Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Oh, nonsense.

We already know the drill, in advance, by which the normalization of prostitution will lead to the normalizatrion of child prostitution.

Here is one -- of many -- ways it will happen.

1). Who defines a child? 16? 14? 12? The age of consent in traditional societies can be as low as 9. Aren't you being far too judgmental and biased in declaring a ten-year-old is a "child" when other, perfectly equal, societies declare she is an "adult"?

2). Child prostitutes who are from traditional societies and caught at, say, age 14 will make (or rather, their pimps will make) a "you're a raaaaaaacist" hue and cry about that.

3). The spineless "nonjudgmental" folks will instantly capitulate, demand the social workers excercise "sensitivity to social background factors" when reporting child prostitution to authorities, or in other words, allowing Muslim / Hidu / non-western in general pimps to corner the market on the nine-year-old market.

4). Once that is done, all kinds of "non-judgmental" studies will declare that, really, honesty, "there is no evidence" child prostitution really hurts kids that much, and we must not be "judgmental" about it: if adult prostitution is OK, just how wrong can child prostitution be? And besides isn't it totally unfair that a girl, just because she is white, and thus comes from a sexually repressive society which for some reason sees "child" as "16" or "18", instead of 9 or 12, be denied the wonderful field of prostitution now available to her Muslim or Hindu friends?

5). Voila! Child prostitution is the new normal.

Many of these -- (3) and (4) for instance -- are already happening.

Thanks for the heads up on "Our Culture - What's left of it". It seems that some of that (about the guy smashing his two-year-old child's head against the door) I have already read in a collection of his essays called "Not With A Bang".

I also have been through the whole, "Ah! But that's a different culture" thing with someone here.

If you're interested to read our argument it appears in the comments box but the comments are displayed in a very weird way with the first comment last and you have to go to the last page to read the first comment:

http://christopherhitchenswatch.blogspot.com/2009/10/shorter-hitch-polanski-was-bad-but.html
 
Why are drugs illegal?

Its illegal because the majority of the population make moral mistakes themselves on which they have little control at the time, and feeling that forceful enforcement would do them moral good, they legitimize controlling the behavior of others.

I doubt many care for the women who choose this profession, given their commitment to an illegal trade, its obviously taken as a last resort.

People probably think that is bad morals for men, who should try harder at finding someone accepting, or are probably betraying a loved one, breaking families etc.
 
I don't think there's any good reason for it to be illegal, but I do think there are some good reasons for it to be regulated. These include increasing the safety for both prostitutes and clients and hopefully removing it from being a source of income for organised crime and pimps.

Personally I think something along the lines of New Zealand's small owner-operated brothels are the way to go.
 
Of course, the easy solution is:

People, keep your desires in your pants and your skirts.

I'm being polite here. :rolleyes:
 
The squemishness, seems to me, lies on the other side: the side of those who are terrified of saying anything is wrong, lest they be dumped on as "judgmental" and "prejudiced". This is precisely the "rush from judgment" that Dalrymple is talking about from much experience.

I asked for a reason why you think it is wrong. Care to tell me now? No ridiculous slippery slope arguments, no 12 year olds, just give me a reason for why you think it should be illegal between consenting adults (that's what we are discussing, not whatever you'd like to twist it into attempting to win rhetorical scores).

It's not a fallacy if the slope is, in fact slippery. Right now social workers are "nonjudmentally" distributing condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes in Britain. If prostitution is legalized and no longer stigmatized, whatever twinge of morality they have left in thinking it might be wrong to encourage girls to go into prostitution will be eradicated.

But who says 12 year olds should work as prostitutes?

In Sweden (I assume there are similar laws in the UK) nobody is allowed to work below the age of 13, or to work at nighttime below the age of 18. Likewise, unemployed people are not sent to join our troops in Afghanistan.

There could be similar restrictions around prostitution.

Perhaps not. But it will, quite certainly, lead to the re-established of de facto female slavery (a.k.a. "polygamy"). Indeed there are already groups calling for the legalization of such unions as the next step in "sexual liberation" ("liberation" as in, "I won't divorce you, you old hag; I'll just spend all my time with the younger trophy wife while you do the dishes and take care of the children".)

What a big red herring.

"Quite certainly" is a give-away that you simply don't like the idea, and therefore don't want it to exist. If people make such choices, you want to punish them.

And what do you have against polyamorists? Such unions are not illegal anyways, they are just not legally recognized. There is nothing ti my knowledge that prevents a group of lovers to move into an apartment together.

And, as for pedophilia remaining illegal... don't bet on it.

Pedophilia in itself isn't illegal, but to have sexual engagement with person below the legal age (which differs from country to country) is illegal. And it is likely to remain so.

angrysoba said:
We're not simply talking about sex though, are we? We're talking about prostitution. You shouldn't conflate sex with prostitution because you are not asking what good reason there is for sex being illegal but what good reason there is for prostitution being illegal.

What I said was that I understood the rationale, but I disagree with it. So no, I don't think drugs should be illegal. Will you now please give me a good reason for why prostitution should be illegal?
 
...and hopefully humorous.

Of course. :)

I don't see why something that is legal in most countries between two or more consenting, mature adults should suddenly become illegal when it's turning into a buyer-seller scenario.

The trick is to make sure the parties involved are informed, mature and consenting. :rolleyes:
 
The squemishness, seems to me, lies on the other side: the side of those who are terrified of saying anything is wrong, lest they be dumped on as "judgmental" and "prejudiced".

You however have failed to answer the initial question, other than "it's wrong because it will lead to child prostitution, which is wrong"

This is precisely the "rush from judgment" that Dalrymple is talking about from much experience.

I had to google Mr Dalrymple, and the results were ... enlightening. For example, from a NZ interview ...

He advocates marriage incentives such as a tax-free allowance of "say $20,000 a year" for married couples living together, but only $5000 a year for people living singly. He thinks divorce should be allowed only for violence, infidelity or "failure to keep one's responsibilities".
...
He said people would still be free to form relationships outside marriage - they would just be discouraged.

A critique here.

Your reply amounts to, "if you disagree wth me I'll call you bad names, so shut up". Ah well.

And your reply amounts to a one person anecdote.

It's not a fallacy if the slope is, in fact slippery. Right now social workers are "nonjudmentally" distributing condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes in Britain.

Any evidence apart from Dalrymple to support the idea this is policy? Has this happened in the many other countries where prostitution is legal?

If prostitution is legalized and no longer stigmatized, whatever twinge of morality they have left in thinking it might be wrong to encourage girls to go into prostitution will be eradicated.

"and no longer stigmatized" is a rather significant qualifier don't you think?

Perhaps not. But it will, quite certainly, lead to the re-established of de facto female slavery (a.k.a. "polygamy"). Indeed there are already groups calling for the legalization of such unions as the next step in "sexual liberation" ("liberation" as in, "I won't divorce you, you old hag; I'll just spend all my time with the younger trophy wife while you do the dishes and take care of the children".)

Say what? Gay marriage will lead to the "re-establish(ment) of de facto female slavery"?
Or prostitution?
And that has happened in how many countries where gay marriage and/or prostitution is legal? :confused:

And, as for pedophilia remaining illegal... don't bet on it.

Your source nowhere indicates support for legalisation of pedophilia, indeed the exact opposite - "Berlin also disputed Reisman’s contention that he wants to decriminalize pedophilia"

So I suppose you believe that since there are people who believe the root causes of the London riots need to be discovered and acted upon means that rioting and looting is at risk of being decriminilized? :confused:
 
It's not a fallacy if the slope is, in fact slippery. Right now social workers are "nonjudmentally" distributing condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes in Britain. If prostitution is legalized and no longer stigmatized, whatever twinge of morality they have left in thinking it might be wrong to encourage girls to go into prostitution will be eradicated.
So, distributing condoms encourages sex?

Perhaps not. But it will, quite certainly, lead to the re-established of de facto female slavery (a.k.a. "polygamy"). Indeed there are already groups calling for the legalization of such unions as the next step in "sexual liberation" ("liberation" as in, "I won't divorce you, you old hag; I'll just spend all my time with the younger trophy wife while you do the dishes and take care of the children".)
Well, I assume that divorce will still be legal.

And, as for pedophilia remaining illegal... don't bet on it.

Are you serious??
 
And of course, if prostitution shouldn't be legal, neither should porn, where people are paid for sex. Another double standard in the U.S., like pot being illegal.
 
And of course, if prostitution shouldn't be legal, neither should porn, where people are paid for sex. Another double standard in the U.S., like pot being illegal.

I always wondered about that. Couldn't you just get the prostitute and client to pay the relevant actors union fees, setup a camera, and you're good to (legally) go? Client even gets a souvenir.

Should cut down on the cheating politicians too :)
 
Perhaps not. But it will, quite certainly, lead to the re-established of de facto female slavery (a.k.a. "polygamy"). Indeed there are already groups calling for the legalization of such unions as the next step in "sexual liberation" ("liberation" as in, "I won't divorce you, you old hag; I'll just spend all my time with the younger trophy wife while you do the dishes and take care of the children".)

Good grief, you must be stuck somewhere in the fifties of last century. :jaw-dropp

Who are those groups and why do you think we would give in to their demands so easily?

 
Back to the basics: Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Yes, but most of them are indirect reasons, there is a solution for them other than banning prostitution. For example, the problem of a pimp taking all the money and keeping his hookers in debt slavery would be solved by applying minimum wage laws etc. in the sector. Give any other problem, it has solutions other than banning prostitution.
 
I always wondered about that. Couldn't you just get the prostitute and client to pay the relevant actors union fees, setup a camera, and you're good to (legally) go? Client even gets a souvenir.

Should cut down on the cheating politicians too :)

Yeah, there's a thread on that here somewhere. It truly seems absurd to me, that it's illegal for two adults to exchange money for sex in private, but it's legal (in some states at least), to pay 20 people to have raunchy sex with each other--as long as you film it and sell it. :confused:
 
I don't see why something that is legal in most countries between two or more consenting, mature adults should suddenly become illegal when it's turning into a buyer-seller scenario.
Legislators focus on everything where money moves, because that is where serious and organized big business happens. Having your neighbour do volunteer work for you is legal, but hiring him for a sum smaller than the minimum wage is illegal. Seems paradoxal, but volunteer work hardly ever destroys any person. Sub poverty line salaries would destroy the standard of living of entire segments of the population. Therefore allowing sub poverty line salaries is harmful for the society, but allowing volunteer work is not.
 
Last edited:
Back to the basics: Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Yes, but most of them are indirect reasons, there is a solution for them other than banning prostitution. For example, the problem of a pimp taking all the money and keeping his hookers in debt slavery would be solved by applying minimum wage laws etc. in the sector.

But isn't that more a result of prostitution being illegal, rather than an indirect reason for it being illegal?

Or both?

As I see it many of the "problems" of prostitution are not problems of prostitution at all, but manifestations of other problems, such as poverty, drug addiction, and child abuse.

If you took away all the prostitutes who were in the business because of those reasons, would there still be prostitutes? I'm guessing there would be, but "exploitation" wouldn't be occurring.
 
Legislators focus on everything where money moves, because that is where serious and organized big business happens. Having your neighbour do volunteer work for you is legal, but hiring him for a sum smaller than the minimum wage is illegal. Seems paradoxal, but volunteer work hardly ever destroys any person. Sub poverty line salaries would destroy the standard of living of entire segments of the population. Therefore allowing sub poverty line salaries is harmful for the society, but allowing volunteer work is not.

I was talking about the moral aspect of prostitution, which seems to be the main reason why it is illegal in many countries.

And in Germany there is no general minimum wage. Sad, but true.
 
So, distributing condoms encourages sex?

The social workers distribute condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes instead of doing their actual job of stopping them from being child prostitutes.

Besides, yes, distribution condoms encourages sex, much like distributing free ammunition would probably encourage shooting, statistically speaking.

Well, I assume that divorce will still be legal.

Divorce is also legal in most countries that accept polygamy, but it doesn't take much to note in most of them women's status leaves much to be desired.

Are you serious??

Sadly, those who suggest de-criminalizing pedophilia probably are.
 
Who are those groups and why do you think we would give in to their demands so easily?

In the USA, Mormors and Muslims; in Europe, mostly Muslims.

As for why I think people will give in, the intelligentia would for certain, dreading nothing more than opposing something some minority group wants. And it sets the tone of the public discussion, alas.
 
Besides, yes, distribution condoms encourages sex, much like distributing free ammunition would probably encourage shooting, statistically speaking.

You can't fire a gun without ammunition. It's easier (and preferable for most people) to have sex without a condom. Condoms are not aphrodisiacs--quite the opposite.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom