For me, the question remains as to whether you actually are dying in this scenario. Because there is no change in subjectivity, and because the self anyway does not persist, but is merely another aspect of this subjectivity, it is imo acutely questionable as to whether you are dying.
Same thing, Nick. It makes no difference whether I am really dying in this scenario, no more that it makes no difference whether I am actually gonna be haunted by a real ghost if a go into one of those haunted houses. It makes no difference because I still don't want to go through the experience of going in there, because of the sensation of the experience itself (in the case of the haunted house, I mean the sensation of fear. In the case of the clones, I mean the
sensation of dying) A sensation is pretty much like a flavor. Picture a scenario where someone doesn't want to eat a biscuit because of the mere flavor of the biscuit, and the person who's offering it is trying to convince him that it's ok, that the biscuit isn't poisoned. And the person being offered the biscuit is trying to explain that he knows he's gonna be ok after he eats it, that the only reason he refuses it is because of the mere taste.
One body is replaced with another, that is true. But because there is no actual self which experiences, merely the appearance of one, there really is nothing that has changed subjectively. You have to assume, of course, an instantaneous death and a precisely located replacement, but given that this is a thought experiment, that seems ok.
Pure rationalization, Nick. We can go through this a million times if you want. I am now going to repeat what you said to me, but through the other example (the Haunted House scenario):
"You will be scared a couple times in the haunted house, that is true. But because there are no actual ghosts, there really is nothing to fear. You have to assume, of course, that there will be some major scares in the ride, but given this is just a fun house, everything will be ok"
And I will respond: "I know. But I still don't want to go inside because haunted houses scare me, and I have a right to choose if I don't want to go through a scary experience if I can avoid it" (regardless of whether I'm acting based on an irrational fear and regardless of whether or not I believe something is actually going to happen to me or not).
What part of your life is being taken? If there is no subjective change, then nothing has been lost or added.
"What actual ghost is taking your soul? If there are no ghosts, there is nothing that can happen to you in the haunted house"
I am concerned that you still believe there to be some persisting recipient of experience (self) somewhere and this is of course inconsistent with materialism.
Nick
"I am concerned that you still believe there to be some kind of spirit or poltergeist experience somewhere and this is of course inconsistent with materialism"