"What's a key lime tart", asked Sam, instantly recognising the sole interesting thing in the thread, "and can they be air freighted to Kazakhstan?"
There were five key lime tarts. Now there are two. Where did the other three go?
(Maia hastily hides the three itty bitty empty tart pans)
Um... they were never a part of objective reality. Yup. That's it.
Oh! Here's some news.

I led the Secular Life Meetup discussion on John Shelby Spong last night. (Yes, this actually has a lot of relevance to this thread.) It was held at a local upscale pizza place during happy hour, so there was a lot of beer at the table. I handed out his 12 Theses for the Reformation of Christianity and talked about his ideas, and got varying responses.
Atheist: "It sounds like he wants to have his cake and eat it too."
Me: "Well, if you have your cake, you can eat it. Don't you think?"
Atheist: "Okay, it sounds like he just threw a bunch of cake ingredients in a pan and CALLED it cake."
Me: "Maybe you could make a pudding."
The most frequent criticism was that after dismantling the vast majority of everything associated with traditional Christianity (as JSS does), nobody saw the point of what was left. Well, I did. An atheist in the group I knew who goes to the Quaker meeting house sort of did too. #2 AItGIK was showing everyone illustrated verses from the Brick Testament on his IPhone. That was fun.
Anyway, all of JSS's books that I had are now packed in boxes for the move, except for his autobiography and the most recent book,
Eternal Life: A New Vision, Beyond Religion, Beyond Theism, Beyond Heaven and Hell. We didn't get to the eternal-life part of that book in the discussion, focusing instead on the parts where he talked about life being accidental, we are not the products of anyone's intelligent design, religion has enabled us to hide from reality, traditional prayer is an experience of ritual hypnosis where everyone says the words but nobody is expected to actually believe them... and then there was the chapter called “The Tools of Religious Manipulation”, here’s another one, “The Death of Religion”... so we kind of got sidetracked.
But it's all there. It's definitely a book about dismantling just about everything in Christianity connected with beliefs about life after death, particularly ideas about heaven, hell, reward, and punishment. But there's even more than that; in the book's intro, in fact, JSS says that after all of his research into NDE's, "I came away more skeptical than convinced." Now, that's really something to admit when you realize he's edited a book that was basically on that subject (1987 - Consciousness and Survival: An Interdisciplinary Inquiry into the possibility of Life Beyond Biological Death (edited by John S. Spong, introduction by Claiborne Pell) and came close to writing another one. And the NDE stuff is not at all what he bases his conclusions on in this book, and they aren't based on quantum-y weirdness or convoluted philosophical arguments, either.
To see a good example of this kind of silliness, you could read Dinesh D'Souza's book (
Life After Death:The Evidence), which is an obvious ripoff of JSS's book, IMHO. It even has the same cover design!! Driven by morbid curiousity, I did get that book, and even started a thread on it here. (I could find it again, if anybody really wants to see it.)
But the last chapter in the book is "I Believe in Life Beyond Death." (JSS's book, I mean.)
