Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Yes, for you God does not exist, but you have got to know the concept of God.

Originally Posted by yrreg
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge* of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.

[ * "knowledge" here should be "acknowledgment", so as to correlate with believe in "need to believe in god" from tsig below . ]​

Atheists need to believe in god then we can ask god who made him?



I guess that is fair to God, and logical to you, first take the existence of God to be a fact, then you and I can ask Him the question who made Him.

It is it like if your father is God, and he is my father also, then we can us both ask Him: "Father God you make everything that is not You God Yourself, who made You?"

Our Father God will answer, "Don't be silly."


Now, I want you to know that, even though for you God does not exist, you have got to have the acquaintance of the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith.

So that you can avoid making the mistake of disbelieving in the wrong God insofar as Christians are concerned, fundamentally in relation to the universe, on the one hand.

And on the other hand, also avoid speaking and writing against the wrong God, again, insofar as Christians are concerned, Which God for Christians in relation to the universe is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Knowledge of the fundamental concept of God for Christians in relation to the universe is not equivalent to the acknowledgment i.e. recognition of the existence of God for Christians.

Hope you get that subtlety.



Yrreg
 
It is it like if your father is God, and he is my father also, then we can us both ask Him: "Father God you make everything that is not You God Yourself, who made You?"

Our Father God will answer, "Don't be silly."

"Your grandfather and grandmother made me."

So who made your god?
 
I guess that is fair to God, and logical to you, first take the existence of God to be a fact, then you and I can ask Him the question who made Him.

It is it like if your father is God, and he is my father also, then we can us both ask Him: "Father God you make everything that is not You God Yourself, who made You?"

Our Father God will answer, "Don't be silly."


Now, I want you to know that, even though for you God does not exist, you have got to have the acquaintance of the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith.

So that you can avoid making the mistake of disbelieving in the wrong God insofar as Christians are concerned, fundamentally in relation to the universe, on the one hand.

And on the other hand, also avoid speaking and writing against the wrong God, again, insofar as Christians are concerned, Which God for Christians in relation to the universe is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Knowledge of the fundamental concept of God for Christians in relation to the universe is not equivalent to the acknowledgment i.e. recognition of the existence of God for Christians.

Hope you get that subtlety.



Yrreg

We might be able to if it was redrafted into good English.
 
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?
But you need to ask questions in a logical sequence, not “horse before cart”. Before any questions regarding a god make any logical sense there needs to be at least some credible evidence that at least one god exists (unless we’re merely playing “let’s pretend“). Given you’re the one claiming a god exists you’re the one that should provide such credible evidence. You won’t because you can’t.

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.
Yrreg
But if Atheists “come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith” they would no longer be Atheists (DOH!). I think you suffer from premature articulation.
 
Well, you do have a limited acquaintance with the Christian God.

I've always wondered why religious people try to prove that God exists. Isn't faith believing in something without any evidence? A Christian might believe Jesus was the son of God. A Muslim might believe that Muhammed was a prophet of God. A child might believe that Santa Claus exists. A Ranger fan might believe that Glen Sather won't make a ridiculous signing this off-season that cripples the Rangers future opportunities to sign decent players in subsequent seasons. All these things have no evidence and require faith. And there's nothing wrong with that as long as you admit that there is no evidence. I have no problem with religious people who tell me that they don't have evidence, they just have faith. It's not good enough for me and I think it shows a serious lack of critical thinking skills, but at least they admit it. Aren't those who try to show evidence of God contradicting themselves by trying to prove their faith when they don't actually have any?



Well, you do have a limited acquaintance with the Christian God.

He is fundamentally in relation to the universe maker of everything that is not God Himself.

The existence of God as in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, namely, maker of everything that is not God Himself, according to the Christian faith is accessible to human reason.

In the beginning God made heaven and earth. Gen. 1:1.

I believe in God... maker of heaven and earth. Apostles' Creed line one.
​

That God made heaven and earth is in the Bible and in the Apostles Creed, but insofar as maker of heaven and earth is concerned which is the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith, and up to that point:

Christians don't need faith nor revelation to know that God, for it is the doctrine of Christianism that that God can be and is known by and to human reason.

Of course Christians also know God by faith and from revelation, but still man with his reason can and does know the existence of God in His fundamental relation to the universe as maker of everything that is not God Himself.

​

You don't know that?

Please read up on reason and faith in Christianism from the established authorities of the Christian faith, not please not from atheists and non-Christians or ex-Christians.



Yrreg
 
My definition of God is as follows:

God in the fundamental concept in relation to the universe for Christians is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.


Gerry, why are we going around in circles, stating your definition of god over and over again?

Are you waiting for every single post from every single person to agree with you?

Why are you only concentrating on people who are trying to pull you off topic?

I have agreed to grant that your definition of God, as the maker of the universe, correctly describes a real being. That God exists. No further proof is necessary.

So what is the next step? Now that we agree such a god exists, what would you next like us to agree upon?

Please don't ignore the people who want to hear your argument and move forward. Please don't repeat the same things over again. Tell us the next step in your thinking.


or Judaists


Still not a word.
 
I think I was last here in February 2011, but no posting from me then.

Evidence, as others have said before, is anything that tends to make a statement more or less true.

Proof, as has been said before, is an accumulation of evidence sufficient to convince the mind.

[...]

ETA: I wonder what the stressor was that brought you back here.


Please give examples of proof as of evidence.


I came back on an impulse when I was reading the exchanges between lifegazer and his counter-posters.




Yrreg
 
I guess that is fair to God, and logical to you, first take the existence of God to be a fact, then you and I can ask Him the question who made Him.

It is it like if your father is God, and he is my father also, then we can us both ask Him: "Father God you make everything that is not You God Yourself, who made You?"

Our Father God will answer, "Don't be silly."

So now "God" has gone from "Maker of everything except himself" to being an entity that converses with people, and whose responses you can predict?
 
*snip*

I have agreed to grant that your definition of God, as the maker of the universe, correctly describes a real being. That God exists. No further proof is necessary.

So what is the next step? Now that we agree such a god exists, what would you next like us to agree upon?


*snip*

I'd be interested in your response to this as well, yrreg.
 
Please give examples of proof as of evidence.



Your question makes no sense. It literally is too ungrammatical to understand. What level of proof do you want examples of: mathematical, scientific, beyond a reasonable doubt, probable cause, or something else?

Why do you want examples of evidence and proof?

You are the person creating an argument. Shouldn't you be the one advancing your definition of evidence and proof?

Also, what does this have to do with your main argument? You wanted to talk about agreeing upon a definition of God. I have agreed to it, without the need for proof. So what's the big deal with proof?
 
Last edited:
All such name-calling is not worthy of true academics and gentlemen in exchange of...

Originally Posted by yrreg
Says nothing to people who don't hear or can't hear, but there are many who hear and come to the knowledge of God in His fundamental concept in relation to the universe, for Christians, as the maker of everything that is not God Himself.

Of course you can deny that they know God to exist, while they are flabbergasted that you don't.

​


I am flabbergasted that they believe in a sky daddy,without a shred of evidence.


All such name-calling is not worthy of true academics and gentlemen in exchange of thoughts for mutual efforts to come to the facts in the world of concepts as also in specially the world of reality outside concepts.

No matter how you want to justify such disparaging epithets that you are just saying that God does not exist for you as sky daddy does not exist, the thing is that in fundamental concepts in relation to the universe they are not in the same class, and any such name-calling is tantamount to gross violation of rules of engagement in civil discussion.

Your attitude is that God does not exist, and my attitude is that God exists, but there is attitude and attitude. so please please watch your tongue.



Yrreg
 
Your attitude is that God does not exist, and my attitude is that God exists, but there is attitude and attitude. so please please watch your tongue.


You are saying that "sky daddy" is such an offensive term for God as to cut off debate?

Why not just ignore the ONE person who said sky daddy and continue on with those people who want to hear what you have to say next? Please.
 
This thread is about atheists coming to the fundamental concept of God etc.

Originally Posted by Loss Leader
*snip*

I have agreed to grant that your definition of God, as the maker of the universe, correctly describes a real being. That God exists. No further proof is necessary.

So what is the next step? Now that we agree such a god exists, what would you next like us to agree upon?


*snip*

​
I'd be interested in your response to this as well, yrreg.


This thread is about atheists coming to the fundamental concept of God etc.

Now as regards the proof of the existence of God in objective reality corresponding to that concept of God, that should be in another thread.

I am laying the foundations for that thread.

That is why also I ask for examples of evidence and proof as defined by atheists here.

Now, the examples of evidence and of proof are not hypothetical and flippant examples, but things which are taken to be existing in science and also in everyday's life which atheists can prove to exist indeed on their definition of what is evidence and what is proof.



Yrreg
 
EDIT: Nevermind. Yrreg beat me.
 
Last edited:
Please give some examples of evidence and of proof.



Yrreg

Yrreg's posting history is evidence that he is still nothing more than a pseudo-intellectual and a third-rate apologist.

This thread is proof that he is.
 
Apologies or being late to the illogic party, but let me see if I've got this right: this is the thread where:

1. I set a definition of something as a default position, no evidence required; then

2. Set the parameters of the discussion so that the definition itself is not for discussion, only the result of that definition; then

2. Challenge people that disagree with my definition by asking for proof of my definition? (I must admit to being challenged in distilling the logic of this third point down to a single sentence).

This is not a logical or valid basis for a discussion. It presupposes the initially defined object exists.

So, what is the point of this thread?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom