Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

I always like Samuel Johnson's reply to much the same question.."I refute it thus!" (kicking a rock to emphasize...)
As Hokulele says above, it's certainly more practical to accept that the universe exists as objective reality, and that we just happen to inhabit it, than it is to think that we somehow generate the whole thing with the power of our minds.
That always begs the question of what the universe might have looked like when there was nothing more evolved than a sea slug...
I know philosophers get all wound up with such things; we had several young philosphy students on the Facebook "Atheist" forum and they would go on and on and on....
 
"What's a key lime tart", asked Sam, instantly recognising the sole interesting thing in the thread, "and can they be air freighted to Kazakhstan?"

There were five key lime tarts. Now there are two. Where did the other three go?

(Maia hastily hides the three itty bitty empty tart pans)

Um... they were never a part of objective reality. Yup. That's it.

Oh! Here's some news. :) I led the Secular Life Meetup discussion on John Shelby Spong last night. (Yes, this actually has a lot of relevance to this thread.) It was held at a local upscale pizza place during happy hour, so there was a lot of beer at the table. I handed out his 12 Theses for the Reformation of Christianity and talked about his ideas, and got varying responses.

Atheist: "It sounds like he wants to have his cake and eat it too."

Me: "Well, if you have your cake, you can eat it. Don't you think?"

Atheist: "Okay, it sounds like he just threw a bunch of cake ingredients in a pan and CALLED it cake."

Me: "Maybe you could make a pudding."

The most frequent criticism was that after dismantling the vast majority of everything associated with traditional Christianity (as JSS does), nobody saw the point of what was left. Well, I did. An atheist in the group I knew who goes to the Quaker meeting house sort of did too. #2 AItGIK was showing everyone illustrated verses from the Brick Testament on his IPhone. That was fun.

Anyway, all of JSS's books that I had are now packed in boxes for the move, except for his autobiography and the most recent book,Eternal Life: A New Vision, Beyond Religion, Beyond Theism, Beyond Heaven and Hell. We didn't get to the eternal-life part of that book in the discussion, focusing instead on the parts where he talked about life being accidental, we are not the products of anyone's intelligent design, religion has enabled us to hide from reality, traditional prayer is an experience of ritual hypnosis where everyone says the words but nobody is expected to actually believe them... and then there was the chapter called “The Tools of Religious Manipulation”, here’s another one, “The Death of Religion”... so we kind of got sidetracked.

But it's all there. It's definitely a book about dismantling just about everything in Christianity connected with beliefs about life after death, particularly ideas about heaven, hell, reward, and punishment. But there's even more than that; in the book's intro, in fact, JSS says that after all of his research into NDE's, "I came away more skeptical than convinced." Now, that's really something to admit when you realize he's edited a book that was basically on that subject (1987 - Consciousness and Survival: An Interdisciplinary Inquiry into the possibility of Life Beyond Biological Death (edited by John S. Spong, introduction by Claiborne Pell) and came close to writing another one. And the NDE stuff is not at all what he bases his conclusions on in this book, and they aren't based on quantum-y weirdness or convoluted philosophical arguments, either.

To see a good example of this kind of silliness, you could read Dinesh D'Souza's book (Life After Death:The Evidence), which is an obvious ripoff of JSS's book, IMHO. It even has the same cover design!! Driven by morbid curiousity, I did get that book, and even started a thread on it here. (I could find it again, if anybody really wants to see it.)

But the last chapter in the book is "I Believe in Life Beyond Death." (JSS's book, I mean.):eye-poppi
 
Last edited:
Are all theoretically situations insulting?

If I pose a maths question that starts "If Suzie took the number 2 bus to.."

Would I then be questioned over the existence of Suzie or the number 2 bus? If I could not prove that Suzie exists, and that Suzie took the bus on that day... would I have insulted the intellect?

Can you define what an insult to intellect would be? Can you prove that the intellect does in fact exist? and is not over inflated? And why would 'the' intellect has so little grace as not to be able to withstand the smallest of slights? Is the intellect that inexperienced in life? Was the intellect sheltered?

Is there an end to the endless dissecting of questions in order to escape confronting of their basis?


Belief in angels would be insulting to my intellect.

It ought to be to yours.

The assumption of the existence of angels in the original question renders the question useless and not interesting philosophically.
 
Is science the only way to understand objective and expperience reality?


Yes.

I will note, however, that your question is oddly phrased. I answered what I thought you were asking.

Science isn't always done by scientists - it is a way of approaching and modeling reality.
 
Last edited:
Y'all know what's going to happen if this keeps up, right?

Oh, come on. You KNOW what's going to happen.

I'm going to bring in Stephen Jay Gould... and NOMA... I WILL bring up NOMA. It'll happen. We will go there, if need be. ;)

(hands out key lime tarts for everyone to help with the discussion. I just finished making some. They're so cute. However, these are virtual key lime tarts, because the real ones... let's just say that they're not going to last very long.)


Don't. Gould was wrong about NOMA. It has been beaten to death.
 
Belief in angels would be insulting to my intellect.

It ought to be to yours.

The assumption of the existence of angels in the original question renders the question useless and not interesting philosophically.

Can you explain how your intellect is insulted? Do you believe it has a separate sense of self? Or do you mean that you feel insulted?

Earlier in this thread we also had someone claim that their brain "experienced." Brains process. They don't experience.

Regarding the soul, as a materialist who also meditates, I would say that personally it is clear for me that there appears to be "something" behind this self that is constantly constructed by the mind through thinking. Whether this "something" is really a thing, as in "limited entity", I don't know. But there is something present or witnessing of self in meditation could not take place. Maybe it's soul or maybe it's neural substrate or maybe they're the same.

Nick
 
Can you explain how your intellect is insulted? Do you believe it has a separate sense of self? Or do you mean that you feel insulted?

Earlier in this thread we also had someone claim that their brain "experienced." Brains process. They don't experience.

Regarding the soul, as a materialist who also meditates, I would say that personally it is clear for me that there appears to be "something" behind this self that is constantly constructed by the mind through thinking. Whether this "something" is really a thing, as in "limited entity", I don't know. But there is something present or witnessing of self in meditation could not take place. Maybe it's soul or maybe it's neural substrate or maybe they're the same.

Nick


People speak of a substance being an insult to the liver, for example. I simply extended that to the intellect, which is an aspect of a functioning brain.

I think you are wrong about your interpretation of what is happening when you meditate. There is no soul or anything similar to one.
 
Regarding the soul, as a materialist who also meditates, I would say that personally it is clear for me that there appears to be "something" behind this self that is constantly constructed by the mind through thinking. Whether this "something" is really a thing, as in "limited entity", I don't know. But there is something present or witnessing of self in meditation could not take place. Maybe it's soul or maybe it's neural substrate or maybe they're the same.

This is a good post because it I think it clearly illustrates the thought process behind the concept of a soul.

The difference between Nick and religious crazies is that Nick isn't saying his personal opinion is proof of a soul.
 
The 'objective reality' question boils down to 'Can things happen without, I, the asker of this question, being aware of them?'

And, as this question is impossible to answer, the answer is unknowable, and thus irrelevant.

On the other issues, I believe that science is the only way to understand reality and I don't believe that souls exist, because I see no evidence.
 
People speak of a substance being an insult to the liver, for example. I simply extended that to the intellect, which is an aspect of a functioning brain.

Fair enough.

I think you are wrong about your interpretation of what is happening when you meditate. There is no soul or anything similar to one.

Well, for me I still find it inevitable that people try and objectively account for phenomena encountered in meditation. Regular practice of vipassana (placing all attention of the breath) subjectively demonstrates to me the immateriality of the mental self. It is not what it appears to be, but merely an "illusion" created by thinking. This is in line with materialism.

But, in this subjective demonstration, there now arises the question - what is it that apparently experiences this illusory sense of self? What is this sense of "presence" discovered beneath the wrigglings of the thinking mind? And, in trying to answer this question, several millenia worth of meditators have come up with "soul." Some claim it is endless, others that it is limited to the individual body. Either way it is an issue for those with sufficient awareness to come across it.

Nick
 
Do you think the existence of a soul enduring after death is an objective or subjective idea?

So whether you believe you go to Christian heaven, Mormon heaven, Buddhist rebirth or athiest style material non-existence..... is there an actual objective reality to this?

Can it be determined?

Even if the answer is - nothing... can that be determined?

And if there is life after death, and for example it's a Christian protestant one... can we know in the here and now that this is real?

What can we base any knowledge of an afterlife on?


I might start by asking the question -- what do we mean by 'objective'?

We seem to mean several different things when we use the word, but I assume you refer to the existence of reality completely independent of people, as Twiler just posted.

So, analyzing the situation, we all 'live' in our own subjective realities. But we think, probably rightly, that there is an independent reality for two very good reasons. One is that we share a common reality that we can speak of as inter-subjective (one meaning of 'objective') and the other is that when we close our eyes and re-open them we still encounter the same world, the same tree we were looking at. There is no way for us to prove in our subjective experience that there is an objective world, but it's the best, most practical solution to the knowledge problem.

When it comes to life after death, though, we don't have the same sort of information. We have very limited reports from only some people who experience near-death. And those reports tend to have only a vague similarity. A tunnel and light as well as a presence and a feeling of love are often reported immediately after awakening from such experiences; but aside from that there do not seem to be any concrete, shared experiences that most people report. What they do report tends to be culturally biased; and the memories grow over time with all sorts of details being thrown into the mix long after the events (so the memories are almost definitely created after the fact).

These experiences, like our experience of the world, are subjective. But the near-death experiences lack the coherence, the shared congruence, and the persistence of our experience of the outside world that allows us to postulate that there is an external reality. Add to this that we can recreate some of the same experiences by depriving the brain of blood/oxygen in a large centrifuge and the fact that these experiences happen to people under extraordinary stress (they are near death). We know that stressed brains hallucinate. So we have reason to doubt the reality of the experiences that people do report. And we should expect that brains of similar construction (human brains) will tend to have some similar experiences when stressed, which could easily account for the mild similarities we see with near-death experiences.

Taken together, I would have to say that I have pretty good reasons to suspect that there is an external world and no particularly good reasons to suspect that there is anything after death based on the limited evidence that is available. There might be. Who knows? We are not privvy to the information, though.
 
Fair enough.



Well, for me I still find it inevitable that people try and objectively account for phenomena encountered in meditation. Regular practice of vipassana (placing all attention of the breath) subjectively demonstrates to me the immateriality of the mental self. It is not what it appears to be, but merely an "illusion" created by thinking. This is in line with materialism.

But, in this subjective demonstration, there now arises the question - what is it that apparently experiences this illusory sense of self? What is this sense of "presence" discovered beneath the wrigglings of the thinking mind? And, in trying to answer this question, several millenia worth of meditators have come up with "soul." Some claim it is endless, others that it is limited to the individual body. Either way it is an issue for those with sufficient awareness to come across it.

Nick


Hey, Nick. Good to see you back.
 
Are all theoretically situations insulting?

If I pose a maths question that starts "If Suzie took the number 2 bus to.."

Would I then be questioned over the existence of Suzie or the number 2 bus? If I could not prove that Suzie exists, and that Suzie took the bus on that day... would I have insulted the intellect?

Can you define what an insult to intellect would be? Can you prove that the intellect does in fact exist? and is not over inflated? And why would 'the' intellect has so little grace as not to be able to withstand the smallest of slights? Is the intellect that inexperienced in life? Was the intellect sheltered?

Is there an end to the endless dissecting of questions in order to escape confronting of their basis?

that is a very apples and oranges situation.

A math question's intent is nothing more than to show that the person answering the question knows how to arrive at the answer. A philosophical question is intended to come to a conclusion.

It is called GIGO garbage in garbage out, if your question contains flaws, then the answer is going to be flawed, so one has to figure out what is the proper question before trying to answer.

It would be like if you wrote your math problem as follows

" suzy has 2 apples, maybe. And tim possibly has 5 apples. Now find out how much they could sell the apples for."

As you can see it makes no sense to even attempt to answer the question because of the flaws therein, so said question needs to be dissected and fixed before any useful answer can be obtained. No one wants to waste their time answering what languages a unicorn speaks.
 
Fair enough.



Well, for me I still find it inevitable that people try and objectively account for phenomena encountered in meditation. Regular practice of vipassana (placing all attention of the breath) subjectively demonstrates to me the immateriality of the mental self. It is not what it appears to be, but merely an "illusion" created by thinking. This is in line with materialism.

But, in this subjective demonstration, there now arises the question - what is it that apparently experiences this illusory sense of self? What is this sense of "presence" discovered beneath the wrigglings of the thinking mind? And, in trying to answer this question, several millenia worth of meditators have come up with "soul." Some claim it is endless, others that it is limited to the individual body. Either way it is an issue for those with sufficient awareness to come across it.

Nick


I think that your understanding of what happens when you meditate is in error.

You are experiencing and interpreting what you experience in light of your worldview and beliefs. Others, having different worldviews and beliefs, experience and interpret differently. What you think about what you experience and how you interpret it really isn't reliable and shouldn't be given any credence.
 
Last edited:
Is science the only way to understand objective and expperience reality?

I would say no. For example, one way to understand and experience reality might be to evaluate hypotheses through an elaborate system of coin flipping. I'm confident in saying that it wouldn't lead to a very good understanding, but you could do it.

Science is the best (maybe the best possible) tool we have for investigating the universe and approximating truth. One thing I think everybody should try is sitting down and honestly considering how we should go about evaluating hypotheses and why. When I did this at least, the scientific method is more or less what I came up with. Science is objective, rigorous, and self correcting. No competing method has ever been able to match it for predictive power.
 
I think that your understanding of what happens when you meditate is in error.

You are experiencing and interpreting what you experience in light of your worldview and beliefs. Others, having different worldviews and beliefs, experience and interpret differently. What you think about what you experience and how you interpret it really isn't reliable and shouldn't be given any credence.

What he said.

One might as well say that an experience which felt like being in the presence of god, while taking a drug, showed that there was a god and therefore the next logical step would be to figure out that god's attributes.
 
Do you have a belief either way? Which side would you take?

I tend to veer towards Objective reality existing.
.
Souls and angels and devils are constructs of wishful thinking, that one is just too magnificent a creation to stop after death, so there has to be something sensible following.
There's no reason other than ego for the idea.
Hammer hits thumb.
Real.
Guardian angel protecting from harm.
Childish and naive.
I can point you to 19 guardian angels that overwhelmed 3000 others, just a few years back, if you wish to consider angels as real and having some (any) influence on reality.
 
Last edited:
Don't. Gould was wrong about NOMA. It has been beaten to death.

If you mean by those horrible UE threads, I think he was always beating something else to death. It's hard to say what this was, but it didn't have much to do with anything SJG actually said. As for Gould being wrong, well...that's one of those statements which is a matter of opinion.
I really think it's better to presage them with "I think", "I believe," "IMHO," "it seems to me," "as a result of my research, I have come to the conclusion that"... Sorry, but there's a little too much of the opposite around here sometimes... IMHO!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom