Humes fork
Banned
- Joined
- Jul 9, 2011
- Messages
- 3,358
Yes, I'm sure. Would you be ok with a TV show where contestants are paid a lot of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment?
I'll repeat myself: I believe my freedom ends when I'm hurting other people. And I consider tempting others to hurt themselves, with money, promises of fame, or any other means, is not ok. Sometimes, if the problem is serious and widespread, we should even legislate against such behaviour.
Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution is, well, sex.
It can and does happen, but such prostitution is clearly a small part of all prostitution. It simply does not meet the demand. In fact, despite the rather high price a young woman can ask for having sex with older men, it seems clear that few are willing, making it worthwhile for traffickers to lure Romanian women to Sweden and keep them captive. You can have your romantic fantasy about horny young girls who just love to have sex with random old guys, but it's simply not the common situation in reality.
That it's only young women who sell and old men who buy is your prejudice. As is your idea that only men buy. Here is a story about a woman who sells sex, and here is her blog. The text under the picture also refutes your prejudice that it's only young people who sell.
I don't have anything against porn in principle, but I think it is clearly a very exploitative business in practice. I have an idea that we could institute a law that people taking part in pornography would have a 2 week period of remorse, so that they would have to sign a document 2 weeks after a movie or picture was shot, or it could not be released. This would dissuade pornographers from trying to persuade young women (and men) who they know are likely to regret it, while not being much of an obstacle for those working with people who know what they are doing.
I see. Do you have any evidence that people are tricked into taking part in the way that you are suggesting? One would think that sites like Pornotube, Redtube and so on cast some doubt over that notion.
I have made no such assumption. Like I said, it is my current conclusion from available research that many prostitutes, possibly most, are seriously harmed by these activities. I have never said that all of them are, I do not believe that, it's a strawman. What is your opinion? How many percent do you believe are seriously harmed? What percentage do you find acceptable?
You got any link to that research?
But in any case, here is what I think, let's see if you agree:
1. People who don't want to work with such things should absolutely not have to.
2. If poverty is driving people, then the poverty is the problem
3. And then it will do little good to simply hammer at the symptome (like populist politicians do).
Btw, your link is useless, it clearly states that this organization is not only for prostitutes, but also welcomes people buying sex, and even anyone who just sympathizes with this cause. But again I do not doubt that there are some people who are just selling sex for the thrill of it and who are not harmed by that at all. Heck, this could even be most prostitutes, even though I doubt that. But let us say that 20% are seriously harmed. Is that ok? I don't think so.
See my reasoning above.
You're not acting rationally here, but emotionally. Never did I suggest anything of what you claim. Yes, if there was a study showing that McDonald's employees had serious issues with keeping normal relationships, I'd be very alarmed. It is definitely something that should warrant further inquiries. I would certainly expect that relevant authorities made a very careful examination of the working conditions that appeared to have such consequences. I would certainly not just shrug and assume that everything is fine.
You miss the point. There must be shown to be a cause and effect (and someone expressing that the job is causing the problem), not merely a correlation.

