Limiting God to the Big Bang universe.

Evidence - That which tends to prove or disprove a given conclusion.
Proof - Evidence sufficient to establish an idea as true or false.

May we move on?

Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.



Yrreg

Sorry, pal. That's not the way it works. This is a very subtle ad hominem argument, in that it attempts to establish that criticisms of a worldview are invalidated, because the critic does not accept that the underlying idea is true. Please try again.
 
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.



Yrreg

Go and preach in a church,you are wasting our own and our time. Let's start with proof that the god you believe in exists. Got any?
 
yrreg, the Christian god is not defined as the maker of the universe. He is defined as a personal god, who made the universe specifically for humans, who cares about their sex lives, who offers them salvation, who can see into their hearts, and all sorts of other nonsense.

So if you want to talk about a god who is the maker of this universe, fine. Just know that it has nothing to do with Christianity; that can be settled with simple deism. If you want to talk about the maker of everything that is not himself, then that's nonsense and not an argument worth pursuing, unless you really want to claim that he's busy in all the factories and fields and kitchens of the world.
 
I am inviting atheists to give the fundamental concepts of proof and evidence...

Yes,those awkward questions that theists never answer. Those pesky atheists,always demanding proof of the existence of alleged super beings. Why can't they just have blind faith? Btw,if proof is unprovable,it is not proof.


I am inviting atheists to give the fundamental concepts of proof and evidence in relation to the universe from their knowledge of proof and evidence.

Because otherwise when I bring forth the evidence and the proof for the existence of God outside the mind of man in objective reality, they will say that my proof on my evidence is not proof and not evidence.



Yrreg
 
I can't even begin to tell you how glad I am that yrreg is back. This section has been rather boring lately.
 
I am inviting atheists to give the fundamental concepts of proof and evidence in relation to the universe from their knowledge of proof and evidence

But I did that, and you ignored it. That seems strange to me. Here it is again :

A manifestation of god acting within the universe.

If you want to present evidence of god to an atheist, you need to make a statement like "If god exists then we should observe X happening, whereas if he doesn't exist we should observe Y happening, and when we look around, we find X happening rather than Y, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

What X and Y are depends on you and your conception of what god is and will do. As a purely hypothetical example, somebody might say :

"If god exists then we should observe that sick people become well more often if they are prayed for, whereas if he doesn't exist we should find that prayer makes no difference, and when we look around, we find sick people who are prayed for do get better more often than those who are not prayed for rather than them all getting better at the same rate, and therefore this supports the existence of god."

Only the actual fact is that this doesn't actually happen, and in truth prayer makes no difference at all.

But that would be evidence. Tell us something which we can go out and investigate where one thing would be true if your god existed and false if he didn't. It's that simple.
 
What Seismosaurus said.


If there was one true god, he should have had no trouble getting his message to humans in a clear and consistent manner. He shouldn't be choosing favorites and giving some people the right message and letting others languish with false ideas. When you've got all kinds of people claiming all kinds of gods, then it all looks like people just making up stuff to make themselves look good and the non-believers look bad so they can gain power and claim authority.

If any supernatural gods had any power whatsoever, they should be able to provide clear proof to anybody asking, instead of most people just accepting the truth of whatever stories they heard first or loudest. Why would a real god be content to leave his message in the hands of illiterate misogynists and hypocritical morons?
 
I am inviting atheists to give the fundamental concepts of proof and evidence in relation to the universe from their knowledge of proof and evidence.

Because otherwise when I bring forth the evidence and the proof for the existence of God outside the mind of man in objective reality, they will say that my proof on my evidence is not proof and not evidence.



Yrreg

You know, I've seen this many times. Someone will come in with something to prove, but before we get to all that, we have to establish what proof is. What is evidence?

I am not an unreasonable person. I have had many, many conversations about all sorts of subjects (yes, even God!) without going through this song and dance. I have already stated simple definitions for "proof" and "evidence." I'll repeat them here:

Evidence - That which tends to prove or disprove a given conclusion.
Proof - Evidence sufficient to establish an idea as true or false.

May we move on?
 
Because otherwise when I bring forth the evidence and the proof for the existence of God outside the mind of man in objective reality, they will say that my proof on my evidence is not proof and not evidence.



Yrreg

It isn't proof or evidence,just stories from an old book of fiction.
 
Suppose we edit your words this way, and remove the phrase, "but no proof of one."

Originally Posted by yrreg

Now, suppose we limit the proof of the existence of God to this universe, that should be simpler, wouldn't it?


​


If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes, then you could only say that the universe is consistent with such a God, but not proof of one.


You say:

1. If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes,

2. then you could only say that the universe is consistent with such a God,

3. but not proof of one.

​


Suppose we edit your words this way:

1. If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes, then these natural processes are the processes God operates,

2. and then you could [remove 'only'] say that the universe is consistent with such a God [period].

[Remove] 3. but not proof of one.​



Yrreg
 
When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.


Please try your best to limit your posting to the Christian God which is defined by me as in fundamental concept in relation to the universe the:

Maker of everything that is not God Himself.​



WOAH WOAH WOAH WOAH!!


Stop! Just stop, right there.



This is why I reject your definition of god as worse than useless.

How on earth do you jump from "Maker of everything that is not God Himself" to the Christian god?


Second, didn't anyone ever tell you not to use the term you are defining in the definition? You can't define "god" as "maker of everything except god". It's absurd. In order to know what your definition of god means, we have to know what your definition of god is. :boggled:


Thirdly, the sentence
"When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him."​
is unintelligible.
 
Last edited:
Who made God, that is another question, but one question at a time, okay?

When you atheists have come to the knowledge of the existence of God according to the fundamental concept of God in relation to the universe, in the Christian faith, then we can together you atheists and we Christians work together to ask God who made Him.



Yrreg

Atheists need to believe in god then we can ask god who made him?
 
You say:
1. If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes,

2. then you could only say that the universe is consistent with such a God,

3. but not proof of one.

​
Suppose we edit your words this way:
1. If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes, then these natural processes are the processes God operates,

2. and then you could [remove 'only'] say that the universe is consistent with such a God [period].

[Remove] 3. but not proof of one.
​


Yrreg

Which becomes a self defeating argument. God can not be proved or disproved under these rules. The fall back then has to be perception - something science is not built to explore. So ultimately the individual has to decide. I think God exist, I dont think God exists, and leave it at that
 
Atheists need to believe in god then we can ask god who made him?


Atheists need to believe in the Christian god so that we can ask god who made him.
 
You say:

1. If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes,

2. then you could only say that the universe is consistent with such a God,

3. but not proof of one.

​


Suppose we edit your words this way:

1. If God exists and operates in a way that is indistinguishable from natural processes, then these natural processes are the processes God operates,

2. and then you could [remove 'only'] say that the universe is consistent with such a God [period].

[Remove] 3. but not proof of one.​



Yrreg

And if I define "God" as the process by which I make a sandwich, then I can say that God made my sandwich.
 
Atheists need to believe in god then we can ask god who made him?

How so? If an atheist is in a position to ask God anything, there must be some evidence of God's existence, you cant ask a belief where it came from
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom