Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

Victims can also be perpetrators, there is no contradiction there.


Yes, absolutely. When we make rules for society, we must be pragmatic, and see what are the dominant and typical consequences. We can't expect laws to be ideal in 100% of all cases.

Argument sounds familiar :rolleyes:. There is no evidence that suggests a regulated industry would be bad :/.

That's a ridiculous analogy.

I second this.
 
Anyway, the argument you wanted.
1. Prostitution is exceptionally dangerous, psychologically and physically.
2. Banning people from buying sex reduces demand for prostituition.
3. Reduced demand translates into fewer people entering prostitution.
4. Fewer people in prostitution means fewer people getting harmed.

These aren't arguments, and I don't think that you're even trying here. I'll go point by point:

1) Not very relevant, as it has been pointed out that there are a lot of legal things things much more exceptionally dangerous. Danger is only one consideration
2) You haven't shown any evidence or presented any arguments that making buying sex illegal reduces the demand. You certainly haven't shown any evidence or presented any arguments that it reduces the danger.
3) See 2.
3) See 2 and 3.

Now, you've been presented with the example of Prohibition. Prohibition actually did reduce drinking to a level that did not go back up until the 1970s. It's been going down ever since, not due to more Prohibition. Prohibition also hugely increased organized crime (especially national networks and alliances that were necessary for the distribution of alcohol), the murder rate, the depression, and all sorts of things that were bad and dangerous.

Making something illegal is not always the smart thing to do. I have no interest in paying for sex. There is nothing in my mind that would make me think it would be fun in any way. I've never done it, nor have I even been tempted, and about the only reason I would ever do it would be as an ethnographic study to know more about it.

Nor do I enjoy being mobbed by prostitutes when I walk down the street, nor do I enjoy not being able to tell at first if a woman I've just started talking to is interested in me or is looking for business. I've also known ex-prostitutes, most of whom I found damaged in various ways that I didn't like. I'd be just as happy, if not happier, if prostitution just went away. So if someone has a good idea of how to make it go away, I'm all ears.

However, I haven't seen any evidence at all that making either prostitution or hiring prostitutes illegal is going to do that. If anything, from my personal experiences, where it's illegal, it's a lot worse.

The reason I have not seen it is because nobody has presented any. You haven't argued that making paying for sex illegal makes things better, and I'd be quite surprised if you were to start. You just wave your hands and make bald assertions.
 
Did Sweden criminalize pimping?
Yes, I believe it has 'always' been illegal, at least in modern times.

If by "prostitution" you mean just buying/selling sex between two parties and no pimps/middle men benefiting from the woman, then what exactly is the problem with "prevalence of prostitution"? Ie. the whole point of this thread...
The problem is that it is physically and psychologically dangerous.

Earlier in this thread, we considered New Zealand, where prostitution is legal. Furthermore, this is probably the country with such laws that has been most active to actually promote the well-being of sex workers. Other countries, such as Germany and the Netherlands, seem to have legislation that is really more catering for the wishes of pimps and sex buyers than of sex sellers.

Anyway, statistics from the evaluation of the New Zealand law still show a horrible picture, as I explained in this post. And that does not even cover the psychological effects.
 
Something that annoys me is the belief that people who, for a whole variety of reasons (e.g., looks, disability, shyness, etc.), are rejected by society should just be stoic and, well, not have sex with another human being until they are either lucky enough to bump into someone who finds them sexually attractive or shape up and stop acting like freaks.
No, I believe they should have sex with each other. Basically, if you've concluded that you're not the most attractive person, you need to adapt your expectations of the level of attractiveness of the people that you can expect to have sex with. Everyone has fantasies, but we must all learn to live in reality.
 
That's a ridiculous analogy.
Well, it's not entirely fair. It's quite plausible that technology will make drunk driving safe within perhaps only a few decades. I don't think this is realistic at all when it comes to prostitution.
 
Victims can also be perpetrators, there is no contradiction there.

Your response makes no sense. If the prostitutes who work in the brothel own and run it who, exactly, is coercing them into or stopping them from leaving the sex industry? Why are they not much safer working in an owner-operated brothel than alone because of a law against paying for sex which makes legal, recognised brothels a practical impossibility?

Yes, absolutely. When we make rules for society, we must be pragmatic, and see what are the dominant and typical consequences. We can't expect laws to be ideal in 100% of all cases.

But making paying for sex illegal is not the best solution as far as prostitutes or their clients are concerned. If fact, it's only people who aren't involved in the sex industry who seem to think it's a good idea to make clients criminals.

Funny how often people who have nothing to do with a human activity seem to want to interfere in the name of saving "the victims".
 
No, I believe they should have sex with each other. Basically, if you've concluded that you're not the most attractive person, you need to adapt your expectations of the level of attractiveness of the people that you can expect to have sex with. Everyone has fantasies, but we must all learn to live in reality.

Seems to me you need to take a slice of your own advice.
 
These aren't arguments, and I don't think that you're even trying here.
Your counter-arguments show very clearly that you do understand them as arguments, however.

1) Not very relevant, as it has been pointed out that there are a lot of legal things things much more exceptionally dangerous. Danger is only one consideration
Such as? Please elaborate. I have not seen anything that has been discussed in this thread that would be a) comparably dangerous and b) legal to pay someone to do.

2) You haven't shown any evidence or presented any arguments that making buying sex illegal reduces the demand.
I have certainly presented arguments, but it is correct that I have not presented any evidence. It's pretty obvious I think, and unless someone is seriously claiming the contrary (and not just trolling) I don't find it very useful to prove to some random person on the internet that ice is cold, while they themselves offer nothing. Anyway, there was an evaluation which is quoted on Wikipedia. Of course, supporters of legalization are not happy with that report but as far as I know they have not been able to either demonstrate any decisive flaws, or produce any empirical counter-evidence.

You certainly haven't shown any evidence or presented any arguments that it reduces the danger.
This is simply a logical consequence. If prostitution is dangerous and if a ban on buying sex reduces prostitution, then that ban reduces the danger.

Making something illegal is not always the smart thing to do.
I'm 100% in agreement here. But the fact is that the Swedish ban on buying sex has wide popular support (iirc something like 75% of men and 90% of women) and this support has risen since the law was enacted.

So I think the comparison with prohibition does not hold. Rather, I have already drawn a parallel with the Swedish law against corporal punishment for children which was enacted in 1979 and is credited as partly responsible for the shift in attitudes which has resulted in extremely low popular tolerance for that practice.
 
I don't think arguments as to people's safety are relevant when the industry is safe, regulated, and the persons of the industry must get frequent check-ups. I'm just failing to see the danger. I'm also of the opinion that if you prevented pimping women would be much safer in the industry than if you forced it to be illegal and thus forced it to be coordinated exclusively by the merit of pimps.

I think people are making this a moral argument, when this is not an issue of morality but an issue of practicality and safety. I'm sorry I just don't see any reason to prohibit prostitution if the industry were well regulated and safe.

Personally, I would very much agree on the grounds that a safe, regulated industry tends to be far healthier for society than one that survives solely in the shadows, often sacrificing the safety and well being of the people for secrecy and wasting the resources that are used to suppress it.

In this area, I will fully admit that I'm not an expert. That said, it's always seemed to me that, before anyone throws out either blanket condemnations or endorsements, it's best to look and see how such things actually play out in the real world. Earlier, there was much talk of the evils of legalizing drugs. Recently, I stumbled upon Portugal's decriminalization of drug use, normally somewhat blind as I am. It's certainly not all positive, though much of the negatives may be attributable to prior dishonesty and failures to fully find the data, but it's also certainly not all negative in the consequences. Personally, I would think that legalizing and regulating prostitution would be far more likely to be more beneficial than that, for the society as a whole, and for the members of the profession. Child prostitution, personally, I would consider to be a separate issue, having far more to do with the legal interactions between minors and adults than prostitution. Unfortunately, given the very nature of professions when they are forced to keep their actions secret, reliable data is difficult to obtain.

I would think that beyond any of that, though, one can look to places where prostitution has been legalized and regulated and examine the relative quality of life for the workers and the health of both the community and the workers to gain a better understanding of the actual results of such a thing.
 
Your response makes no sense. If the prostitutes who work in the brothel own and run it who, exactly, is coercing them into or stopping them from leaving the sex industry?
Prostitutes are individuals too, now you're treating them as a collective. Also this depends on your definition of 'brothel'. I do not believe that there is anything in the Swedish law to stop two Swedish prostitutes from co-owning an apartment where they take turns selling sex. If there is a law that forbids that, I would be in favour of repealing that law.

However, I think the typical definition of a brothel means that there is some individual A who procures sex buyers who are then being serviced by another individual B. In this case, it does not really matter if A is also selling sex, B may still be coerced, pressured or persuaded by A.

There are a lot of real-world examples of older prostitutes who end up being madams at a brothel, sometimes occasionally still serving customers, and treating the younger prostitutes very badly.

Why are they not much safer working in an owner-operated brothel than alone because of a law against paying for sex which makes legal, recognised brothels a practical impossibility?
The data I have seen does not suggest to me that such brothels would be very safe. Neither do I have any reason to believe that most prostitutes would want to work in such places. I don't believe that prostitutes are typically operating alone because they are unable to operate together, I believe they do that mostly because they want to be as anonymous as possible.

If fact, it's only people who aren't involved in the sex industry who seem to think it's a good idea to make clients criminals.
Expand your group also to ex-prostitutes and you have no problem finding proponents of the Swedish law.
 
How do they compare with figures from the normal population. Or from the prison population?
Feel free to find such figures yourself if you seriously believe you have an argument. I'm not going to waste time proving that ice is cold to some internet troll who contributes nothing to the discussion.

If the prison figures are worse should we make them illegal?
Absolutely.
 
<snip>

This is simply a logical consequence. If prostitution is dangerous and if a ban on buying sex reduces prostitution, then that ban reduces the danger.

<snip>

Only if one naively assumes there are no negative externalities. Clamping down in one area often makes problems worse in others.

I think the idea that people who are inclined to rape or assault sex workers are suddenly going to stop or reduce the frequency of their activities because they might get a year in prison for paying someone for sex is ridiculous. Clearly someone who thinks they can get away with being violent towards a sex worker isn't worried about getting caught paying for what is already a much more serious crime.
 
Your counter-arguments show very clearly that you do understand them as arguments, however.


Such as? Please elaborate. I have not seen anything that has been discussed in this thread that would be a) comparably dangerous and b) legal to pay someone to do.

Having sex with someone is not at all dangerous. The "johns" may have a heart attack of course...

Working with other people in any capacity though, can be, like being a bus or taxi driver late at night. So I don't think there's anything inherently dangerous about having sex with someone for money, so it's a bad argument. I mean come on, you really think there's something inherently "dangerous" about having sex? Really, cear to ellaborate?

Maybe the argument can be made that someone who would rape or kill somebody would do it anyhow but it is easier to target sex workers (you get to be alone with them), but I think that is a silly argument against legalized prostitution. A few nutcases can't be the reason we do or don't do things.

Some other professions on the other hand are inherently dangerous, and people die from them. I believe there was a list in this thread (like fishermen).
 
I think the idea that people who are inclined to rape or assault sex workers are suddenly going to stop or reduce the frequency of their activities because they might get a year in prison for paying someone for sex is ridiculous. Clearly someone who thinks they can get away with being violent towards a sex worker isn't worried about getting caught paying for what is already a much more serious crime.
I think people who are inclined to rape or assault sex workers, or anyone, are likely to do that more if they often visit sex workers. But that in turn is a consequence of having easy access. Therefore, if there are fewer sex workers, they will less often have an opportunity to rape or abuse anyone. Contrary to some common belief, rapists are frequently socially capable individuals who can appear normal to co-workers or sometimes even their own family. So I think they would often be deterred by the risk of getting caught and exposed.

I think you have something of a point though and I think these people have to get caught. But it's much easier to catch them if we only have to prove that they bought sex. Proving rape in an ordinary situation is often quite hard, how do you know the person claiming to be raped did not agree to have sex? With a prostitute it is even harder, because even in the most unlikely situation for sex, it is not unreasonable that a prostitute would have accepted to have sex even with a perfect stranger. Consider the Strauss-Kahn case. At first, it seemed really like a clear-cut case: physical evidence showed that he had engaged in sexual acts with the woman, and it appeared beyond belief that she would just have agreed to have sex with him just like that while cleaning his room. But then it was alleged that she had been selling sex. And under that assumption, Strauss-Kahn could be innocent of rape.
 
And moreover, if women want to be in a business that pays them well but contains some risk, who are you to deny them this?
There are many jobs which are glorified exactly because of the risks. Having someone maybe beat you up in a fight can be really lucrative!
Of course the women didn't consent to be beaten up but the end result is pretty much the same (sans possible emotional issues, but again, the woman wanted to work in this "highly dangerous" field, so maybe they aren't as traumatized by this).

So in the end your argument boils down to:
- prostitutes may get traumatized and thus prostitution should be banned.


Hmm, I know some professions were the (mostly) men get pretty traumatized, and still we aren't banning these professions.
 
I think people who are inclined to rape or assault sex workers, or anyone, are likely to do that more if they often visit sex workers. But that in turn is a consequence of having easy access. Therefore, if there are fewer sex workers, they will less often have an opportunity to rape or abuse anyone. Contrary to some common belief, rapists are frequently socially capable individuals who can appear normal to co-workers or sometimes even their own family. So I think they would often be deterred by the risk of getting caught and exposed.

<snip>

That doesn't follow at all. What does follow is that as the law on paying for sex does nothing to reduce the number of violent sexual predators but puts off men who want consensual sex and drives some sex workers out of business, the sex workers that remain each have a higher probability of encountering a violent sexual predator.
 
Working with other people in any capacity though, can be, like being a bus or taxi driver late at night. So I don't think there's anything inherently dangerous about having sex with someone for money, so it's a bad argument. I mean come on, you really think there's something inherently "dangerous" about having sex?
I'm simply not interested in philosophical hair-splitting over whether the danger is 'inherent' or not. It is dangerous in practice, because of the extreme risks of rape, assault, STDs and psychological damage. It is not 'inherently dangerous' to fire a machine gun at the city square. You need to actually hit someone and as long as you don't it's perfectly safe. But we wouldn't allow it anyway based on such sophistry.

Some other professions on the other hand are inherently dangerous, and people die from them. I believe there was a list in this thread (like fishermen).
First, it's much more safe to be a fisherman than a prostitute. Second, the danger level for fishermen is not 'inherent' but very much dependent on risk behaviour. If there is a storm and you choose to go out anyway, it can be very dangerous. Let's assume for the sake of argument that it was as dangerous as being a prostitute. If that was the case, I would support a ban on hiring someone to go out on a fishing boat when weather reports indicate a storm.

But anyway, I checked some Swedish stats. It says about 13 people per year die in Sweden due to fishing accidents. It says most of them are amateurs fishing from small boats and the second largest group are amateurs fishing on the ice. I find no evidence for the idea that being a professional fisherman would be even nearly as dangerous as being a prostitute.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom