Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

If the debate is going to be relevant, we need to get everyone involved - prostitutes, ex-prostitutes, buyers, pimps, police - and listen to them. I have no problem understanding that people are emotional about it, but no one benefits from turning away from reality.

I'm a practically minded person, so if the illegalization of prostitution evidently does not work as intended, leading to worse working conditions while doing nothing to get rid of prostitution, I'm prepared to consider other ways to handle it.

Good points.
 
The status of prostitution research is a huge topic and I really don't have time for that at the moment. Before even engaging in that, I think it is important to reach some understanding on the implications of the research. What, in your opinion, constitutes an acceptable risk? What types of data would you accept to indicate that prostitution is harmful?

For instance, let us say that we make the following study: we interview women at the age of 40 and classify them in three groups: those who have sold sex on at least 50 occasions, those who have never sold sex, and those in between. Let us say that we then look at for how long these women have had their current romantic relationship (eg 0 days for no relationship). If we then find out that women who have sold sex at least 50 times are in much shorter relationships and are more often not in a relationship, would you accept this as indicative that prostitution is harmful? Or would you rather argue that perhaps these women simply don't want longer relationships and are happier with casual sex and staying single?

My first thoughts are why use such an obscure proxy for harm and how much of the harm of prostitution has it's roots in prejudice.
 
As Damian Evans suggests: What is the experience of prostitution in countries/states where it is legal?
If the practice is universally legal and regulated to some degree (health, working conditions, etc.) then many of the ills associated would not be relevant. The human trafficking, the drug addiction, the "pimp", STDs, "Johns" getting "rolled" for their money, etc, etc.
Utter poverty is not the only reason women enter prostitution. There is always an underclass of "street walkers" on the lower levels of the practice. However, there is always an upper-cadre of "high-priced call girls" and "consorts" who are at entirely the other end of the scale.
Then you can put the various "escort services" into whatever part of the mix you like, as well as the lucrative but generally no-intercourse-involved business of high-priced "dungeons" where the wealthy can indulge their dominant/submissive fantasies.

Lets face it, the "world's oldest profession" has indeed been with us for a long time. There are still extant fresco-painting advertisements for brothels on artifacts from the Roman world.
Here in Saint Louis, we had functioning brothels that were hardly underground into the 50s at least. Just as in the movies, "everyone" knew they were there, and since the clientele was usually well-heeled pillars of local politics and business, nothing was done.
It was generally understood that such establishments simply paid off local law enforcement, or had them for clients....
A friend of ours actually lived in one of these. From the ground, it was a simple apartment building with a rather spacious garage on the ground floor.
When you entered the garage. you found it was MUCH larger than it looked like from outside, and could accommodate 20-30 vehicles, all parked out of sight from passers-by.
A spiral staircase led from this garage to the upper story, which featured a huge full-service bar, at least a dozen small, intimate rooms (all rather garish with "flocked" wallpaper and all), several bathrooms, and one larger room for whatever entertainment had been laid on.
Establishments like this flourished in all major cities to my knowledge, and likely many smaller ones as well.
As to the motivation of men to visit prostitutes, that would require perhaps another thread; John Money had a lot to say on the subject, with our American dichotomy about "holy love" and "sinful lust"....
 
Even where prostitution is legal, women and girls (boys as well) end up being exploited by pimps.

I know that the libertarian view is that prostitution is a "victimless" crime, but my first-hand experience is otherwise.

That old "Happy Hooker" meme is about as rare as an honest politician.
 
My first thoughts are why use such an obscure proxy for harm and how much of the harm of prostitution has it's roots in prejudice.
Then please suggest a better study. I didn't try to invent the perfect study, my purpose was to come up with a theoretical example that I personally would find convincing but which prostitution proponents may be apt to dismiss.

I'm the first one to agree that the status of prostitution research is not ideal. It is very hard to come up with studies that are not flawed one way or the other. I think it is eminently clear that there are qualitative studies showing a number of very bad effects resulting from prostitution. However, the issue then is how prevalent are these effects? How is it dependent on factors such as legal status, attitudes, access to assistance for prostitutes who want to quit, the general level of affluence of society, etc etc. My personal conclusion, based on available imperfect evidence, is only provisional. I'm ready to change my mind. But at the moment, I'm convinced that prostitution really does have quite serious negative effects for a high percentage of prostitutes, possibly the majority. I'm certainly not willing to accept the idea that just because we have imperfect information, we should therefore assume that prostitution is harmless and that society should find it acceptable to pay for sex.

One comment on attitudes though. Let us assume for the sake of arguments - I am not at all convinced - that the bad effects of prostitution are mainly due to negative attitudes towards prostitutes in the rest of society. In my opinion, that should not lead us to conclude that it would be acceptable to pay for sex. That would be equivalent to saying that since there is nothing wrong with homosexuality per se, it is perfectly fine to out a homosexual in Uganda. We are responsible for the consequences of our actions, even if someone else is ultimately to blame.
 
Even where prostitution is legal, women and girls (boys as well) end up being exploited by pimps.

I know that the libertarian view is that prostitution is a "victimless" crime, but my first-hand experience is otherwise.

That old "Happy Hooker" meme is about as rare as an honest politician.

hookers in amsterdam do not fit your mold.
 
If the practice is universally legal and regulated to some degree (health, working conditions, etc.) then many of the ills associated would not be relevant. The human trafficking, the drug addiction, the "pimp", STDs, "Johns" getting "rolled" for their money, etc, etc.
This is not consistent with empirical evidence. For instance, the Netherlands, where prostitution is legal, has serious and it appears increasing problems with sex trafficking. From what I've been able to gather, the possibility to run legal brothels provides sex traffickers with a cover that makes it easier to hide slave brothels both from authorities and from customers (yes, somehow it seems most of the johns do not realize when the woman they are served by is in fact held captive!).

Utter poverty is not the only reason women enter prostitution. There is always an underclass of "street walkers" on the lower levels of the practice. However, there is always an upper-cadre of "high-priced call girls" and "consorts" who are at entirely the other end of the scale.
Yeah, but do you believe these two are unrelated? What do you think makes the high-priced girls able to charge so much? I don't think it is just their attitude. What do you think happens when they can no longer be so picky about their johns? As I said, some of these girls might be able to have a career change, but then again, sometimes not. In reality anyway, these high-priced girls are such a small percentage of the market that is really just a distraction. If this is an issue of avoiding unacceptable harm, they are irrelevant.
 
hookers in amsterdam do not fit your mold.

At least one prostitute in the East Midlands doesn't either.

I think we need to be pragmatic about the situation: people are going to sell sex whether it's legal or not. What we should be aiming for is reducing the number of people who are involved in prostitution unwillingly and providing support and protection for those who do want to work in the sex industry.
 
My first thoughts are why use such an obscure proxy for harm and how much of the harm of prostitution has it's roots in prejudice.

That's the main problem there. Prostitution can't be judged as just sex for money, the broader sociological implications must be considered.

Prostitution is seen as degrading, whether it is or not, so prostitutes are seen as a lower social class and one that does not have autonomy over their own bodes. This puts prostitutes at greater risk for violence and exploitation. Young women are seen as commodities by pimps and clients, and as targets by whatever serial killer happens to be working the area. Prostitutes in countries with legal red light districts are less likely to be murdered because brothels and areas with frequent police patrols are safer. But they are still at risk for violence and rape.

Amsterdam is seen as the modern, clean form of street prostitution. prostitution is defined as a job, regulated and taxed. One might go, pick a girl from a window and feel that they were engaging in a mutually beneficial transaction.

There's a very good chance this wouldn't be the case. Most of the women working in red light districts are foreigners (Locals tend to be drug addicts, btw) and the majority have been brought in by pimps. The most profitable prostitute is young and easily talked into taking a job as a nanny. Once she's been taken from her home, she is abused, her papers taken away and she is set up to work. Threats of violence to herself or children left behind in her home country keep her from seeking help. Although trafficking is illegal in the Netherlands, the punishment is not severe and immigration authorities do not make it a priority.

World-wide, prostitution is primarily sex trafficking even in a liberal western country that tries to offer dignity to the profession. Which is not to say that there aren't completely autonomous and happy sex workers. They exist but they are a very small minority.
 
At least one prostitute in the East Midlands doesn't either.

I think we need to be pragmatic about the situation: people are going to sell sex whether it's legal or not. What we should be aiming for is reducing the number of people who are involved in prostitution unwillingly and providing support and protection for those who do want to work in the sex industry.

agreed.
 
My argument isn't that sex workers are of a lower class, or lesser people.

My observations on the subject come from my own experiences with prostitutes out in the world when I was serving or working offshore, and my experiences as a LEO - I never encountered a prostitute otj that wasn't either a victim of exploitation or an addict or alcoholic - sometimes all three.

I did encounter women who were victims of sex trafficing, primarily Asian, and it was such a problem in the county where I worked that eventually the county instituted a very strict set of regulations governing the types of business "fronts" used to conceal the prostitution activity.

I can't conceive a regulatory model that would allow legal prostitution, and also provide protection for the workers at all levels that wouldn't grow into a huge government bureaucracy.
 
There are well meaning reasons why prostitution should be illegal, mainly to do with the prevention of exploitation of women. However, many of the laws are legacy laws where the prostitute is the criminal not the man soliciting. This is, in my view, counter-productive and a tad Victorian.

Ultimately the law should be as practical and as enforceable as possible. Do countries with more liberal laws to prostitution have a better record at protecting women and edging out the pimps and gangsters? If so then the more logical approach is to decriminalise. If not how can our laws be improved?

However, my personal knowledge on the matter is zero. It isn't a career choice I would want for my daughter either and if she did I would recommend she went in for the electric zappers, nipple devices and masks brigade. They pay more, you don't have to let them touch you and tend to be high court judges (allegedly).
 
Last edited:
I think we need to be pragmatic about the situation: people are going to sell sex whether it's legal or not. What we should be aiming for is reducing the number of people who are involved in prostitution unwillingly and providing support and protection for those who do want to work in the sex industry.
I agree with that, and I think making it illegal to pay for sex appears to be a good way towards that end.
 
That is certainly something one can speculate about. We can conclude one obvious difference: a prostitute is clearly having sex with a lot of people he or she would not have had sex with if there was no money involved. This means that he or she is frequently having sex with people whom he or she is not sufficiently attracted to to have sex with for his or her own pleasure. It does not seem implausible to me that this may in fact be the cause for observed social and psychological problems.

But what if he or she thinks the money makes it worthwhile? There are a lot of things that people can find worthwhile if they get money from it.

Moreover, while people are indeed having casual sex with people they meet in nightclubs etc, this clearly does not happen with the same frequency for the same individual as for typical prostitutes encountering new clients.

So what?

And who says someone selling sex has to be working as a prostitute? It can be something that someone does from time to time besides his or her usual job, to get some quick money.

How do you view porn? Is sex for money suddenly okay when it is filmed? Or you are part of the ~50% of our Calvinistic population that wants porn prohibitted?

Contrary to what is commonly claimed, prostitution is not illegal in Sweden. Police can indeed try to catch people paying for sex by waiting outside locations believed to be used by prostitutes and attempt to collect evidence. In practice, this does not happen much but there has been cases. I believe they should not do that unless there is a suspicion of trafficking or child prostitution. Rather, I believe they should intervene in such cases only when the prostitute calls on the police for help or there are other signs of immediate danger. It is in any case extremely hard to prove that someone paid for sex without cooperation from the prostitute.
If this was the case, I believe it would indeed be helpful for prostitutes, because they would be offered protection without having to prove for instance that they had been raped or abused, but only that the customer had paid for sex, which is easier to prove. This would have the dual benefit first of deterring people from paying for sex, since the prostitute may turn them in for any reason, and of treating prostitutes better if they still pay for sex, in order to avoid this from happening.

You don't answer the question, you simply assume that prostitutes are victimized by their customers. I don't share that assumption. And neither do those voluntary involved.

And we are talking about voluntary prostitution, not enforced one. Nobody is proposing to legalize enforced prostitution.

Merko said:
For instance, let us say that we make the following study: we interview women at the age of 40 and classify them in three groups: those who have sold sex on at least 50 occasions, those who have never sold sex, and those in between. Let us say that we then look at for how long these women have had their current romantic relationship (eg 0 days for no relationship). If we then find out that women who have sold sex at least 50 times are in much shorter relationships and are more often not in a relationship, would you accept this as indicative that prostitution is harmful? Or would you rather argue that perhaps these women simply don't want longer relationships and are happier with casual sex and staying single?

What a piece of moralistic crap. SO WHAT? Is it a sake for the authorities to legislate in a way that people will stay in long romantic relationships?

If it could be shown that people who work at McDonalds tend not to be involved in long-term romantic relationships, would you then ban McDonalds?
 
the core of what is harmful is exactly selling your body for strangers to use it for their pleasure. There seems to be some fundamental psychological reasons why this is socially and psychologically harmful.

And it seems pretty hard to ban this without actually banning prostitution. If you have another view, please spell it out rather than theorizing that there 'might' be some other factor.
I have a different view, and I have offered as much evidence for it as you have. Which is zero.

My view is that this job is not harmful or unwanted for everyone who works in it, at least if the price is high enough. Therefore it is not reasonable to ban it from everyone.
 
New Zealand appears to be having some limited success.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prostitution_in_New_Zealand#Evaluation

Yes, they have. If they continue with this trend, address unforeseen issues as they arrive and keep the focus on the sex-workers instead of the brothels, they may have found a decent balance. The law restricts sex trafficking from outside, legal "single owner" brothels allow sex workers to report crime against them, and sex workers have access to medical and social services as needed. It is a very good compromise.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom