Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Blackened Cat,

I'd love to know how level a playing field you have around this reincarnation thing. If it were demonstrated to you, theoretically and via some unknown means, that reincarnation absolutely couldn't happen, would you be cool with this?

I mean, do you consider that you have an emotional investment in believing in reincarnation or are you just interested and not bothered either way? I ask because my experience is that a lot of people who are acutely concerned about their mortality start believing in reincarnation as a way of avoiding their fears.

For myself, I can tell you something that you can of course accept or not. There may be a soul. There may be higher dimensional bodies and they may have the possibility to incarnate another physical body. For me it's possible. But what I can 100% guarantee you is that, if this should happen, then this new body will form its own sense of self. The "you" that appears to be experiencing the world around you is not coming back after death, because it has no actual existence anyway. It emerges from brain activity and appears to be the subject of various experiences but it is not. It's an illusion. So the "you", the "me," has no possibility to return. There is no one looking out from your eyes so the notion that he could return is invalid.

Nick
.
How come it is that none of these "reincarnated" souls were William or Johnny spear chucker, dead at say Hastings... like these two guys?
The "reincarnated" are always like King Harold, or some other muckety from history, but never just an ordinary bloke, cannon fodder, etc.
 

Attachments

  • reincarnation.jpg
    reincarnation.jpg
    144.9 KB · Views: 3


No, thank you. I participated in that thread early on, and if I recall correctly, you did not address any of the points I made. In addition, if you are calling upon the ghost of Kepler to support your case for reincarnation, as I said in the post you partially quoted, people believe all kinds of looney things. Smarts in one field does not guarantee smarts in all fields.
 
Smarts in one field does not guarantee smarts in all fields.


On the other hand, utter ignorance in one field does not guarantee competence in any field.

It is not a case of "Everyone is special in their own way!"

Many people aren't smart about anything.
 
Never heard of Sprong, but as with life after birth: I'll believe it when I see it.

I never heard of Sprong either, but John Shelby Spong... yes. ;)

Anyway, I was actually convinced by the end of the book that he had proved his case, which was, as stated in the last chapter, that he believed in life after death. This may seem like an easy case to prove, but after reading through most of the chapters in the book, it seemed about as likely as proving the afterlife itself.

Niles Eldridge also does an excellent summary of NOMA, but it's too late at night to talk about it right now.
 
The idea of an afterlife strikes me a strange, because it's really a very arbitrary scenario to consider.

Is it more or less likely that when we die our spirits all drift to the magnetic north pole and form clouds that lead to the Earth's weather system than it is that when we die our minds go to another reality where we are rewarded or find improvement of some sense? I think the idea of an afterlife is really just as arbitrary as saying when we die we teleport to the sun and the invisible light of our souls turns to the stuff of nuclear fusion.

Is one any less arbitrary than the other?

Does one seem to give comfort in the face of a bleak materialist reality? Which funny enough incidentally, we know that at least all there is to be seen and know is what one would expect from a purely material reality.

Does the idea of an afterlife make more sense logically than the existence of a before life? Before you were born? Why would you suddenly start to exist and then go on to live forever, when you could have always been existing?
Infinity makes more sense when it's always been and forever been, than to arbitrarily begin and then go on forever. Or does it? If there was a before life, why don't you remember it? Will you expect to remember this life in the afterlife?

Sadly in the romantic sense, the idea that we were not always here implies we won't always be here to me. But I am just a half centaur.

I find great joy and inspiration in this finite life, an accidental gift to be appreciated for it's sheer complexity. And I find that complexity infinitely more inspiring than the anthropomorphic limitations of a creator or an afterlife, considering how large the field is for such a tiny game.

I would aslo wonder, if there is a possibility of an afterlife and a before life, is there also a possibility of an inbetween life? Where do we go when we sleep?
 
Last edited:
Blackened Cat,

I'd love to know how level a playing field you have around this reincarnation thing. If it were demonstrated to you, theoretically and via some unknown means, that reincarnation absolutely couldn't happen, would you be cool with this?

I mean, do you consider that you have an emotional investment in believing in reincarnation or are you just interested and not bothered either way? I ask because my experience is that a lot of people who are acutely concerned about their mortality start believing in reincarnation as a way of avoiding their fears.

For myself, I can tell you something that you can of course accept or not. There may be a soul. There may be higher dimensional bodies and they may have the possibility to incarnate another physical body. For me it's possible. But what I can 100% guarantee you is that, if this should happen, then this new body will form its own sense of self. The "you" that appears to be experiencing the world around you is not coming back after death, because it has no actual existence anyway. It emerges from brain activity and appears to be the subject of various experiences but it is not. It's an illusion. So the "you", the "me," has no possibility to return. There is no one looking out from your eyes so the notion that he could return is invalid.

Nick



Well stated. What he said.
 
The "you" that appears to be experiencing the world around you is not coming back after death, because it has no actual existence anyway. It emerges from brain activity and appears to be the subject of various experiences but it is not. It's an illusion. So the "you", the "me," has no possibility to return. There is no one looking out from your eyes so the notion that he could return is invalid.

I have to be honest-- there's one thing that really bothers me about statements like this. They begin with a statement that is factually accurate (that would be the highlighted one.) But they then go on to make philosophical/psychological conclusions which are not automatically supported by the one statement that is empirically verifiable.

Here's an example of what I mean. Steven Rose is a neuroscientist. He is an atheist and a materialist, and he flatly states that any genuine scientist believes that thoughts emerge from brain activity and that anything resembling "Cartesian dualism" has no place in science. However, the conclusions he draws from his body of work about the functioning of the brain are very much opposed to those of Steven Pinker (who doesn't have Rose's credentials, actually). They've had a number of debates.

He certainly wouldn't agree with the quoted statement above. However, there is no way to say that this disagreement would be based on weird, vague, woo-ish ideas about reincarnation, or soul-like things floating around, or anything that David Chalmers might bring up. So the thing I don't like is the implication in these types of statements that anybody who would disagree with the rest of what's in them can't possibly be coming from a scientific stance, because this is just not the case. The statement itself is not particularly scientific ("There is no one looking out from your eyes" is a phrase that should not be appearing anywhere in a double-blind study anytime soon); it just includes one fact that is empirically verifiable, but the rest of the ideas can't simply piggyback on that. To be fair, though, I think that when people make these kinds of statements, they really don't realize that this is what they're doing.
 
Nick227 said:
The "you" that appears to be experiencing the world around you is not coming back after death, because it has no actual existence anyway. It emerges from brain activity and appears to be the subject of various experiences but it is not. It's an illusion. So the "you", the "me," has no possibility to return. There is no one looking out from your eyes so the notion that he could return is invalid.


I have to be honest-- there's one thing that really bothers me about statements like this. They begin with a statement that is factually accurate (that would be the highlighted one.) But they then go on to make philosophical/psychological conclusions which are not automatically supported by the one statement that is empirically verifiable.


I disagree with your (highlighted) assertion.

I recommend Dennett's Consciousness Explained.

Maia, please include the original poster's nick when you quote them.
 
I have to be honest

Great. Always the basis for a good relationship.

-- there's one thing that really bothers me about statements like this. They begin with a statement that is factually accurate (that would be the highlighted one.) But they then go on to make philosophical/psychological conclusions which are not automatically supported by the one statement that is empirically verifiable.

You may be bothered, but I am not trying to draw conclusions from prior statements. I'm giving you my take, which I think I stated pretty clearly at the beginning of the paragraph you quoted.

Here's an example of what I mean. Steven Rose is a neuroscientist. He is an atheist and a materialist, and he flatly states that any genuine scientist believes that thoughts emerge from brain activity and that anything resembling "Cartesian dualism" has no place in science. However, the conclusions he draws from his body of work about the functioning of the brain are very much opposed to those of Steven Pinker (who doesn't have Rose's credentials, actually). They've had a number of debates.

Sure, people disagree.

He certainly wouldn't agree with the quoted statement above.

Who wouldn't and why not?

However, there is no way to say that this disagreement would be based on weird, vague, woo-ish ideas about reincarnation, or soul-like things floating around, or anything that David Chalmers might bring up. So the thing I don't like is the implication in these types of statements that anybody who would disagree with the rest of what's in them can't possibly be coming from a scientific stance, because this is just not the case.

See reply at top.

The statement itself is not particularly scientific ("There is no one looking out from your eyes" is a phrase that should not be appearing anywhere in a double-blind study anytime soon);

Maybe not. But I think it's a clear statement that may be easily understood and one that addresses the issue directly. For those that believe in reincarnation, it does seem to often be the case that they believe that there is this soul experiencing the world and that if this body should die then it will one day grow a new one and the soul will continue its experiencing.

What I'm saying is that even if there is a soul, even if there is reincarnation, then still this will not happen. For the simple reason that it isn't happening now and actually never has.

Nick
 
Last edited:
Must disagree - I don't think that "Can we ever determine how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?" is either valid or philosophical.

Are all theoretically situations insulting?

If I pose a maths question that starts "If Suzie took the number 2 bus to.."

Would I then be questioned over the existence of Suzie or the number 2 bus? If I could not prove that Suzie exists, and that Suzie took the bus on that day... would I have insulted the intellect?

False analogy.

We don't need there to be an actual Suzie. The math problem you've suggested is one that can be proved in real life by using 1) any human being (regardless of whether it's a Suzie or not) and 2) any real bus. In other words, the example you provided uses variables that are proven to exist: buses and human beings.

The example Complexity provided uses a variable that isn't proven to exist at all: Angels.

The argument Complexity made is: Using a theorem that is already assuming that some or all of its variables exist; is a waste of time and an insult to intelligence.
 
False analogy.

We don't need there to be an actual Suzie. The math problem you've suggested is one that can be proved in real life by using 1) any human being (regardless of whether it's a Suzie or not) and 2) any real bus. In other words, the example you provided uses variables that are proven to exist: buses and human beings.

The example Complexity provided uses a variable that isn't proven to exist at all: Angels.

The argument Complexity made is: Using a theorem that is already assuming that some or all of its variables exist; is a waste of time and an insult to intelligence.


Exactly.
 
Watching the extremely subtle changes in my father's mind after the head injuries from his youth began to catch up with him in his later years in life, and the radical changes that came with the strokes he experienced later in his life, it really drove home to me a lot of the things we think about self are really very arbitrary. The same sort of issues with my mother's deteriorated mental state, as well as the moments when she was actually dying before my eyes, in many ways sealed the deal on a lot of ideas about consciousness I have had.

Many of the religious would say these states were injuries to some kind of true self deep down, and death would free them of these defects, like some sort of reboot. The trouble I have with that, is when exactly is this point of their self that is being rebooted? In the case of my father, he witnessed his mother being murdered by his father when he was 8 years old, and that messed him up in a lot of ways psychologically. He was raised in a state home, endured all manner of abuse there, as well as by the Catholic Priest who looked over the boys there, and he then went on to have more jarring experiences in the Vietnam war. In his twenties he hit a tree on his motorcycle going nearly 90 mph, and after dying for nearly 3 minutes was in a coma for 5 days (where he interestingly had a classic near death experience of his own he recounted for me often). There were also several car crashes in his life after that, all of which led to him having to have fluid drained from his brain in his later years.

Many of these traumas shaped who he was, and by the time I came around, this would mean I never knew my father, and every moment we had in my 29 years never happened. Or perhaps the spiritual argument would say he's really down there somewhere waiting to be freed of his mortal coil and regain his clarity of mind. He also suffered from agoraphobia and bipolar disorder, and I have show tendencies towards those as well since I was a toddler.

Watching the gradual deterioration of my mother's mind, especially in the last 3 minutes of her life as the light of lucidity faded from her eyes, there was no indication to me of anything but increased loss of self awareness. In those three minutes, it was very clear that the blood clot from her leg that passed to her lungs and heart was damaging her mind even more, and while she was awake until the last moment, her sense of self was growing more and more cloudy, until it was over.

If these are damaged states to some core soul or spirit that endures after death, at which point is there in your life that is being rebooted? The experiences that shape us and damage us make us who we are, and if damage to the brain can wipe out entire aspects of your personality, does mental illness also qualify as some malady you will shed at death? Or do those endure in this afterlife, or are we suddenly relieved of these things and given a clarity never experienced before, like we were silent observers in our own lives?

Without my own issues with mood and anxiety, I would not be who I was today. And this is all a very shallow examination without even getting into the experiences themselves in life who shape who we are. At any given moment we are changing our fundamental sense of identity, throughout life we are in some ways many different people. I think our sense of self is really an illusion, a process we have to have to maintain a frame of reference. I've heard this is talked about in a book, I am a Strange Loop, I've been meaning to read. I think it's worth examining though, this idea of the brain's physical make up being responsible for much of what we think of as self. Simply believing deep down there is a soul that is keeping a back up file of your true self brings some scary realizations with it.

I was raised by a mother who loved her Christian culture and family, and by an athiest father. His near death experience he attributes to natural phenomenon. He described a beautiful comforting light, and the sensation of moving on an escalator up towards this light. He felt all his loved ones around him, and then felt the presence of God himself, who he said reminded him of Santa Claus, this jolly superior intelligence. My father demanded he was not yet ready to die, and next thing he knew he was awake from his 3 day coma.

He is still alive today, but his mind is badly deteriorated, he suffers from extreme dementia that leaves him nearly a vegetable but for when he experiences his manic states. He then believes he is going to go to school online and get his degree to cure cancer, as well as run for political office. All the while he is unable to swallow and is given nourishment from a tube and is barely able to answer a question. It's impossible to draw a line really from when I was young and how he seemed then, to how he is now.

I suppose I am mostly thinking out loud more than making a point. But it does raise some questions I think that are connected with the idea of an enduring consciousness.
 
Last edited:
First one. "If objective reality exists" It's something I'm questioning at the moment.

I have devised a simple test for this.

1. Blindfold yourself.

2. Walk around your house or apartment with the blindfold on.

You will soon encounter evidence of an objective physical reality. It may be painful.
 
He certainly wouldn't agree with the quoted statement above. However, there is no way to say that this disagreement would be based on weird, vague, woo-ish ideas about reincarnation, or soul-like things floating around, or anything that David Chalmers might bring up. So the thing I don't like is the implication in these types of statements that anybody who would disagree with the rest of what's in them can't possibly be coming from a scientific stance, because this is just not the case. The statement itself is not particularly scientific ("There is no one looking out from your eyes" is a phrase that should not be appearing anywhere in a double-blind study anytime soon); it just includes one fact that is empirically verifiable, but the rest of the ideas can't simply piggyback on that. To be fair, though, I think that when people make these kinds of statements, they really don't realize that this is what they're doing.



Maia,

Perhaps I did not either, but I'm not sure you completely understood Nick's point.

What I took him to mean (outside of the no-self stuff, which goes way back and requires much more explication) can be summarized by thinking in terms of a teleporter thought experiment.

If we could do the Star Trek thing and disintegrate you and have you re-emerge over there, it would still be the case that the bundle of wants and desires that is 'you' right now would die. Whatever might form over there when the pattern is re-established would not be that bundle of desires, but another identical bundle of desires and motivations having the same form and same pattern.

While that would be great for that 'new' bundle of desires and motivations, it still would not be me; it would not be my current fears which are going to be extinguished when the teleporter kicks in. While that pattern is going to persist in the future, it won't be me, 'me' being an entirely personal construct. Of course, the funny thing is that there is, strictly speaking, no completely integrated 'me' or 'you' to begin with. 'We' are just a bundle of patterns.

The thing that gets us bogged down in all debates about consciousness is that desires and motivations are always entirely personal/subjective (which some folks take advantage of and warp the conversation inappropriately when they misuse subjective-objective distinctions). While may people may share some set of desires, the desires I have constitute 'me', one of the more important being, at least for me, that I want to continue living.
 
Watching the extremely subtle changes in my father's mind after the head injuries from his youth began to catch up with him in his later years in life, and the radical changes that came with the strokes he experienced later in his life, it really drove home to me a lot of the things we think about self are really very arbitrary. The same sort of issues with my mother's deteriorated mental state, as well as the moments when she was actually dying before my eyes, in many ways sealed the deal on a lot of ideas about consciousness I have had.

Many of the religious would say these states were injuries to some kind of true self deep down, and death would free them of these defects, like some sort of reboot. The trouble I have with that, is when exactly is this point of their self that is being rebooted? In the case of my father, he witnessed his mother being murdered by his father when he was 8 years old, and that messed him up in a lot of ways psychologically. He was raised in a state home, endured all manner of abuse there, as well as by the Catholic Priest who looked over the boys there, and he then went on to have more jarring experiences in the Vietnam war. In his twenties he hit a tree on his motorcycle going nearly 90 mph, and after dying for nearly 3 minutes was in a coma for 5 days (where he interestingly had a classic near death experience of his own he recounted for me often). There were also several car crashes in his life after that, all of which led to him having to have fluid drained from his brain in his later years.

Many of these traumas shaped who he was, and by the time I came around, this would mean I never knew my father, and every moment we had in my 29 years never happened. Or perhaps the spiritual argument would say he's really down there somewhere waiting to be freed of his mortal coil and regain his clarity of mind. He also suffered from agoraphobia and bipolar disorder, and I have show tendencies towards those as well since I was a toddler.

Watching the gradual deterioration of my mother's mind, especially in the last 3 minutes of her life as the light of lucidity faded from her eyes, there was no indication to me of anything but increased loss of self awareness. In those three minutes, it was very clear that the blood clot from her leg that passed to her lungs and heart was damaging her mind even more, and while she was awake until the last moment, her sense of self was growing more and more cloudy, until it was over.

If these are damaged states to some core soul or spirit that endures after death, at which point is there in your life that is being rebooted? The experiences that shape us and damage us make us who we are, and if damage to the brain can wipe out entire aspects of your personality, does mental illness also qualify as some malady you will shed at death? Or do those endure in this afterlife, or are we suddenly relieved of these things and given a clarity never experienced before, like we were silent observers in our own lives?

Without my own issues with mood and anxiety, I would not be who I was today. And this is all a very shallow examination without even getting into the experiences themselves in life who shape who we are. At any given moment we are changing our fundamental sense of identity, throughout life we are in some ways many different people. I think our sense of self is really an illusion, a process we have to have to maintain a frame of reference. I've heard this is talked about in a book, I am a Strange Loop, I've been meaning to read. I think it's worth examining though, this idea of the brain's physical make up being responsible for much of what we think of as self. Simply believing deep down there is a soul that is keeping a back up file of your true self brings some scary realizations with it.

I was raised by a mother who loved her Christian culture and family, and by an athiest father. His near death experience he attributes to natural phenomenon. He described a beautiful comforting light, and the sensation of moving on an escalator up towards this light. He felt all his loved ones around him, and then felt the presence of God himself, who he said reminded him of Santa Claus, this jolly superior intelligence. My father demanded he was not yet ready to die, and next thing he knew he was awake from his 3 day coma.

He is still alive today, but his mind is badly deteriorated, he suffers from extreme dementia that leaves him nearly a vegetable but for when he experiences his manic states. He then believes he is going to go to school online and get his degree to cure cancer, as well as run for political office. All the while he is unable to swallow and is given nourishment from a tube and is barely able to answer a question. It's impossible to draw a line really from when I was young and how he seemed then, to how he is now.

I suppose I am mostly thinking out loud more than making a point. But it does raise some questions I think that are connected with the idea of an enduring consciousness.



Welcome to the forum, and excellent post.
 
Watching the gradual deterioration of my mother's mind, especially in the last 3 minutes of her life as the light of lucidity faded from her eyes, there was no indication to me of anything but increased loss of self awareness. In those three minutes, it was very clear that the blood clot from her leg that passed to her lungs and heart was damaging her mind even more, and while she was awake until the last moment, her sense of self was growing more and more cloudy, until it was over.

If these are damaged states to some core soul or spirit that endures after death, at which point is there in your life that is being rebooted?


On top of the obvious metaphysical problems with dualism I've thought similar to you. Of my octogenarian grandmother, she is very rapidly declining into a second childhood, physically and mentally; which prompts me to wonder how one could take a physical view, a doctor says this or that is happening to her brain, but when a person dims completely? AHH the incorporeal immortal soul! One can imagine a slider of brain function that corresponds to a person, an "I", it can be taken all the way down to 1 where a person's "I" is very dim, little or no self-awareness, but it is only at 0 that the magic can happen.

And which stage of identity does the soul assume? The 20-year-old, 30, 40, 50? What if a person is happiest at 20 but most developed as a person at 50? Or becomes unrecognizable from 20 to 50, or 20 to 30? What an incredibly untenable position, both philosophically/scientifically and in the everyday.

You will like Hofstadter's Strange Loop if for no other reason than for liking Hofstadter himself.
 
Thanks for the warm reception, I've been lurking for quite a while, just started to post really. I've been waiting on a friend to lend me Strange Loop. Learning about chaos, how feedback of a very basic variance looped can lead to incredibly complex designs one would only expect from a designer at first glance, had me speaking with a friend about it who recommended the book based on that. It served to inspire within me a whole new regard for concepts like the golden ratio, seeing branching patterns and fractals emerge from chaos, and got me thinking of how intelligence would almost inevitably emerge from such a process on it's own, and how great it is to reach that point of being able to become aware of the process. In a poetic sense, it's almost like I am the product of the universe waking up to see itself, not to sound woo'ish, but it's a very romantic idea, and I am after all a component of the universe. I also only recently really discovered the categorization and terminology of fallacies, and am taking a great delight in having all these common errors I've noticed ( I think the first occasions were when watching talk show audiences in the 90s with their biased commentary) being used by people and being given names, it's great to see other people are aware of them to such a complicated depth. I hope one day to be able to recognize more of them by name and concept with greater competence and command. It's always an hour after the debate I work them out at this point, besides a few. :blush:
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom