Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Perhaps the proof is behind the event horizon of the formless and therefore unreachable.
 
Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?



Yrreg

If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes, then you could only say that the universe is consistent with such a God, but not proof of one.
 
If god manifests in our universe in anyway... by anwsering prayers, by preforming micacles, etc. then these would be claims that we could test regardless of if god was in our universe or not.
 
There is a plenty of proof, but unfortunately it is entirely unprovable.
That must be about the shortest contradiction ever. :rolleyes:

It looks like folk are going to tie you up in knots about what is God, what isn't God and where did God come from etc.
Entirely reasonable questions, at least the first two. How are you going to prove something exists if you don't define what that something is?

Otherwise, I have a very short proof that God exists.
for the sake of argument, I christened the keyboard I'm typing this on as "God". :rolleyes:
 
The fact that the universe, as we know it, exists says nothing, one way or another, about the possible existence of a God or gods.

Seconded!

Our science is very good these days and it has not shown anything about the existence of a God and/or Gods.
 
That must be about the shortest contradiction ever. :rolleyes:


Entirely reasonable questions, at least the first two. How are you going to prove something exists if you don't define what that something is?

Otherwise, I have a very short proof that God exists.
for the sake of argument, I christened the keyboard I'm typing this on as "God". :rolleyes:

Blasphemer! My cat is God!
 
Welcome back yrreg. I agree that the deity you're proposing is less problematic, at least based on what I've heard so far, than many others I've heard of. Am I correct in thinking you're talking about a God who starts everything but doesn't intervene physically thereafter? That is, the physical world is unfolding according to God's plan, he doesn't do miracles (since everything is going to plan), but he does provide an afterlife outside of our ability to detect it? Please clarify anything I'm mistaking in your concept.

And good luck on your fresh start.
 
We have got to know what is proof and what is evidence from you atheists.

A manifestation of god acting within the universe.

If you want to present evidence of god to an atheist, you need to make a statement like "If god exists then we should observe X happening, whereas if he doesn't exist we should observe Y happening, and when we look around, we find X happening rather than Y, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

What X and Y are depends on you and your conception of what god is and will do. As a purely hypothetical example, somebody might say :

"If god exists then we should observe that sick people become well more often if they are prayed for, whereas if he doesn't exist we should find that prayer makes no difference, and when we look around, we find sick people who are prayed for do get better more often than those who are not prayed for rather than them all getting better at the same rate, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

Only the actual fact is that this doesn't actually happen, and in truth prayer makes no difference at all.

But that would be evidence. Tell us something which we can go out and investigate where one thing would be true if your god existed and false if he didn't. It's that simple.
 
Last edited:
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, the universe is the one where we humans are residing in, in one of its planets, from where we can see its sun and also the moon that we see at night.

And also everything that makes up the what astrophysicists call popularly as the Big Bang universe.


Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?

No, it wouldn't actually.

You'd need to show that in addition to the BB universe something else exists. That is a tall order in and of itself. But not enough with that.

You'd need to show that the "something else" is God and not ~God, e.g. not for instance the rest of the multiverse, not a parallel universe, not the meta-nultiverse, or what have you.

IOW, what you suggest as maybe being simpler, is something that is just not going to happen.
 
Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?

Sure.
But you still haven't presented any evidence for your God.

Soo... are you gonna work on presenting the evidence or are you gonna try to persuade us to believe in something blindly, by using silly arguments? My guess is the latter.
 
I define the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe in the Christian faith as:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

Now, the universe is the one where we humans are residing in, in one of its planets, from where we can see its sun and also the moon that we see at night.

And also everything that makes up the what astrophysicists call popularly as the Big Bang universe.


Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?

Simpler than what?

We have got to know what is proof and what is evidence from you atheists.

Evidence is facts which are more likely under one set of circumstances than another, thus lending credence to that set of circumstances above other potential sets.

Proof is either a mathematical proof or simply such an overwhelming weight of evidence that dismissing it is impossible when thinking rationally.

NOTE: Both of these definitions are highly simplified.

Because otherwise Christian theists would be producing proof, evidence, which you would insist not to be proof, evidence from your part.

No. Proof and evidence are not different across differing viewpoints. What is evidence to theists is evidence to atheists. It's just that theists have neither evidence nor proof.

There is a plenty of proof, but unfortunately it is entirely unprovable.

The above sentence is one of the dumbest things I have ever seen written.

"There is plenty of red paint, but unfortunately it is entirely green."
 
We have got to know what is proof and what is evidence from you atheists.
Something observable would be a good start.

Because otherwise Christian theists would be producing proof, evidence, which you would insist not to be proof, evidence from your part.
No, they wouldn't be producing any proof. All of their "proofs" are poorly-constructed philosophical arguments or talk about how they feel Jesus in their hearts. That's not proof. Give me a picture, or show me his power. Show me anything at all that requires a supernatural process and that would at least be a start. Everything we see in this universe is completely consistent with natural processes, which we understand more and more about every single day. Christians have had 2000 years to produce evidence, and have failed miserably at every turn. I have yet to find a believer who was converted by evidence. It's all emotion and wishing.
By the way, allow me to request that we just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, as namely:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​

To make the thread simpler.
What does that have to do with Christianity? All kinds of religious people have gods who create the universe. The Christian god is much more specific. He's a right prick, and he raped a gal so he could become Jesus, and he can save people from their awful humanness (so-called sin). So if you really want to talk about proof of the Christian god, you're going to have to go much further than just proving that any sort of god created a universe, which for all appearances, is a natural phenomenon, with no gods required. Put up the disclaimer: No actual gods were harmed in the making of this universe.


So, please don't bring in the matter of God being this or that, just keep to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, which is that He is the maker of everything that is not God Himself.
Again, the fundamental concept of the Christian god in relation to this universe, is that he created it ALL specifically for the human beings that inhabit thisteeny tiny little planet, and that he made this planet perfectly until Adam and Eve ate from the wrong tree, and that he's been forced to punish all people for all eternity since that time, until he brought Jesus into the picture so everybody can go to heaven if they accept him. Oh, and he really really cares about people when he's not thinking about how much he wants to kill them, and he'll listen to your prayers and give you advice, and he's totally cool with babies dying and a half million people being wiped out by a tsunami.

I am trying a new approach, and I want to be more solemn now.
Is that what you're calling it? The only thing you've changed is that you used to say the maker of the moon and everything.

God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself, I think that is a very simple, plain, clear and to my mind very precise way of conceiving God in our mind, so that we can go forward in the world outside our mind to look for God, seeking for the entity that satisfies that description.

That's not clear at all. If he's the maker of everything, does that he mean he made my breakfast this morning?

Why don't you start everything off by saying what it was specifically that you think your god made (because I know it doesn't include my breakfast, or the sweater I'm wearing). And then maybe say what you think made your god, since you said he didn't make himself.
 
Last edited:
Hello, Gerry!

I will answer you the same way I have many times in the past, and I hope that other posters follow my lead and answer you in this way as well:

I grant you that God, the maker of the universe, exists. I grant and agree that the universe was created by God who created the entire universe - the sun and moon and whatever else you wrote.

Such a God does exist. I agree. There is no need for you to present any further proof of the matter. Nor is there a need to define proof.

Let us grant you that such a God exists, as I have offered to do in the past.

Now what? What is the next step of your argument once we agree that the universe was created by a creator?
 
I have myself considered an "idiot god" who's sole talent is the causation of "bang" events.
No planning, no design... Just, "Ooooh, pretty!"

This notion of a God that exists outside of the universe neatly avoids falsification. No evidence is available, and it could not be observed.
That is in fact the position a number of Christian apologists have taken of late. Instead of the anthromorphic God of the Old Testament, we get a nebulous god very much similar to the Hindu idea.... Totally devoid of any characteristics humans could appreciate.

This seems like nothing more than a logic trick to me.... "There! Disprove that!"
 
God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself, I think that is a very simple, plain, clear and to my mind very precise way of conceiving God in our mind, so that we can go forward in the world outside our mind to look for God, seeking for the entity that satisfies that description.


I'll agree with "simple". Clear, plain and precise? No.

Your definition is useless. It establishes nothing, it explains nothing. You've defined your god into an abstraction, at best.

IF I accept the universe has a beginning, your definition of god is necessarily the cause of that beginning. If said cause turns out to be purely natural, mundane physical phenomena, then your god becomes a curiosity of physics/nature. Much like quantum mechanics or chemistry. Congratulations Yrreg. Your god is 2C8H18 + 25O2 --> 16CO2 + 18H2O

So how does gravity work? Does calling it "god" grant us some insight? No. Does it explain anything? No. All it does is stifle inquiry. You will say "This is God!", and end all investigation. We learn nothing new, and science comes to screeching halt in your inability to investigate explanations.

Fundamentally useless.

Pure Argent has answered your request for definitions of proof and evidence, but to be frank I flat-out reject your argument as a non-starter. I don't think we should discuss evidence and proof until you can provide a definition for your god that permits us to assign specific testable attributes. At the moment, based on your God, the argument is a non-starter.

You might as well start off by saying that your computer monitor is god, and therefore god exists.

I reject your proof by attempted re-definition of terms.
 
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

So who made god?

(Wonder if a yrreg thread will tempt Fiona back?)



Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.



Yrreg
 
Please try your best to limit your posting to the Christian God which is defined...

Originally Posted by yrreg

I am trying a new approach, and I want to be more solemn now.

We are all interested in getting to the facts, so it behooves us all to be serious and not flippant, and also not into diversionary tactics which do not serve any profitable advance to us all in the quest for facts.

God is the maker of everything that is not God Himself, I think that is a very simple, plain, clear and to my mind very precise way of conceiving God in our mind, so that we can go forward in the world outside our mind to look for God, seeking for the entity that satisfies that description.


​

Which one of the many gods that mankind has invented are you talking about?



Please try your best to limit your posting to the Christian God which is defined by me as in fundamental concept in relation to the universe the:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​




Yrreg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom