Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Yes, I'm sure. Would you be ok with a TV show where contestants are paid a lot of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment?

I'll repeat myself: I believe my freedom ends when I'm hurting other people. And I consider tempting others to hurt themselves, with money, promises of fame, or any other means, is not ok. Sometimes, if the problem is serious and widespread, we should even legislate against such behaviour.

Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution is, well, sex.

It can and does happen, but such prostitution is clearly a small part of all prostitution. It simply does not meet the demand. In fact, despite the rather high price a young woman can ask for having sex with older men, it seems clear that few are willing, making it worthwhile for traffickers to lure Romanian women to Sweden and keep them captive. You can have your romantic fantasy about horny young girls who just love to have sex with random old guys, but it's simply not the common situation in reality.

That it's only young women who sell and old men who buy is your prejudice. As is your idea that only men buy. Here is a story about a woman who sells sex, and here is her blog. The text under the picture also refutes your prejudice that it's only young people who sell.

I don't have anything against porn in principle, but I think it is clearly a very exploitative business in practice. I have an idea that we could institute a law that people taking part in pornography would have a 2 week period of remorse, so that they would have to sign a document 2 weeks after a movie or picture was shot, or it could not be released. This would dissuade pornographers from trying to persuade young women (and men) who they know are likely to regret it, while not being much of an obstacle for those working with people who know what they are doing.

I see. Do you have any evidence that people are tricked into taking part in the way that you are suggesting? One would think that sites like Pornotube, Redtube and so on cast some doubt over that notion.

I have made no such assumption. Like I said, it is my current conclusion from available research that many prostitutes, possibly most, are seriously harmed by these activities. I have never said that all of them are, I do not believe that, it's a strawman. What is your opinion? How many percent do you believe are seriously harmed? What percentage do you find acceptable?

You got any link to that research?

But in any case, here is what I think, let's see if you agree:

1. People who don't want to work with such things should absolutely not have to.

2. If poverty is driving people, then the poverty is the problem

3. And then it will do little good to simply hammer at the symptome (like populist politicians do).

Btw, your link is useless, it clearly states that this organization is not only for prostitutes, but also welcomes people buying sex, and even anyone who just sympathizes with this cause. But again I do not doubt that there are some people who are just selling sex for the thrill of it and who are not harmed by that at all. Heck, this could even be most prostitutes, even though I doubt that. But let us say that 20% are seriously harmed. Is that ok? I don't think so.

See my reasoning above.

You're not acting rationally here, but emotionally. Never did I suggest anything of what you claim. Yes, if there was a study showing that McDonald's employees had serious issues with keeping normal relationships, I'd be very alarmed. It is definitely something that should warrant further inquiries. I would certainly expect that relevant authorities made a very careful examination of the working conditions that appeared to have such consequences. I would certainly not just shrug and assume that everything is fine.

You miss the point. There must be shown to be a cause and effect (and someone expressing that the job is causing the problem), not merely a correlation.
 
Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution is, well, sex.

So is rape. But most of us tend to think there is more to it than that.

Would you say that rape is merely another kind of assault? In fact, in some cases there may not be any violence involved in rape and yet who says, it's just sex? Curious, isn't it?
 
So is rape. But most of us tend to think there is more to it than that.

Would you say that rape is merely another kind of assault? In fact, in some cases there may not be any violence involved in rape and yet who says, it's just sex? Curious, isn't it?

:boggled:

You've never knowingly talked with or had sex with a current or former prostitute, have you?

The prostitute sets the boundaries. Clients who push against the boundaries are being rude and those that cross them are committing assault or rape and should be prosecuted.

Unfortunately people seem to think prostitutes are 'asking for it' and/or are substantially different to other human beings.

What shocked me was how normal they are.
 
:boggled:

You've never knowingly talked with or had sex with a current or former prostitute, have you?

The prostitute sets the boundaries. Clients who push against the boundaries are being rude and those that cross them are committing assault or rape and should be prosecuted.

:hb:

I'm not saying prostitution = rape, I am pointing out that it is a well-established idea that prostitution is no more "just sex" than rape is "just sex".

Unfortunately people seem to think prostitutes are 'asking for it' and/or are substantially different to other human beings.

What shocked me was how normal they are.

You mean that you saw them as substantially different to other human beings and that's why you were shocked by how normal they are. I absolutely don't see them as substantially different so please don't project your own views on to me.

Thank you.
 
What if someone wanted to make a TV show where contestants are paid a lot of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment? Do you think it would be reasonable to ban that?
Yes.

I think it is reasonable to recognize what exactly harms people, and ban that exactly.

Next you say, let us ban prostitution then, because it harms some people.

I agree to follow this logic, as soon as you agree to ban also cars and motorbikes, because they kill numerous people every year. And handguns and iron mines and parachutes and aeroplanes and cigarettes and alcohol and whatnot.
 
:hb:

I'm not saying prostitution = rape, I am pointing out that it is a well-established idea that prostitution is no more "just sex" than rape is "just sex".

If I've parsed that correctly, I think I mostly agree. For some it's just sex, for others it's as diverse as any other human relationship. Why did you choose to use rape as an analogy rather than, say, a hiring plumber or going to see a counsellor or therapist?

You mean that you saw them as substantially different to other human beings and that's why you were shocked by how normal they are. I absolutely don't see them as substantially different so please don't project your own views on to me.

Thank you.

Okay. So if we agree prostitutes are by and large as normal as you or I and have simply chosen to earn their living by selling their time and particular sexual services (which they are in control of), where is the harm?

As others have said, it isn't having consensual sex for money which is particularly dangerous or exploitative, it's the environment people who want to sell sexual services are forced to work in by the law and how sex workers are viewed by society that causes many of the problems.
 
Russian roulette can kill you. Prostitution is, well, sex.
What if they are offered a million dollars and they think it's worth the risk? Please answer my question: should we ban it?

That it's only young women who sell and old men who buy is your prejudice. As is your idea that only men buy.
If you read my posts in this thread, heck, even just the bits you've quoted yourself, you'll see that I've made it very clear that both men and women sell sex. Just because make an example about the most common scenario doesn't mean you get to invent some kind of strawman that I would think it is always exactly like that.

I see. Do you have any evidence that people are tricked into taking part in the way that you are suggesting?
Yes, there is plenty of evidence from interviews with current and former porn models. I have no idea if this is true for one percent, five percent, fifty percent or ninety percent of porn models. I don't believe doing porn is necessarily damaging. But there seems to be an obvious problem with people being lured into the industry, and if we can do something about that without causing any significant problems for anyone else, why not? I'm not saying my proposal should be law tomorrow, surely it needs to be examined and we should hear the opinions of experts etc. But I think your readiness to just dismiss it out of hands speak volumes about your attitude towards the well being of others.
One would think that sites like Pornotube, Redtube and so on cast some doubt over that notion.
Could you explain your logic behind that thinking? I do not see any connection here. No one claimed that everyone who does porn has been tricked into it.

1. People who don't want to work with such things should absolutely not have to.

2. If poverty is driving people, then the poverty is the problem

3. And then it will do little good to simply hammer at the symptome (like populist politicians do).
You seem to have this black/white world view where there is only one problem and one must never do anything that does not directly strike at the 'root cause'. Certainly when it comes to trafficking, poverty would be most of the problem. But that does not mean we could not do anything else. If a cancer patient has chronic pain, should we then refrain from giving her pain killers, because it does not address 'the problem', but only symptoms?

I say, if it works, it works. Reducing poverty in Romania would be great to help women from ending up as sex slaves in Sweden, and I'm all for doing that. But it's not exactly easy and it's going to take a while. In the mean time, I think we should do what we can to reduce sex slavery also by taking action here in Sweden, not just in Romania.

Also, while poverty is certainly a major contributing factor, I do not believe it is the only factor. For instance, there definitely seems to be many women with a self-injuring behaviour (eg cutting themselves with razors etc) who also end up in prostitution in a way that is obviously not healthy.

You miss the point. There must be shown to be a cause and effect (and someone expressing that the job is causing the problem), not merely a correlation.
But correlation is a clear indication that there is something we need to look at, don't you agree? If we're in 1940 and someone publishes a study showing that smokers often get lung cancer, would you just say that 'correlation does not prove causation!!!' and then refuse to agree that it might be prudent to provisionally conclude that smoking may in fact be very dangerous?

I know you're asking for 'evidence', but I'm not willing to go there at least until we've first agreed on what kind of evidence would be convincing, and what level of harmfulness you find acceptable.
 
I agree to follow this logic, as soon as you agree to ban also cars and motorbikes, because they kill numerous people every year. And handguns and iron mines and parachutes and aeroplanes and cigarettes and alcohol and whatnot.
That would depend on the level of danger. So you agree that Russian roulette - eg a 1/6 chance of near-certain death - is dangerous enough to ban. I would agree that motorbikes, while being quite dangerous, are not so dangerous that it should be illegal to pay someone to ride a motorbike. It is my informed belief that prostitution is much more dangerous than riding a motorbike. Probably closer to Russian roulette if you include direct fatalities, increased risk of STDs, increased suicide risk, extended psychiatric hospitalization, increased risk of substance abuse, severely reduced ability to live in a relationship, etc.

Parachuting is dangerous, and there are some sports, like base jumping, that are extremely dangerous. If it was common for people to pay others to perform base jumping, I think investigating a ban on that would be in order. Not base jumping itself, but paying others to do it. Fortunately, we do not have that problem.
 
<snip>

It is my informed belief that prostitution is much more dangerous than riding a motorbike. Probably closer to Russian roulette if you include direct fatalities, increased risk of STDs, increased suicide risk, extended psychiatric hospitalization, increased risk of substance abuse, severely reduced ability to live in a relationship, etc.

<snip>

What proportion of those harms is caused by having protected consensual sex for money and what proportion is attributable to other factors, such as prior and current drug use, laws which push prostitution underground and a society which looks down on people who sell sexual services?

Is it not possible to be a bit more nuanced addressing the problems associated with prostitution rather than, say, making paying for sex illegal?

Do you believe everyone who pays for sex should be treated as a criminal?
 
What proportion of those harms is caused by having protected consensual sex for money and what proportion is attributable to other factors, such as prior and current drug use, laws which push prostitution underground and a society which looks down on people who sell sexual services?
I don't know exactly but I think there is good evidence that prostitution itself is very dangerous. When it comes to the opinions in society, well, that's not an excuse for a sex buyer. The opinions are what they are. If you do something that makes people look down on a person, then you are responsible for that, even if the general attitudes are wrong. Like I compared earlier, outing a homosexual in Uganda is wrong, even though there is nothing wrong with homosexuality.

Is it not possible to be a bit more nuanced addressing the problems associated with prostitution rather than, say, making paying for sex illegal?
I believe that it is in fact a nuanced and pragmatic move. I'm willing to change my mind if someone can show that there would be forms of prostitution that are not typically harmful, but so far the evidence I have seen does not support that.

Do you believe everyone who pays for sex should be treated as a criminal?
Yes, in the sense that I believe it should be a crime. But of course if the current law in your country says it is not a crime, then sex buyers in that country should not be 'treated' as criminals. I would still strongly disapprove of buying sex in those countries, however.
 
I'm willing to change my mind if someone can show that there would be forms of prostitution that are not typically harmful
Simple. Recognize a harmful detail. Ban it.

For example, if being publicly known as a prostitute is socially harmful, the solution would be working anonymously, with a cat mask on face, so nobody knows who they are dealing with. Problem removed.

If diseases are the problem, use appropriate protection. Problem solved.
 
I don't know exactly but I think there is good evidence that prostitution itself is very dangerous.

Then please post a link to that evidence. I predict the vast majority of the harm from prostitution comes from drug addiction, organised crime, pimps and violent clients, all of which could be tackled by means other than turning the buyers and/or sellers of sexual services into criminals.

When it comes to the opinions in society, well, that's not an excuse for a sex buyer. The opinions are what they are. If you do something that makes people look down on a person, then you are responsible for that, even if the general attitudes are wrong. Like I compared earlier, outing a homosexual in Uganda is wrong, even though there is nothing wrong with homosexuality.

That's really screwed up thinking and a terrible analogy. Clients of prostitutes are *not* 'outing' the people they pay to have sex with.

I believe that it is in fact a nuanced and pragmatic move. I'm willing to change my mind if someone can show that there would be forms of prostitution that are not typically harmful, but so far the evidence I have seen does not support that.

It's not nuanced at all. It's turning large numbers of ordinary people into criminals.

Yes, in the sense that I believe it should be a crime. But of course if the current law in your country says it is not a crime, then sex buyers in that country should not be 'treated' as criminals. I would still strongly disapprove of buying sex in those countries, however.

So what was a man such as myself to do?

I'm not very attractive, I have a boring/repulsive personality and a speech impediment. I have very few friends none of which want to socialise with me and of the women I do know, none want a short or long term relationship with me. I tried online dating with numerous profiles for over 4 years with no success. I was a virgin until the age of 32 until I had sex with an independent escort who was advertising online. She was a nice person.

Was/Am I supposed to suppress all desires I have for physical intimacy for the rest of my life even though there are women who are willing to have sex with me for payment?
 
I predict the vast majority of the harm from prostitution comes from drug addiction, organised crime, pimps and violent clients, all of which could be tackled by means other than turning the buyers and/or sellers of sexual services into criminals.
I disagree. I think there is plenty of evidence that there are psychological effects probably resulting from the very act of selling one's body for money. People usually have fairly strong feelings about their own bodies, don't you agree? Anyway I do not pretend to understand these mechanisms or to be able to fully theorize why things happen the way they do. But this seems to be the conclusion of many psychologists who treat former prostitutes and I'm inclined to take their word for it.

That's really screwed up thinking and a terrible analogy. Clients of prostitutes are *not* 'outing' the people they pay to have sex with.
You misunderstand the analogy. My claim is that if A does something to B, which causes B to be harmed by C, then A still does something wrong. If A outs B, and this causes C to kill B, then A did something wrong if A knew that this was likely to happen. If A pays B for sex, and B is therefore looked down upon by society and feels miserable because of that, then A does something wrong, if A knows that this is likely to happen. A can not escape blame because of C.

It's not nuanced at all. It's turning large numbers of ordinary people into criminals.
That is a non-argument. Studies have shown that 25% of South African men report themselves to be rapists. So in South Africa, banning rape (which is of course illegal) turns large numbers of ordinary people into criminals. So what? Either it is wrong and harmful, or it is not. If it is harmful, then it is no excuse that it is common.

So what was a man such as myself to do?

I'm not very attractive, I have a boring/repulsive personality and a speech impediment. I have very few friends none of which want to socialise with me and of the women I do know, none want a short or long term relationship with me. I tried online dating with numerous profiles for over 4 years with no success. I was a virgin until the age of 32 until I had sex with an independent escort who was advertising online. She was a nice person.

Was/Am I supposed to suppress all desires I have for physical intimacy for the rest of my life even though there are women who are willing to have sex with me for payment?
I'm sure you can find someone better suited to give you advise, but I'll try. First, you should not give up so easily. You need to realize that since you are inexperienced with relations, you simply have to practice. Just talking to people on the internet is a good start. Don't expect anyone to want to have sex with you or even meet you right away. Second, you have to realize that if you are not all that attractive yourself, you simply have to relax your standards when it comes to women as well. Now I would assume that there are women that you simply find repulsive and that you would never want to be with, but you should also be able to find women who are not very attractive by common standards, but who you can still see 'something' in. If you're dating online, you need to be honest. If you make yourself look better than you are, you will always be refused when the woman finds out what you really are like. Make it quite clear in your profile that you are not perfect and that you don't expect a perfect woman. Clearly, you have good sides that you don't have to lie about. Tell women what you think is truly important, so that women who are in a similar position as yourself will feel that you might be a good match for them.

But in the end, it's not ok to harm others just because it makes you feel a bit better. I must stress that I don't think you are a terrible person. I can understand why you behave like you do. But it is not a good solution either for you or for them.
 
Merko,

You really don't understand me, people like me, or people who engage in prostitution. For the latter I suggest you start here.
 
You really don't understand me, people like me, or people who engage in prostitution. For the latter I suggest you start here.
I listened to it, and I don't have a diametrically different view than the researcher. I did notice though that the interviewer repeatedly tried to put words into her mouth that she clearly did not want to own. Mainly, he kept talking about benefits of prostitution, while she was talking about harm reduction. If you talk about harm reduction, then you're basically on the same page as me. Prostitution is harmful, we can't wish it away, so we need to find ways to make it less harmful. If you start talking about benefits, then we should not even try to reduce prostitution since hey, it's beneficial!
 
I listened to it, and I don't have a diametrically different view than the researcher. I did notice though that the interviewer repeatedly tried to put words into her mouth that she clearly did not want to own. Mainly, he kept talking about benefits of prostitution, while she was talking about harm reduction. If you talk about harm reduction, then you're basically on the same page as me. Prostitution is harmful, we can't wish it away, so we need to find ways to make it less harmful. If you start talking about benefits, then we should not even try to reduce prostitution since hey, it's beneficial!

You didn't listen at all. The researcher talked about the ways criminalizing clients and/or sex workers increases harm. But your brain filtered those points out because it didn't agree with what your prior beliefs about clients (nasty, selfish people) or sex workers (victims). She also mentioned the misrepresented statistics for people being trafficked for sex work, those put out by governments pandering to the tabloid/right-wing press and research done by rescue organisations with a vested interest in making people such as yourself believe prostitute = victim.
 
"I don't understand why prostitution is illegal. Selling is legal, *********** is legal. So, why isn't it legal to sell ***********?"

George Carlin
 
Over the last few years we have had several cases where polish people were brought into Denmark, worked for peanuts and lived under horrible conditions.

Somehow that have not lead to a ban of the professions carpenter and mason? :rolleyes:

Why should similar problems with prostitutes be easier to solve by banning the profession?
How about making it a honest trade instead?
 
My aunt has Parkinson's dementia. We've recently had to move her into a nursing home which specialises in care for elderly people with dementia and other mental illnesses.

If I had to choose between spending 2-3 days working there or sucking a guy's condom-covered cock until he climaxed, I'd be on my knees in a second.
 
Last edited:
You didn't listen at all. The researcher talked about the ways criminalizing clients and/or sex workers increases harm. But your brain filtered those points out because it didn't agree with what your prior beliefs about clients (nasty, selfish people) or sex workers (victims). She also mentioned the misrepresented statistics for people being trafficked for sex work, those put out by governments pandering to the tabloid/right-wing press and research done by rescue organisations with a vested interest in making people such as yourself believe prostitute = victim.

I wondered if indeed I had not been listening, so I listened again. But in fact the researcher does not talk at all about criminalizing clients. It's not ever mentioned or even alluded to. Of course I do not believe in criminalizing sex workers and I have made that quite clear in this thread so I completely agree with her there. And I have also previously made it clear in this thread that I believe the law against buying sex must be used carefully so that it does not cause problems for the prostitutes.

As for trafficking, again did she say anything that goes contrary to anything I have claimed in this thread? She does not mention any numbers for trafficking and neither have I in this thread. People are being convicted for trafficking and also when looking at convictions of pimps, there are sometimes very clear signs of trafficking (such as very many clients per day) even though the evidence was not enough to convict for trafficking. So clearly trafficking is a very serious problem, even if it has no doubt been exaggerated. But I mean, murder is also exaggerated, that does not mean murder is not a problem.

I would note two things though. First, she claims that her research is on sex buyers, not on sex sellers. So when she is talking about the sellers, while she is no doubt an expert in her field, I'm not really sure she is a real authority. For instance, she creates a binary distinction (2:20) between prostitutes working in the street, and consenting sex workers working for themselves. This is clearly a false dichotomy and quite a serious error.

As far as that distinction goes, however, it seems to support the Swedish law, because the most clear effect of the law has been to reduce street prostitution.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom