Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

And funnily enough, they have similar rates of reported rape. Ok, so you learned something about rape statistics, can we move on now?

Does the UK have similar rates? Answer that and we can move on.
 
Then what the heck is your argument?

Ok, you're a troll, case closed.

You should know you have read and answered my posts. Apart from the ones you dishonestly snipped bits out because they were incovenient to your flawed arguments.

I was asking you if you had taken other data into account before proclaiming that the NZ data was what you thought it was. It seems you didnt.
 
<snip>

Prostitution means increased risk of rape, assault, STDs and psychological problems. If you're 'nice' then you will not rape or assault her, but she can't know that. You're encouraging her to keep taking risks. Your being a nice bloke doesn't protect her from STDs and neither does it protect her against psychological problems resulting from selling her body to many men to be used for their pleasure.

Btw I do not understand the nature of these psychological problems either, but they are well documented and I'm not a person who dismisses things merely on the ground that I don't understand them.

Women going to bars and hooking up with lots of different men are at an increased risk of rape, assault and STDs. What difference does it make if they ask for payment or not? Does money changing hands suddenly turn an okay guy into a violent rapist?

A prostitute does not "sell her body to many men to be used for their pleasure". A prostitute sells her time and sexual services to as many or as few men as she wants. I understand why radical feminists would like to dis-empower women who sell sex and demonize men who pay women for it, but what's your agenda?

Stop buying into the propaganda put out by radical feminists pretending to be researchers and start looking at ways to actually help women who want to leave prostitution and make selling sex safer for those that don't.
 
A coercing B does not mean that B may not at the same time coerce A. How can you even believe this would be logically valid? Well, you don't, because you're a troll and you make idiotic stuff up just to destroy the discussion.

Had to happen eventually. I like how you use "may". I am stating a specific case. Are they coercing me or not? Am I coercing them in anyway from what I have posted here? You do know what the legal definition of coercing is?




There is no law against that and since there's no demonstrated serious damage from such behaviour I don't see a reason to have a law against that.

There is no law against inciting someone to break the law? Really? Do you have much experience of time share touts on holiday? Who is enticing who?
 
Now you have to add the qualifier "sharply". Did the numbers increase or not after 1999?
They increased since the statistics started in 1975 and until 2005 at a steady pace. In fact there was a very slight decrease (or rather no increase) between 1999 and 2002 but I would not attribute that to the law. There's some noise in the numbers obviously and the big change happened in 2005. No one knows if the steady increase from 1975 is due to changed attitudes of reporting or if there is also a real increase, but at least some believe there is also a real increase related to young people being less careful, particularly an increased tendency to join people they don't know very well for late-night parties.
 
<snip>

There is no law against that and since there's no demonstrated serious damage from such behaviour I don't see a reason to have a law against that.

Yeah, what could be the damage from being arrested, charged with a crime, put in prison for a year, losing your job...

:rolleyes:
 
They increased since the statistics started in 1975 and until 2005 at a steady pace. In fact there was a very slight decrease (or rather no increase) between 1999 and 2002 but I would not attribute that to the law. There's some noise in the numbers obviously and the big change happened in 2005. No one knows if the steady increase from 1975 is due to changed attitudes of reporting or if there is also a real increase, but at least some believe there is also a real increase related to young people being less careful, particularly an increased tendency to join people they don't know very well for late-night parties.

Yes, I read the same newpaper argument you did, that you pulled this from.

From 1989 in the UK there was ahuge increase in the amount of all night/all weekend house parties with copious amount of drugs being taken. Did that cause a sharp incease in rape reports in the UK?

Touche.
 
You should know you have read and answered my posts. Apart from the ones you dishonestly snipped bits out because they were incovenient to your flawed arguments.
What bits?

I was asking you if you had taken other data into account before proclaiming that the NZ data was what you thought it was. It seems you didnt.
What data is there that you believe would be relevant, and how?

I mean, you're acting like some 9/11 truther who, when presented with evidence that the towers did not collapse at free fall speed as he claimed, then asks if you've considered the 'impossible' molten metal in the basement.

Do you even have a theory or are you just throwing things at me at random?
 
I am still wondering how you would set up a nice and clean brothel in Sweden.
Even if it is legal for the owners/workers there would be some problems with attracting customers if the vice squad were waiting outside.
 
Women going to bars and hooking up with lots of different men are at an increased risk of rape, assault and STDs. What difference does it make if they ask for payment or not? Does money changing hands suddenly turn an okay guy into a violent rapist?
No, it's mainly the number of people involved that makes the difference I believe.

A prostitute does not "sell her body to many men to be used for their pleasure". A prostitute sells her time and sexual services to as many or as few men as she wants.
Yes, but typically they are very many. People who only do it once or twice probably are not at that much risk. If that was how most sex sales occurred I would not worry much.

I understand why radical feminists would like to dis-empower women who sell sex and demonize men who pay women for it, but what's your agenda?
Avoiding people getting raped, assaulted, getting STDs or experiencing serious psychological issues. That's my agenda. Your agenda seems to be to excuse your own behaviour.

I've noticed that the hatred of these supposedly all-powerful 'radical feminists' seems to be a popular fuel for conspiracy theory among sex buyers. It's a bit like you rarely find a global warming denier who doesn't nurture a personal hatred for Al Gore.
 
Yes it does. Especially England and Wales, for some reason reported rates in Scotland are a lot lower.

I think when you look at NZ and the UK (England and Wales)you have to have some nerve to claim similar. Now if you had said Belgium I might have let you have that one.

How do you explain Sweden being double if NZ laws make it similar between those two nations.

And the UK has similar laws? What is your belief?
 
In sweden the prostitution business was fast driven underground and in the hands of various criminal organizations after buying became illegal. The prostitutes are forced to quickly jump into the "john's" cars so that the customer doesn't get into trouble. This way the prostitutes can't chat leisurely with the potential clients and get a feel about them prior to working with them (or deciding not to if they feel something is wrong), so probably more rapes and assaults occur because of this.
So on all account this new law is very bad for the prostitutes.

Very nice, this is probably just what our merko wants. Probably works for the mob.
 
What bits?

Are you denying you snipped part of a quote to answer it?

What data is there that you believe would be relevant, and how?

I mean, you're acting like some 9/11 truther who, when presented with evidence that the towers did not collapse at free fall speed as he claimed, then asks if you've considered the 'impossible' molten metal in the basement.

Do you even have a theory or are you just throwing things at me at random?

There is only only person here acting like a truther and that is the one flinging those ad homs like truthers. I am picking holes in your flawed logic that is all.
 
Had to happen eventually. I like how you use "may". I am stating a specific case. Are they coercing me or not? Am I coercing them in anyway from what I have posted here? You do know what the legal definition of coercing is?
Coerce/seduce/convince/tempt/motivate/incentivize, take your pick. In your example you did not have any money, and you will not pay them to have sex with you, so you are not buying sex, you are not breaking the law, your example simply has no bearing on this discussion. In your specific example, they were trying to tempt you (coercing if you insist, I don't know why you keep switching terms all the time) but since you were unable to pay them anything they were bound to fail.

If you had money, by paying them you could coerce/seduce/convince/tempt/motivate/incentivize them and that is what this is about.

There is no law against inciting someone to break the law? Really?
Not in general, no. It varies from crime to crime. In this case, no.
 
Yes, I read the same newpaper argument you did, that you pulled this from.
I did not read any newspaper 'argument', I checked directly with the source at http://www.bra.se but it's in Swedish so I'm not sure it helps you much.

From 1989 in the UK there was ahuge increase in the amount of all night/all weekend house parties with copious amount of drugs being taken. Did that cause a sharp incease in rape reports in the UK?
I don't have the faintest idea, but really, if you have some kind of argument, spell it out.
 
Well I do. I would not marry a former mercenary killer, mafia boss, major drug dealer or even top tobacco executive. I do have a list of former jobs that I despise and that would disqualify a woman even if I found her otherwise attractive. Prostitute is not on that list.
...and yet you rank a prostitute in the same boat as a former mercenary killer, a mafia boss and a major drug dealer. Its good that you finally put your cards on the table so we can see what you really think about prostitutes.
I also support that reform vs the status quo, so I don't think they are wrong, and I certainly don't think the law should be repealed. I think this just proves that you're not capable of reading what I actually write, you just make stuff up and insult me.
I haven't insulted you once. Go back and read my posts. I would appreciate it if you would stop making stuff up about me. I'm here to debate. There is only one person in this thread throwing around accusations of "troll" and it isn't me.

You have made your feelings very clear in this thread. I have read your posts perfectly fine thank you very much. You don't think the NZ laws should be repealed, yet you think it should be illegal to offer money for sex. This doesn't make any sense.

If you think that it should be illegal to offer money for sex, how can you not advocate for the repeal of the NZ laws?

Please explain what you mean. My calculations are extremely basic and accurate.
No they were not. They were made up. You invented them. You plucked them out of thin air. Please provide some evidence for your assertion that "Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career" without resorting to inventing statistics, or concede that you have no basis to make this assertion.


You mean you are not interested in facts.
You haven't presented any facts. You have invented numbers. You have made up numbers. You are citing fantasy.

That is the meaning of those numbers. You can't ignore that just because you don't like reality.
Of course I can ignore your numbers. You made them up! I supplied you with the contact details of the New Zealand Prostitutes Collective. In the time it has taken you to type all of the replies to this thread you could have simply sent them an email to get their perspective of your use of maths. You obviously haven't. Why is that?

Please show me any peer review study in the world that uses the same maths as you do. Just one.

Your theory seems to be that yes, this is the case today.. but since everything is going to be heavenly happiness in just a few years, we can't extrapolate.

Can you explain why you extrapolated upwards? What evidence can you supply of an upward trend in NZ? How long do prostitutes stay in the industry in NZ? With all of the flaws in your "analysis", the biggest ones are the assumption of a static population and the assumption of an upward trend. Please show your working. Please provide some evidence or concede.

Or maybe Jesus will come down from heaven or something. Yeah, maybe. But those are the facts today. If you disregard any predictions about the future based on the current situation, then you can't make any fact-based arguments at all about any law change.
I can safely disregard your predictions because they are made with invented numbers.
Supporters of a ban on prostitution could equally argue that we have absolutely no way of knowing what will happen and therefore we should just assume that in the future everything is going to be perfect and cozy and fine.
Are you arguing this? Or are you just setting up a strawman?

The facts are.. practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'.. unless they get out of this 'job' very soon. That is the situation today.

Not proven by you. Not proven by the evidence.
 
Coerce/seduce/convince/tempt/motivate/incentivize, take your pick. In your example you did not have any money, and you will not pay them to have sex with you, so you are not buying sex, you are not breaking the law, your example simply has no bearing on this discussion. In your specific example, they were trying to tempt you (coercing if you insist, I don't know why you keep switching terms all the time) but since you were unable to pay them anything they were bound to fail.

If you had money, by paying them you could coerce/seduce/convince/tempt/motivate/incentivize them and that is what this is about.

This is so incorrect it is unreal. You call me a troll and continue with this disgraceful attempt to twist things. MY example has every bearing. I was quietly minding my own business and not breaking the law when they came over and forced themselves at me and offered me incentives and sweeteners to the deal they wanted to make.

Lets put it his way. I am walking past a car dealer ship on the opposite side of the road. The salesman runs across and offers me the deal of a lifetime and all sorts of extras and perks. I tell him I am not interested in what he is selling but he is insistent. Who is enticing/coercing/inciting who?

What about the same for timeshare touts? Just by being in Tenerife I am enticing him to sell me something?

Not in general, no. It varies from crime to crime. In this case, no.

This is handwavng nonsense again. You can certainly be prosecuted fror enticing others to commit illegal acts. Yet another fail on your part.
 
Last edited:
How does making paying for sex illegal actually help prostitutes with the problems they face?

Does it provide them with an alternative source of income? No.

Does it help them with health problems such as drug addiction or STDs? No.

Does it reduce the probability prostitutes will be attacked? No. If anything it increases the probability a client is violent because the nice ones will have been scared off and brothels are driven underground.

Does it improve the status of people working as prostitutes? No. Anyone working as a prostitute is considered a victim.

The only people this law benefits are politicians by helping them win votes from the ignorant mob and those who want to control other people's consensual sexual behaviour.
 
I did not read any newspaper 'argument', I checked directly with the source at http://www.bra.se but it's in Swedish so I'm not sure it helps you much.

The last part of your post is almost a straight lift from an English version of a Swedish newspaper where I saw it. Funny that eh?

I thought this was the source?

http://ec.europa.eu/justice/fundamental-rights/programme/daphne-programme/index_en.htm

Maybe not.

I don't have the faintest idea, but really, if you have some kind of argument, spell it out.

No, there was not, hence the Swedish must be special if you can use that sort of excuse from the newspaper eh?
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom