Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

So are you against one-night-stands also, or is that somehow 'different'?

Yes, I am against one-night stands. They are bad for you. They tend -- with exceptions -- to be something you are sorry about later precisely because they are not due to any intimacy or knowledge of the other person.

This doesn't mean I think anybody who ever had a one-night stand is a prostitute, or everybody who ever got drunk is an alcoholic. But I would certainly say that someone who, every night, has sex with five different guys in a different bar, is a prostitute in all but name - just like someone who gets drunk every night is a drunk.
 
Most of the women working in red light districts are foreigners (Locals tend to be drug addicts, btw) and the majority have been brought in by pimps. The most profitable prostitute is young and easily talked into taking a job as a nanny. Once she's been taken from her home, she is abused, her papers taken away and she is set up to work. Threats of violence to herself or children left behind in her home country keep her from seeking help.

Strange, isn't it? I thought is was supposed to be a job like any other which is just a case of mutual benefit! Why won't local women do it, then? With all that easy money?
 
But what if he or she thinks the money makes it worthwhile? There are a lot of things that people can find worthwhile if they get money from it.
Yes, I'm sure. Would you be ok with a TV show where contestants are paid a lot of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment?

I'll repeat myself: I believe my freedom ends when I'm hurting other people. And I consider tempting others to hurt themselves, with money, promises of fame, or any other means, is not ok. Sometimes, if the problem is serious and widespread, we should even legislate against such behaviour.

And who says someone selling sex has to be working as a prostitute? It can be something that someone does from time to time besides his or her usual job, to get some quick money.
It can and does happen, but such prostitution is clearly a small part of all prostitution. It simply does not meet the demand. In fact, despite the rather high price a young woman can ask for having sex with older men, it seems clear that few are willing, making it worthwhile for traffickers to lure Romanian women to Sweden and keep them captive. You can have your romantic fantasy about horny young girls who just love to have sex with random old guys, but it's simply not the common situation in reality.

How do you view porn? Is sex for money suddenly okay when it is filmed? Or you are part of the ~50% of our Calvinistic population that wants porn prohibitted?
I don't have anything against porn in principle, but I think it is clearly a very exploitative business in practice. I have an idea that we could institute a law that people taking part in pornography would have a 2 week period of remorse, so that they would have to sign a document 2 weeks after a movie or picture was shot, or it could not be released. This would dissuade pornographers from trying to persuade young women (and men) who they know are likely to regret it, while not being much of an obstacle for those working with people who know what they are doing.

You don't answer the question, you simply assume that prostitutes are victimized by their customers. I don't share that assumption. And neither do those voluntary involved.
I have made no such assumption. Like I said, it is my current conclusion from available research that many prostitutes, possibly most, are seriously harmed by these activities. I have never said that all of them are, I do not believe that, it's a strawman. What is your opinion? How many percent do you believe are seriously harmed? What percentage do you find acceptable?

Btw, your link is useless, it clearly states that this organization is not only for prostitutes, but also welcomes people buying sex, and even anyone who just sympathizes with this cause. But again I do not doubt that there are some people who are just selling sex for the thrill of it and who are not harmed by that at all. Heck, this could even be most prostitutes, even though I doubt that. But let us say that 20% are seriously harmed. Is that ok? I don't think so.

What a piece of moralistic crap. SO WHAT? Is it a sake for the authorities to legislate in a way that people will stay in long romantic relationships?

If it could be shown that people who work at McDonalds tend not to be involved in long-term romantic relationships, would you then ban McDonalds?
You're not acting rationally here, but emotionally. Never did I suggest anything of what you claim. Yes, if there was a study showing that McDonald's employees had serious issues with keeping normal relationships, I'd be very alarmed. It is definitely something that should warrant further inquiries. I would certainly expect that relevant authorities made a very careful examination of the working conditions that appeared to have such consequences. I would certainly not just shrug and assume that everything is fine.
 
My view is that this job is not harmful or unwanted for everyone who works in it, at least if the price is high enough. Therefore it is not reasonable to ban it from everyone.
What if someone wanted to make a TV show where contestants are paid a lot of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment? Do you think it would be reasonable to ban that?
 
What if someone wanted to make a TV show where contestants are paid a lot of money to play Russian roulette for our entertainment? Do you think it would be reasonable to ban that?

Celebrity Russian Roulette?
 
What????!?!?!?

Maybe it's because I'm tired and not articulate enough but what is it that don't get?

I'll repeat myself: I believe my freedom ends when I'm hurting other people. And I consider tempting others to hurt themselves, with money, promises of fame, or any other means, is not ok. Sometimes, if the problem is serious and widespread, we should even legislate against such behaviour.

It's funny how you frame it that way. Apparently when an escort puts up an ad on a website specifically trying to find willing customers to pay them for sex it's the customer who was 'tempting' them? Am i getting this right?

Yes, I am against one-night stands. They are bad for you. They tend -- with exceptions -- to be something you are sorry about later precisely because they are not due to any intimacy or knowledge of the other person.

Strange because this has not been my experience. Do you have any statistical evidence for this assertion of yours or are you, as always, making **** up?

This doesn't mean I think anybody who ever had a one-night stand is a prostitute, or everybody who ever got drunk is an alcoholic. But I would certainly say that someone who, every night, has sex with five different guys in a different bar, is a prostitute in all but name - just like someone who gets drunk every night is a drunk.

:boggled:
 
It's funny how you frame it that way. Apparently when an escort puts up an ad on a website specifically trying to find willing customers to pay them for sex it's the customer who was 'tempting' them? Am i getting this right?
If you don't believe that money tempts prostitutes to prostitute themselves, then how about this. Let's agree to have a law that says it's legal to have sex with prostitutes, as long as you don't pay them any money.
 
If you don't believe that money tempts prostitutes to prostitute themselves, then how about this. Let's agree to have a law that says it's legal to have sex with prostitutes, as long as you don't pay them any money.

It's already legal to have sex with prostitutes and not pay them any money. :confused:
 
Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?




No. OTOH, there is no good reason for letting pimps live (I don't hate the game, I hate those particular players.)
 
However, a comparison between the number of sex workers in Christchurch in 1999, before decriminalisation, and 2006 - after the act was passed - showed the total had stayed about the same.

A 2007 estimate in five centres - Auckland, Wellington, Christchurch, Hawkes Bay and Nelson - found a total of 2332 sex workers, the committee said.

Numbers of sex workers should continue to be monitored, it said.

Around 93 per cent of sex workers cited money as the reason for getting into and staying in the sex industry.


"The most significant barriers to exiting are loss of income, reluctance to lose the flexible working hours available in the sex industry and the camaraderie and sense of belonging that some sex workers describe."

The committee said a Christchurch School of Medicine survey found that more than 90 per cent felt they had legal rights under the act.

More than 60 per cent felt they were more able to refuse to provide commercial sexual services to a particular client since the enactment of the law.

Before the act, the illicit status of the industry meant workers were open to coercion and exploitation by managers, pimps and clients. Research indicated there had been "some improvement" in employment conditions "but this is by no means universal".

Linky.

I find it very funny that people aren't backing up their statements when many studies have been done on the sex worker population. Yes, there are coercive and abusive situations, but how does the legality or illegality effect that?
 
Linky.

I find it very funny that people aren't backing up their statements when many studies have been done on the sex worker population. Yes, there are coercive and abusive situations, but how does the legality or illegality effect that?

In New Zealand, legality created a less abusive, more easily regulated and potentially more profitable atmosphere for sex workers. Until Ivor pointed it out, I wasn't aware that such a common sense approach had been taken anywhere. (Thanks, Ivor.)

In countries where prostitution is legal but the laws around it are different, (for example, the restrictions on immigration for the purpose of sex work are either non-existent or not very well enforced), the situation is very different.

It would appear that legalization that allows the sex worker to be the primary beneficiary (instead of brothels, taxes, landlords, etc) is the most effective way to regulate.
 
Yeah, but do you believe these two are unrelated? What do you think makes the high-priced girls able to charge so much? I don't think it is just their attitude. What do you think happens when they can no longer be so picky about their johns? As I said, some of these girls might be able to have a career change, but then again, sometimes not. In reality anyway, these high-priced girls are such a small percentage of the market that is really just a distraction. If this is an issue of avoiding unacceptable harm, they are irrelevant.

bookitty said:
Which is not to say that there aren't completely autonomous and happy sex workers. They exist but they are a very small minority.

OK, figures.

The best guesstimate seems to be that there are around 80,000 prostitutes in the UK;
http://people.exeter.ac.uk/watupman/undergrad/aac/scale.htm

A relatively high profile 'adult' UK website has approximately 11,500 persons who apparently offer penetrative sex for money. Of these (men and women) approximately 10,000 offer sex at a rate of £100/hour or more, a rate that would require seeing an average of less than one client per day to make the average UK salary (probably 2 clients every 3 days if you want to be more exact).

Based on these bald figures (and let's face it not many others seem happy to quote sources) it would seem to appear that far from the 'small percentage' imagined, in the region of 1 in 8 UK prostitutes acts autonomously, and whilst £100/hr might not be regarded as high-class I would think it is certainly lower-middle. Whether they are happy or harmed by what they are doing well, they have email addresses, so why not ask them?


Of course this could mean that there may be up to 70,000 persons kept as slaves. The thing is, I don't know and neither do you, but when you dismiss valid experiences of perhaps 10% or more of all those involved as a tiny minority who muddy the waters, it smacks of putting ideology before evidence.
 
NPR just last week ran a couple of segments on young, intelligent women who actually advertise (on social media) for "sugar daddies". It's a straight exchange. Sex/companionship with an attractive young woman in return for financial favors. Generally, these women are looking for assistance getting through college.
Is this prostitution?
Certainly seems like it in principal; play for pay. However, the general consensus of the people being interviewed was no. A temporary entry into an "eyes wide open" relationship for a specific purpose.
It's certainly a defensible claim that prostitution is "bad" for all concerned, but a more pragmatic view might be that absolutely nothing that has ever been done to ban or limit the practice has worked.
People want to have no-attachment sex. They are willing to pay for it. Where there is a demand....
 
I think most of us agree on at least a few issues here. Let's not forget, the main (and titular) question, is should prostitution be illegal? If your main concern is that sex workers are mistreated, do you think they'd be better off or worse off if prostitution was legal and regulated?
 
I think most of us agree on at least a few issues here. Let's not forget, the main (and titular) question, is should prostitution be illegal? If your main concern is that sex workers are mistreated, do you think they'd be better off or worse off if prostitution was legal and regulated?
It does seem that the Swedish ban on paying for sex has reduced especially street prostitution a lot. Also, internet based prostitution has not increased the same way it has in comparable countries such as Norway that did not have the Swedish law.

I don't think the law solves all problems and there are other things we can and should do. But it seems to be a step in the right direction. It certainly matters if people in general think that it is ok to pay for sex, or if it is considered shameful. In Sweden, attitudes have clearly shifted, maybe as a result of the law or because of the debate surrounding it.
 
Based on these bald figures (and let's face it not many others seem happy to quote sources) it would seem to appear that far from the 'small percentage' imagined, in the region of 1 in 8 UK prostitutes acts autonomously, and whilst £100/hr might not be regarded as high-class I would think it is certainly lower-middle. Whether they are happy or harmed by what they are doing well, they have email addresses, so why not ask them?
what makes you think the pimp with 4 slave girls locked up in his apartment would not advertize on that site? Do you think pimps are stupid? How would you have any idea who is responding to your email? I would guess that even if you did reach the right person, you might get maybe a 1 percent response rate. Prostitutes, whatever their motivations, are quite focused on 'business' while appearing in that role.
 
A key difference between these two is that for adults it is legal to have sex with an adult passer-by, for children it is not. If you want to make a point about sex between adults, use an example where adults are involved.


So you have a ban-this-from-those attitude.

Firstly, you assume that no customer should have the right to access this service -- making it illegal would make it unavailable (in theory, if not so easily in practice).

Then you assume that no person should have the right to offer this service to others. Not even with a high price tag that would liberate the person wrom a week´s earning obligations in a few hours. In which case the woman might consider this job "better" than most or all other jobs that are realistically available for her. You decide on her behalf what is "better" for her.

Everyone is free to have his own opinions, but I don´t think that this policy has much future, not in nonreligious countries anyway. The future probably brings legalization and tighter state control of this kind of services, so the working and salary conditions in the sector will become harmonized.

First of all, I would like to apologize for some intemperate words earlier such as:

Utter rubbish! That is not my logic!

I want to retract the hostile tone as I think it spoilt an otherwise good discussion.

And I want to agree with you that the policy of banning or making illegal prostitution may not be that practical.

Nevertheless, I still think that it answers the question that the OP asked previously especially given that the OP "understood" the reason for banning drugs.

I would say that on health grounds and on the grounds that there is insidious coercion of the more vulnerable in society to resort to prostitution that such an avenue should be prevented.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom