Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Well, in the whole of this thread, you are the one who has been making unsupported assertions. You don't back them up, and the assertions that others make that are backed up you readily dismiss, to again ask them to back it up.
That's a bit rich from someone who summarily dismissed all existing empirical research on the subject.

Who are these mystical "scholars" you refer to?
Anyone. I'll let you choose anyone you like, although it has to be someone who actually studies prostitution empirically. A philosopher or economist who has only done theoretical work does not qualify.
I'm not aware of any such study being seriously performed.

So your position basically boils down to "I don't agree with what scientists say about prostitution, so I'll just declare that all empirical prostitution research is 'unserious' so that I can continue to believe whatever I want".
 
Last edited:
That's a bit rich from someone who summarily dismissed all existing empirical research on the subject.

This coming from a poster who, even after being repeatedly asked, provided essentially no material to back up his assertions despite the claim that there was volumes of information available. So after 11 pages and nearly three weeks we have one survey from New Zealand which I admittedly haven't read yet but seems underwhelming. And one study from Colorado which seems to demonstrate (surprise surprise) that ** illegal ** street prostitutes are the targets of crime at a substantially higher rate. I'd be interested to see statistics on legal brothels such as those in Nevada. Do we think that the homicide rate in those is as high as those who operate outside the law?

So your position basically boils down to "I don't agree with what scientists say about prostitution, so I'll just declare that all empirical prostitution research is 'unserious' so that I can continue to believe whatever I want".

One can't reject information that wasn't provided. There are 11 pages of discussion, you’ve provided exactly two references one of which came around only after three weeks.
 
I'd be interested to see statistics on legal brothels such as those in Nevada.
Me too. By all means, please post some such studies if you believe that would give a radically different picture!

There are 11 pages of discussion, you’ve provided exactly two references one of which came around only after three weeks.
You've provided exactly zero. Why should I take you seriously?
 
Me too. By all means, please post some such studies if you believe that would give a radically different picture!

If I come across such research then I would post it, rather than demand that people just accept my opinion on the behavior of two consenting adults engaging in an act that was otherwise legal.

You've provided exactly zero. Why should I take you seriously?

Your question doesn't make sense to me. I never suggested to have read, interpreted, or to have been aware of the oceans of research that you claimed and then never shared until weeks in the thread when that ocean turned out to be one paper and one survey. I haven't really outlined a position to ask that it be taken seriously either. I only wonder (along with others) where the data is that lead you to your conclusion.
 
The whores end up fat, lazy, flabby and on dope. Then they die prematurely after overburdening the health system.
 
That's a bit rich from someone who summarily dismissed all existing empirical research on the subject.

What?

So your position basically boils down to "I don't agree with what scientists say about prostitution, so I'll just declare that all empirical prostitution research is 'unserious' so that I can continue to believe whatever I want".

I don't really think this is about "belief". What do you believe about this, and what do you think I believe?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom