Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Scientists are people.

The bulk of Western science was developed in the Western world by people who went to Church, who had religious upbringing.

Even when I was a good little Catholic altar boy, I never once bought into the concept of angels.
 
Johannes Kepler.


To the larger point, scientists can believe looney stuff as easily as anyone. Compartmentalization isn't just for trains!

That's a one. I was hoping for the "many" Cat claimed. And a bit more contemporary.

Though your point about compartmentalization is noted and agreed with.
 
Problem is that most, if not all religions make claims about the physical universe that are overt trespasses into the realm of scientific endeavor. These claims are found in their texts (virgin birth, rising from the dead) and unless they are advanced as metaphorical, one can argue they indeed overlap.

Of course if one makes the argument that all these stories are metaphorical, metaphysical in nature, or philosophical . . . well, a good tart, lime or otherwise, is more interesting.

That's not exactly what I meant... SJG's NOMA was not of a simplistic character, which was, I think, exactly what he intended. There was a very strong element of shrewd compromise with reality. Religious people are not disappearing. They are not leaving the planet tomorrow (the Rapture definitely isn't happening.) So what's the best way to start dialogues with them? Agressive confrontations and rants will not work; SJG knew that better than anyone. He wasn't interested in addressing fundamentalists, because they weren't going to listen no matter what happened, so the book was designed to appeal to more mainstream Christians.

But if y'all have read it, the structure was also pretty sneaky. The beginning lulled people's anxieties and drew them in, essays about creationism in the middle, softly softly catchee monkee, and then the trap gradually CLOSED!! Well, okay, it didn't exactly snap shut.. but what people were reading by the end was NOT what they'd been led to believe they were going to get from the beginning of the book at all.
 
Last edited:
the book was designed to appeal to more mainstream Christians.

And the problem with this is that I am not familiar with single mainstream, "moderate" christian who is familiar with NOMA, much less one who has read it and found it appealing.

However I am aquainted with moderate christians who have no problem accepting most "miracles" attributed to Christ. These are violations of known physical laws and as such subject to scientific scrutiny. An overlap, if you will. My take only, of course.
 
I present the New Synthesis:-
"It's only the best model we have to date that works."



While it turns out there are atheists in foxholes, (also foxes) it seems unlikely there exists a single person who, at 33000 feet in heavy turbulence , does not believe in proximate reality; and who would not prefer to believe the aircraft carrying him was designed by scientific engineers rather than by post modernist english professors.
 
Last edited:
What is the criteria for impossible, and has that criteria been met?

I'd say a question is impossible to answer if evidence cannot be used to distinguish between a reality where one answer is true, and a reality where another answer is true.

In order to prove that things can happen without you knowing about them, you would have to discover something which had happened without you knowing about it; But as soon as you did, you would know about it, thus making the effort self-defeating. Hence, impossible question.


I know it's a turn of phrase, but does the evidence have to be visual?

If it is, are blind people screwed over in never being able to know?

I can't see any reason why it needs to be visual.
 
We could go on and on and on about this argument. I could quote many famous scientists who had a belief in Angels...

But let's just accept that you are insulted by this.

I apologise for any slight. None was intended.


Many people have accomplished things in spite of believing in woo and other foolish things.

That is no excuse not to honestly examine one's beliefs, discarding all that are discovered to be unfounded.
 
To know what is real, should we first consult science? Or are we making leaps of faith until science confirms this?

How many studies do we do until we confirm something is real? 1, 2? 12?

Or are most of us constantly running on assumptions. I assume that office building across the street is real. But I'm not sure. I haven't read studies. I haven't tested that it is built of materials and in a certain way that constitutes a building. In fact I haven't read studies or science that defines the parameters of what is a building.

Instead, when I was a child I was told that shape is a building. I can see it. I assume.


As I said, science isn't always done by scientists - it is primarily a way of approaching the world, and some of us try to approach the world scientifically as much of the time as we can. We tend to be skeptics.
 
Yeah, logically...that's pretty much where I sit on the matter.


I think that's as far as we can take it from a positive outlook -- meaning only looking at the good side of the matter, which is pretty bad for the life after death crowd.

But there is the other issue -- the negative side -- which has been brought up more than once in this thread. It is this: we know that we think magically at times and we know that we project our wants on the universe. Life after death has this character -- magical thinking and based in human desire.

So, not only do we not have good reason to believe that life after death is likely, but we have very good reason to suspect that it is human projection, sheer fantasy.

Sounds like two major strikes against the idea, which should be teetering on the brink of non-existence.
 
What is the criteria for impossible, and has that criteria been met?
I know it's a turn of phrase, but does the evidence have to be visual?

If it is, are blind people screwed over in never being able to know?
.
Measurable. Pints, frog yards, pounds, furlongs, light years, something tangible.
Beauty, intangible.
Religion, impossible. :)
 
Johannes Kepler.


To the larger point, scientists can believe looney stuff as easily as anyone. Compartmentalization isn't just for trains!
.
And the giant of all, Newton.
Copernicus. Galileo.. Most of the early archeologists who began to ponder the true of the earth were preachers with lots of time on their hands to look at things.
 
I present the New Synthesis:-
"It's only the best model we have to date that works."



While it turns out there are atheists in foxholes, (also foxes) it seems unlikely there exists a single person who, at 33000 feet in heavy turbulence , does not believe in proximate reality; and who would not prefer to believe the aircraft carrying him was designed by scientific engineers rather than by post modernist english professors.
.
Read up on the "Chrismas Bullet". A killer of a machine that got funded based on a good sales pitch.
 
How can we interpret anything then? even science data? We can't rely on the scientists either, because they operate the same as you describe above.

Blackened Cat,

I'd love to know how level a playing field you have around this reincarnation thing. If it were demonstrated to you, theoretically and via some unknown means, that reincarnation absolutely couldn't happen, would you be cool with this?

I mean, do you consider that you have an emotional investment in believing in reincarnation or are you just interested and not bothered either way? I ask because my experience is that a lot of people who are acutely concerned about their mortality start believing in reincarnation as a way of avoiding their fears.

For myself, I can tell you something that you can of course accept or not. There may be a soul. There may be higher dimensional bodies and they may have the possibility to incarnate another physical body. For me it's possible. But what I can 100% guarantee you is that, if this should happen, then this new body will form its own sense of self. The "you" that appears to be experiencing the world around you is not coming back after death, because it has no actual existence anyway. It emerges from brain activity and appears to be the subject of various experiences but it is not. It's an illusion. So the "you", the "me," has no possibility to return. There is no one looking out from your eyes so the notion that he could return is invalid.

Nick
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom