Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Things that we say are objectively known can always be tested for accuracy by either side in a debate, because knowledge is demonstrable and measurable. The afterlife is an idea that lacks supporting evidence because nothing about it is testable, and the whole thing is centred around a handful of assumptions which themselves are based on nothing. Consequently, the afterlife is not an objective idea and we currently cannot base claimed knowledge about it on anything.
 
Are you asking about the existence of an objective reality? Or are you assuming that there is a measurable and definable objective reality and just asking if the afterlife exists within it?
Yeah that is part of my current pondering. I may not have spelled that out well in the OP.


Well, um, which one? I asked an either/ or question. Are you asking if objective reality exists OR are you assuming that objective reality exists? Pick one or the other.
 
Well, um, which one? I asked an either/ or question. Are you asking if objective reality exists OR are you assuming that objective reality exists? Pick one or the other.

First one. "If objective reality exists" It's something I'm questioning at the moment.
 
Do you think the existence of a soul enduring after death is an objective or subjective idea?

So whether you believe you go to Christian heaven, Mormon heaven, Buddhist rebirth or athiest style material non-existence..... is there an actual objective reality to this?

Can it be determined?

Even if the answer is - nothing... can that be determined?

And if there is life after death, and for example it's a Christian protestant one... can we know in the here and now that this is real?

What can we base any knowledge of an afterlife on?

There is no knowledge of an afterlife at all. If there was this kind of knowledge, it would have to be based on evidence.
 
First one. "If objective reality exists" It's something I'm questioning at the moment.


Well, good luck with that. There's no answer. There's just an endless debate that goes something like this:

Realist: The universe exists because I have gathered evidence of its existence.
Anti-Realist: But all of that evidence was gathered by your senses.
Realist: So?
Anti-Realist: Your senses could be lying to you.
Realist: So, what? Nothing exists?
Anti-Realist: Things exist as constructs in our minds.
Realist: So, our minds must exist.
Anti-Realist: Well, mine does. Yours, I'm not so sure about.
Realist: You're a jerk.
Anti-Realist: And you're an idiot.
Realist: Well, at least I'm an idiot who exists!
Anti-Realist: Not for long!
[Huge sissy slapfight ensues. Non-philosophy majors laugh, have lives, and get laid.]
 
Last edited:
It makes as much sense to posit a daisy afterlife or a chrysanthemum afterlife. We esteem ourselves too highly.
 
Thanks for the welcome.

To answer all the question dodgers....you know what I mean...

Then rephrase the question, can we know the buddhist after life exists (if Greek concepts of soul somehow offends).

Is there an objective afterlife reality?


No, and no.
 
That's a perfectly valid philosophical question and is akin to what I was asking.


Must disagree - I don't think that "Can we ever determine how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?" is either valid or philosophical.

It assumes something for which there is no evidence.

It is also insulting to the intellect.
 
Last edited:
First one. "If objective reality exists" It's something I'm questioning at the moment.


Yes, I think there is an objective reality.

I do not think that we will every understand any aspect of it perfectly.

The best we can hope for is incrementally better models of reality that serve us well as we can muster.

These we get from science.

It may be that none of our brains will ever be able to imagine, let alone apprehend, many aspects of it. We won't know this, of course.
 
Last edited:
The best answer I've ever found to this is probably in John Shelby Spong's latest book. (But then, isn't everything?) ;)
 
It makes as much sense to posit a daisy afterlife or a chrysanthemum afterlife. We esteem ourselves too highly.

So when approaching religious questions or philosophical questions...is it better to evaluate or explore them, or instead just accept them? or discard them?
 
Must disagree - I don't think that "Can we ever determine how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?" is either valid or philosophical.

It assumes something for which there is no evidence.

It is also insulting to the intellect.

Are all theoretically situations insulting?

If I pose a maths question that starts "If Suzie took the number 2 bus to.."

Would I then be questioned over the existence of Suzie or the number 2 bus? If I could not prove that Suzie exists, and that Suzie took the bus on that day... would I have insulted the intellect?

Can you define what an insult to intellect would be? Can you prove that the intellect does in fact exist? and is not over inflated? And why would 'the' intellect has so little grace as not to be able to withstand the smallest of slights? Is the intellect that inexperienced in life? Was the intellect sheltered?

Is there an end to the endless dissecting of questions in order to escape confronting of their basis?
 
Is science the only way to understand objective and expperience reality?

Science is the only way we can gather and interpret data about out reality objectively. Its also the only known way with which to predict things about our reality.
However it has nothing to do with experiencing reality, that is something our brain does.

As for an afterlife, no scientific experiment has ever shown anything to prove it exists. So if it does our best current methods are unable to interact with it making the whole question philosophical.

If an intangible soul that does not interact with matter in any way truly exists, you'd best hope there is an afterlife to go to though, otherwise each time someone dies they'll be stuck in empty space watching the earth and the entire solar system rush away from them at high speed.
 
Is science the only way to understand objective and expperience reality?



Y'all know what's going to happen if this keeps up, right?

Oh, come on. You KNOW what's going to happen.

I'm going to bring in Stephen Jay Gould... and NOMA... I WILL bring up NOMA. It'll happen. We will go there, if need be. ;)

(hands out key lime tarts for everyone to help with the discussion. I just finished making some. They're so cute. However, these are virtual key lime tarts, because the real ones... let's just say that they're not going to last very long.)
 
Last edited:
Do you think the existence of a soul enduring after death is an objective or subjective idea?


Objective.


Ba.jpg


Ba (not humbug)​


So whether you believe you go to Christian heaven, Mormon heaven, Buddhist rebirth or athiest style material non-existence..... is there an actual objective reality to this?


No. These things you speak of are at best just make-believe and at worst, heresy. There is only the Tuat.


Can it be determined?


Yes. Ask Hathor


Even if the answer is - nothing... can that be determined?


Yes. Ask Anubis.


And if there is life after death, and for example it's a Christian protestant one... can we know in the here and now that this is real?


What's a Christian? What's he protesting about? Is this anything to do with those reedcutters?


What can we base any knowledge of an afterlife on?


The Book of Spells of Going Forth By Day, sometimes referred to as the Book of the Dead.

Try Amazon.
 
"What's a key lime tart", asked Sam, instantly recognising the sole interesting thing in the thread, "and can they be air freighted to Kazakhstan?"

Look- Either we exist, or we don't. If we don't, then let's concentrate on imagining more beer.
If we do exist (and by heck it feels like it in the mornings) then it looks like life is actually a chemical process and awareness is too. When the process stops, the candle flame doesn't go anywhere. The burning of wax just stops. The flame WAS the burning of wax. That's what burning of wax looks like.

Of course we can't test for life after death, but as in Monty Python's Great Debate on the question, all the dead people stand silent.

My bet is that being dead is a lot like not having been born.
ETA- Unless you manage to be fossilised.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom