Right, so when I say that prostitutes are not like mercenary killers, mafia bosses and major drug dealers, you get to re-interpret that to mean that I really mean the opposite.
...you claimed that you would consider marrying an ex-prostitute. You would not consider marrying a prostitute, correct? They are in the same category as mercenary's and drug dealers?
My motivation is to protect people from prostitution.
Why do you think that people need protection from prostitution?
Here is a list of the 20 most dangerous jobs:
http://www.thedailybeast.com/galleries/2011/04/12/deadliest-jobs.html
Do you think it should be legal to fish, but not to buy fish? It should be legal to fly planes but not to pay to fly in one?
Prostitution does not rank in the top twenty most dangerous jobs. Why are you more concerned about prostitution than the roofing industry?
What is so evil about prostitution that you think that people need protection from it? Surely if you have a problem with rape, you should be protecting people from rapists? If you have a problem with assault you should protect them from assaulters?
Prostitution is about the exchange of money for sex or companionship. Why do we need protection from it?
The NZ law achieves some of that, therefore it is obviously better than the situation before the law. In Sweden we have a different history. Prostitution (selling sex) was decriminalized already in 1969. Of course I would not want NZ to go back to a situation where a 17 year old selling sex would be facing jail time.
But do you believe a man offering money for sex should face jail time?
Sigh. Making a (trivial) mathematical calculation is not 'making stuff up'. If you didn't go to school, here's how it works. If the incidence of rape is 3% in 12 months, then the chance of not getting raped in 12 months is 97% or 0.97. If you want to find out what your chances are of getting raped in 24 months, you can multiply the number for the first year with that of the second year, like this: 0.97*0.97 = 0.94. Thus, the chance of not getting raped in 2 years is 94%. Keep doing this and you get my numbers. I'm sorry if you still don't get it but then it's really meaningless to discuss.
I'm not arguing your ability to use your calculator. You make the following claim:
"practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career."
I have asked you to back up this claim. I expected you to cite some studies, some survey's. I'm not asking your probabilities here.
I have not claimed any upward trend.
What if as a result of the change in legislation the rate of rape went downwards? If in five years time only 1% claim rape? And in ten years time less than .5%?
Please show me any peer review study in the world that uses the same maths as you do. Just one.
That's irrelevant. My claim was not that everyone gets raped or assaulted within five minutes, but that they will probably be unless they get out of the industry really fast.
Bolding mine. That was not your claim. This is your claim: "Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'."
Since you claimed it was just like any other job, I provided stats for staying up to 45 years which would be the normal duration of 'any other job'.
According to one source, the average amount of time that a person stays in a job is 3-5 years. Where on earth do you get 45 years from?
http://wiki.answers.com/Q/What_is_the_average_length_of_time_someone_stays_at_one_job_in_the_US
Then of course, prostitution defenders love to cite anecdotal evidence that prostitutes love their job so much that they keep selling sex even in their 70's, so maybe I should have made the tables longer.
Strawman.
There are no such assumptions. The Prostitution Law Review's numbers that I extrapolated show that if you stay in prostitution for X years, then the risk for being raped or assaulted at least once is so and so. Where you get the 'upward trend' from I do not know, but I would guess you simply don't understand the first thing about probabilities.
I understand probability just fine. You don't seem to understand evidence.
Please provide some evidence that practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'. Please do that by not making up numbers or playing with probabilities. And please use statistics derived from New Zealand, since you used the NZ figures when you made your initial claim.
You didn't say:
"There is a strong probability that everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times during their career."
You stated:
"Practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'"
There has to either be some real world evidence of this, or you have to concede that you are just guessing. You have made a positive assertion that, if true, should be easily verifiable. I've given you the contact details for the NZPC. You seem to be very good at google. You've been online several times over the last couple of days. You can either verify your statement or concede that you can't.