X happening, whereas if he doesn't exist we should observe Y happening, and when we look around, we find X happening rather than Y, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

What X and Y are depends on you and your conception of what god is and will do.

If you will not do this, then you have not given us evidence of god.

If there is no programming in the universe, the sun will not rise tomorrow, then wait for tomorrow, if the sun rises as always so far, then there is programming in the universe, and there is what? a programmer, yes, no?
No. You haven't shown that the sun rising requires god - we already have an explanation of how and why the sun rises which does not require god.

"Tell us something which we can go out and investigate where one thing would be true if your god existed and false if he didn't. It's that simple."

That is a very good idea, we can organize an expedition to search for the entity called God described by yours truly to be in fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians to be the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

That expedition can start with the nose in our face.

No joking.
Okay. Now you need to tell us, what would a nose look like if god did exist, and what would it look like if god didn't exist, and why. Then we can begin to examine the question.

Off you go.
 
Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Do you have a problem limiting our conclusions to a little thing called "reality?
 
Fundamental means so crucial that without it nothing is of any worth to Christians.

yrreg, the Christian god is not defined as the maker of the universe. He is defined as a personal god, who made the universe specifically for humans, who cares about their sex lives, who offers them salvation, who can see into their hearts, and all sorts of other nonsense.

So if you want to talk about a god who is the maker of this universe, fine. Just know that it has nothing to do with Christianity; that can be settled with simple deism. If you want to talk about the maker of everything that is not himself, then that's nonsense and not an argument worth pursuing, unless you really want to claim that he's busy in all the factories and fields and kitchens of the world.


Fundamental means so crucial that without it nothing in God is of any worth to Christians.

That is why I say, God in the fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Now, that deists have that idea of God, that is good for them, and they stop there, that is their business.

Christians don't stop there, but I am only delimiting the topic to the fundamental concept of God etc.



Yrreg
 
Hmmm lets see, proof I would consider convincing.

Flaming letters in the sky proclaiming 'I am you god and mohammed is my prophet'
appearing all over the world at the same time, readable by all people would be a good proof.

My dead grandparents appearing in the flesh, telling me. 'accept jesus or burn for always'. Again, good proof, especially if its tapble to prove its not me just hallucinating.

A perfect copy of the talmud found in a cave on the moon, saying 'my messiah still has not been, quit following that fraud' in modern day hebrew... again, good proof/evidence
 
Well, that is my definition of God as from a Christian, though it can also apply...

[...]

...I reject your definition of god as worse than useless.

How on earth do you jump from "Maker of everything that is not God Himself" to the Christian god?

[...]


Read carefully:

My definition of God is as follows:

God in the fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Well, that is my definition of God as from a Christian, though it can also apply to other peoples with the knowledge of God that adheres to the same fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians.

For examples, Muslims and religious Jews or Judaists as distinct to atheist or non-religious Jews.


See if you can understand from an illustration.

A very good baker makes a toy house as large as a small typical house that he the baker can go in and stay in for fun, everything that goes to make the house is confected by the baker himself with bread, and everyday he goes inside the house to appear to live inside.

So, people say everything in the house that is not the baker himself is made by the baker.


Yrreg
 
Read carefully:

My definition of God is as follows:

God in the fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Well, that is my definition of God as from a Christian, though it can also apply to other peoples with the knowledge of God that adheres to the same fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians.

For examples, Muslims and religious Jews or Judaists as distinct to atheist or non-religious Jews.


See if you can understand from an illustration.

A very good baker makes a toy house as large as a small typical house that he the baker can go in and stay in for fun, everything that goes to make the house is confected by the baker himself with bread, and everyday he goes inside the house to appear to live inside.

So, people say everything in the house that is not the baker himself is made by the baker.


Yrreg

Hmm. Who made the oven in which the bread house was baked? :confused:
 
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, the universe is the one where we humans are residing in, in one of its planets, from where we can see its sun and also the moon that we see at night.

And also everything that makes up the what astrophysicists call popularly as the Big Bang universe.


Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?



Yrreg
Proof? What proof?
 
Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?



Yrreg

Yes, that should make it simpler for you.

1. What evidence did you examine to come to the conclusion that your god made the universe?

2. What made your god?​
 
The fact that man studies God is already a limitation of God...


No it isn't. The model that we use to describe something doesn't constrain it, whatever that something is. When people thought combustion liberated something called phlogiston, it did not do so.

The real limitation of God is that man created God in his own image.
 
That is why I say, God in the fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


But this is not a useful concept of the Christian god, because it also applies to any other creator god.
 
Last edited:
Read carefully:

My definition of God is as follows:

God in the fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Well, that is my definition of God as from a Christian, though it can also apply to other peoples with the knowledge of God that adheres to the same fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe for Christians.

For examples, Muslims and religious Jews or Judaists as distinct to atheist or non-religious Jews.


Stop being condescending. I did read your definition carefully, and my opinion on it has not changed.

Worse than useless.

Your definition is vague and self-referential.

It's like defining a lake as a watery body which is the size of a lake.

You have to know what a lake is to make sense of the definition. Just one first must know what god is to make sense of your definition.

And I still have no clue how you've jumped from your vague, amorphous "definition" to the Christian god.



See if you can understand from an illustration.

A very good baker makes a toy house as large as a small typical house that he the baker can go in and stay in for fun, everything that goes to make the house is confected by the baker himself with bread, and everyday he goes inside the house to appear to live inside.

So, people say everything in the house that is not the baker himself is made by the baker.


Wonderful.
But you're not trying to explain what is made by the baker. You're trying to define who/what the baker is.




Your definition is worse than useless.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom