Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

The social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes instead of doing their actual job of stopping them from being child prostitutes.

I've been tracking this story down and the earliest reference I can find is Anthony Daniels aka Theodore Dalrymple's article All Sex, All the Time published in 2000.

That's 11 years ago, if anyone is counting.

I can find no other references to this other than repeated rehashings and republishing of the story by Daniels and others.
 
Sure, it's POSSIBLE for someone to engage in prostitution without pressure of her own free will and enjoy it. But it's not likely.

Who ever said you had to enjoy it? I'm pretty sure those students who work at McDonald's to 3 in the morning on a Saturday night don't enjoy their work but we all have to pay our bills...
 
What I said was that I understood the rationale, but I disagree with it. So no, I don't think drugs should be illegal. Will you now please give me a good reason for why prostitution should be illegal?

Yes, prostitution should be illegal for the same reason (or rationale, if you prefer) that drugs are illegal. Because prostitution is harmful to its practitioners. And no, I am not talking about the johns but rather those who are desperate enough to have to resort to it.

I am sure you can understand the rationale, even though you may disagree with it, but you seem to be trying to downplay the harm by, for example, arguing that drug-taking could be harmful while sex is not. This is not even true in itself as sex can indeed be harmful physically in terms of venereal diseases etc... but prostitution is not simply sex but sex for money. And those most likely to be attracted to selling their bodies for cash are the poor and the desperate.

While you can argue an idealized situation in which no one would go into prostitution that they didn't freely and happily agree to the reality is more likely to be that the poor and the vulnerable will disproportionately become prostitutes.

That is the rationale. I am surprised you cannot "understand" the rationale as you do in the case of drugs but if you insist on seeing prostitution for something other than what it is then you can't really expect to understand the rationale.
 
Who ever said you had to enjoy it? I'm pretty sure those students who work at McDonald's to 3 in the morning on a Saturday night don't enjoy their work but we all have to pay our bills...

Working in MacDonalds, however bad we may think it is, is still not as degrading as having to sell your body to pay the bills.
 
Working in MacDonalds, however bad we may think it is, is still not as degrading as having to sell your body to pay the bills.

But that is your opinion. And some would disagree. The world is full of a variety of people, I'm sure there's somebody out there who prefers being paid to have sex, instead of being paid to flip burgers. (Or any other hellish minimum wage job, there are many.)

Regardless, nobody has the right to tell you what you can and cannot do for work, in order to pay your bills.
 
Yes, prostitution should be illegal for the same reason (or rationale, if you prefer) that drugs are illegal. Because prostitution is harmful to its practitioners. And no, I am not talking about the johns but rather those who are desperate enough to have to resort to it.
This is not a very good argument considering the disaster called "War on Drugs" and the corresponding trouble arising from banning prostitution. It would be easier to limit the risks of the job if it was legal and in registered brothels.
Originally Posted by Skeptic
Sure, it's POSSIBLE for someone to engage in prostitution without pressure of her own free will and enjoy it. But it's not likely.
It does not have to be likely.
How many prostitutes are there customers for?
 
But that is your opinion. And some would disagree. The world is full of a variety of people, I'm sure there's somebody out there who prefers being paid to have sex, instead of being paid to flip burgers. (Or any other hellish minimum wage job, there are many.)

Regardless, nobody has the right to tell you what you can and cannot do for work, in order to pay your bills.

Okay, then. Some people would probably like to earn their money bumfighting as well. Would you be okay with that given that nobody has the right to tell you what you can and cannot do for work, in order to pay your bills.

In the latter case you will find that some people do have the right to tell you what you can or can't do to pay your bills. It should be obvious that this is the case.
 
Working in MacDonalds, however bad we may think it is, is still not as degrading as having to sell your body to pay the bills.

Subjective emotional drivel aside, you are simply blatantly wrong and dishonest when you say that a prostitute 'sells their body'. A prostitute sells a service, sex, in which their body is used. No more and no less.
 
Subjective emotional drivel aside, you are simply blatantly wrong and dishonest when you say that a prostitute 'sells their body'. A prostitute sells a service, sex, in which their body is used. No more and no less.

What makes it "emotional drivel"? The fact that it is subjective? Is anything that is subjective or emotional by definition "drivel" and is your resorting to the term "drivel" not itself emotional and subjective?

"To sell one's body" is a widely understood figure of speech for prosititution and it is quite apt given that it is the use of the body that a customer of a prostitute wants. No doubt there have been some tender, loving relationships which have flowered from the oldest profession and immortalized in such romantic classics as "Pretty Woman" but my hunch is that prostitution is, in fact, degrading for the majority of these servants.
 
What makes it "emotional drivel"? The fact that it is subjective?

Exactly. Discussing whether being a sewer worker who stands waist-deep in **** every single day is more 'degrading' than being a prostitute who sleeps with fat, pot bellied 65 year olds is a huge pointless waste of time.

"To sell one's body" is a widely understood figure of speech for prosititution and it is quite apt given that it is the use of the body that a customer of a prostitute wants.

Oh and here i thought you were using loaded language. Silly me.

No doubt there have been some tender, loving relationships which have flowered from the oldest profession and immortalized in such romantic classics as "Pretty Woman" but my hunch is that prostitution is, in fact, degrading for the majority of these servants.

Who said anything about any 'tender, loving relationships'? I sure as hell didn't. I don't have naive ideas about prostitutes.
 
Exactly. Discussing whether being a sewer worker who stands waist-deep in **** every single day is more 'degrading' than being a prostitute who sleeps with fat, pot bellied 65 year olds is a huge pointless waste of time.

I wonder why you chose "sewer workers"? My brother-in-law is a "sewer worker" but that doesn't describe his daily routine. However, it does seem to me that you are choosing "sewer workers" because you think there is a likelihood that there is a mutually agreed idea of degradation. You didn't say, "Discussing whether or not being a bank clerk is more degrading than being a prostitute is a huge pointless waste of time".

I think that in principle it is discoverable if we found out that an extremely high proportion of prostitutes were miserable at having to be prostitutes. I will admit that it is up to me to show this and will try to look for some evidence which either supports or refutes my conjecture IFF you will agree that this is a good objective test of what counts as a determining how degrading a job is.

Oh and here i thought you were using loaded language. Silly me.

Well, that may be true. Much of our language is loaded - we just can't help it! It doesn't make it "drivel" (another loaded term in that its connotive meaning is far more obvious than its denotive meaning) though.

Who said anything about any 'tender, loving relationships'? I sure as hell didn't. I don't have naive ideas about prostitutes.

Actually, I think you do. I think it is naiive to think that one job could be just as degrading as the next and that we have no way of deciding whether or not prostitution is more or less degrading than say, working in the sewers or in MacDonalds. I think that is very naiive. But hey, that's just like my opinion so you can't say I'm wrong. Right?
 
I think there's a good chance that sex workers would be treated better if prostitution was legal and regulated. Obviously if the sex worker is being coerced, or otherwise mistreated, that's a bad thing. But what if a prostitute enjoys having sex or money, or at least finds it preferable to other work? Then it's a victimless crime. The reason it's illegal, in my view, is because many countries are puritanical. Look at the U.S.--booze and cigarettes kill tens of thousands a year, pot kills no one, yet that's the illegal substance.

Prohibition didn't keep people from drinking; it created a criminal enterprise (see: Al Capone) and was responsible for people drinking horrible chemicals like shoe polish. Making booze legal didn't end society's alcohol related problems, but it did make it harder for kids to buy it, and regulations kept sellers from selling toxic concoctions (even more toxic than regular booze). When I was underage it was far easier to buy illegal drugs than a six pack. Drug dealers tend not to card.

Obviously sex trafficking and child prostitution is ghastly and should not be tolerated under any circumstance. Arguably if sex work was legal and regulated that could be kept under better control.

Join and support COYOTE (Supporting and representing sex workers since 1973) http://www.bayswan.org/COYOTE.html
 
Yes, prostitution should be illegal for the same reason (or rationale, if you prefer) that drugs are illegal. Because prostitution is harmful to its practitioners. And no, I am not talking about the johns but rather those who are desperate enough to have to resort to it.

What percentage of prostitutes are exchanging money for sex because of desperation (as opposed to making a free choice without being desperate)?

I am sure you can understand the rationale, even though you may disagree with it, but you seem to be trying to downplay the harm by, for example, arguing that drug-taking could be harmful while sex is not. This is not even true in itself as sex can indeed be harmful physically in terms of venereal diseases etc... but prostitution is not simply sex but sex for money. And those most likely to be attracted to selling their bodies for cash are the poor and the desperate.

Sex can be physically harmful. So can smoking cigarettes, drinking booze, driving cars, skiiing, mountain climbing, eating unhealthy foods, etc. Should we outlaw all things that are potentially physically harmful? Should we outlaw sex period?

While you can argue an idealized situation in which no one would go into prostitution that they didn't freely and happily agree to the reality is more likely to be that the poor and the vulnerable will disproportionately become prostitutes.

What about poor and vulnerable people that are desperate and end up working under slave labor conditions as fruit pickers or garment workers? Should we make fruit picking and garment working illegal, or make exploiting workers illegal?
 
What percentage of prostitutes are exchanging money for sex because of desperation (as opposed to making a free choice without being desperate)?

Good question and I think the answer to it could assist us in formulating laws on prostitution. I am not actually arguing, yet, for the banning of prostitution. I am responding to the question of whether there is any good reason for it being illegal.

Sex can be physically harmful. So can smoking cigarettes, drinking booze, driving cars, skiiing, mountain climbing, eating unhealthy foods, etc. Should we outlaw all things that are potentially physically harmful? Should we outlaw sex period?

No, we shouldn't outlaw sex. But the relative health effects of certain activities may well be relevant in formulating laws. It already is in some cases which are controversial as well as in cases which are relatively uncontroversial such as driving laws. Some laws are silly. Some aren't.

What about poor and vulnerable people that are desperate and end up working under slave labor conditions as fruit pickers or garment workers? Should we make fruit picking and garment working illegal, or make exploiting workers illegal?

Good question. There are laws about this in many countries such as minimum wage, health and safety regulations etc... so yes, we probably should make certain business practices illegal and also made certain forms of "employment" illegal if it appears to be of too high a risk to the prospective employee even if they would be in favour of taking that employment despite the risks.

Maybe you disagree with that. What do you think?
 
There is good sociological evidence that sewer workers, or other people who do "dirty" jobs, do not consider themselves "degraded" or "exploited" -- for the very good reason that a job being unpleasant is not at all the same as it being degrading. It is often, indeed usually, useful and necessary (or else people won't bother with it) and thus not degrading, least of all to those who do it.

Prostitutes, on the other hand, for all the propagnda about this being a "free choice" and "nothing wrong with it", is the inherently degrading business of selling one's body, or making sexual relations, which should express intimacy and love and caring, into something sold to the highest bidder. This is why most prostitutes want desperately to escape prostitution.
 
Last edited:
The social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes instead of doing their actual job of stopping them from being child prostitutes.
They do the same for drug users too. Distribute free needles, so they will not reuse needles and spread HIV to each other through them.

These kind of policies do sound impotent indeed, the reasoning is that _if_ we cannot stop the said activity, it is better to limit its bad consequences than not do even that. Logical, but the "if" easily sounds more like "we don´t care to try our best" than "we are unable to".

Divorce is also legal in most countries that accept polygamy, but it doesn't take much to note in most of them women's status leaves much to be desired.
So the problem is equal rights of men and women, not the right of people to enter a polygamous marriage of N men and M women if they so wish? All discussions about these kind of topics tend to focus on indirect reasons, why "we should ban X" because X indirectly leads to Y, while the actual problem is Y and not X, and we could simply ban Y and not X.
 
Last edited:
Yes, prostitution should be illegal for the same reason (or rationale, if you prefer) that drugs are illegal. Because prostitution is harmful to its practitioners (...) those who are desperate enough to have to resort to it.
Prostitution earns you money, but by your logic we should rather leave these people as desperate as they are economically, than give them this chance of earning money.

Anyway, this is another indirect reason, which has nothing to do with prostitution itself: economically desperate people do exist, that is a social problem that should be addressed, and that has nothing to do with prostitution being legal or not. Except that we could enforce minimum wage laws in prostitution to prevent people being taken unfair advantage of.

What percentage of prostitutes are exchanging money for sex because of desperation (as opposed to making a free choice without being desperate)?
(...)
Should we make fruit picking and garment working illegal, or make exploiting workers illegal?
So the problem of people accepting undesirable work in desperate economical circumstances is not unique to prostitution, and should find its answers from broader economical policies.
 
So the problem of people accepting undesirable work in desperate economical circumstances is not unique to prostitution, and should find its answers from broader economical policies.

Yes to the first part. Regarding the second part--I didn't state or imply that. I'm not sure where you got the "broader economic policies" or what you mean by that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom