Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

And moreover, if women want to be in a business that pays them well but contains some risk, who are you to deny them this?
I don't want to deny them that. I want to ban buying sex, not selling sex.

In a free society, we have the right to do what we want with our own bodies. We do not have the right to do what we want with other peoples' bodies.

There are many jobs which are glorified exactly because of the risks. Having someone maybe beat you up in a fight can be really lucrative!
That's illegal in Sweden though. Unfortunately, the law was designed for boxing only and has regrettably not been adapted to include some other forms of dangerous fighting. It should be, but of course these fights are still very rare so the problem is not so important as prostitution.
 
In a free society, we have the right to do what we want with our own bodies. We do not have the right to do what we want with other peoples' bodies.

Buying sex is not just doing what one wants with someone elses body. That would be rape.

If someone wants to have sex with me but wants me to pay for it. Explain why that should be illegal?
 
Feel free to find such figures yourself if you seriously believe you have an argument. I'm not going to waste time proving that ice is cold to some internet troll who contributes nothing to the discussion.

So trolling is asking someone to back up their evidence with comparisons that would give a clearer picture of those initial figures?


Absolutely.

Make prisons illegal? Wow.
 
If someone wants to have sex with me but wants me to pay for it. Explain why that should be illegal?
It should not be illegal.

However, if you pay for someone to have sex with you, that should be illegal. The reason is that you are using coercion, persuasion or incitement (depending on your definitions) to get another person to engage in risky behaviour.
 
So trolling is asking someone to back up their evidence with comparisons that would give a clearer picture of those initial figures?
Yes, if you have no serious doubt and you are just asking for frivolous information that you could easily find yourself, in order to bog other people down with doing your useless research.

Make prisons illegal? Wow.
Inhumane prisons should be and frequently are closed down because they are declared illegal.
 
Maybe the illegality of buying sex explains the numbers that put Sweden at the top of the EU rape leagues according to a 2009 study?

I guess if its illegal to buy it you might as well go the whole hog and just steal it eh?

Kind of bursts your bubble.
 
Yes, if you have no serious doubt and you are just asking for frivolous information that you could easily find yourself, in order to bog other people down with doing your useless research.

Too lazy then? Rather just ad hom.

Inhumane prisons should be and frequently are closed down because they are declared illegal.

So any prison that has higher rape statistics than the general population should be closed? I just want to be clear on your stance.
 
It should not be illegal.

However, if you pay for someone to have sex with you, that should be illegal. The reason is that you are using coercion, persuasion or incitement (depending on your definitions) to get another person to engage in risky behaviour.

It is not corecion if they want me to do it. That is an utter logic fail. They chose to want me to do it. If they say no I walk away. Fair enough?

ETA - Why would having sex with me be risky behaviour?
 
It should not be illegal.

However, if you pay for someone to have sex with you, that should be illegal. The reason is that you are using coercion, persuasion or incitement (depending on your definitions) to get another person to engage in risky behaviour.

If a man goes to a bar, flashes his cash around, spends lots of money on a woman half his age and then takes her to a hotel or home and has consensual unprotected sex with her, that's legal.

Whereas paying a woman who comes up to you in a bar, chats you up and offers to have sex for money is illegal.

Merko, how long will it take for you to realise that you're being played by radical feminists who quite frankly think the vast majority of men (whether or not they use the services of prostitutes) are complete bastards for breathing air, let alone actually having sex with women?
 
Last edited:
Maybe the illegality of buying sex explains the numbers that put Sweden at the top of the EU rape leagues according to a 2009 study?
Maybe, maybe not. Anyone seriously interested in this field knows that the number of rapes cannot easily be compared between countries or even over time in the same country. This is because the event 'a rape' and 'a reported rape' are not nearly the same. Differences are due to different attitudes (rape victims increasingly feel acceptance and support rather than condemnation) and also changing definitions of what a rape is. Sweden today has a wider definition of what is called rape compared to most European countries. For instance, having sex with a drunken or sleeping person would be rape in Sweden, where in other countries it may fall under other laws, as it also used to do here. Also, there is every reason to believe that rape victims in Sweden would be more likely to turn to the police than in more conservative/religious countries that are still widely affected by notions about rape victims being 'stained' or 'ruined'.
 
Too lazy then? Rather just ad hom.
Yes, you certainly seem to be lazy, I have provided stats, you question them but you're unwilling to provide any sort of basis for your argument. And you're not even stating any argument, you're just sort of hinting.

So any prison that has higher rape statistics than the general population should be closed? I just want to be clear on your stance.
Sounds like a reasonable stance at least as long as we are talking about advanced, developed nations. Prisons should be safe and it is not hard to keep them safe if there is a political will to do so.
 
It is not corecion if they want me to do it. That is an utter logic fail. They chose to want me to do it. If they say no I walk away. Fair enough?
Coercion, persuasion or incitement - as I said, take your pick depending on your definitions. If you put a gun to someone's head they want to give you their money. If you pay someone to clean your windows they want to do that. You're just engaging in philosophical hair-splitting, it does not take us anywhere.

ETA - Why would having sex with me be risky behaviour?
This is the 'there are no forests, only trees' fallacy. Prostitution is dangerous. But prostitution is to have sex for money with a lot of people. That you are only one person and it does not 'seem' dangerous to you for someone to have sex with you for money does not mean that it is in fact not dangerous to have sex for money with a lot of people.
 
Maybe, maybe not. Anyone seriously interested in this field knows that the number of rapes cannot easily be compared between countries or even over time in the same country. This is because the event 'a rape' and 'a reported rape' are not nearly the same. Differences are due to different attitudes (rape victims increasingly feel acceptance and support rather than condemnation) and also changing definitions of what a rape is. Sweden today has a wider definition of what is called rape compared to most European countries. For instance, having sex with a drunken or sleeping person would be rape in Sweden, where in other countries it may fall under other laws, as it also used to do here. Also, there is every reason to believe that rape victims in Sweden would be more likely to turn to the police than in more conservative/religious countries that are still widely affected by notions about rape victims being 'stained' or 'ruined'.

A lot of speculation and belief there and not much numbers or evidence eh? No surprises for me.
 
Yes, you certainly seem to be lazy, I have provided stats, you question them but you're unwilling to provide any sort of basis for your argument. And you're not even stating any argument, you're just sort of hinting.

I was asking you if you had looked at that? You have fluffed about Swedens rape figures and how they may be different compared to other countries due to various things you think or you believe. You gave us one sample from one country and did not use a control sample in your evidence. Whats sauce for the goose and all that............


Sounds like a reasonable stance at least as long as we are talking about advanced, developed nations. Prisons should be safe and it is not hard to keep them safe if there is a political will to do so.

OK then.
 
If a man goes to a bar, flashes his cash around, spends lots of money on a woman half his age and then takes her to a hotel or home and has consensual unprotected sex with her, that's legal.

Whereas paying a woman who comes up to you in a bar, chats you up and offers to have sex for money is illegal.
I have not seen any stats to show that 'sugar daddy' type relationships would be dangerous, though I wouldn't advise it. It's not like the same person will typically engage in hundreds of such relationships anyway so I really would not expect the situation to be comparable at all.

Merko, how long will it take for you to realise that you're being played by radical feminists who quite frankly think the vast majority of men (whether or not they use the services of prostitutes) are complete bastards for breathing air, let alone actually having sex with women?
Well, that's a theory. Unfortunately, I don't know any such people. The feminists I know are all quite sex positive. Well, I once had a date with a girl who only wanted to talk about rape, but frankly I did not find that very attractive.

Perhaps you should consider the possibility that you are in fact contributing to serious suffering for a lot of women, but you refuse to see this because you just want to justify your own behaviour and this makes you blind to empirical data on the subject?
 
Coercion, persuasion or incitement - as I said, take your pick depending on your definitions. If you put a gun to someone's head they want to give you their money. If you pay someone to clean your windows they want to do that. You're just engaging in philosophical hair-splitting, it does not take us anywhere.

Put it this way, I am walking back to my hotel at the end of the night and a young lady walks up to me and begs me to pay her money to sleep with her. She even keeps reducing the price she would be willing to take. She even offers extras. She then pulls her friend over and says they will do twos up. Who's coercing who?*


This is the 'there are no forests, only trees' fallacy. Prostitution is dangerous. But prostitution is to have sex for money with a lot of people. That you are only one person and it does not 'seem' dangerous to you for someone to have sex with you for money does not mean that it is in fact not dangerous to have sex for money with a lot of people.

No. You said that a woman who wants me to have sex for money with her is engaging in risky behaviour. How so? This is all about what you imagine men who could be persuded to do this are really like eh? All the bloody same eh? Perverts.

Prostitution is dangerous, so is living in Sweden if you dont want to get raped it seems. Maybe making it legal to pay for sex may change the rape figures to a downwards trend? Maybe not. But in the spirit of this thread I am just going to claim it would anyway. Ha!


* Disclaimer - not going to happen where I am at the moment but lets ignore that.
 
A lot of speculation and belief there and not much numbers or evidence eh? No surprises for me.
I can't educate you against your will. I'm just referencing the opinion of just about any criminologist you could find out there. Seriously, no one believes Sweden has the second-highest incidence of rapes in the world, as indicated by another comparison.
If criminologists want to compare different countries, they use different methods, such as anonymous surveys that are the same in all examined countries. Then you get completely different numbers. But you can't trust those numbers either, because people have different opinion of what it means to be raped and if rape is considered extremely shameful people will not admit being raped even in anonymous surveys (some islamic countries have extremely low statistics for rape, although no one believes these stats are accurate).
 
Over the past ten years there has been a 58 percent increase in reported sex crimes and according to BRÅ, it is now statistically more likely for a person in Sweden to be sexually assaulted than robbed.

When was that law introduced again Merko?
 
I was asking you if you had looked at that? You have fluffed about Swedens rape figures and how they may be different compared to other countries due to various things you think or you believe. You gave us one sample from one country and did not use a control sample in your evidence. Whats sauce for the goose and all that............
If you want to disprove my numbers, do so. If you actually believe my stats would not hold up, show that. Why on Earth should anyone take you seriously? You act as if I'm the only one who needs to present evidence.

I'm sorry that your understanding of rape statistics is minimal, but I guess it's my own fault for arguing with random people on the internet.
 
I can't educate you against your will. I'm just referencing the opinion of just about any criminologist you could find out there. Seriously, no one believes Sweden has the second-highest incidence of rapes in the world, as indicated by another comparison.
If criminologists want to compare different countries, they use different methods, such as anonymous surveys that are the same in all examined countries. Then you get completely different numbers. But you can't trust those numbers either, because people have different opinion of what it means to be raped and if rape is considered extremely shameful people will not admit being raped even in anonymous surveys (some islamic countries have extremely low statistics for rape, although no one believes these stats are accurate).

That first link takes you to the same link I used in the cite. It says that the attitudes to reporting rape in Sweden cannot be used to account for those figures.

Higher numer of reported rapes and very low conviction. Maybe they should be more strict on rapists rather than guys just looking for a quickie with a prossie eh?

Wait I get it. I cannot trust numbers when it relates to Sweden but I can when it relates to NZ. Do I have that about right?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom