Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

Blackened Cat

Scholar
Joined
Jul 21, 2010
Messages
50
Do you think the existence of a soul enduring after death is an objective or subjective idea?

So whether you believe you go to Christian heaven, Mormon heaven, Buddhist rebirth or athiest style material non-existence..... is there an actual objective reality to this?

Can it be determined?

Even if the answer is - nothing... can that be determined?

And if there is life after death, and for example it's a Christian protestant one... can we know in the here and now that this is real?

What can we base any knowledge of an afterlife on?
 
Show me the soul, then we'll talk about what happens to it after death.
 
Best bumper sticker I've ever seen:

"MILITANT AGNOSTIC: I DON'T KNOW AND NEITHER DO YOU."
 
A soul enduring after death isn't necessarily "life after death". What's a soul? What is life when its shell can't interact with the real world? There is a long way to go in defining your terms before you can even think of getting anything but stock answers.

Welcome, by the way.


ETA: Hey guys, we have to quit meeting this way!:D
 
Last edited:
You are asking if a soul or a place you go after death can be determined. This would be objective if you could determine it -- if you are using "determined" to mean known for a fact and demonstrable for everyone. Otherwise its subjective like someone being dead for a few minutes, getting resuscitated, and saying they saw angles. I dont have anything to site, but i think those kinds of experiences are rare, cant be shown to be real, and can be explained neurologically without evoking the supernatural.
 
Thanks for the welcome.


To answer all the question dodgers....you know what I mean...

Then rephrase the question, can we know the buddhist after life exists (if Greek concepts of soul somehow offends).

Is there an objective afterlife reality?
 
Thanks for the welcome.


To answer all the question dodgers....you know what I mean...

Then rephrase the question, can we know the buddhist after life exists (if Greek concepts of soul somehow offends).
No one was offended, and no one was dodging the question. If what you said isn't what you meant, the problem lies with your post, not the people responding to it.
Is there an objective afterlife reality?
No.
 
Do you think the existence of a soul enduring after death is an objective or subjective idea?

So whether you believe you go to Christian heaven, Mormon heaven, Buddhist rebirth or athiest style material non-existence..... is there an actual objective reality to this?

Can it be determined?

Even if the answer is - nothing... can that be determined?

And if there is life after death, and for example it's a Christian protestant one... can we know in the here and now that this is real?

What can we base any knowledge of an afterlife on?


Could be, no evidence that there is.
 
Thanks for the welcome.


To answer all the question dodgers....you know what I mean...

Then rephrase the question, can we know the buddhist after life exists (if Greek concepts of soul somehow offends).

Is there an objective afterlife reality?

Well the buddhist after life is in contradiction to the teachings of thw Alleged Historical Buddha.

Consequences carry, there is no atman.

ETA: So taught the AHB: anatta.
 
Not a question of offending, but the words are just so slippery, "soul", "afterlife", "spirit", etc that they only have meaning for theists, much like "sin". I have no real concept of "sin" in my world. I understand hurting people and breaking the law, and having guilt for what I do wrong, but "sin", this is only relevant if one is a believer. I'm not dodging any questions, I just don't understand a question that is similar to, "can we ever determine how many angels can dance on the head of a pin?" Namely, what the heck is an angel to an atheist?
 
Last edited:
What's a soul and what use is it?

An invisible fairy-like thing that lives inside you, which leaves your body when you die and allows admittance to the heaven or (slides down to the hell) of whichever religion you have ascribed to so you can hang out with your dead relatives.

...and it weighs 21 grams.
 
Is there an objective afterlife reality?


Really, you could put any word in place of "afterlife" and have the same question. Is there an objective afterlife realty? There's no evidence of one. Is there an objective Peyton Manning reality? There is evidence (some of it in Tennessee) that Peyton Manning exists. Is there an objective Iranian nuclear weapon reality? There is some evidence of one but some evidence that there is not.

In all cases, we are making deductions based on the evidence of our senses. And in all cases, the evidence of our senses is in some ways equivocal.

At its heart, you may be asking, "Is there an objective reality?" That question has no satisfactory answer. Each of us has no evidence that anything exists outside of our individual selves or that we existed in any moment but the present. I tend to think the answer is yes. Reality is consistent and boring (where as dreams are shifting and exciting). But some would disagree.

Are you asking about the existence of an objective reality? Or are you assuming that there is a measurable and definable objective reality and just asking if the afterlife exists within it?
 
That's a perfectly valid philosophical question and is akin to what I was asking.

I don't have any agenda to push, just asking a question.
But first you need to actually define the terms you are using. In philosophical discussion, semantics and definitions really matter. We don't don't know what you mean with a "soul".

If you can define it, we can at least start with that issue.
 
That's a perfectly valid philosophical question and is akin to what I was asking.

I don't have any agenda to push, just asking a question.

If one cannot define "angel", I'm going to have to say, "no", it cannot be determined how many can dance on the head of a pin, though I can certainly define a pin, and tell you the surface area.

I would have to know how much space they take up, and how much they weigh before I can even begin to say that it can or cannot be determined. Then, I can say, well, I don't have enough information yet, or yes, I can now attempt to determine how many can dance, providing your definition of angel states that they are able to dance.
 
Are you asking about the existence of an objective reality? Or are you assuming that there is a measurable and definable objective reality and just asking if the afterlife exists within it?

Yeah that is part of my current pondering. I may not have spelled that out well in the OP.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom