Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Working in MacDonalds, however bad we may think it is, is still not as degrading as having to sell your body to pay the bills.

But that is only because most people consider the integrity of their mind less important than the integrity of their body.
 
Prostitution had been legal here for years. All the anti-legalisation posts in this thread are so absurd that I almost question whether to invoke Poe's Law.
 
I think it's simply that the issue of coercion, whatever the form, is a more sensitive subject when it comes to sex. And it should be. People can compare prostitution to other undesirable professions all they like; at the end of the day, forcing someone to perform boring, uncomfortable or demanding tasks when they don't want to isn't nearly as bad as forcing someone to have sex when they don't want to.

Of course, whether or not economic problems and pressure is enough to count as 'coercion' in any way, shape or form is something that people will argue a lot about based on their political opinions. But please try to keep this in mind when you deride the 'prohibitionists' as squeamish or emotional: To most of us, this is essentially an issue of forced sex. Let that viewpoint sink in, and then try to respect the fact that everyone can't talk about the issue like it's just another job.

I'm Swedish, and it's true that the political debate around has had quite a few issues. That politicians who claim to have the best interests of prostitutes in mind seem utterly shocked that actual prostitutes aren't terribly happy about the purchase of their services being criminalized... well, it doesn't help the cause. If the debate is going to be relevant, we need to get everyone involved - prostitutes, ex-prostitutes, buyers, pimps, police - and listen to them. I have no problem understanding that people are emotional about it, but no one benefits from turning away from reality.

I'm a practically minded person, so if the illegalization of prostitution evidently does not work as intended, leading to worse working conditions while doing nothing to get rid of prostitution, I'm prepared to consider other ways to handle it.
 
Prostitution earns you money, but by your logic we should rather leave these people as desperate as they are economically, than give them this chance of earning money.

Utter rubbish! That is not my logic!

If I went to Calcutta and found some starving child in the gutter and said that I would give them some food if I could have my wicked way with them would you then make the same odious platitudinous excuse for my behaviour as you just have for prostitution?

No, of course not because you know that would be wrong! And this by the way absolutely demolishes the tendentious distinction between saying that adult prostitutes need to be sex servants to pay the bills and that child sex servants need to be sex servants to pay the bills or would you say, by your logic, that we should rather leave these people as desperate as they are economically, than give them this chance of earning money.

Of course you wouldn't say such an evil thing. So don't try it on with your example!

What follows from my logic is that we should work towards ways in which people can have better - yes BETTTER and LESS DEGRADING! - forms of employment or forms of well-targetted welfare to prevent people having to do these jobs rather than to have smug "non-judgmental" liberals cheering on the only nasty options available to those vulnerable people.
 
I wonder why you chose "sewer workers"?
Since you apparently failed to see my point I'm going to put it simply: debating whether something is more 'degrading' than something else is just as pointless as arguing that the color blue is just 'worse' than the color green. Now, you can very well argue that the color blue is worse than green when used as jungle camouflage but that's actually tied to an actual measurable claim.

Unless you're going to tie 'degrading' to a real measurable quality (see below) then don't even mention it.

I think that in principle it is discoverable if we found out that an extremely high proportion of prostitutes were miserable at having to be prostitutes. I will admit that it is up to me to show this and will try to look for some evidence which either supports or refutes my conjecture IFF you will agree that this is a good objective test of what counts as a determining how degrading a job is.

If you define 'degrading' as 'being miserable at work', and i might misunderstand you here, then sure. That's actually a measurable, albeit slightly diffuse, quality of a job. Go for it.

Just remember: not all prostitutes are street-walking crack addicts desperately trying to find cash to pay for their next fix. Many, especially now thanks to the internet, are professional escorts who just want to make extra money in-between studies and, since they don't have many other marketable skills, simply think working as a prostitute works off better than not working at all. These prostitutes aren't generally the kind you find in womens shelters, prisons and addiction clinics, which ought to be the simplest place to find prostitutes and discover their views about their own work.

Well, that may be true. Much of our language is loaded - we just can't help it! It doesn't make it "drivel" (another loaded term in that its connotive meaning is far more obvious than its denotive meaning) though.

Actually it does, because it doesn't tell us anything insightful about it and is just a way to stir up irrational emotions.

Actually, I think you do. I think it is naiive to think that one job could be just as degrading as the next and that we have no way of deciding whether or not prostitution is more or less degrading than say, working in the sewers or in MacDonalds. I think that is very naiive. But hey, that's just like my opinion so you can't say I'm wrong. Right?

Exactly! For the record i don't think anything is 'degrading', just like i don't find anything anything to be 'dishonorable'. It just feels like a cheap way for people to find more things in support of their personal preferences and views.

You can argue that having prostitution being legal is bad (whether it's true or not) because it leads to increased amounts of STD's, rape, abuse, depression, sexual promiscuous and unwanted pregnancies all you want but bringing an totally abstract and subjective interpretation of it into the mix dose nothing but stifle the debate.
 
Prostitutes, on the other hand, for all the propagnda about this being a "free choice" and "nothing wrong with it", is the inherently degrading business of selling one's body, or making sexual relations, which should express intimacy and love and caring, into something sold to the highest bidder. This is why most prostitutes want desperately to escape prostitution.

So are you against one-night-stands also, or is that somehow 'different'?
 
There are, I believe, two issues here. First, there is the philosophical issue of whether it is acceptable for the majority to limit the freedom of individuals to do what they please.

I am of the opinion that people should be free to do things that are harmful to themselves, but not to harm others. I believe that it is desirable to prevent people from coercing or bribing other people to harm themselves. Therefore, if it can be shown that prostitution is harmful, we should enact laws that prevent people from offering money to prostitutes to expose themselves to this harm.

The second issue is then empirical. Is prostitution harmful? Here, I think it is clear that some prostitutes are very seriously harmed, both physically, socially, and psychologically. I think it is also clear that not all prostitutes are harmed. The empirical question then is: what percentage of prostitutes are being harmed, and how seriously?

While examining that issue, we must then ask ourselves what level of harm can be considered acceptable. No occupation is perfectly safe. But, I believe, there is definitely a level of danger which is simply not acceptable. We can debate where that line is, but we should be able to agree that it exists. Should it be legal to offer people large sums of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment? I assume few people would think so.

My personal understanding of current research is that prostitution is in fact harmful enough that a ban on offering money is warranted. Therefore I support the Swedish law. However, I am not happy with how it is enforced in practice, as it seems police is still to a large extent targeting the prostitutes themselves. I believe that is a result of a remnant from the old, morality-based sentiments against prostitution, and not a result of the law. I would want prostitutes to see police as being clearly on their side, and I think this requires political directives although the law probably does not need to be changed.
 
Since you apparently failed to see my point I'm going to put it simply: debating whether something is more 'degrading' than something else is just as pointless as arguing that the color blue is just 'worse' than the color green. Now, you can very well argue that the color blue is worse than green when used as jungle camouflage but that's actually tied to an actual measurable claim.

What????!?!?!?
 
And this by the way absolutely demolishes the tendentious distinction between saying that adult prostitutes need to be sex servants to pay the bills and that child sex servants need to be sex servants to pay the bills
A key difference between these two is that for adults it is legal to have sex with an adult passer-by, for children it is not. If you want to make a point about sex between adults, use an example where adults are involved.

What follows from my logic is that we should work towards ways in which people can have better - yes BETTTER and LESS DEGRADING! - forms of employment (...) to prevent people having to do these jobs
So you have a ban-this-from-those attitude.

Firstly, you assume that no customer should have the right to access this service -- making it illegal would make it unavailable (in theory, if not so easily in practice).

Then you assume that no person should have the right to offer this service to others. Not even with a high price tag that would liberate the person wrom a week´s earning obligations in a few hours. In which case the woman might consider this job "better" than most or all other jobs that are realistically available for her. You decide on her behalf what is "better" for her.

Everyone is free to have his own opinions, but I don´t think that this policy has much future, not in nonreligious countries anyway. The future probably brings legalization and tighter state control of this kind of services, so the working and salary conditions in the sector will become harmonized.
 
Last edited:
some prostitutes are very seriously harmed, both physically, socially, and psychologically. I think it is also clear that not all prostitutes are harmed. The empirical question then is: what percentage of prostitutes are being harmed, and how seriously?
Ehh, the empirical question would rather be: what in prostitution is harmful? Then ban what is harmful in it. And that is why pimping is illegal in most countries, for example, because it has been recognized as a harmful factor in the trade, most of the money going to someone else than the worker.
 
Ehh, the empirical question would rather be: what in prostitution is harmful? Then ban what is harmful in it. And that is why pimping is illegal in most countries, for example, because it has been recognized as a harmful factor in the trade, most of the money going to someone else than the worker.
Well, there have been attempts. But I would say that current research indicates that the core of what is harmful is exactly selling your body for strangers to use it for their pleasure. There seems to be some fundamental psychological reasons why this is socially and psychologically harmful.

And it seems pretty hard to ban this without actually banning prostitution. If you have another view, please spell it out rather than theorizing that there 'might' be some other factor. We have to deal with the best theories we have, we cannot simply go for inaction because there 'might' be a better explanation that no one has thought of so far.
 
An implicit assumption that some people seem to make is that clients of prostitutes have more control over the direction of activities than prostitutes do.
 
Well, there have been attempts. But I would say that current research indicates that the core of what is harmful is exactly selling your body for strangers to use it for their pleasure. There seems to be some fundamental psychological reasons why this is socially and psychologically harmful.

<snip>

Got any links to that?
 
I can think of a list of reasons for prostutution to be LEGAL. All the "problems" of prostitution -- crime, disease, exploitation -- would be lessened by a legal structure and social acceptance.
 
My personal understanding of current research is that prostitution is in fact harmful enough that a ban on offering money is warranted. Therefore I support the Swedish law.

But in what way is it harmful? It's just sex. People have sex all the time with ****-buddies or people they drag home from bars and nightclubs. How is it suddenly harmful if money is involved?

However, I am not happy with how it is enforced in practice, as it seems police is still to a large extent targeting the prostitutes themselves. I believe that is a result of a remnant from the old, morality-based sentiments against prostitution, and not a result of the law. I would want prostitutes to see police as being clearly on their side, and I think this requires political directives although the law probably does not need to be changed.

How could the police ever be on the prostitutes' side if they incarcerate their customers? If the police penalized people buying at Ica, would they be on Ica's side?:confused:
 
But in what way is it harmful? It's just sex. People have sex all the time with ****-buddies or people they drag home from bars and nightclubs. How is it suddenly harmful if money is involved?

<snip>

Because the assumption is that prostitutes hate the vast majority of the sex they have with their clients and people who have sex for "free" are only doing it for mutual pleasure.

I think it's a bit more complicated than that...
 
But in what way is it harmful? It's just sex. People have sex all the time with ****-buddies or people they drag home from bars and nightclubs. How is it suddenly harmful if money is involved?
That is certainly something one can speculate about. We can conclude one obvious difference: a prostitute is clearly having sex with a lot of people he or she would not have had sex with if there was no money involved. This means that he or she is frequently having sex with people whom he or she is not sufficiently attracted to to have sex with for his or her own pleasure. It does not seem implausible to me that this may in fact be the cause for observed social and psychological problems.

Moreover, while people are indeed having casual sex with people they meet in nightclubs etc, this clearly does not happen with the same frequency for the same individual as for typical prostitutes encountering new clients.

How could the police ever be on the prostitutes' side if they incarcerate their customers? If the police penalized people buying at Ica, would they be on Ica's side?:confused:
Contrary to what is commonly claimed, prostitution is not illegal in Sweden. Police can indeed try to catch people paying for sex by waiting outside locations believed to be used by prostitutes and attempt to collect evidence. In practice, this does not happen much but there has been cases. I believe they should not do that unless there is a suspicion of trafficking or child prostitution. Rather, I believe they should intervene in such cases only when the prostitute calls on the police for help or there are other signs of immediate danger. It is in any case extremely hard to prove that someone paid for sex without cooperation from the prostitute.
If this was the case, I believe it would indeed be helpful for prostitutes, because they would be offered protection without having to prove for instance that they had been raped or abused, but only that the customer had paid for sex, which is easier to prove. This would have the dual benefit first of deterring people from paying for sex, since the prostitute may turn them in for any reason, and of treating prostitutes better if they still pay for sex, in order to avoid this from happening.
 
Got any links to that?
The status of prostitution research is a huge topic and I really don't have time for that at the moment. Before even engaging in that, I think it is important to reach some understanding on the implications of the research. What, in your opinion, constitutes an acceptable risk? What types of data would you accept to indicate that prostitution is harmful?

For instance, let us say that we make the following study: we interview women at the age of 40 and classify them in three groups: those who have sold sex on at least 50 occasions, those who have never sold sex, and those in between. Let us say that we then look at for how long these women have had their current romantic relationship (eg 0 days for no relationship). If we then find out that women who have sold sex at least 50 times are in much shorter relationships and are more often not in a relationship, would you accept this as indicative that prostitution is harmful? Or would you rather argue that perhaps these women simply don't want longer relationships and are happier with casual sex and staying single?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom