Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

I hate -not quite- to spoil the strawmanship exhibition within the latest posts but Yrreg explaining himself in worse English is probably evidence of him trying to reply properly. Why? Because he, as everybody trying to communicate in a foreign language, says what he can, not what he wants. He speaking in an increasingly broken English may be evidence of he trying to say what he must.



I had put it down to yrreg trying to use big words and complex phrasing, perhaps in an attempt to make himself appear intellectual. If so, there is irony in the fact that simpler language would make him more understandable and increase his apparent language skills.
 
My guess, only a guess of course, is that our temporarily absent friend stews over these ideas, works them up, imagines the exchanges and the way things will go, and then posts a thread thinking that he's really got the master "gotcha" this time. He's thought of all the angles, rehearsed and honed his repartée. Of course it never quite goes that way, things go from bad to worse, the script is departed from, he gets upset and loses his cool, then bails. He takes his tattered argument back to its lair, patches it up and changes its suit, drills and exercises it, and brings it back to the fray a few months later for the next bout.

Just a guess, but I think Yrreg is quite an optimist.
 
He's talked about 7 year olds so much I think that that is the only audience he gets IRL. Maybe he teaches a Sunday school class or something. His arguments always work perfectly on 7 year olds!
 
My guess, only a guess of course, is that our temporarily absent friend stews over these ideas, works them up, imagines the exchanges and the way things will go, and then posts a thread thinking that he's really got the master "gotcha" this time. He's thought of all the angles, rehearsed and honed his repartée. Of course it never quite goes that way, things go from bad to worse, the script is departed from, he gets upset and loses his cool, then bails. He takes his tattered argument back to its lair, patches it up and changes its suit, drills and exercises it, and brings it back to the fray a few months later for the next bout.

Just a guess, but I think Yrreg is quite an optimist.


It's nothing nearly as complicated as that. Gerry is a narcissist. He must always feel good about himself. When his real life gives him enough satisfaction, he doesn't need us. But then something will happen to make him doubt his own intelligence. This could be anything. He could be at bible study, explain his personal idea, and the priest says something like, "Thank you, Gerry, but that's not quite what I meant." That would be enough to crush him completely.

That's when he comes here. Our disapproval registers on him as positive, because he feels superior to us. That lasts as long as anyone says anything negative to him. He feeds off it.

Until he gets a Mod warning. Since Mods are people in authority, any disapproval from them is absolutely humiliating. He can't even click on the JREF link anymore.

A couple rejections like that, piled up on top of each other, and he'd be hard-pressed to even get up in the morning. If Gerry has ever sought psychiatric help, it would have been because he misdiagnosed himself with depression.

Eventually, the shame of the mod warning fades and the memory of the victory over our small minds takes over, something in his life goes slightly against him, and he comes back.

Gerry doesn't put any thought whatsoever into his arguments here. It doesn't matter to him what he says, it's guaranteed to be brilliant. And it doesn't matter what we say to him, we'll always be inferior.

He'll be back. He needs us.
 
It's nothing nearly as complicated as that. Gerry is a narcissist. He must always feel good about himself. When his real life gives him enough satisfaction, he doesn't need us. But then something will happen to make him doubt his own intelligence.

...
I'm not saying that's not it, but I see in his behaviour a certain viral insistence that is common to see among some branches of Christianity: they have to massively convert the heathens in order to get a pole position in the race to heavens. Avon and Tupperware just copied the notion. With such a mentality, convincing an intellectual "atheist" is worth a hundred poor in spirit; an act that would be "such a get to the Lord", to say it in Flandersese.

But the narcissistic component is certainly there. How was it called in Internet wikis that mental defect of people believing themselves way smarter than they are and also believing the rest of mankind to be much more stupid? Yrreg might be the pietist embodiment of that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom