Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Humes fork

Banned
Joined
Jul 9, 2011
Messages
3,358
Prostitution is illegal in plenty of countries, as evident by this map:

400px-Prostitution_in_Europe.png

(In the red ones, it's illegal, in the exchange of sex for money is legal but brothels are illegal, and in the green ones prostitution is legal and regulated.)

What is the rationale from prohibitting prostitution? Judging from the case in Sweden, the politicians seem to view it as icky. They dislike the idea, and therefore don't want it to exist. To me it simply doesn't make sense. Even though I think the current approach to drugs is misguided, I can at least understand the rationale behind it, as drugs cause harm. But sex doesn't.

If you happen to understand Swedish, you can watch this discussion between a comedian and a Green politician discussing the issue. The latter illustrates just how squeamish the prohibitionists are.

 
Can't think of a good reason for prostitution being illegal, so long as there is a professional body keeping prostitutes safe, like any other trade union / regulatory body.
 
Because it is an inherently degrading transaction that is mainly entertained by desperate women looking for a quick fix for their pimps.

[/da]
 
Perhaps. But some prejudices are more or less accurate. Sure, it's POSSIBLE for someone to engage in prostitution without pressure of her own free will and enjoy it. But it's not likely.
 
I think there's a good chance that sex workers would be treated better if prostitution was legal and regulated. Obviously if the sex worker is being coerced, or otherwise mistreated, that's a bad thing. But what if a prostitute enjoys having sex or money, or at least finds it preferable to other work? Then it's a victimless crime. The reason it's illegal, in my view, is because many countries are puritanical. Look at the U.S.--booze and cigarettes kill tens of thousands a year, pot kills no one, yet that's the illegal substance.

Prohibition didn't keep people from drinking; it created a criminal enterprise (see: Al Capone) and was responsible for people drinking horrible chemicals like shoe polish. Making booze legal didn't end society's alcohol related problems, but it did make it harder for kids to buy it, and regulations kept sellers from selling toxic concoctions (even more toxic than regular booze). When I was underage it was far easier to buy illegal drugs than a six pack. Drug dealers tend not to card.

Obviously sex trafficking and child prostitution is ghastly and should not be tolerated under any circumstance. Arguably if sex work was legal and regulated that could be kept under better control.
 
Perhaps. But some prejudices are more or less accurate. Sure, it's POSSIBLE for someone to engage in prostitution without pressure of her own free will and enjoy it. But it's not likely.

Yes, I think that while Humes fork mocks Noam Chomsky, possibly quite rightly, for believing in the anarchist delusion of communal happy living with no war and only unicorns and rainbows there is also a libertarian delusion in which prositution and drug-taking are activities that can be freely dabbled in without many adverse consequences and which won't disproportionately affect the poorest and most vulnerable in society.

[hyperbole]The anarchist delusion leads to something like the Khmer Rouge's Cambodia and the libertarian delusion leads to something like the Hobbesian nightmare of Somalia. {/hyperbole]
 
I think there's a good chance that sex workers would be treated better if prostitution was legal and regulated. Obviously if the sex worker is being coerced, or otherwise mistreated, that's a bad thing. But what if a prostitute enjoys having sex or money, or at least finds it preferable to other work? Then it's a victimless crime. The reason it's illegal, in my view, is because many countries are puritanical. Look at the U.S.--booze and cigarettes kill tens of thousands a year, pot kills no one, yet that's the illegal substance.

Prohibition didn't keep people from drinking; it created a criminal enterprise (see: Al Capone) and was responsible for people drinking horrible chemicals like shoe polish. Making booze legal didn't end society's alcohol related problems, but it did make it harder for kids to buy it, and regulations kept sellers from selling toxic concoctions (even more toxic than regular booze). When I was underage it was far easier to buy illegal drugs than a six pack. Drug dealers tend not to card.

Obviously sex trafficking and child prostitution is ghastly and should not be tolerated under any circumstance. Arguably if sex work was legal and regulated that could be kept under better control.

Perhaps we could legalize child prostitution to keep it out of the hands of criminal gangs. The child prostitutes would thereby have better working conditions and would be less mistreated that way.

Yes, that is also hyperbole but it is only an extension of your argument that legalizing things and regulating them is better than making them illegal and enforcing the law properly.

One of the reasons why prohibition didn't work is because people already liked drinking and it had been socially acceptable for a long time. Also, the local law enforcement tended to be corrupt. It wasn't so much the end of prohibition that put an end to the mafia so much as a federal police department which was more difficult to corrupt.

Also, given that Japan has very strict laws against drug-taking and a very low profile for drug-taking suggests that it isn't drug-laws which lead to an increase in child drug-taking but perhaps lax enforcement.
 
there is also a libertarian delusion in which prositution and drug-taking are activities that can be freely dabbled in without many adverse consequences and which won't disproportionately affect the poorest and most vulnerable in society.

Sad but true. Of course, when it comes to prostitution and drug taking, the libertarians and the progressives share the same end recommendation -- prostitution and drug-taking should be legal -- if due to different delusions.

The liberatarians have the delusion you just said, the progressives the idea that surely the best way to help those victims of society (nobody who is poor or marginalized can ever do anything for themselves, you know) is to legalize the same sort of behavior that helps ruin their lives in the first place.

Legalizing drugs and prostitution would make the poors' #1 career choices to become pimps, whores, or pushers, as all of these -- initially, at least -- pay far more than most other available jobs.

[hyperbole]The anarchist delusion leads to something like the Khmer Rouge's Cambodia and the libertarian delusion leads to something like the Hobbesian nightmare of Somalia. [/hyperbole]

It's not really hyperbole, consider both actually happened.
 
Perhaps we could legalize child prostitution to keep it out of the hands of criminal gangs. The child prostitutes would thereby have better working conditions and would be less mistreated that way.

Yes, that is also hyperbole

No it's not.

As Theodore Dalrymple noted, in his own neighborhood in Britain, a requirement for the social workers dealing with underage prostitutes is to "work nonjudgmentally" -- that is, to have no qualms about aiding and abetting child prostitution.

They must not be "judgmental" in telling them what they're doing is wrong or illegal, but must, instead, limit themselves to supplying condoms and comfort the child when, for some incomprehensible reason, she is depressed.

Gee, you'd think part of the depression is her realization that the social services she goes to to escape child prostitution are "nonjudgmental" and would do nothing of the sort to help, since that would "stigmatize" her?
 
No it's not.

As Theodore Dalrymple noted, in his own neighborhood in Britain, a requirement for the social workers dealing with underage prostitutes is to "work nonjudgmentally" -- that is, to have no qualms about aiding and abetting child prostitution.

They must not be "judgmental" in telling them what they're doing is wrong or illegal, but must, instead, limit themselves to supplying condoms and comfort the child when, for some incomprehensible reason, she is depressed.

Gee, you'd think part of the depression is her realization that the social services she goes to to escape child prostitution are "nonjudgmental" and would do nothing of the sort to help, since that would "stigmatize" her?

What? The social services provided child prostitutes with condoms?????

I've read quite a bit of Dalrymple but haven't come across this article. Do you have a link?
 
Perhaps we could legalize child prostitution to keep it out of the hands of criminal gangs. The child prostitutes would thereby have better working conditions and would be less mistreated that way.

Yes, that is also hyperbole but it is only an extension of your argument that legalizing things and regulating them is better than making them illegal and enforcing the law properly.

No it isn't. Read my post again. First of all, I said:
Obviously sex trafficking and child prostitution is ghastly and should not be tolerated under any circumstance.
Child prostitution is inherently wrong; that's why I said it should not be tolerated under any circumstance. On the other hand, in my opinion, prostitution between consenting adults is not inherently wrong. Mistreating any kind of worker is wrong. Garment work is not inherently wrong, but treating employees the way sweatshop workers are often treated is wrong.

ETA: prostitution is a victimless crime, AS LONG AS it's between two freely consenting adults. If children are involved, of course they're victims. If Heidy Fleiss wants to have sex with a dude for $2000, and they keep it off the streets, what's the problem?
 
Last edited:
What? The social services provided child prostitutes with condoms?????

It's in "Our Culture, What's Left of it". The essay ("The Frivolity of Evil"?) isn't online but this review has some of it:

Each night a city van rolls through the streets "non-judgmentally" handing out free condoms to girls as young as 12 and 13. While patting themselves on the back for a job well done, the health authorities seem unmoved by the fact that they are aiding and abetting child prostitution. Anxiety about the sexual abuse of children subsists with an utter indifference to the age of consent.

You think that is bad? How about social workers causing the murder of a two-year-old due to adherence to idiotic "non-judgmental" dogma?

That same week I was consulted by another patient who had experienced even worse consequences of nonjudgmentalism, though this time not entirely her own. Her life had been that of the modern slum dweller: three children by different fathers, none of whom supported her in any way and the last of whom was a vicious, violent drunk. She had separated from him by fleeing with their two-year-old to a hostel for battered women; soon afterward she found herself an apartment whose whereabouts he did not know.

Unfortunately, sometime later she was admitted to the hospital for an operation. As she had no one to whom she could entrust the child, she turned to Social Services for help. The social workers insisted, against her desperate pleas, that the child should stay with his biological father while she was in the hospital. They were deaf to her argument that he was an unsuitable guardian, even for two weeks: he would regard the child as an encumbrance, an intolerable interference with his daily routine of drinking, whoring, and fighting. They said it was wrong to pass judgment on a man like this and threatened her with dire consequences if she did not agree to their plan. So the two-year-old was sent to his father as they demanded.

Within the week he and his new girlfriend had killed the child by swinging him against the wall repeatedly by his ankles and smashing his head. At this somewhat belated juncture, society did reluctantly make a judgment: the murderers both received life sentences.

The life of a two year old? Meh. Who cares, compared to the holy goal of not being judgmental towards violent drunks? Being judgmental will just make it worse youknow. It is the root cause of the problem.

Yes, just like it couldn't possibly be that there is something wrong with prostitution or drug taking that caused people to stigmatize it and make it illegal in the first place. No -- the only problem with such wholesome, fun activities is the incomprehensivbe, probably racist and class-driven, desire of the evil capitalist society to stigmatize them. If only that stopped, everything would be honky dory.

Dalrymple adds in conclusion, after this woman had her apartment burned down twice when the neighbors, outraged, blamed her for the child's death (with some justification of "folk justice", since she after all DID have the child with this violent drunk knowing he is a violent drunk):

When she applied to the housing department for help, it refused her on the grounds that she was already adequately housed, in the sense of having four walls around her and a roof over her head (and it would be wholly wrong to stigmatize drug addicts as undesirable neighbors), and also because she had no young dependents—her only young dependent having been murdered and therefore not part of the equation. Stones might have wept at my patient's predicament, but not the housing department: it is far too nonjudgmental to do so.
 
No it isn't. Read my post again. First of all, I said: Child prostitution is inherently wrong; that's why I said it should not be tolerated under any circumstance.

Oh, nonsense.

We already know the drill, in advance, by which the normalization of prostitution will lead to the normalizatrion of child prostitution.

Here is one -- of many -- ways it will happen.

1). Who defines a child? 16? 14? 12? The age of consent in traditional societies can be as low as 9. Aren't you being far too judgmental and biased in declaring a ten-year-old is a "child" when other, perfectly equal, societies declare she is an "adult"?

2). Child prostitutes who are from traditional societies and caught at, say, age 14 will make (or rather, their pimps will make) a "you're a raaaaaaacist" hue and cry about that.

3). The spineless "nonjudgmental" folks will instantly capitulate, demand the social workers excercise "sensitivity to social background factors" when reporting child prostitution to authorities, or in other words, allowing Muslim / Hidu / non-western in general pimps to corner the market on the nine-year-old market.

4). Once that is done, all kinds of "non-judgmental" studies will declare that, really, honesty, "there is no evidence" child prostitution really hurts kids that much, and we must not be "judgmental" about it: if adult prostitution is OK, just how wrong can child prostitution be? And besides isn't it totally unfair that a girl, just because she is white, and thus comes from a sexually repressive society which for some reason sees "child" as "16" or "18", instead of 9 or 12, be denied the wonderful field of prostitution now available to her Muslim or Hindu friends?

5). Voila! Child prostitution is the new normal.

Many of these -- (3) and (4) for instance -- are already happening.
 
Why is anything illegal, whatsoever? Because a large share of the population, or powerful smaller elites, wish it to be illegal.

I think something of the kind should be legal, and the permissible worker conditions and contents dictated by law and monitored by the state. I think it would statistically improve the medical and humanitarian conditions of the workers and customers. A law can never save the whole society, but a law can bring statistical changes for the better or worse.

If we think that the workers are abused, raise the minimum salary to 5000 EUR a month, if that is necessary to make you feel that they are not taken unfair advatage of.
 
Last edited:
Why is anything illegal, whatsoever? Because a large share of the population, or powerful smaller elites, wish it to be illegal.

That was not the question. Re-read the title of the OP.

The replies here demonstrate very well how squeamish, prejudiced and moralistic the prohibitionists are. The example with child prostitution is ridiculous, and constitutes the slippery slope fallacy. It is no more sane than the anti-gay-marriage activists who claim that gay marriage will eventually lead to marriage with animals and children being legal.
 
That was not the question. Re-read the title of the OP.

The replies here demonstrate very well how squeamish, prejudiced and moralistic the prohibitionists are. The example with child prostitution is ridiculous, and constitutes the slippery slope fallacy. It is no more sane than the anti-gay-marriage activists who claim that gay marriage will eventually lead to marriage with animals and children being legal.

Actually, I didn't argue that legalizing prostitution leads to child prostitution or other slippery slope arguments. All I said was that the argument that legalizing X because it is best to have X regulated on health grounds is the same for anything that could be X.

There may be better arguments for the legalizing of prostitution than that.

I also said that it is something of a libertarian fantasy to believe that prostitution should be legalized on the basis that people should be free to do what they want and I think that prostitution tends to victimize those who don't have the kind of absolute freedoms that we may wish exist.

Your analogy, on the other hand, of gay marriage is completely different as it is hardly likely that people will be forced to enter gay marriages out of desparation or lack of alternatives (except perhaps in China in the near-future [J/K])

Now instead of scorning "prohibitionists" as "squeamish, prejudiced and moralistic" why don't you answer why it is that you think drugs can be kept illegal because they cause harm but prostitution should be legal on the presumed basis that you think it doesn't cause harm?
 
Now instead of scorning "prohibitionists" as "squeamish, prejudiced and moralistic" why don't you answer why it is that you think drugs can be kept illegal because they cause harm but prostitution should be legal on the presumed basis that you think it doesn't cause harm?

I said no such thing.
 
The replies here demonstrate very well how squeamish, prejudiced and moralistic the prohibitionists are.

The squemishness, seems to me, lies on the other side: the side of those who are terrified of saying anything is wrong, lest they be dumped on as "judgmental" and "prejudiced". This is precisely the "rush from judgment" that Dalrymple is talking about from much experience.

Your reply amounts to, "if you disagree wth me I'll call you bad names, so shut up". Ah well.

The example with child prostitution is ridiculous, and constitutes the slippery slope fallacy.

It's not a fallacy if the slope is, in fact slippery. Right now social workers are "nonjudmentally" distributing condoms to 12-year-old prostitutes in Britain. If prostitution is legalized and no longer stigmatized, whatever twinge of morality they have left in thinking it might be wrong to encourage girls to go into prostitution will be eradicated.

It is no more sane than the anti-gay-marriage activists who claim that gay marriage will eventually lead to marriage with animals and children being legal.

Perhaps not. But it will, quite certainly, lead to the re-established of de facto female slavery (a.k.a. "polygamy"). Indeed there are already groups calling for the legalization of such unions as the next step in "sexual liberation" ("liberation" as in, "I won't divorce you, you old hag; I'll just spend all my time with the younger trophy wife while you do the dishes and take care of the children".)

And, as for pedophilia remaining illegal... don't bet on it.
 
Last edited:
I said no such thing.

Here's what you said:

To me it simply doesn't make sense. Even though I think the current approach to drugs is misguided, I can at least understand the rationale behind it, as drugs cause harm. But sex doesn't.

We're not simply talking about sex though, are we? We're talking about prostitution. You shouldn't conflate sex with prostitution because you are not asking what good reason there is for sex being illegal but what good reason there is for prostitution being illegal.

You say, "I can at least understand the rationale behind it, as drugs cause harm."

"It" presumably means prohitibition of drugs and you can "understand it" because drugs cause harm. Then you say "sex doesn't".

Is this clear?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom