Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Well I m glad for us both that you know the fundamental concept of God to be in...

So, in other words, we're just gonna go around in circles, then. Terrific. I'll be back when this thread hits page 12.



Well I am glad for us both that you know the fundamental concept in relation to the universe in the Christian faith is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

In the meantime you can read the works of atheists who seek to prove the non-existence of God, to find out whether they do have in regard to the Christian God, the fundamental concept of God etc.

Then also whether they do delimit the universe where God is the maker etc., to the Big Bang universe where man resides in, so that their reasoning to the non-existence of that God has bearing to a concrete universe.



Yrreg
 
Well I am glad for us both that you know the fundamental concept in relation to the universe in the Christian faith is that God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

In the meantime you can read the works of atheists who seek to prove the non-existence of God, to find out whether they do have in regard to the Christian God, the fundamental concept of God etc.

Then also whether they do delimit the universe where God is the maker etc., to the Big Bang universe where man resides in, so that their reasoning to the non-existence of that God has bearing to a concrete universe.



Yrreg
Atheists do not have to prove the non existence of any god or gods,that would be a long job,the list of gods that mankind has invented is a long one. Atheists do not have to do anything,you are the one making the claim. Would you like non believers to prove the non existence of Santa Claus,The Tooth Fairy,Zeus and Jupiter while we're at it?
 
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

So, if everything that is not God was made by God, what did God make everything out of?

To start with, all he had was himself, so logically, everything must be made of God...
 
Threads like this grow so fast I may have missed something in prior pages, but before we decide who made the universe, we have to make a convincing argument that it was made at all. And if, as some people suggest, time itself did not exist/occur/ or otherwise have any applicability before the big bang, then your definition of God immediately hits an intractable obstacle. For the universe to have a maker, there must have been a time before its making in which the maker made it.

So if the universe can be said to have been "made," then sure, we can call whatever made it "God" and get on with the juicy part in which we argue at swords' point over God's attributes and attitudes and threaten each other with hellfire or genocide or tsunamis. But we've a long way to go before that fun begins.
 
So, if everything that is not God was made by God, what did God make everything out of?

To start with, all he had was himself, so logically, everything must be made of God...
My new theory: God was the first and greatest suicide bomber. All that Jesus stuff is just a metaphor for the truly great sacrifice made by a loving god who realized the only way out of his logical contradiction was to blow himself up.
 
I'd be interested in your response to this as well, yrreg.

This thread is about atheists coming to the fundamental concept of God etc.

Now as regards the proof of the existence of God in objective reality corresponding to that concept of God, that should be in another thread.

I am laying the foundations for that thread.

That is why also I ask for examples of evidence and proof as defined by atheists here.

Now, the examples of evidence and of proof are not hypothetical and flippant examples, but things which are taken to be existing in science and also in everyday's life which atheists can prove to exist indeed on their definition of what is evidence and what is proof.



Yrreg

Well, you started out by specifically defining God and suggesting that we limit the discussion of the proof of the existence of God to that definition.

From the OP said:
Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?

Loss Leader, agreeing to grant that your definition of God correctly describes a real being, and that no further proof is necessary, asked where that leaves us. I am interested in your response, but if that's not what you want to talk about, okay.

As an aside, the tenets of Christianity as I understand them are based on followers having faith. If you produce irrefutable proof of the existence of God, what need will there be for faith, and how will this affect the fundamental underpinnings of the Christian religion?
 
When we talk about possibility we are talking about concepts.

The fact that the universe, as we know it, exists says nothing, one way or another, about the possible existence of a God or gods.

When we talk about possibility we are talking about concepts.


From the fact of the existence of the universe which is a very very big fact, man has asked whether someone made it, or it made itself.

These are conceptual questions.

Now, according to astrophysicists in their theory of the Big Bang which is the standard model for the beginning of the universe, it has a beginning where everything in it has also accordingly a beginning.

So, conceptually the universe could not have made itself, because according to man's intelligence in thinking, nothing can make itself that has a beginning.

Wherefore the universe conceptually has a maker that starts it on the beginning point of its existence.


That is all in concepts of course.




Yrreg
 
Of course atheists by their own logic don't have to prove, but psychologically...

Atheists do not have to prove the non existence of any god or gods,that would be a long job,the list of gods that mankind has invented is a long one. Atheists do not have to do anything,you are the one making the claim. Would you like non believers to prove the non existence of Santa Claus,The Tooth Fairy,Zeus and Jupiter while we're at it?


I am talking about the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith.

So, atheists can say that to their logic they don't have to prove the non-existence of God, that is fine, but psychologically they are compelled to do some kind of proving.

And I propose that they psychologically do the some kind of proving by focusing on the existence of God corresponding to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith.

Why do I say that psychologically they are compelled to do some kind of proving to the non-existence of God?

Well, if you look around they is so much writing from atheists precisely working to prove in effect to convince mankind that there is no entity corresponding to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith.

Look up all the writings in the library of the Infidels.org website.

Go to any bookstore and ask for atheist authors proving the non-existence of God.


Now, about atheists don't have to prove a negative, because they say it is impossible to prove a negative, I propose to atheists that it is so simple to prove a negative, by picking an enclosure that you can search all over to prove the negative of there is God here, because for example if you put yourself inside an isolation prison cell, then you can see, hear, touch, smell, taste, everything inside and every spot of the floor, ceiling, walls, that there is no God that you can smell, etc.

And I am sure fellow atheists will agree with you.

Now, you just consider the whole universe as small as your isolation prison cell, then you can prove a negative, namely, that there is no God in the universe of your prison isolation cell.



Yrreg
 
God conceptually made everything that is not God Himself out of His thoughts.

So, if everything that is not God was made by God, what did God make everything out of?

To start with, all he had was himself, so logically, everything must be made of God...


God conceptually made everything that is not God Himself out of His thoughts.

So, in concepts, he wills to create with his thought as the material and when He does not want to create He stops thinking about the thoughts which go to make the universe and everything in it.


Of course we are dealing with concepts, not with what exactly God used to make everything that is not God Himself.


So, in concepts, there was a point in the realm of existence when God had not created the universe and He was all alone, the whole realm of existence was He Himself.

Then He decided to create, and by thinking, that is with His thoughts, the universe and everything came forth.

When God wills to not think about me and you, we will stop existing, or when he wills to stop thinking about us staying alive, we die.




Yrreg
 
There is another kind of existence not in space/time, it is possible.

Threads like this grow so fast I may have missed something in prior pages, but before we decide who made the universe, we have to make a convincing argument that it was made at all. And if, as some people suggest, time itself did not exist/occur/ or otherwise have any applicability before the big bang, then your definition of God immediately hits an intractable obstacle. For the universe to have a maker, there must have been a time before its making in which the maker made it.

So if the universe can be said to have been "made," then sure, we can call whatever made it "God" and get on with the juicy part in which we argue at swords' point over God's attributes and attitudes and threaten each other with hellfire or genocide or tsunamis. But we've a long way to go before that fun begins.



In concepts:

There is another kind of existence not in space/time, it is possible.

There could be many kinds of existence, not only the kind which scientists know to be the material universe.

That is why the universe of the pre modern atheistic scientists -- of course not all scientists are atheists -- is more huge than the material universe which is the only universe atheist scientists know about and limit themselves to.

That is a kind of self-censorship.


Now, you say nothing existed prior to time/space, but time/space came with the Big Bang universe which also saw the 'beginning' of time/space, and the Big Bang universe started with time/space.

So, is it your contention that the material universe came forth from absolute nothing -- but you don't believe in miracles.




Yrreg
 
I already said that God as maker of the universe does not require faith.

Well, you started out by specifically defining God and suggesting that we limit the discussion of the proof of the existence of God to that definition.



Loss Leader, agreeing to grant that your definition of God correctly describes a real being, and that no further proof is necessary, asked where that leaves us. I am interested in your response, but if that's not what you want to talk about, okay.

As an aside, the tenets of Christianity as I understand them are based on followers having faith. If you produce irrefutable proof of the existence of God, what need will there be for faith, and how will this affect the fundamental underpinnings of the Christian religion?


I already said that God as maker of the universe does not require faith.


Use the search function and look for Apostles' Creed, Gen. 1:1.


Of course for people who are not enjoying the leisure to reason to the existence of God in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, as maker of everything that is not God Himself, they need faith, and also faith in the rest of the Christian revelation repertoire.

But it is the teaching of Christianism that God's existence as the maker of everything that is not God Himself can be known and is known by reason.



Yrreg
 
Well, you do have a limited acquaintance with the Christian God.

He is fundamentally in relation to the universe maker of everything that is not God Himself.

The existence of God as in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, namely, maker of everything that is not God Himself, according to the Christian faith is accessible to human reason.

In the beginning God made heaven and earth. Gen. 1:1.

I believe in God... maker of heaven and earth. Apostles' Creed line one.
​

That God made heaven and earth is in the Bible and in the Apostles Creed, but insofar as maker of heaven and earth is concerned which is the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, and up to that point:

Christians don't need faith nor revelation to know that God, for it is the doctrine of Christianism that that God can be and is known by and to human reason.

Of course Christians also know God by faith and from revelation, but still man with his reason can and does know the existence of God in His fundamental relation to the universe as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

​

You don't know that?

Please read up on reason and faith in Christianism from the established authorities of the Christian faith, not please not from atheists and non-Christians or ex-Christians.



Yrreg

I don't really know how to respond to this. I don't think it addresses any of the things I said but I'm not sure. I recognize the words as English words but they're not put together in a way that makes sense in the English language. It's as if his keyboard vomited. Could somebody possibly translate that drivel into actual English and tell me if he was actually responding to my post that he quoted?
 
Last edited:
So how do we get from this first cause God to the specifically Christian God? You know, the God that appeared to all those old testament prophets. The God who put Adam and Eve into a garden containing forbidden fruit. The God who sent the flood, destroyed Soddom and Gemorrah, led Joshua on a genicidal rampage through Canaan, got some Jewish teenager pregnant and used the child as his cat's-paw and could only forgive us if we believe that this innocent kid being tortured by ancient Romans is somehow our fault and also a good thing.

How does anything in the bible follow from someones inability to imagine a universe that comes into existence unassisted by magic?
 
Did the read the title of the thread, limiting God to the Big Bang universe?

So how do we get from this first cause God to the specifically Christian God? You know, the God that appeared to all those old testament prophets. The God who put Adam and Eve into a garden containing forbidden fruit. The God who sent the flood, destroyed Soddom and Gemorrah, led Joshua on a genicidal rampage through Canaan, got some Jewish teenager pregnant and used the child as his cat's-paw and could only forgive us if we believe that this innocent kid being tortured by ancient Romans is somehow our fault and also a good thing.

How does anything in the bible follow from someones inability to imagine a universe that comes into existence unassisted by magic?


Did the read the title of the thread, limiting God to the Big Bang universe?


That is why I keep repeating that I am into the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, which is maker of everything that is not God Himself.

To get people to focus on the God that is maker of everything that is not God, meaning maker of the universe that is introduced into existence by God at the point of the Big Bang.

Before anything else in the Christian faith, God is the maker of the universe or everything that is not God Himself.

Without that feature of God, God is nothing notwithstanding everything else in the Christian faith.



Yrreg
 
My new theory: God was the first and greatest suicide bomber. All that Jesus stuff is just a metaphor for the truly great sacrifice made by a loving god who realized the only way out of his logical contradiction was to blow himself up.

I'd be ok with this and it meets yrreg's definition of God as the maker of everything that isn't God.

God made the universe but blew himself up in making it and no longer exists.

Does that work for you, yrreg?
 
Did the read the title of the thread, limiting God to the Big Bang universe?


That is why I keep repeating that I am into the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, which is maker of everything that is not God Himself.

To get people to focus on the God that is maker of everything that is not God, meaning maker of the universe that is introduced into existence by God at the point of the Big Bang.

Before anything else in the Christian faith, God is the maker of the universe or everything that is not God Himself.

Without that feature of God, God is nothing notwithstanding everything else in the Christian faith.



Yrreg

OK. So if we ignore everything else the bible says about this God, then we have the fundamental essence of what God means?

Unfortunately for you, if we leave out everything else the bible says about Him, there isn't anything left to identify Him as Christian. For all you know, this big bang god might be the great Mumbo Jumbo of the Congo and every time you pray to Jesus you are just making him angrier.
 
In concepts:

There is another kind of existence not in space/time, it is possible.

There could be many kinds of existence, not only the kind which scientists know to be the material universe.

That is why the universe of the pre modern atheistic scientists -- of course not all scientists are atheists -- is more huge than the material universe which is the only universe atheist scientists know about and limit themselves to.

That is a kind of self-censorship.


Now, you say nothing existed prior to time/space, but time/space came with the Big Bang universe which also saw the 'beginning' of time/space, and the Big Bang universe started with time/space.

So, is it your contention that the material universe came forth from absolute nothing -- but you don't believe in miracles.




Yrreg

You say there could be many kinds of existence but saying it doesn't make it true. If you have some idea of another kind of existence, you'll need to describe it in order to discuss it. Disqualifying contradictory points of view by saying "there could be something else" is no argument at all.

If time existed before time existed you have a contradiction. If time did not exist before the universe existed, then the very idea of something "prior" is nonsensical and contradictory. If you're going to prove God you're going to have to come up with a solution to this question, or find a convincing argument that time existed before the universe did.

I don't contend anything about the material universe, and I have never stated that I don't believe in miracles. I simply question your contentions and your ability to support them. Your ideas are the subject of this thread. I need none of my own.
 
Yrreg, you can't on the one hand insist that we are discussing only god (maker of everything not god) who is the Xian god, from Genesis and the Apostles creed, while at the same time telling us we can't discuss the bible or Xianity.

It's hypocritical.

YOU brought Christianity and the bible and the creed into this. We are fully justified in asking you to justify the leap from "maker of everything" to the Xian god.
 
Now, about atheists don't have to prove a negative, because they say it is impossible to prove a negative, I propose to atheists that it is so simple to prove a negative, by picking an enclosure that you can search all over to prove the negative of there is God here, because for example if you put yourself inside an isolation prison cell, then you can see, hear, touch, smell, taste, everything inside and every spot of the floor, ceiling, walls, that there is no God that you can smell, etc.

And I am sure fellow atheists will agree with you.




Yrreg
Agree with what? What are you groping at? There is no point at all to the above.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom