Life or no-life after death - Is it an Objective reality?

I think the problem is that when you draw the line between the magisteria, you're hard pressed to find any religion that's willing to stay on its side of the line.
 
If you mean by those horrible UE threads, I think he was always beating something else to death. It's hard to say what this was, but it didn't have much to do with anything SJG actually said. As for Gould being wrong, well...that's one of those statements which is a matter of opinion.
I really think it's better to presage them with "I think", "I believe," "IMHO," "it seems to me," "as a result of my research, I have come to the conclusion that"... Sorry, but there's a little too much of the opposite around here sometimes... IMHO!


I preface everything that I or anyone else says with something like "it seems to me that". I don't worry about making it explicit.

As to Gould's being wrong - whether he was right or wrong on NOMA is a matter of fact - we simply do not have a way of determining what this fact is.

Based upon my life's experience through this afternoon, Gould was wrong about NOMA.

Any discussion of NOMA will boil down to "I'm right, you're wrong" repeated ad nauseum. No resolution is possible.

Have the discussion if you need to, but I find the subject rather tacky.
 
Souls and angels and devils are constructs of wishful thinking, that one is just too magnificent a creation to stop after death, so there has to be something sensible following.
There's no reason other than ego for the idea.

:clap: I like that and I plan to steal it.
 
I think that your understanding of what happens when you meditate is in error.

You are experiencing and interpreting what you experience in light of your worldview and beliefs. Others, having different worldviews and beliefs, experience and interpret differently. What you think about what you experience and how you interpret it really isn't reliable and shouldn't be given any credence.

If you read what I'm writing you will see that I am not saying that "soul" exists. I'm saying that in meditation materialism is ratified - there is no mental self, in the sense of there being an observer or experiencer. Yet there is this sense of presence that is clear underneath all the thinking that causes the arisal of the belief in self.

What spiritualists call "soul", may be to materialists "neural substrate." They can be the same. Now, is it truly limited? That's a good question.

Nice to see you again too, INW!

Nick

eta: BTW, Complexity, no one is experiencing. The concept of experience is inconsistent with materialism.
 
Last edited:
If you read what I'm writing you will see that I am not saying that "soul" exists. I'm saying that in meditation materialism is ratified - there is no mental self, in the sense of there being an observer or experiencer. Yet there is this sense of presence that is clear underneath all the thinking that causes the arisal of the belief in self.

What spiritualists call "soul", may be to materialists "neural substrate." They can be the same. Now, is it truly limited? That's a good question.


My apologies for not having read carefully enough.
 
I preface everything that I or anyone else says with something like "it seems to me that". I don't worry about making it explicit.

As to Gould's being wrong - whether he was right or wrong on NOMA is a matter of fact - we simply do not have a way of determining what this fact is.

Based upon my life's experience through this afternoon, Gould was wrong about NOMA.

Any discussion of NOMA will boil down to "I'm right, you're wrong" repeated ad nauseum. No resolution is possible.


I can't agree, because there were simply too many aspects to his NOMA. There was nothing particularly simple about it. That being said, what happened to BC???
 
Belief in angels would be insulting to my intellect.

It ought to be to yours.

The assumption of the existence of angels in the original question renders the question useless and not interesting philosophically.


We could go on and on and on about this argument. I could quote many famous scientists who had a belief in Angels...

But let's just accept that you are insulted by this.

I apologise for any slight. None was intended.
 
Yes.

I will note, however, that your question is oddly phrased. I answered what I thought you were asking.

Science isn't always done by scientists - it is a way of approaching and modeling reality.

To know what is real, should we first consult science? Or are we making leaps of faith until science confirms this?

How many studies do we do until we confirm something is real? 1, 2? 12?

Or are most of us constantly running on assumptions. I assume that office building across the street is real. But I'm not sure. I haven't read studies. I haven't tested that it is built of materials and in a certain way that constitutes a building. In fact I haven't read studies or science that defines the parameters of what is a building.

Instead, when I was a child I was told that shape is a building. I can see it. I assume.
 
here is no soul or anything similar to one.

What point of reference can you make that assumption then?

Are you just a bunch of temporary formations? Like an illusion.

Why should anyone believe a temporary illusion? In fact if you content that you don't have any inherent existence.... then why should you believe your own conclusions?
 
Taken together, I would have to say that I have pretty good reasons to suspect that there is an external world and no particularly good reasons to suspect that there is anything after death based on the limited evidence that is available. There might be. Who knows? We are not privvy to the information, though.


Yeah, logically...that's pretty much where I sit on the matter.
 
Last edited:
We could go on and on and on about this argument. I could quote many famous scientists who had a belief in Angels...

But let's just accept that you are insulted by this.

I apologise for any slight. None was intended.

Could you do that please?
 
I think that your understanding of what happens when you meditate is in error.

You are experiencing and interpreting what you experience in light of your worldview and beliefs. Others, having different worldviews and beliefs, experience and interpret differently. What you think about what you experience and how you interpret it really isn't reliable and shouldn't be given any credence.

How can we interpret anything then? even science data? We can't rely on the scientists either, because they operate the same as you describe above.
 
Could you do that please?

Would it satisfy the criteria, to get a list of famous scientists who had varying Religious/spiritual/occult beliefs through the Judeo-christian world?

If you come from the Christian or Jewish tradition, belief in Angels would be part of the package.

For instance Issac Newton was an Anti-trinitarian Christian who had occult like beliefs and even had his own end times predictions happening.

But I suppose he would be considered an insulting bashtard on this board? I kid! :P
 
Scientists are people.

The bulk of Western science was developed in the Western world by people who went to Church, who had religious upbringing.
 
I can't agree, because there were simply too many aspects to his NOMA. There was nothing particularly simple about it. That being said, what happened to BC???

Problem is that most, if not all religions make claims about the physical universe that are overt trespasses into the realm of scientific endeavor. These claims are found in their texts (virgin birth, rising from the dead) and unless they are advanced as metaphorical, one can argue they indeed overlap.

Of course if one makes the argument that all these stories are metaphorical, metaphysical in nature, or philosophical . . . well, a good tart, lime or otherwise, is more interesting.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom