Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

The fact that man studies God is already a limitation of God, but it can't be...

You don't start with God's limitations. You start with proving God even exists. No skipping steps.


The fact that man studies God is already a limitation of God, but it can't be otherwise, because man's knowledge of God can never do justice to God.

No matter the limitations however man must not skirt from the study of God.

That is why as God makes everything that is not God Himself, I always find it most ironical but amazing that man does dare to study God, and such as man is God makes him such as he is.

Now, it is all right for man a limited being to limit his study of God to the universe where man and God are both resident in, but man as a knowing entity is not saying in effect that God is limited to being God in the present universe where God and man are resident in -- and God is resident not only in this universe, He is everywhere and in every time and in every dimension whatever of existence.

Some atheist cosmologists want to postulate many universes, whereas the word universe already encapsulates all existence whatever, including the non-accessible existence parts of the universe, non-accessible that is to the scientific method but still man can write science fictions about those realms of existence not accessible to science.

Are there realms of the universe not accessible to man's socalled scientific method?

I submit there are.

Now, if atheists can and will come to the knowledge of God as maker of the universe in which man actually resides, then that is already a most marvelous enlightenment on their part, no matter that man's knowledge of the universe is a limited knowledge compared to the knowledge of God, the author of the universe of all existence whatever that is not God Himself.


In sum, delimiting the proof of God's existence to the present universe as known to man in his limited knowledge of things, that is the viable methodology in any realistic research.

Again, that is not shortchanging atheists.

You cannot do any examination of anything without first delimiting the subject, otherwise you will be into an unwieldy study which is not in consonance with the scientific method of doing any research work.



Yrreg
 
Please try your best to limit your posting to the Christian God which is defined by me as in fundamental concept in relation to the universe the:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​




Yrreg

Christian god? which one, the one that is father son and holy spirit in one? trinity, a personal intervening god?
or one of the other version that get teached in christianity? a non intervening non trinity version?

Christians have made up so many different gods, which one is yours?
 
The fact that man studies God is already a limitation of God, but it can't be otherwise, because man's knowledge of God can never do justice to God.

No matter the limitations however man must not skirt from the study of God.

That is why as God makes everything that is not God Himself, I always find it most ironical but amazing that man does dare to study God, and such as man is God makes him such as he is.

Now, it is all right for man a limited being to limit his study of God to the universe where man and God are both resident in, but man as a knowing entity is not saying in effect that God is limited to being God in the present universe where God and man are resident in -- and God is resident not only in this universe, He is everywhere and in every time and in every dimension whatever of existence.

Some atheist cosmologists want to postulate many universes, whereas the word universe already encapsulates all existence whatever, including the non-accessible existence parts of the universe, non-accessible that is to the scientific method but still man can write science fictions about those realms of existence not accessible to science.

Are there realms of the universe not accessible to man's socalled scientific method?

I submit there are.

Now, if atheists can and will come to the knowledge of God as maker of the universe in which man actually resides, then that is already a most marvelous enlightenment on their part, no matter that man's knowledge of the universe is a limited knowledge compared to the knowledge of God, the author of the universe of all existence whatever that is not God Himself.


In sum, delimiting the proof of God's existence to the present universe as known to man in his limited knowledge of things, that is the viable methodology in any realistic research.

Again, that is not shortchanging atheists.

You cannot do any examination of anything without first delimiting the subject, otherwise you will be into an unwieldy study which is not in consonance with the scientific method of doing any research work.



Yrreg


What?
 
Last edited:
Says nothing to people who don't hear but there are many who hear and come to the...

The fact that the universe, as we know it, exists says nothing, one way or another, about the possible existence of a God or gods.


Says nothing to people who don't hear or can't hear, but there are many who hear and come to the knowledge of God in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Of course you can deny that they know God to exist, while they are flabbergasted that you don't.



Yrreg
 
The fact that man studies God is already a limitation of God, but it can't be otherwise, because man's knowledge of God can never do justice to God.

No matter the limitations however man must not skirt from the study of God.

That is why as God makes everything that is not God Himself, I always find it most ironical but amazing that man does dare to study God, and such as man is God makes him such as he is.

Now, it is all right for man a limited being to limit his study of God to the universe where man and God are both resident in, but man as a knowing entity is not saying in effect that God is limited to being God in the present universe where God and man are resident in -- and God is resident not only in this universe, He is everywhere and in every time and in every dimension whatever of existence.

Some atheist cosmologists want to postulate many universes, whereas the word universe already encapsulates all existence whatever, including the non-accessible existence parts of the universe, non-accessible that is to the scientific method but still man can write science fictions about those realms of existence not accessible to science.

Are there realms of the universe not accessible to man's socalled scientific method?

I submit there are.

Now, if atheists can and will come to the knowledge of God as maker of the universe in which man actually resides, then that is already a most marvelous enlightenment on their part, no matter that man's knowledge of the universe is a limited knowledge compared to the knowledge of God, the author of the universe of all existence whatever that is not God Himself.


In sum, delimiting the proof of God's existence to the present universe as known to man in his limited knowledge of things, that is the viable methodology in any realistic research.

Again, that is not shortchanging atheists.

You cannot do any examination of anything without first delimiting the subject, otherwise you will be into an unwieldy study which is not in consonance with the scientific method of doing any research work.



Yrreg

knowledge of god? how about first bringing up EVIDENCE for your god?
so far this thing you call god has nothing to do with knowledge, and everything with delusion.
 
Last edited:
Says nothing to people who don't hear or can't hear, but there are many who hear and come to the knowledge of God in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Of course you can deny that they know God to exist, while they are flabbergasted that you don't.



Yrreg

i deny it, they don't know, they believe. :rolleyes:
 
I am inviting atheists to give the fundamental concepts of proof and evidence in relation to the universe from their knowledge of proof and evidence.


Evidence, as others have said before, is anything that tends to make a statement more or less true.

Proof, as has been said before, is an accumulation of evidence sufficient to convince the mind.


You ask a question. You get an answer that is on target. And then you ignore that answer to go around in circles with someone who said something you didn't like.

And all this being true, I am still willing to grant WITHOUT ANY NEED to show any evidence whatsoever, that God, defined as the maker of the universe, does exist. I grant you that premise and ask that you move to whatever your next step might be.

If that's not good enough, and you instead want to talk about evidence, I ask that you consider my answer above.



ETA: I wonder what the stressor was that brought you back here.
 
Delimiting God to this universe is pointless unless you have first demonstrated that this God of yours exists.
 
I've always wondered why religious people try to prove that God exists. Isn't faith believing in something without any evidence? A Christian might believe Jesus was the son of God. A Muslim might believe that Muhammed was a prophet of God. A child might believe that Santa Claus exists. A Ranger fan might believe that Glen Sather won't make a ridiculous signing this off-season that cripples the Rangers future opportunities to sign decent players in subsequent seasons. All these things have no evidence and require faith. And there's nothing wrong with that as long as you admit that there is no evidence. I have no problem with religious people who tell me that they don't have evidence, they just have faith. It's not good enough for me and I think it shows a serious lack of critical thinking skills, but at least they admit it. Aren't those who try to show evidence of God contradicting themselves by trying to prove their faith when they don't actually have any?
 
Last edited:
ETA: I wonder what the stressor was that brought you back here.


Standard yrreg, I think. Get suspended, then disappear for a while (a long while in this case, his last post was Sept 16, 2010 and he was suspended for 1 week on Sept 17, 2010) then come back on his own terms.

Ultimately it doesn't matter.

I'm glad he's come back, and would like him to answer my questions.
 
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.



Yrreg

Standard Christian logic.

"Here's how you find evidence/proof for God. First, believe God exists. Now that you believe he exists, he exists. So we've proven God exists."

I don't think logic is necessarily for some people.

Also I used the word "exists" too many times and now it looks strange.
 
Aren't those who try to show evidence of God contradicting themselves by proving their faith when they don't actually have any?

Absolutely correct. As a Catholic I have always felt this was a sign of insecurity about your faith. I dont care who believes in God or who doesn't. Thats your business not mine
 
Do you remember I used to tell you people about the Latin phrases "sensu aienti" ...

Welcome back yrreg. I agree that the deity you're proposing is less problematic, at least based on what I've heard so far, than many others I've heard of. Am I correct in thinking you're talking about a God who starts everything but doesn't intervene physically thereafter? That is, the physical world is unfolding according to God's plan, he doesn't do miracles (since everything is going to plan), but he does provide an afterlife outside of our ability to detect it? Please clarify anything I'm mistaking in your concept.

And good luck on your fresh start.


Do you remember I used to tell you people about the Latin phrases "sensu aienti" and "sensu neganti"?*


"Sensu aienti" means in affirmation of but not implying any negation of anything not mentioned in one's words.

"Sensu neganti" means denying what is not mentioned.

So, if you say that the following employees can go on vacation with pay, you are already into 'sensu neganti'.

But when I say that I am delimiting God to the Big Bang universe, and in particular I define God as in fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians, to be the maker of everything that is not God, I am into 'sensu aienti', meaning I don't exclude from the concept of God anything and everything that is to the credit of God.

I am just delimiting the discourse so that we will not be into a very overly broad topic that the exchange of thoughts becomes so unwieldy, that we ourselves cannot navigate efficiently, the result being that everything is an overwhelming challenge to keep track of, owing to the enormous quantity of ideas and words that ensue.



Yrreg

*Correct me if I am mistaken, as the Romans or Latin speaking academics say: Salva meliori sententia.​
 
But when I say that I am delimiting God to the Big Bang universe, and in particular I define God as in fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians, to be the maker of everything that is not God, I am into 'sensu aienti', meaning I don't exclude from the concept of God anything and everything that is to the credit of God.


Right, yes, I agree with you. God is the maker of everything that is not God. That is a true statement. I take it as a given that this is true without any need for further debate.

Now, what is the next step?
 
Says nothing to people who don't hear or can't hear, but there are many who hear and come to the knowledge of God in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Of course you can deny that they know God to exist, while they are flabbergasted that you don't.



Yrreg

I am flabbergasted that they believe in a sky daddy,without a shred of evidence.
 
That is one example that is not relevant, please be relevant.

A manifestation of god acting within the universe.

If you want to present evidence of god to an atheist, you need to make a statement like "If god exists then we should observe X happening, whereas if he doesn't exist we should observe Y happening, and when we look around, we find X happening rather than Y, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

What X and Y are depends on you and your conception of what god is and will do. As a purely hypothetical example, somebody might say :

"If god exists then we should observe that sick people become well more often if they are prayed for, whereas if he doesn't exist we should find that prayer makes no difference, and when we look around, we find sick people who are prayed for do get better more often than those who are not prayed for rather than them all getting better at the same rate, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

Only the actual fact is that this doesn't actually happen, and in truth prayer makes no difference at all.

But that would be evidence. Tell us something which we can go out and investigate where one thing would be true if your god existed and false if he didn't. It's that simple.


"If god exists then we should observe that sick people become well more often if they are prayed for, whereas if he doesn't exist we should find that prayer makes no difference, and when we look around, we find sick people who are prayed for do get better more often than those who are not prayed for rather than them all getting better at the same rate, and therefore this supports the existence of god."
​

That is one example that is not relevant, please be relevant.

I am talking about God's existence as in fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians: maker of everything that is not God Himself.

You are into the mechanical manner that God should answer prayer, otherwise there is no God.

God is not a robot.

And prayer is not turning on a switch.


But if you really want to do a serious testing of whether prayer to God works or not, even though I submit that is a very unscientific study, you can get 100,000 people at least to pray for 1000 people who are already pronounced by doctors to be hopeless to bring back to health, that they will eventually certainly die.

And you keep very complete and faithful documentation as regards the people praying, the people prayed for, how many hours, where, when, how, etc.

Still I will say that it is an unscientific research, because God is not a robot, and prayer is not turning on a switch.


Perhaps, if you make this conditional chain of thoughts:

If there is no programming in the universe, the sun will not rise tomorrow, then wait for tomorrow, if the sun rises as always so far, then there is programming in the universe, and there is what? a programmer, yes, no?
​

You have the free choice to insist that the programmer is a human randomizer, and the random programming he wrote just happens to result in the sun rising every morning faithfully, that is your privilege as a human being with conscious free will to do what you want with your brain.

You also say:
"Tell us something which we can go out and investigate where one thing would be true if your god existed and false if he didn't. It's that simple."​

That is a very good idea, we can organize an expedition to search for the entity called God described by yours truly to be in fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians to be the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

That expedition can start with the nose in our face.

No joking.

I am really serious.



Yrreg
 
That is a very good idea, we can organize an expedition to search for the entity called God described by yours truly to be in fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians to be the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

That expedition can start with the nose in our face.

No joking.

I am really serious.


Is this the next step after we accept as true that there is a God, defined as the creator of the universe?

If this isn't the next step, would you please move on to that step?
 
Please give some examples of evidence and some examples of proof.

[...]

Evidence is facts which are more likely under one set of circumstances than another, thus lending credence to that set of circumstances above other potential sets.

Proof is either a mathematical proof or simply such an overwhelming weight of evidence that dismissing it is impossible when thinking rationally.

[...]


Please give some examples of evidence and some examples of proof.




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom