Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

It served to inspire within me a whole new regard for concepts like the golden ratio, seeing branching patterns and fractals emerge from chaos, and got me thinking of how intelligence would almost inevitably emerge from such a process on it's own, and how great it is to reach that point of being able to become aware of the process. In a poetic sense, it's almost like I am the product of the universe waking up to see itself, not to sound woo'ish, but it's a very romantic idea, and I am after all a component of the universe.

If you really follow materialist theories of consciousness to their natural conclusion, I don't think you can avoid sounding woo'ish. It's inevitable, if you ask me, because as soon as you really touch on selfhood you come to conclusions which appear deeply counter-intuitive.

The way to avoid sounding woo'ish is to join the JREF, and to absolutely demand that scientific principles be applied to the world outside of you, but then to steadfastly refuse to apply the same to what you consider to be "yourself." And, of course, to immediately react to an assortment of "woo-sounding" buzzwords with scorn and pomposity.

Say it loud and proud, Halfcentaur... may consciousness awaken to its own true nature!

Nick
 
Last edited:
I'd say the danger in the woo with that statement would really only be woo were I speaking of my-self alone. But I was talking about consciousness as a whole being an inevitable thing to emerge somewhere given a long enough loop of the most basic feedback as long as there's a tiny amount of variation. And it seems that's the nature of what reality does, for some reason, it creates what we would think of as complex order out of chaos by it's own behavior, and as long as there are variables in that process, a whale could spontaneously appear in the atmosphere,... maybe(no not really though). The Secret Life of Chaos is a great BBC documentary that got me thinking about this seemingly natural behavior of reality to give rise to self emergent order. Now that I think about it, I think Carl Sagan had the same line of thought regarding the evolution of consciousness. Consciousness being the point at which the universe wakes up to reflect upon itself.

But then, maybe you are being facetious and making a funny at the expense of the common behaviors that crop up in this community and I am confused in my nubile noobishness. I've had a problem lately of staying up for 24 hour stretches and sleeping for ten. I just hit the 25th hour and am preparing to go to the "in between" life, where the mind goes when you sleep, yeah? (Lake Baikal, Siberia of course)

Really, much as we're just a collection of billions of tiny independent components working in seeming concert that call's itself a self, that moment the universe churned something out that could look around and reflect on it's surroundings is in some sense the universe waking up to look at itself, woo free, no? But it won't be until the trans galactic federation of entities creates a universe wide wireless internet connection that the universe then becomes what it was destined to be, which is the RESURRECTION OF ZEUS with the lower body of Jesus fused at the spine with Kali the Destroyer, and this shall be the hermaphrodite empress of the ultra moment !


While these things and more are subject to change, I'm just a half centaur, so I can't really say what's what.
 
Last edited:
But then, maybe you are being facetious and making a funny at the expense of the common behaviors that crop up in this community and I am confused in my nubile noobishness. I've had a problem lately of staying up for 24 hour stretches and sleeping for ten. I just hit the 25th hour and am preparing to go to the "in between" life, where the mind goes when you sleep, yeah? (Lake Baikal, Siberia of course)

Well, I like the occasional dig at what I consider the JREF materialist mindset, to create somewhat unfairly another self out of something that is not really so concrete.

Really, much as we're just a collection of billions of tiny independent components working in seeming concert that call's itself a self, that moment the universe churned something out that could look around and reflect on it's surroundings is in some sense the universe waking up to look at itself, woo free, no?

Yup. But for many JREFers you'd no doubt be getting dangerously close to the woo line with such terminology, and the reality of the situation is lost on them.

As I mentioned before, if you follow materialism and apply it to the inner world as well as the outer, you run slap bang into major paradox, and for many JREFers they prefer to stick on more solid ground. See an earlier thread for example.

Nick
 
You do? Like what?

Would you have an issue with dying if an exact replica of you took your place? If so, how do you justify this as a materialist? Or do you accept that there is in reality no experiencer, no self which experiences? And that thus no one is dying in such a scenario.

Nick
 
Would you have an issue with dying if an exact replica of you took your place? If so, how do you justify this as a materialist? Or do you accept that there is in reality no experiencer, no self which experiences? And that thus no one is dying in such a scenario.

If my memories were replicated along with everything else, I couldn't even tell it happened unless I was conscious during the procedure. For all I know, someone did that to me while I slept last night. Isn't there a factoid or urban legend or something that every seven years all our molecules have been replaced by other ones anyway? So it wouldn't bother me at all.
 
If my memories were replicated along with everything else, I couldn't even tell it happened unless I was conscious during the procedure. For all I know, someone did that to me while I slept last night. Isn't there a factoid or urban legend or something that every seven years all our molecules have been replaced by other ones anyway? So it wouldn't bother me at all.

It's true, the skeletal system and organs for the most part have been replaced by new cells in around a 7 year period as I recall. The much more "spooky" thing though, is at particle levels, your matter is bumping into other matter at all times and exchanging properties, flowing, in effect trading places. So in that sense, every second from the next you are fluctuating, a new body every moment. That's just really spooky to me. Your memories happened to another figure, your sense of self is the only constant. But everytime you change your mind about one thing, your "me" is a little bit different too.

Dawkins talks about it in his Ted talk on the queerness of the universe.
I recommend it.

I can't post URLs yet, not having 15 posts under my belt. Just go to ted.com and find Dawkins talk labeled "The queerness of the universe".
 
The much more "spooky" thing though, is at particle levels, your matter is bumping into other matter at all times and exchanging properties, flowing, in effect trading places. So in that sense, every second from the next you are fluctuating, a new body every moment. That's just really spooky to me. Your memories happened to another figure, your sense of self is the only constant. But everytime you change your mind about one thing, your "me" is a little bit different too.

Well, I don't see it that you can really consider "sense of self" a constant. There are no constants here. It is simply that the body is relatively constant.

There is no "persisting self" under materialism, to use the more philosophical term. "Your memories" didn't really happen to anyone - now or previously. It is rather that the passage of thinking creates the sense of there being someone who is doing the thinking or hearing the thinking. And the sense of this person existing is actually all there is and it is constantly in flux - existing in the instant, dying away again, and being recreated with the next thought. Cool, eh?

Nick
 
Last edited:
Would you have an issue with dying if an exact replica of you took your place? If so, how do you justify this as a materialist? Or do you accept that there is in reality no experiencer, no self which experiences? And that thus no one is dying in such a scenario.

Nick



How does that reveal a paradox? Not wanting to die is a local feeling, built into 'our' structure aiding survival. That there is no integrated self that actually dies doesn't make that feeling go away.
 
Well, I don't see it that you can really consider "sense of self" a constant. There are no constants here. It is simply that the body is relatively constant.

There is no "persisting self" under materialism, to use the more philosophical term. "Your memories" didn't really happen to anyone - now or previously. It is rather that the passage of thinking creates the sense of there being someone who is doing the thinking or hearing the thinking. And the sense of this person existing is actually all there is and it is constantly in flux - existing in the instant, dying away again, and being recreated with the next thought. Cool, eh?

Nick

Yeah, yeah, yeah, truth in the context of materialism. I suppose I was speaking in the context of the "things you take for granted about reality as an average joe". I could have split hairs all day, but seeing as we already established the illusion of self, where would my point have wandered off to (and I thought when I threw in the bit about your "me" being different too I had successfully eluded to that) ? An interesting factoid must draw the line somewhere. :)

If I was to be as literal as possible from this point forward, words like I, you, me, him, etc would end up lost in a pool of reiteration.
 
Last edited:
How does that reveal a paradox? Not wanting to die is a local feeling, built into 'our' structure aiding survival. That there is no integrated self that actually dies doesn't make that feeling go away.

I would consider the disparity between logic and feeling here essentially paradoxical. For it doesn't seem to me, on a feeling level, that it would "make it better" to have an identical copy of me take my place at the moment of death. Yet, materialist logic dictates that in such a scenario no one has been lost. Understanding self as non-persisting is IMO paradoxical for most people.

Nick
 
Would you have an issue with dying if an exact replica of you took your place?
Yup.
If so, how do you justify this as a materialist?
Justify what? A desire to not die? Sorry that's an emotional response.
Or do you accept that there is in reality no experiencer, no self which experiences? And that thus no one is dying in such a scenario.
No. The original is dead. The copy is alive. Does not change the fact I(the original) would be dead.
 
I would consider the disparity between logic and feeling here essentially paradoxical. For it doesn't seem to me, on a feeling level, that it would "make it better" to have an identical copy of me take my place at the moment of death. Yet, materialist logic dictates that in such a scenario no one has been lost. Understanding self as non-persisting is IMO paradoxical for most people.

Nick

And this is why Bones despised the transporter pad, along with green blooded hobgoblins.
 
Yeah, yeah, yeah, truth in the context of materialism. I suppose I was speaking in the context of the "things you take for granted about reality as an average joe". I could have split hairs all day, but seeing as we already established the illusion of self, where would my point have wandered off to (and I thought when I threw in the bit about your "me" being different too I had successfully eluded to that) ? An interesting factoid must draw the line somewhere. :)

If I was to be as literal as possible from this point forward, words like I, you, me, him, etc would end up lost in a pool of reiteration.

I submit that you are missing the point. Your statement was "your sense of self is the only constant." You could equally have written "the sense of self is the only constant," which would leave out personal pronouns altogether. It is not about splitting hairs and it is not about not being able to use personal pronouns. It is simply that the statement you made is not IMO accurate.

Nick
 
Yet, materialist logic dictates that in such a scenario no one has been lost.
When people state "materialistic logic", I smell a tidal full of bullcrap coming.
No. The original is gone. The original is quite dead.
Understanding self as non-persisting is IMO paradoxical for most people.
Nope. Not to those who actually understand the "logic".
 
I don't think it's paradoxical, it just appeals to most people's emotions and makes them uncomfortable.
 
Yup.
Justify what? A desire to not die? Sorry that's an emotional response.

For sure there's a desire not to die. It's scary. But materialist logic dictates that the fear is invalid, because nothing is lost if you are replaced by the copy. Can you state what you believe would be lost?

No. The original is dead. The copy is alive. Does not change the fact I(the original) would be dead.

I shouldn't have written "no one is dying" because "dying" is not strictly accurate here. My apologies.

Nick
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom