Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

yrreg

Master Poster
Joined
Nov 24, 2005
Messages
2,420
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, the universe is the one where we humans are residing in, in one of its planets, from where we can see its sun and also the moon that we see at night.

And also everything that makes up the what astrophysicists call popularly as the Big Bang universe.


Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?



Yrreg
 
The fact that the universe, as we know it, exists says nothing, one way or another, about the possible existence of a God or gods.
 
Well, yes I'd have to agree that your definition of what this universe is sounds reasonable.
And since this is the only universe we can (at the moment) observe, limiting proof of god to this universe is logical.

Now with science we can explain in detail how the universe formed from the earliest observable moments, and we have a pretty good theory on the moments before the earliest observable phase.
None of this requires divine intervention.
And more to the point, while understanding how it formed is hard, at least its more logical than assuming that instead of a non-intelligent universe forming, a fully functioning, reasonable, ethical, all-powerful being popped out of nothingness before the universe.

What evidence do you have then?
 
Last edited:
Now that you bring up evidence, that's very good for you to tell us what is evidence.

Well, yes I'd have to agree that your definition of what this universe is sounds reasonable.
And since this is the only universe we can (at the moment) observe, limiting proof of god to this universe is logical.

Now with science we can explain in detail how the universe formed from the earliest observable moments, and we have a pretty good theory on the moments before the earliest observable phase.
None of this requires divine intervention.
And more to the point, while understanding how it formed is hard, at least its more logical than assuming that instead of a non-intelligent universe forming, a fully functioning, reasonable, ethical, all-powerful being popped out of nothingness before the universe.

What evidence do you have then?


Now that you bring up evidence, that's very good for you to tell us what is evidence.



Yrreg
 
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, the universe is the one where we humans are residing in, in one of its planets,
[nitpick]On one of its planets, unless you live in a cave.[/nitpick]

from where we can see its sun and also the moon that we see at night.
[nitpick]The Moon is also visible during the day.[/nitpick]

And also everything that makes up the what astrophysicists call popularly as the Big Bang universe.

Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?
Okay, all nitpicking aside, let's use your definitions and run with them.

1. God is the maker of everything that isn't God.
2. God created the Universe and everything in it.
3. Therefore God is not anything in the Universe.
4. i.e. God does not exist within the Universe.
5. We are limited to considering things within the Universe.
6. Therefore God does not exist.

Well, that was, indeed, much simpler.





Now I have to remember not to use any zebra crossings. ;)
 
No need to go too fast, we are no into what is evidence.

No need to go too fast, we are no into what is evidence.



Yrreg
 
No need to go too fast, we are no into what is evidence.



Yrreg
No need for evidence, my proof relies solely on your definition of God and the limitations you placed on our consideration.
 
How do you arrive at non-existence from concept?

No need for evidence, my proof relies solely on your definition of God and the limitations you placed on our consideration.


How do you arrive at non-existence from concept?

Anyway, now that you say you have proof, suppose in addition to evidence you also tell readers here what is proof?



Yrreg
 
Now that you bring up evidence, that's very good for you to tell us what is evidence.



Yrreg

I'm not the person trying to reconcile my belief in a god with the observable universe.

So it'd be up to you to bring up any evidence for a god YOU find convincing and then for others to evaluate that.
 
How do you arrive at non-existence from concept?

Anyway, now that you say you have proof, suppose in addition to evidence you also tell readers here what is proof?



Yrreg
You can't handle the proof!
 
We have got to know what is proof and what is evidence from you atheists.

We have got to know what is proof and what is evidence from you atheists.

Because otherwise Christian theists would be producing proof, evidence, which you would insist not to be proof, evidence from your part.


By the way, allow me to request that we just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, as namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

To make the thread simpler.

So, please don't bring in the matter of God being this or that, just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, which is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.



Yrreg
 
I've noticed that, unlike other threads on exactly the same topic, you are now defining God differently by using "that is not god himself". Is this your new attempted gotcha?
 
I am trying a new approach, and I want to be more solemn now.

I've noticed that, unlike other threads on exactly the same topic, you are now defining God differently by using "that is not god himself". Is this your new attempted gotcha?


I am trying a new approach, and I want to be more solemn now.

We are all interested in getting to the facts, so it behooves us all to be serious and not flippant, and also not into diversionary tactics which do not serve any profitable advance to us all in the quest for facts.

God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself, I think that is a very simple, plain, clear and to my mind very precise way of conceiving God in our mind, so that we can go forward in the world outside our mind to look for God, seeking for the entity that satisfies that description.



Yrreg
 
gods are limited to fantasy universes.
 
Last edited:
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, the universe is the one where we humans are residing in, in one of its planets, from where we can see its sun and also the moon that we see at night.

And also everything that makes up the what astrophysicists call popularly as the Big Bang universe.


Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?



Yrreg

There is a plenty of proof, but unfortunately it is entirely unprovable.

It looks like folk are going to tie you up in knots about what is God, what isn't God and where did God come from etc.
 
I am trying a new approach, and I want to be more solemn now.

We are all interested in getting to the facts, so it behooves us all to be serious and not flippant, and also not into diversionary tactics which do not serve any profitable advance to us all in the quest for facts.

God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself, I think that is a very simple, plain, clear and to my mind very precise way of conceiving God in our mind, so that we can go forward in the world outside our mind to look for God, seeking for the entity that satisfies that description.



Yrreg

Which one of the many gods that mankind has invented are you talking about?
 
There is a plenty of proof, but unfortunately it is entirely unprovable.

It looks like folk are going to tie you up in knots about what is God, what isn't God and where did God come from etc.
Yes,those awkward questions that theists never answer. Those pesky atheists,always demanding proof of the existence of alleged super beings. Why can't they just have blind faith? Btw,if proof is unprovable,it is not proof.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom