Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Claims claims claims.

Running is not an illusion, it is a process. Why would counsciousness be any different ?

Running is not an illusion. Consciousness is not an illusion. But the experiencing self is illusory, in that it is not what it appears to be.

In the end, though, it's all irrelevant: the illusion is there, and I want to keep it that way.

Then why get into these debates?

Nick
 
Well, if I look at myself in this kind of situation, I would say that it is rather that I am scared of the unknown. Creepy house, middle of the night, strange noise from the cellar - do I go down there? No, not unless there's a big incentive, and ideally some kind of weaponry.

No, Nick. You're either not understanding or pretending not to. I'm not talking about an abandoned house that is rumored to be haunted. I'm talking about actual RIDES, such as the ones they have in parks. Places which are specially designed, which are actually commercially sold to the public as an experience. Which feature actors dressed as monsters, hiding in corridors. Which feature a box office ticket at the entrance. Do you now understand what I'm talking about?

Now read the argument again: I'm offered to go into one of those haunted hauses (which are obviously a ride, with fake actors dressed) and I refuse to go to because I'm afraid. Then someone claims "Aha! So that means you secretly believe in ghosts!" No. It doesn't. It just means that, regardless of how convinced I am that there are no real ghosts there and that nothing bad is gonna happen, I am still afraid of those experiences.
 
No, Nick. You're either not understanding or pretending not to. I'm not talking about an abandoned house that is rumored to be haunted. I'm talking about actual RIDES, such as the ones they have in parks. Places which are specially designed, which are actually commercially sold to the public as an experience. Which feature actors dressed as monsters, hiding in corridors. Which feature a box office ticket at the entrance. Do you now understand what I'm talking about?

Now read the argument again: I'm offered to go into one of those haunted hauses (which are obviously a ride, with fake actors dressed) and I refuse to go to because I'm afraid. Then someone claims "Aha! So that means you secretly believe in ghosts!" No. It doesn't. It just means that, regardless of how convinced I am that there are no real ghosts there and that nothing bad is gonna happen, I am still afraid of those experiences.

OK, fair enough. Apologies, I didn't quite follow the gist earlier.

So, you're saying... just because I don't want to go on the Ghost Train ride, doesn't prove I believe in ghosts? Yes? Well, with this example I have to say - for sure. Because the Ghost Train is mostly about shocking people. I don't suppose many adults believe there are real ghosties lurking about in there. To me this just indicates that you don't like to be shocked.

Now, if you move it back to, say, a derelict property rumoured to be haunted. If you will not go in there, when offered at least a reasonable incentive, then I would think, well you are afraid of something. This much seems clear. Thus you secretly do believe in ghosts, or are not wholly convinced they don't exist. Or there is something else that is scaring you.

eta: If you won't travel by teleporter, as I see it, it is because you do believe that something tangible will be lost. This is a refutation of the materialist perspective on consciousness and the self. Yes, it is logical to be afraid, because at first glance it appears that something will be lost - you. But, on close examination, it can be seen that, according to materialism, this is not the case. Thus if you won't travel, then it must be because you actually don't really believe in materialism, or at least are not wholly convinced.

Nick
 
Last edited:
OK, fair enough. Apologies, I didn't quite follow the gist earlier.

So, you're saying... just because I don't want to go on the Ghost Train ride, doesn't prove I believe in ghosts? Yes? Well, with this example I have to say - for sure. Because the Ghost Train is mostly about shocking people. I don't suppose many adults believe there are real ghosties lurking about in there. To me this just indicates that you don't like to be shocked.

Thank you.

Likewise, in the example of the "clones", the reason I don't want to be killed and replaced by another clone is not because I don't abide by my belief that the replacement is an exact replica of myself, but because I don't want to die.

Now, if you move it back to, say, a derelict property rumoured to be haunted. If you will not go in there, when offered at least a reasonable incentive, then I would think, well you are afraid of something. This much seems clear. Thus you secretly do believe in ghosts, or are not wholly convinced they don't exist. Or there is something else that is scaring you.

No. I already explained this to you. See above.

eta: If you won't travel by teleporter, as I see it, it is because you do believe that something tangible will be lost. This is a refutation of the materialist perspective on consciousness and the self. Yes, it is logical to be afraid, because at first glance it appears that something will be lost - you. But, on close examination, it can be seen that, according to materialism, this is not the case. Thus if you won't travel, then it must be because you actually don't really believe in materialism, or at least are not wholly convinced.

Nick

No.

However Nick, let me add that given a hypothetical scenario in which, for some hypothetical reason, it turns out that the best thing I can do is to accept killing myself and be replaced by a copy, that I will definitely do it. It will still be hard for me, because like I said, I and everybody on this planet, have a natural fear of death. But given the proper scenario I will of course sacrifice myself for this.

But what I will not do is taking my own life to prove a point to someone. I don't need to take my life to prove a point to you or anybody, no more that I need to ride a roller coaster or a haunted house themed park to demonstrate that I really don't believe something is actually gonna happen to me. I know nothing's gonna happen to me, but I don't want to go on those rides.
 
Last edited:
Thank you.

Likewise, in the example of the "clones", the reason I don't want to be killed and replaced by another clone is not because I don't abide by my belief that the replacement is an exact replica of myself, but because I don't want to die.

For me, the question remains as to whether you actually are dying in this scenario. Because there is no change in subjectivity, and because the self anyway does not persist, but is merely another aspect of this subjectivity, it is imo acutely questionable as to whether you are dying.

One body is replaced with another, that is true. But because there is no actual self which experiences, merely the appearance of one, there really is nothing that has changed subjectively. You have to assume, of course, an instantaneous death and a precisely located replacement, but given that this is a thought experiment, that seems ok.

But what I will not do is taking my own life to prove a point to someone.

What part of your life is being taken? If there is no subjective change, then nothing has been lost or added.

I am concerned that you still believe there to be some persisting recipient of experience (self) somewhere and this is of course inconsistent with materialism.

Nick
 
Last edited:
For me, the question remains as to whether you actually are dying in this scenario. Because there is no change in subjectivity, and because the self anyway does not persist, but is merely another aspect of this subjectivity, it is imo acutely questionable as to whether you are dying.

Same thing, Nick. It makes no difference whether I am really dying in this scenario, no more that it makes no difference whether I am actually gonna be haunted by a real ghost if a go into one of those haunted houses. It makes no difference because I still don't want to go through the experience of going in there, because of the sensation of the experience itself (in the case of the haunted house, I mean the sensation of fear. In the case of the clones, I mean the sensation of dying) A sensation is pretty much like a flavor. Picture a scenario where someone doesn't want to eat a biscuit because of the mere flavor of the biscuit, and the person who's offering it is trying to convince him that it's ok, that the biscuit isn't poisoned. And the person being offered the biscuit is trying to explain that he knows he's gonna be ok after he eats it, that the only reason he refuses it is because of the mere taste.

One body is replaced with another, that is true. But because there is no actual self which experiences, merely the appearance of one, there really is nothing that has changed subjectively. You have to assume, of course, an instantaneous death and a precisely located replacement, but given that this is a thought experiment, that seems ok.

Pure rationalization, Nick. We can go through this a million times if you want. I am now going to repeat what you said to me, but through the other example (the Haunted House scenario):

"You will be scared a couple times in the haunted house, that is true. But because there are no actual ghosts, there really is nothing to fear. You have to assume, of course, that there will be some major scares in the ride, but given this is just a fun house, everything will be ok"

And I will respond: "I know. But I still don't want to go inside because haunted houses scare me, and I have a right to choose if I don't want to go through a scary experience if I can avoid it" (regardless of whether I'm acting based on an irrational fear and regardless of whether or not I believe something is actually going to happen to me or not).

What part of your life is being taken? If there is no subjective change, then nothing has been lost or added.

"What actual ghost is taking your soul? If there are no ghosts, there is nothing that can happen to you in the haunted house"

I am concerned that you still believe there to be some persisting recipient of experience (self) somewhere and this is of course inconsistent with materialism.

Nick

"I am concerned that you still believe there to be some kind of spirit or poltergeist experience somewhere and this is of course inconsistent with materialism"
 
Last edited:
Same thing, Nick. It makes no difference whether I am really dying in this scenario, no more that it makes no difference whether I am actually gonna be haunted by a real ghost if a go into one of those haunted houses. It makes no difference because I still don't want to go through the experience of going in there, because of the sensation of the experience itself (in the case of the haunted house, I mean the sensation of fear. In the case of the clones, I mean the sensation of dying)

But you are not going to have a sensation of dying. As stated, disintegration is considered immediate and the replacement with the copy likewise.

Consider it another way... say you knew that you would be disintegrated and immediately recreated sometime in the next week, but not when exactly. Would you be concerned? How do you know that it hasn't happened anyway?

This is one reason why I don't consider your scenario to be a useful analogy. The teleporter will in no way alter the subjective state. The haunted house will.

Nick
 
Last edited:
But you are not going to have a sensation of dying. As stated, disintegration is considered immediate and the replacement with the copy likewise.

Consider it another way... say you knew that you would be disintegrated and immediately recreated sometime in the next week, but not when exactly. Would you be concerned? How do you know that it hasn't happened anyway?

This is one reason why I don't consider your scenario to be a useful analogy. The teleporter will in no way alter the subjective state. The haunted house will.

Nick

Oh well, Nick, in that case then I would have no problem. I would go with it, granted that there will be indeed no actual experience of dying.
 

"Well"...?..... Do you have one of those in your basement?

The project seems to still be in developing so of course, we're all just speculating when discussing the act of teleporting oneself. Still, I abide by what I say: I'm not gonna go through a dying experience if I don't want to nor have to, no more than I won't go through a scary experience if I don't want to nor have to.

If on the other hand, they develop this technology to the point that to my experience there is no discernible difference between the body I lost and the new one I'm occupying, then I see no problem in doing it.
 
If on the other hand, they develop this technology to the point that to my experience there is no discernible difference between the body I lost and the new one I'm occupying, then I see no problem in doing it.

"...the body I lost and the new one I'm occupying...?" - sounds a bit dualist. Nick
 
"...the body I lost and the new one I'm occupying...?" - sounds a bit dualist. Nick

I know you were referring to the "the one I'm occupying" part, as if I was claiming that the new body was a recipient that I am going in. Of course that's not what I believe, but we still use those expressions out of custom, in the same way that we still say "The sun rises" as if we still believed that the sun orbits around the earth. So don't get nitpicky on the use of language, Nick.
 
Last edited:
Now don't get started again, Nick. Whether or not there is no practical difference between the two bodies, you can't deny the fact that there are in fact two bodies and that one was replaced by another. That is a fact.

I don't dispute it for a second. However, your apparent notion that there is an "I" which loses one body and then occupies another sounds very clearly like dualism to me.

Nick
 
Last edited:
I don't dispute it for a second. However, your apparent notion that there is an "I" which loses one body and then occupies another sounds very clearly like dualism to me.

Nick

Please re-read the post, as I edited it and addressed the actual issue you were pointing.
 
I know you were referring to the "the one I'm occupying" part, as if I was claiming that the new body was a recipient that I am going in. Of course that's not what I believe, but we still use those expressions out of custom, in the same way that we still say "The sun rises" as if we still believed that the sun orbits around the earth. So don't get nitpicky on the use of language, Nick.

Well, sounds a bit suspicious to me! I mean it is not so customary to speak of being replaced by perfect copies, except around here, and certainly not as often as the sun coming up. If you'd said "my new body" or similar I wouldn't have called it. Still, as you're recanting, I guess the materialist inquisition can be held off. Nick
 
For me, the question remains as to whether you actually are dying in this scenario.

Depends what you mean by "you". If you mean "the exact arrangement of molecules that makes up an object identical to the current you", then no. If you mean "the actual object that is the current you", then yes.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom