Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

I think when you look at NZ and the UK (England and Wales)you have to have some nerve to claim similar. Now if you had said Belgium I might have let you have that one.
Yes they are similar. Do you believe that rape is almost unheard of in Armenia or Egypt? Seriously, I have no idea if rape is more or less common in those countries compared to Sweden, and I doubt many criminologists would want to give any definitive answer to that question. And the difference in that table are two orders of magnitude (100 times!). That should tell you something about the uncertainty in these numbers.

We can divide the countries in some rough groups and Sweden, New Zealand and the UK would fall in the group with very high numbers. Since these are all countries where it would seem women would be less stigmatized for reporting a rape, it seems reasonable to assume that this is a better explanation than assuming that there are many more rapes in these countries than for example in the Arab world.

How do you explain Sweden being double if NZ laws make it similar between those two nations.
Because 'similar' here means 'more similar to each other than between each country and the Arab world or Eastern Europe etc'. A factor of almost two is just not a big difference in this context where we know that the numbers are not directly comparable.

And the UK has similar laws? What is your belief?
I don't have much of a belief regarding UK rape laws, I have heard some claims in relation to the Julian Assange extradition trial to the effect that UK law would not classify some behaviour as rape which would be classified as such in Sweden, but I don't know if that is true and especially I do not know how common those specific cases are. I would think UK rape laws would be more similar to Sweden and the UK than Armenia or even Poland. But again, you seem to just be throwing random questions at me rather than trying to make some coherent argument.
 
Are you denying you snipped part of a quote to answer it?
Obviously I snip parts of quotes, so do you. I haven't snipped anything that contained any identifiable argument. I can't really say I've even seen any argument. You've snipped every post I've made where I've asked you to state your case.

So please do that. What is your theory regarding New Zealand prostitutes? Are they not at a much higher risk than the general population? Are they at a higher risk, but that's somehow justified?

Before you answer this, and then I mean really state your position, I'm not going to answer any other post you make.
 
Yes they are similar. Do you believe that rape is almost unheard of in Armenia or Egypt? Seriously, I have no idea if rape is more or less common in those countries compared to Sweden, and I doubt many criminologists would want to give any definitive answer to that question. And the difference in that table are two orders of magnitude (100 times!). That should tell you something about the uncertainty in these numbers.

Utter dishonesty. Not similar. Different by how mant counts per capita? Disgraceful spin.

We can divide the countries in some rough groups and Sweden, New Zealand and the UK would fall in the group with very high numbers. Since these are all countries where it would seem women would be less stigmatized for reporting a rape, it seems reasonable to assume that this is a better explanation than assuming that there are many more rapes in these countries than for example in the Arab world.

No, we do not divide anything we look at your claim. It was wrong.

Because 'similar' here means 'more similar to each other than between each country and the Arab world or Eastern Europe etc'. A factor of almost two is just not a big difference in this context where we know that the numbers are not directly comparable.

More spin and nonsense.

I don't have much of a belief regarding UK rape laws, I have heard some claims in relation to the Julian Assange extradition trial to the effect that UK law would not classify some behaviour as rape which would be classified as such in Sweden, but I don't know if that is true and especially I do not know how common those specific cases are. I would think UK rape laws would be more similar to Sweden and the UK than Armenia or even Poland. But again, you seem to just be throwing random questions at me rather than trying to make some coherent argument.

Very similar on the incapacitated and sleeping thing. Funnily enough, no huge spike in reports after that.
 
Obviously I snip parts of quotes, so do you. I haven't snipped anything that contained any identifiable argument. I can't really say I've even seen any argument. You've snipped every post I've made where I've asked you to state your case.

You changed the parameters of my case study. That was dishonest because you knew your argument fell at that hurdle.

Please show where I snipped you posts. If you cannot then apologise. If you find them I will apologise as it was unintentional.

So please do that. What is your theory regarding New Zealand prostitutes? Are they not at a much higher risk than the general population? Are they at a higher risk, but that's somehow justified?

My theory was as regardsto your use of the figures. Not of the figures themselves. I do not know how many times I have to lay this out for you.

Before you answer this, and then I mean really state your position, I'm not going to answer any other post you make.

I believe that your arguments are deeply illogical. I believe that either prostitution is illegal or it is not. I really have no preference but I feel that most prostitutes would be safer in a legal setting as I described. And I believe that Sweden should get its house in order regarding rapes before looking at silly laws like the one they have.
 
And before you redfine snipping

Heres is my original post

FdF said:
Put it this way, I am walking back to my hotel at the end of the night and a young lady walks up to me and begs me to pay her money to sleep with her. She even keeps reducing the price she would be willing to take. She even offers extras. She then pulls her friend over and says they will do twos up. Who's coercing who?*

And here is what you snipped it to to "answer"

FdF said:
Put it this way, I am walking back to my hotel at the end of the night and a young lady walks up to me and begs me to pay her money to sleep with her.

You know what that does to the argument dont you? You know what it makes you look like dont you?

Now show me where I have done this in every post like you claimed. If you cannot then retract.
 
...and yet you rank a prostitute in the same boat as a former mercenary killer, a mafia boss and a major drug dealer. Its good that you finally put your cards on the table so we can see what you really think about prostitutes.
Right, so when I say that prostitutes are not like mercenary killers, mafia bosses and major drug dealers, you get to re-interpret that to mean that I really mean the opposite.

I'll adapt your debating style for a while, it seems really easy!
I haven't insulted you once.
It's good that you finally put your cards on the table and admit that you have insulted me many times!

I would appreciate it if you would stop making stuff up about me.
It's good that you finally put your cards on the table and admit that you have made stuff up about me!

I'm here to debate.
It's good that you finally put your cards on the table and admit that you are not here to debate!

I have read your posts perfectly fine thank you very much.
It's good that you finally put your cards on the table and admit that you have not read my posts!

[banquetbear mode off]

If you think that it should be illegal to offer money for sex, how can you not advocate for the repeal of the NZ laws?
My motivation is to protect people from prostitution. The NZ law achieves some of that, therefore it is obviously better than the situation before the law. In Sweden we have a different history. Prostitution (selling sex) was decriminalized already in 1969. Of course I would not want NZ to go back to a situation where a 17 year old selling sex would be facing jail time.

No they were not. They were made up. You invented them. You plucked them out of thin air. Please provide some evidence for your assertion that "Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career" without resorting to inventing statistics, or concede that you have no basis to make this assertion.
Sigh. Making a (trivial) mathematical calculation is not 'making stuff up'. If you didn't go to school, here's how it works. If the incidence of rape is 3% in 12 months, then the chance of not getting raped in 12 months is 97% or 0.97. If you want to find out what your chances are of getting raped in 24 months, you can multiply the number for the first year with that of the second year, like this: 0.97*0.97 = 0.94. Thus, the chance of not getting raped in 2 years is 94%. Keep doing this and you get my numbers. I'm sorry if you still don't get it but then it's really meaningless to discuss.

What evidence can you supply of an upward trend in NZ?
I have not claimed any upward trend.

How long do prostitutes stay in the industry in NZ?
That's irrelevant. My claim was not that everyone gets raped or assaulted within five minutes, but that they will probably be unless they get out of the industry really fast.

Since you claimed it was just like any other job, I provided stats for staying up to 45 years which would be the normal duration of 'any other job'. Then of course, prostitution defenders love to cite anecdotal evidence that prostitutes love their job so much that they keep selling sex even in their 70's, so maybe I should have made the tables longer.

With all of the flaws in your "analysis", the biggest ones are the assumption of a static population and the assumption of an upward trend.
There are no such assumptions. The Prostitution Law Review's numbers that I extrapolated show that if you stay in prostitution for X years, then the risk for being raped or assaulted at least once is so and so. Where you get the 'upward trend' from I do not know, but I would guess you simply don't understand the first thing about probabilities.
 
My theory was as regardsto your use of the figures. Not of the figures themselves. I do not know how many times I have to lay this out for you.
You've snipped every post I've made where I've asked you to state your case.

So please do that. What is your theory regarding New Zealand prostitutes? Are they not at a much higher risk than the general population? Are they at a higher risk, but that's somehow justified?

Before you answer this, and then I mean really state your position, I'm not going to answer any other post you make.
 
<snip>

Sigh. Making a (trivial) mathematical calculation is not 'making stuff up'. If you didn't go to school, here's how it works. If the incidence of rape is 3% in 12 months, then the chance of not getting raped in 12 months is 97% or 0.97. If you want to find out what your chances are of getting raped in 24 months, you can multiply the number for the first year with that of the second year, like this: 0.97*0.97 = 0.94. Thus, the chance of not getting raped in 2 years is 94%. Keep doing this and you get my numbers. I'm sorry if you still don't get it but then it's really meaningless to discuss.

<snip>

:boggled:

You don't think that putting all prostitutes in a homogenous group might make your calculations meaningless? E.g., a street prostitute probably has a much higher probability of being repeatedly violently assaulted than a prostitute working in a owner-operated brothel, wouldn't you say?
 
Right, so when I say that prostitutes are not like mercenary killers, mafia bosses and major drug dealers, you get to re-interpret that to mean that I really mean the opposite.

...you claimed that you would consider marrying an ex-prostitute. You would not consider marrying a prostitute, correct? They are in the same category as mercenary's and drug dealers?
My motivation is to protect people from prostitution.
Why do you think that people need protection from prostitution?

Here is a list of the 20 most dangerous jobs:

http://www.thedailybeast.com/galleries/2011/04/12/deadliest-jobs.html

Do you think it should be legal to fish, but not to buy fish? It should be legal to fly planes but not to pay to fly in one?

Prostitution does not rank in the top twenty most dangerous jobs. Why are you more concerned about prostitution than the roofing industry?

What is so evil about prostitution that you think that people need protection from it? Surely if you have a problem with rape, you should be protecting people from rapists? If you have a problem with assault you should protect them from assaulters?

Prostitution is about the exchange of money for sex or companionship. Why do we need protection from it?

The NZ law achieves some of that, therefore it is obviously better than the situation before the law. In Sweden we have a different history. Prostitution (selling sex) was decriminalized already in 1969. Of course I would not want NZ to go back to a situation where a 17 year old selling sex would be facing jail time.
But do you believe a man offering money for sex should face jail time?

Sigh. Making a (trivial) mathematical calculation is not 'making stuff up'. If you didn't go to school, here's how it works. If the incidence of rape is 3% in 12 months, then the chance of not getting raped in 12 months is 97% or 0.97. If you want to find out what your chances are of getting raped in 24 months, you can multiply the number for the first year with that of the second year, like this: 0.97*0.97 = 0.94. Thus, the chance of not getting raped in 2 years is 94%. Keep doing this and you get my numbers. I'm sorry if you still don't get it but then it's really meaningless to discuss.
I'm not arguing your ability to use your calculator. You make the following claim:

"practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career."

I have asked you to back up this claim. I expected you to cite some studies, some survey's. I'm not asking your probabilities here.


I have not claimed any upward trend.
What if as a result of the change in legislation the rate of rape went downwards? If in five years time only 1% claim rape? And in ten years time less than .5%?

Please show me any peer review study in the world that uses the same maths as you do. Just one.
That's irrelevant. My claim was not that everyone gets raped or assaulted within five minutes, but that they will probably be unless they get out of the industry really fast.
Bolding mine. That was not your claim. This is your claim: "Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'."

Since you claimed it was just like any other job, I provided stats for staying up to 45 years which would be the normal duration of 'any other job'.
According to one source, the average amount of time that a person stays in a job is 3-5 years. Where on earth do you get 45 years from?
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_average_length_of_time_someone_stays_at_one_job_in_the_US

Then of course, prostitution defenders love to cite anecdotal evidence that prostitutes love their job so much that they keep selling sex even in their 70's, so maybe I should have made the tables longer.

Strawman.
There are no such assumptions. The Prostitution Law Review's numbers that I extrapolated show that if you stay in prostitution for X years, then the risk for being raped or assaulted at least once is so and so. Where you get the 'upward trend' from I do not know, but I would guess you simply don't understand the first thing about probabilities.

I understand probability just fine. You don't seem to understand evidence.

Please provide some evidence that practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'. Please do that by not making up numbers or playing with probabilities. And please use statistics derived from New Zealand, since you used the NZ figures when you made your initial claim.

You didn't say:

"There is a strong probability that everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times during their career."

You stated:

"Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'"

There has to either be some real world evidence of this, or you have to concede that you are just guessing. You have made a positive assertion that, if true, should be easily verifiable. I've given you the contact details for the NZPC. You seem to be very good at google. You've been online several times over the last couple of days. You can either verify your statement or concede that you can't.
 
I4. Fewer people in prostitution means fewer people getting harmed.

The wolf disguises himself as the benevolent shepherd. Of course the wolf has to say this. What you need to do though is observe their actions instead of the magical thinking they peddle and the phony benevolent mask. What is he actually for? It is all about enjoying persecution and punishment. But you need to have the cover of society's blessing to act out your fantasies of hurting other people.

The best example of sadistic people posing under social cover are these guys that come out saying they want to cut the scrotum off pedophiles themselves. That's just a person who wants to cut scrotums off people, and is looking for the group he can target that has no protection. He's actually an extreme kind of bully that accuses anyone opposed to his sadism as being a pedophile themselves. They couldn't care less about children. The irony is that the children are just objects to attain their sadistic ends - which is exactly the behavior of the child rapists they villify.


But they must not be free to do what they want with other peoples' bodies. They must also not be free to any type of coercion or persuation to make other people put themselves in harm's way.

*yawn* who is the champion of coercion? Why, it is his highness himself. He's going to fabricate stupid definitions of "coercion" to project onto his target persecution group by saying things like they are "coerced" by money or something. But this is the guy pointing a gun at people's heads, putting them behind bars, ruining their careers, their marriages, causing them shame, etc. - that's what this guy is all about.

The business about not being against "selling", but being against "buying" - I about spit my drink all over the computer with that one. How anyone can say that with a straight face is, well - interesting. It shows the kind of pathology involved.

banquetbear is asking the right questions about why this person is not championing the illegality of dozens of occupations more dangerous than legal, regulated prostitution. Well duh, society has not had two thousand years of pedophile priests saying roofers are "dirty" or fishing is immoral. You have to target a group that is weak and vulnerable. This guy is a predator. A bully. Bullies can't pick on loggers. They pick on people society has shamed for them already. They're cowards.

Under the sheep's clothing is the desire to punish, to control, to inflict harm upon others. But you can't say that. So you disguise youself, and put a lot of effort into that disguise.

Some of you are asking why he can conscience the thousands of prostitutes murdered because they are forced into dark alleys by anti-prostitution laws. Why is he using obvious logical fallacies? All you have to do is understand the real motivation - the desire to hurt others - and everything is explained perfectly. Ignoring the suffering and dying? That is actually his primary character trait, not an anomaly.

There is a lot of very good literature on this, and maybe the best is to look into the pathology of lynching blacks in America. I had no idea how many decades this went on for after the civil war, and how many thousands of innocent blacks were tortured and murdered with the full complicity of the newspapers and law enforcement. They were like carnivals.

Just like this guy, they draped themselves in all this do-gooder filth while burning innocent people alive. The old cliche' about lynching a black for raping a white is not what was going on at all. It was for talking out of place or some other imaginary "crime".

Normal people who should have helped the innocent joined in on the carnival atmosphere because society was saying it is fine to take out your sadistic fantasies on blacks. All you have to do is make something illegal and people will come out of the woodwork to join in on the fun persecuting people in violation of the law.

Because of your warm and generous compassion for the people you are harming, of course...
 
Last edited:
Merko I'm sorry but I can't take your argument seriously. There is too much bias in the argument.
 
You've snipped every post I've made where I've asked you to state your case.

You have no idea what snipped means. I showed you in my earlier post. Now I have to believe that you are just being dishonest.

So please do that. What is your theory regarding New Zealand prostitutes? Are they not at a much higher risk than the general population? Are they at a higher risk, but that's somehow justified?

They probably are but so are many people in the general population who do dangerous jobs. I fail to see how making it illegal to pay for those services makes it any safer. And your use of the numbers was flawed.

What is the capita rate of violence against women in general in NZ and is it higher than other countries?

Before you answer this, and then I mean really state your position, I'm not going to answer any other post you make.

Suit yourself, you have been snipping and cutting away at my posts anyway.
 
True, but the same can be said about, say, pedophilia. That some social prejudices are wrong, or unfair, doesn't mean all are.

I absolutely agree. It makes the 'what would your mother think' argument utterly pointless as evidence either way, so it can be safely discounted.
 
How I know what? Do you have some kind of counter-argument? Just repeating that you don't agree with me doesn't make for a very interesting discussion.

That "they would only do it when that was the only way to get the money.". I'm sorry, but people are different, and different people have different preferences.

I think this shows how incredibly shallow your understanding of economics is. This is what you wrote previously:

I then informed you that in Spain, the demand for milk is much lower, but the price is still somewhat higher. And you're probably educated enough to realize that this has absolutely nothing to do with any difficulties of keeping milk cows in Spain.

It is simply much more complicated than you make it out to be. High demand does not equal high prices. There are so many other factors.

As I said, it could be because of an even lower supply of milk. The low supply is not necessarily connected to how hard it is to keep milk cows in Spain. It may be that there are significantly higher profits in other areas (like keeping pigs), making the opportunity costs keeping milk cows not worth it. I simply don't know enough about Spain to pass a judgement on why the price is higher on their milk market than ours. You got a story to tell? It seems that you deny that prices on a market are set by supply and demand, I hope I'm mistaken about that.

You still have not answered the question. From 1969 to 1999 it was legal in Sweden both to buy and to sell sex. Nowadays it is still legal to sell but not to buy. You seem to argue that not only should we lift the ban on buying sex, but it should also be considered socially acceptable.

It would be nice if the Swedish attitude was less puritan. But I'm not for politicians "sending signals", at least not in such matters.

Now, if that happened, what do you think would happen?

Do you agree that demand would rise massively?

I don't know. It would probably rise. Define "massively".

Do you believe that a significant percentage of men would be interested in buying sex from women, it was considered socially acceptable?

I don't know.

Do you believe that a significant percentage of women would be interested in selling sex?

Probably not.

How do you think these percentages would compare, eg how many men do you think would want to buy sex vs women selling sex?

I think the demand would be high compared to the supply. Which - as I have told you - would lead to rising prices, and the market would find an equilibrium, probably at a rather high price.

(and yes, I'm simplifying this to female prostitution only, which is the most common case and therefore important to discuss, get over it)

From what I remember, it is actually more common with males selling to males.

Opposition was (and is) strong from conservatives and right-wing liberals. The Left, Green and Social democrats are all in favour.

And this challenges my point how?

Anyone. I'll let you choose anyone you like, although it has to be someone who actually studies prostitution empirically. A philosopher or economist who has only done theoretical work does not qualify.

I'm not aware of any such study being seriously performed. Ideologically driven "research" doesn't count.

As I said, I'm not saying that you do, but you should concede that much of the opposition to prostitution is based on metaphysics ("it's inherently degrading") and ickiness. Our war on prostitution is about as empirically based as our war on drugs. And almost as dogmatic.

Stop sending nonsense links, this has absolutely nothing to do with prostitution and just shows your prejudice.

I don't think I'm the prejudiced here.

I don't think argument by referencing the sensationalist press is very convincing. And it is anyway rather irrelevant to the question you were (not) answering because this article does not really give anyone's overall view on prostitution but is rather about one particular sex worker's view on her own situation.

That's the view of one person in the industry, and her experiences and perceptions. You have so far not presented anything like that.

And of course some of the things she 'thinks' are perfect nonsense: she does not believe there is a higher percentage of drug addicts among sex workers than in other 'jobs', she does not believe sex buyers tend to prefer younger women.

She says so based on what she percieves and observes. You simply say that it is in a certain way because it just is. Or rather, because the radical feminists say so, and they can't be wrong.:rolleyes:

The interview also leaves me wondering. It states that she is single and that she does not have another job, but she has not been working [eg selling sex] so much in the last year. Well it's great if she says she's happy and loves what she does, but of course everyone says that regardless of whether it is true or not.

So if someone says he/she is happy with his/her job, you won't believe it?

When there are such obvious question marks, I'm not really that convinced by the story. Why hasn't she been selling sex so much?

Maybe because she doesn't feel like it?

How does she survive then?

Maybe it pays a lot? Maybe she had quite a bit of money since before?

And since she shows such an obviously warped understanding of how the sex industry works in general, can we trust that she has a reality-based understanding even of her own situation?

Maybe you are the one with the warped understanding? Ever considered that possibility?

Maybe it's just the tabloid press asking the wrong questions and warping the answers.

Why wouldn't they twist it in the other direction? Surely a story of the horrors of prostitution from a prostitute would sell a lot, don't you think? Aftonbladet is at least as moralistic as the politicians.

Maybe she's actually a very sensible person. But I'm sorry, that article is extremely unconvincing.

So disagreements with radical feminist dogmas makes one suspected for insanity in your view?

Some people didn't think Russian roulette was really that dangerous.

That you think prostitution is like Russian roulette...:jaw-dropp
 
Okay, new tack.

Person A wants to buy a service from person B

Person B wants to sell this service.

No-one other than persons A and B are effected by this transaction.


What business of it is anyone else's.



Perhaps the job itself is a dangerous one (it's very difficult to tell when it's shrouded in illegality and covertness), but what if it is? People take dangerous jobs all the time, mostly because they pay better than non-dangerous jobs. Provided there's no duplicity on the part of employer, employee or punter, then what's the problem?

If someone has a special talent, they often can make money for it - society approves of that one. If a lady's special talent is oral sex, why can't she make money from that?
 
Here's another story from a sex worker from finland. The story is in finnish, here's googles translation

http://translate.google.com/transla...uomessa+seksia+myyva+milla+antaa+asiakkaalle+

- she gets customers from the internet
- her requirements are that the customer is well behaved, clean and sober
- she writes a receipt for the customer and pays taxes, and never has had a problem getting the customer's signature in the receipt
- her customers are generally polite and well behaving, she hasn't have to be afraid a single time yet
- she says demand is high, even though the "supply" is also high (she estimates "hundreds" in a city with a population around 200k).
- she started working in the field because of the poor job situation. She likes that she can decide when to work and when to keep days off.

The horror, we must ban this taxpayer from doing her job immediately!

I think sex work in general has gotten a bad rap because it has been criminalized and so has been forced to be underground, with all the problems that bring in to the picture. Everybody has in their head an image of whores standing in the streets cruising for customers (of course you can find bad people that way). The truth can be quite different as we can see here, if moralists don't spoil it by creating stupid laws.
 
Here's another story from a sex worker from finland. The story is in finnish, here's googles translation

http://translate.google.com/transla...uomessa+seksia+myyva+milla+antaa+asiakkaalle+

- she gets customers from the internet
- her requirements are that the customer is well behaved, clean and sober
- she writes a receipt for the customer and pays taxes, and never has had a problem getting the customer's signature in the receipt
- her customers are generally polite and well behaving, she hasn't have to be afraid a single time yet
- she says demand is high, even though the "supply" is also high (she estimates "hundreds" in a city with a population around 200k).
- she started working in the field because of the poor job situation. She likes that she can decide when to work and when to keep days off.

The horror, we must ban this taxpayer from doing her job immediately!

I think sex work in general has gotten a bad rap because it has been criminalized and so has been forced to be underground, with all the problems that bring in to the picture. Everybody has in their head an image of whores standing in the streets cruising for customers (of course you can find bad people that way). The truth can be quite different as we can see here, if moralists don't spoil it by creating stupid laws.

And here is my anecdotal account of sex work in Finland:
http://www.hs.fi/english/article/Sex+trade+in+Finland+more+international+than+before/1135251304198

Kauppinen is pleased that two men were given prison sentences of four years last week for raping a prostitute.
“This is a clear message that violence against sex workers is taken seriously. Hopefully people will no longer think that rape somehow belongs to prostitution.

Police are very critical of the present law which makes it illegal to buy sex from the victim of human trafficking.
“The police are unable to enforce the law, and an ordinary customer cannot determine, who are being pimped and who are not. Either a complete prohibition, or complete legalisation would be better”, says Seppo Sillanpää of the Helsinki Police.

This article is in keeping with other trends seen through this thread - legalization has made sex work safer but there are still problems. According to a police officer decriminalizing procurement would be a step towards reducing these problems.

That doesn't mean that you can eliminate all of the risk associated with sex work. Only that it can be identified, addressed and reduced. Even in countries which have decriminalized both buy and selling, the idealized picture of happy hookers who only encounters respectful clients is as false as the idea that all sex-workers are miserable or in danger.

Ironically, the best place to be a prostitute seems to be in the USA. Specifically Nevada where both sex-work and procurement are legal. Legal prostitution is such a novelty that it commands high prices, is completely protected, and the sex-workers have gained a bit of celebrity.

Perhaps the goal should be to reduce the number of sex-workers. If there are fewer, they are more in demand, can charge more money, and be more particular about clients.

The best way to reduce the number of prostitutes is to reduce the need for survival prostitution (Entered into by necessity not choice.) Unfortunately, that involves all the many, many reasons that I'm a liberal.
 
Ironically, the best place to be a prostitute seems to be in the USA. Specifically Nevada where both sex-work and procurement are legal. Legal prostitution is such a novelty that it commands high prices, is completely protected, and the sex-workers have gained a bit of celebrity.

...I personally do not like the Nevada model. The power is in the hands of the brothel owners: woman stay on the ranches for weeks and live on site, and because they are independent contractors don't get the benefits of other employees.

For me, the issue is not only about safety, but also about dignity. If someone chooses to offer their body in exchange for money, it should be on their terms. If they want to work for a big glitzy brothel like the Chicken Ranch then they should be allowed to. If they wish to work out of a private apartment for themselves, then they should be allowed to.

The wiki on Nevada prostitution mentions the Las Vegas Yellow Pages lists 140 pages of "entertainers." If you choose not to live for weeks in a brothel there doesn't seem to be any other alternative except to break the law. Hardly seems ideal to me.
 
And here is my anecdotal account of sex work in
The best way to reduce the number of prostitutes is to reduce the need for survival prostitution (Entered into by necessity not choice.) Unfortunately, that involves all the many, many reasons that I'm a liberal.

On the supply side yes this logic works, but if we will continue with that logic then we must also address the demand side. Men's need for sex and masculinity and women's need for company and to fill voids. Prostitution can be seriously cut down if our society stop demonizing sex and started to encourage single people to have more sex with each other. This I am convinced is one of the few ways to cut down on prostitution from the demand side.

More people need to have sex with each other and feel comfortable without feeling like a "slut" or a "faggot". The issue in my opinion is of self image. I am convinced this is truly one of the few ways to get it down. But I do like your supply side idea.
 
...I personally do not like the Nevada model. The power is in the hands of the brothel owners: woman stay on the ranches for weeks and live on site, and because they are independent contractors don't get the benefits of other employees.

For me, the issue is not only about safety, but also about dignity. If someone chooses to offer their body in exchange for money, it should be on their terms. If they want to work for a big glitzy brothel like the Chicken Ranch then they should be allowed to. If they wish to work out of a private apartment for themselves, then they should be allowed to.

The wiki on Nevada prostitution mentions the Las Vegas Yellow Pages lists 140 pages of "entertainers." If you choose not to live for weeks in a brothel there doesn't seem to be any other alternative except to break the law. Hardly seems ideal to me.

Yes, the percentage of payment that goes to the brothel owner is disturbing, as is the lock down. In terms of safety, however, the Ranch has a terrific record and women do make enough money to retire gracefully. (theoretically.) The ranch is also checked over frequently by the authorities. Women from out of the country would not be allowed to stay, so import sex-trafficking is nearly impossible. Local sex-trafficking is also greatly reduced. Once inside the ranch and protected by the guards, it would be easy to get away.

The situation in Nevada as a state is less than ideal. All of the illegal sex-workers face the same risks and health problems of illegal prostitutes everywhere. Which maybe why so many of the strip clubs seem to have girls working out of them. (Completely anecdotal based on being approached at too many bachelor parties.)

The most ideal circumstance would be a co-op brothel paid for by the sex-workers, in which a portion of income was set aside for guards, upkeep, shared health insurance and investment opportunities. It would be far easier to change the laws to allow pimp-free brothels to exist than to make sex-work generally accepted.

I'm not sure that's the best idea. Not everyone has a communal spirit and it would be wrong to penalize a sex-worker who chooses to work independently.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom