Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Put it this way, I am walking back to my hotel at the end of the night and a young lady walks up to me and begs me to pay her money to sleep with her.
Sure, that's happened to me, the most tempting time was in a Vegas club, the girl was very attractive and I had no idea she wanted money until we had already chatted for 15 minutes. Of course she was tempting me though I was very put off when I realized she was after my money, not me. What kind of argument is that? If A is tempting B, then B cannot be tempting A? You need to re-examine your logic.

No. You said that a woman who wants me to have sex for money with her is engaging in risky behaviour. How so? This is all about what you imagine men who could be persuded to do this are really like eh? All the bloody same eh? Perverts.
Prostitution means increased risk of rape, assault, STDs and psychological problems. If you're 'nice' then you will not rape or assault her, but she can't know that. You're encouraging her to keep taking risks. Your being a nice bloke doesn't protect her from STDs and neither does it protect her against psychological problems resulting from selling her body to many men to be used for their pleasure.

Btw I do not understand the nature of these psychological problems either, but they are well documented and I'm not a person who dismisses things merely on the ground that I don't understand them.
 
If you want to disprove my numbers, do so. If you actually believe my stats would not hold up, show that. Why on Earth should anyone take you seriously? You act as if I'm the only one who needs to present evidence.

I'm sorry that your understanding of rape statistics is minimal, but I guess it's my own fault for arguing with random people on the internet.

I seem to understand better that you that your country has a problem with rape despite having laws to "protect" prostitutes.
 
When was that law introduced again Merko?
In 1999. There was a sharp change in the reporting trend in 2005. Incidentally, there was a redefinition of rape in 2005 which included crimes like having sex with a very drunken person as rape. Previously that was considered a different crime (unless the rapist had forced or tricked the person to become drunk).

But thanks for trying.
 
Sure, that's happened to me, the most tempting time was in a Vegas club, the girl was very attractive and I had no idea she wanted money until we had already chatted for 15 minutes. Of course she was tempting me though I was very put off when I realized she was after my money, not me. What kind of argument is that? If A is tempting B, then B cannot be tempting A? You need to re-examine your logic.

You had to dishonestly snip stuff out. I am afraid your agruments have been shown to be flawed and rooted in fantasy. Come on in my exact example who is coercing who?

Prostitution means increased risk of rape, assault, STDs and psychological problems. If you're 'nice' then you will not rape or assault her, but she can't know that. You're encouraging her to keep taking risks. Your being a nice bloke doesn't protect her from STDs and neither does it protect her against psychological problems resulting from selling her body to many men to be used for their pleasure.

And if she is in a controlled enviroment with security there and not just some grubby darl alley then where do you think she would be safest. I might get psychological problems from women throwing themsleves at me asking for money for grubby sex acts. It should be made illegal.


Btw I do not understand the nature of these psychological problems either, but they are well documented and I'm not a person who dismisses things merely on the ground that I don't understand them.

Yes everyone can end up psychologically disturbed doing a job eh? In my old line it was a lot more common than with prostitutes I bet. They could just stop doing it like I did.
 
In 1999. There was a sharp change in the reporting trend in 2005. Incidentally, there was a redefinition of rape in 2005 which included crimes like having sex with a very drunken person as rape. Previously that was considered a different crime (unless the rapist had forced or tricked the person to become drunk).

But thanks for trying.

You think other countries do not make similar changes. Again you have nothing but handwave at my numbers after castigating me for seemingly doing the same yours. Hypocrisy anyone.
 
You had to dishonestly snip stuff out. I am afraid your agruments have been shown to be flawed and rooted in fantasy. Come on in my exact example who is coercing who?
Both parties are tempting each other, but in very different ways--and with very different consequences.

I might get psychological problems from women throwing themsleves at me asking for money for grubby sex acts. It should be made illegal.
Are you claiming that there is an established body of research showing this to be a frequent problem? Or are you just pissing about because you have no serious arguments?
 
You think other countries do not make similar changes. Again you have nothing but handwave at my numbers after castigating me for seemingly doing the same yours. Hypocrisy anyone.
I'm not aware of any country with a definition of rape that is as inclusive as that of Sweden, no. Reported rates in New Zealand are also exceptionally high. My conclusion is that reported rates will be higher in countries where women's rights issues are taken seriously.

I'm not 'handwaving', I'm showing you why expert criminologists do not believe you can use those numbers in the way you are using them (and you're being dishonest anyway, you clearly don't even believe it yourself).

You haven't yet given any argument at all for why the New Zealand numbers should be considered pessimistic. Not even a bad argument - none.
 
Both parties are tempting each other, but in very different ways--and with very different consequences.

This is false. I am coercing no-one. I see you have dropped that in favour of tempting? What if I have no money in my pocket? How can I be tempting them?

Are you claiming that there is an established body of research showing this to be a frequent problem? Or are you just pissing about because you have no serious arguments?

It is either illegal or not illegal. Not just illegal for the payer.
 
I'm not aware of any country with a definition of rape that is as inclusive as that of Sweden, no. Reported rates in New Zealand are also exceptionally high. My conclusion is that reported rates will be higher in countries where women's rights issues are taken seriously.

You are not aware? Thats not a good start to the post. Again with those pesky beliefs of yours.

I'm not 'handwaving', I'm showing you why expert criminologists do not believe you can use those numbers in the way you are using them (and you're being dishonest anyway, you clearly don't even believe it yourself).

You are showing me nothing of the kind. Please show me proof that the numbers in Sweden are high because it is seemingly more the norm to report them.

It is coincedental that the law was introduced and then thesexual offences increased eh?

You haven't yet given any argument at all for why the New Zealand numbers should be considered pessimistic. Not even a bad argument - none.

Did you look at other social factors in NZ? Domestic violence? Violenec against women? Drink violence studies? Studies around cultural norms?
 
Anyway, let's try and cobble together your 'argument'. So 3% raped prostitutes per year in New Zealand is not that bad? And to show this you reference statistics that 0.053% of Swedish women were raped in a year? Of course you can't compare these numbers, but obviously you don't understand this so let's try to understand your 'argument'. But the difference here is that the risk for New Zealand prostitutes appears to be 56 times higher than for Swedish women and 97 times higher than for New Zealand women in general. Seriously, you need to do better than this..
 
Ok so merko wants to ban a female here in Finland from starting a company, paying taxes, and doing what she wants that hurts exactly no one. And also to ban professional sports where there is fighting involved.Probably also professional soldiers, cops and firemen, and sewer workers and trashmen who do in his eyes "demeaning" work.

I think that about covers it for me, merko can try to rationalize this to himself all he wants. We all know that you think that women just can't take care of themselves and need to be protected from the evils (like, gasp!, sex) from the world, the little virgin angels they all are.

PS: I have not and would not use a prostitute, but still aren't about to stop people from doing things they want that hurt nobody.
 
This is false. I am coercing no-one. I see you have dropped that in favour of tempting? What if I have no money in my pocket? How can I be tempting them?
If you have no money in your pocket, you will not be buying sex from them. You are at no risk of being convicted under the Swedish law and the prostitute will not contract any STD from you. Coerce/seduce/convince/tempt/motivate/incentivize are vague terms and so I'm happy to use whatever you prefer, you picked tempt and I'm fine with that.
 
I am not unaware.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/uk/2002/oct/28/gender.ukcrime

Women who are drunk or under the influence of drugs will automatically be regarded as unable to give consent to sex, as part of an overhaul of the law on rape to be announced next month.
The change is part of a tighter definition of what amounts to consent to sex, which will severely restrict the circumstances in which a man can offer the defence that he "honestly believed" the woman involved wanted to have sex.

New Zealand has pretty much similar. Funnily enough.
 
Anyway, let's try and cobble together your 'argument'. So 3% raped prostitutes per year in New Zealand is not that bad? And to show this you reference statistics that 0.053% of Swedish women were raped in a year? Of course you can't compare these numbers, but obviously you don't understand this so let's try to understand your 'argument'. But the difference here is that the risk for New Zealand prostitutes appears to be 56 times higher than for Swedish women and 97 times higher than for New Zealand women in general. Seriously, you need to do better than this..

Do not get a job as a cobbler. I did not at any time say the rates from NZ were not that bad. You have no need to lie to make your point. Then again maybe you do.

You need to do better.
 
If you have no money in your pocket, you will not be buying sex from them. You are at no risk of being convicted under the Swedish law and the prostitute will not contract any STD from you. Coerce/seduce/convince/tempt/motivate/incentivize are vague terms and so I'm happy to use whatever you prefer, you picked tempt and I'm fine with that.

They do not know I HAVE NO MONEY. They are not vague terms. IF your are talking illegality and lawyers then nothing is vague is it? So how can I be coercing them when it is they who are trying to coerce me?

They are blatantly trying to get me to break the law. Yes or no? Why should they get away with that I and wouldn't if I succumbed through being very drunk?
 
You are not aware?
So if you know better, why don't you educate me? But you're not serious, you're just writing trash that you don't even believe in yourself. Come on, put up or shut up. Do you have such info or don't you?

You are showing me nothing of the kind. Please show me proof that the numbers in Sweden are high because it is seemingly more the norm to report them.
Why should I? It's completely irrelevant.

It is coincedental that the law was introduced and then thesexual offences increased eh?
Except that is not what happened, the reported rates increased sharply in 2005, not in 1999. Maybe you want to devise some 9/11 truther conspiracy reason why clearly this effect was just delayed for 5 years or maybe the numbers are all forged or whatever.

And increased reported rape rates are not the same as increased [rate of] sexual offenses, but you really seem to be exceptionally dense here.

Did you look at other social factors in NZ? Domestic violence? Violenec against women? Drink violence studies? Studies around cultural norms?
So what is your theory here? Spell it out, please. Is the reported rape incidence of New Zealand prostitutes too high? Or is it correct, but normal?
 
So if you know better, why don't you educate me? But you're not serious, you're just writing trash that you don't even believe in yourself. Come on, put up or shut up. Do you have such info or don't you?

Oops, think I just did. UK, NZ any others?

Why should I? It's completely irrelevant.

No it is not and you made a claim. Back it up or let it float about in the wind..

Except that is not what happened, the reported rates increased sharply in 2005, not in 1999. Maybe you want to devise some 9/11 truther conspiracy reason why clearly this effect was just delayed for 5 years or maybe the numbers are all forged or whatever.

Now you have to add the qualifier "sharply". Did the numbers increase or not after 1999?

And increased reported rape rates are not the same as increased [rate of] sexual offenses, but you really seem to be exceptionally dense here.

Ad hom. Thanks.

So what is your theory here? Spell it out, please. Is the reported rape incidence of New Zealand prostitutes too high? Or is it correct, but normal?

I have no idea. I want to see it reported against other countries and look at other data before I blindly take the word of someone who is blatantly bias on this subject. Maybe the different laws in NZ make it easier for them to reportit? Maybe the stigma is not so great in NZ. So they report it just like the Swedes. Or maybe not.
 
They do not know I HAVE NO MONEY. They are not vague terms. IF your are talking illegality and lawyers then nothing is vague is it? So how can I be coercing them when it is they who are trying to coerce me?
A coercing B does not mean that B may not at the same time coerce A. How can you even believe this would be logically valid? Well, you don't, because you're a troll and you make idiotic stuff up just to destroy the discussion.

They are blatantly trying to get me to break the law. Yes or no? Why should they get away with that I and wouldn't if I succumbed through being very drunk?
There is no law against that and since there's no demonstrated serious damage from such behaviour I don't see a reason to have a law against that.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom