Is there any good reason for prostitution being illegal?

On the supply side yes this logic works, but if we will continue with that logic then we must also address the demand side. Men's need for sex and masculinity and women's need for company and to fill voids. Prostitution can be seriously cut down if our society stop demonizing sex and started to encourage single people to have more sex with each other. This I am convinced is one of the few ways to cut down on prostitution from the demand side.

More people need to have sex with each other and feel comfortable without feeling like a "slut" or a "faggot". The issue in my opinion is of self image. I am convinced this is truly one of the few ways to get it down. But I do like your supply side idea.

Demonizing sex is only loosely related to prostitution. Prostitution still exists in sexually liberal countries. I'm not sure how one would convince single people to have more sex in countries where sex is already considered natural and there is little negativity attached to casual sex.

Many people do not have casual sex because they already have high self-esteem. Conversely there are people who are having too much casual sex because their low self-esteem makes them think that is the only way they can get or deserve attention.

Sex also has inherent problems. No birth control method or STD barrier is 100% effective. Turning the world into a big orgy will create more problems than it will solve.
 
Merko I'm sorry but I can't take your argument seriously. There is too much bias in the argument.
I am not taking Merko's argument seriously, and I am not the least bit sorry about it. Calling Merko "biased" is an understatement.
 
Mustang Ranch Report

Okay, new tack.

Person A wants to buy a service from person B

Person B wants to sell this service.

No-one other than persons A and B are effected by this transaction.


What business of it is anyone else's.

The sadist.

He gets joy from the suffering of others. But if he locks people up in his basement he goes to jail for kidnapping and unlawful imprisonment. So it is much more cunning to work through the law to persecute others.

The Mustang Ranch

I have absolutely no shame about going to the Mustang Ranch outside Reno and submit my first-hand report here. It was more than ten years ago, and despite my wife having no issue with it at all if I want to go now, the money is just too hard to part with for what you get. As a novelty, sure. Next time someone else is going to have to pay the tab.

I was at the blackjack tables and found myself up $300.00 almost instantly with all luck and no skill. I thought to myself that I could stick around and lose it to the house, or I could put it to good use. The Mustang Ranch was the only one I had heard of, so I asked a cabbie to take me there. He rang a bell at a gate, and they buzzed us in. Maybe he got a tip or something for bringing me. Why else go inside.

When the door opened, there was a bar in that main greeting room, and all the girls were lined up smiling brightly, putting the shine on. But none of them appealed to me enough to lay down serious cash over, so I was not sure what to do. The bartender must have understood, and told me to just sit around and wait until someone else came along that appealed enough to me.

I don't drink, so I had a diet coke there and sat down talking with a biker dude. A gal came along eventually that motivated Mr. Willy moreso than the rest. She invited me back to her room - it was kind of like a bunch of ATCO units put together. She instructed me on the drill: you make an agreement with the girl in secret, then you pretend to make an agreement for less money, and then she goes to the house with half the phony agreement money.

I had asked the cabbie before I went in how much it cost and he said about $150, again over ten years ago. No idea what it is now. We made a pretend agreement for $100, but the real agreement was $150. So the house got $50 and she got $100.

I guess normally you are done when you're "done", but we were having so much fun together I was in there all afternoon. People kept knocking on the door and getting progressively more stern with her about needing to move on, so finally we exited more than three hours later.

I still had half my winnings, and the afternoon had been so much fun, I stuck around on the advice of my new biker buddy who was engaged in a marathon. I took two more to their rooms as the day drifted into night, and I must confess I went over budget. They had a clever deal with their cash machine where it printed out a receipt with a Truck Stop name on it.

A hundred fifty bucks is three years' worth of industrial-strength fireworks: the mortars with multiple bursts. They need to get these prices down into a much more affordable range before it's an attractive investment for me again.

The main impression I was left with is the dichotomy between all the histrionics over it and the reality. The irony of all the people who oppose prostitution insisting how degrading it is - well, no the only people degrading it are the people opposed to it. All the guys in the club were fans of the girls, and were laying down the cash for them whereas these detractors have nothing but contempt and persecution. The actual interaction was fun for all of us. If you can't have fun having sex then you are some kind of weirdo.

So Merko wants for me to have been jailed and made to suffer. Not for the sex per se. That is just a platform for the persecutor to operate from. He'd be just as happy to persecute blacks or gays or whomever, so long as he can get some blessing from authority.
 
Sex also has inherent problems. No birth control method or STD barrier is 100% effective. Turning the world into a big orgy will create more problems than it will solve.

I disagree, in countries like our own sex is liked and very common but it is demonized. I see the negative impacts it has on society and how damaged women are from being called sluts, whores, or worthless pieces of ****. Our society has a lot of growing to do.
 
Demonizing sex is only loosely related to prostitution. Prostitution still exists in sexually liberal countries. I'm not sure how one would convince single people to have more sex in countries where sex is already considered natural and there is little negativity attached to casual sex.

Many people do not have casual sex because they already have high self-esteem. Conversely there are people who are having too much casual sex because their low self-esteem makes them think that is the only way they can get or deserve attention.

Sex also has inherent problems. No birth control method or STD barrier is 100% effective. Turning the world into a big orgy will create more problems than it will solve.



The bolded bit confuses me. Some people have lots of casual sex because they enjoy it. Some people don't because they don't. What does self esteem have to do with it? Do you have evidence it's a significant factor in a significant percentage of cases?
 
The bolded bit confuses me. Some people have lots of casual sex because they enjoy it. Some people don't because they don't. What does self esteem have to do with it? Do you have evidence it's a significant factor in a significant percentage of cases?

You're right, that was overly-simplified.

Casual sex is not a panacea. Sex is too tied into our gooey slimy lizard brain to be simple - for example, some people who have terrific self-esteem and would not be affected by having casual sex, but choose not to because they prefer to be picky. A different type of person has casual sex because they have low self-esteem issues and getting horny people into bed is the easiest way to get attention. Other people have terrific self-esteem and have casual sex because it is fun. Most people fall somewhere in between.

More importantly, sexually liberated countries have not abolished prostitution. No matter how much casual sex is going on, people will still use the option to visit a sex-worker, even in sexually liberated countries where purchasing sex has been made illegal.

I disagree, in countries like our own sex is liked and very common but it is demonized. I see the negative impacts it has on society and how damaged women are from being called sluts, whores, or worthless pieces of ****. Our society has a lot of growing to do.

I'm going to go with the US for "countries like our own". America has a HUGE problem with sex. We're scared of naked boobies, ffs. Even naked boobies that are currently being used to breastfeed. That's just stupid.

Our national repression has some very nasty side-effects, one of which is the control of women's bodies because women bare the brunt of sexual misadventure in the form of pregnancy. Abortion and birth control are the obvious examples of control. If you must be sexually-active, you will pay the price and (hopefully) being at home with a kid will keep those thighs together for a while. (Not that you'll gain any respect for raising the kid, because targeting single mother's for society's ills is just too easy.)

In order to reduce the social-shame associated with sex-positivity, our society needs to give up on the idea that they can tell women what to do with their own bodies. That includes all varieties of sexual activeness. Women who choose (for themselves) to remain virginal deserve as much respect as those who enjoy casual sex with many different partners.
 
Your counter-arguments show very clearly that you do understand them as arguments, however.

What is shows, clearly, is that I do not accept the unargued assumptions that you are making just because.

Such as? Please elaborate. I have not seen anything that has been discussed in this thread that would be a) comparably dangerous and b) legal to pay someone to do.

Fishing, logging, and roofing for starters. These have already been mentioned, with links to statistics.

Anyway, there was an evaluation which is quoted on Wikipedia. Of course, supporters of legalization are not happy with that report but as far as I know they have not been able to either demonstrate any decisive flaws, or produce any empirical counter-evidence.

Have you read this? It said that street prostitution had been halved, but that indoor prostitution is an expanding market. As for the overall rate, all it said was that prostitution overall had not increased.

Of course, supporters of legalization are not happy with that report but as far as I know they have not been able to either demonstrate any decisive flaws, or produce any empirical counter-evidence.

I'm glad that there is at least a report, which is evidence for something, though not for an overall reduction in prostitution.

This is simply a logical consequence. If prostitution is dangerous and if a ban on buying sex reduces prostitution, then that ban reduces the danger.

At least you say "if." Of course, the Swedish report did not say that it reduced prostitution overall. So that "if" isn't supported.

What we have here is a failure to communicate. I am neither arguing for nor against this or that particular law, and I don't really know for sure if legality or illegality is better.

What I am saying is that there are unsupported "ifs" on the pro-illegality side which prevent any kind of serious rational judgments of the arguments. Telling me that you aren't going to argue that ice is cold really doesn't help.

So I think the comparison with prohibition does not hold.

I believe that you do. You haven't presented an argument.
 
We are assuming that prostitution would be regulated and carried out as a normal profession..but who'll do the regulating? What system will be put in place to protect those who are be forced into prostitution (human trafficking, etc).
The effort and money spent on "regulating" and setting up proper facilities for these men & women, can be better spent on getting them into a different trade/job that they'll not feel ashamed about or put into these risky situations (sexually transmitted diseases, abuse, etc)
 
You don't think that putting all prostitutes in a homogenous group might make your calculations meaningless? E.g., a street prostitute probably has a much higher probability of being repeatedly violently assaulted than a prostitute working in a owner-operated brothel, wouldn't you say?
Sigh. From my original post:
Let us first assume that all prostitutes have an equal risk of being raped. That is of course not the case--so some prostitutes have much worse outcomes.
So, no, it does not make the calculations meaningless. It means those calculations are way too optimistic.
 
...you claimed that you would consider marrying an ex-prostitute. You would not consider marrying a prostitute, correct? They are in the same category as mercenary's and drug dealers?
Your fantasies are really quite absurd. I would not marry a prostitute for the simple reason that a prostitute, by definition, is regularly having sex with many individuals and that is simply not my idea of what it means to be married. I'm not a jealous person but I have some limits.

Prostitution does not rank in the top twenty most dangerous jobs. Why are you more concerned about prostitution than the roofing industry?
Prostitution is way more dangerous than any of those jobs. It is not included because it is not commonly considered a job.

Your source does not give a source for the numbers but fishing is widely regarded as the most dangerous 'regular' job and US stats can be found here. The number given is 128 deaths per 100,000 full-time workers per year, so significantly lower than your 200 but still very high and it should definitely be a major cause for concern.

I found one well-cited US study that looked at 1969 prostitutes and the comparable number was 459 deaths per 100,000 'active' prostitutes per year.

So that's 3,5 times as dangerous as your 'most dangerous' occupation of fisherman, and that's very generous as we are here assuming that all 'active' prostitutes are selling sex full-time which is clearly not true.

Please provide some evidence that practically everyone gets raped, abducted or assaulted, probably several times over during their 'career'. Please do that by not making up numbers or playing with probabilities. And please use statistics derived from New Zealand, since you used the NZ figures when you made your initial claim.
So you want evidence, but any actual evidence is disqualified? Sorry, but the only evidence possible is going to be probabilities, and I've already provided those. No one could ever provide anything else. If you don't want to know, I can't help you. It's also plainly ridiculous how you demand statistics from New Zealand, when you yourself provide unsourced popular media round numbers from the US for your comparison.
 
Who are these mystical "scholars" you refer to?
Anyone. I'll let you choose anyone you like, although it has to be someone who actually studies prostitution empirically. A philosopher or economist who has only done theoretical work does not qualify.
I'm not aware of any such study being seriously performed.
Well, then further discussion is completely meaningless. I'm an empirically minded person. If you just choose to ignore all scholarly research on the subject, then you have nothing to tell me. I am not interested in anecdotes, armchair philosophy or your own private preferences.
 
I said earlier on in the thread that I wasn't really interested in digging up research as it takes too much time and it doesn't lead anywhere if we cannot first agree on the principles involved. Well, now I've brought a lot of statistics anyway and no one really seems to be interested. It's not that I see anyone else digging up their own numbers to counter mine, people are just dismissing the research they don't like with ad-hominem arguments or whatever.

I understand that a lot of people feel very strongly that it should be legal to buy sex. Well, I already knew that and it doesn't seem relevant to me. Unless someone is willing to actually bring some empirical argument, I doubt I'll be interested in continuing this debate.
 
Sigh. From my original post:

So, no, it does not make the calculations meaningless. It means those calculations are way too optimistic.

Incorrect. For example, a few prostitutes being repeatedly assaulted could skew the risk calculations such that they are way too pessimistic. As most studies are performed on street prostitutes and woman who have been trafficked I doubt they include the experiences of current or former escorts/prostitutes such as (type into google) 'lara brooks', or more famously, Dr Brooke Magnanti.
 
Btw, here is a recent example of a case where I think the law against buying sex shows to be very useful. A 50-year old policeman is accused of raping and buying sex from a 16-year old girl. He allegedly paid her with drugs, alcohol and money, and is accused of having raped her while she was on drugs. He is also accused of having bought sex from another young woman and having tried to buy sex from a young man. He found the girl on the internet by posing as a woman.

The reason why they even try to accuse him of buying sex from the 16-year old girl is obvious. It's because they are not quite sure they can prove that he raped her. This is because rape is a much more serious crime so that there is no point in having him convicted for both rape and buying sex. But obviously it's quite hard to prove that a girl was raped, while on drugs, by a man who had paid her to have sex with him.

But proving that he bought sex is much easier especially if the girl cooperates. This may be supported by internet messages and by physical evidence (eg fingerprints on bottles etc). Now, if they can't convict this guy for rape, and he did buy sex from her, I sure hope he's going to be convicted of that. I really would not want him to walk because of not enough evidence. Rape or not rape, if he bribes a 16-year old girl with drugs and money, he's dangerous.
 
I said earlier on in the thread that I wasn't really interested in digging up research as it takes too much time and it doesn't lead anywhere if we cannot first agree on the principles involved. Well, now I've brought a lot of statistics anyway and no one really seems to be interested. It's not that I see anyone else digging up their own numbers to counter mine, people are just dismissing the research they don't like with ad-hominem arguments or whatever.

...oh come on, you haven't posted anything in ten days, and now you are wondering why noone has responded to your cite after posting it for an hour? Give me a break. You've been making unsubstantiated claims throughout this whole thread: you finally use google to try and back up your unsubstantiated assertions and you expect us to be impressed?

Unfortunately I have real life to attend to so it could be days before I can respond to you.

I understand that a lot of people feel very strongly that it should be legal to buy sex. Well, I already knew that and it doesn't seem relevant to me. Unless someone is willing to actually bring some empirical argument, I doubt I'll be interested in continuing this debate.

Just one final thing before I race out the door: this isn't only about the right of people to buy sex and I wish you would stop reframing the debate to suit your limited world view. I have argued from the start that this is about the right for prostitutes to take a part in shaping their own destiny. And part of doing that is to let them participate in the decision making process and to help ensure that the practice is as safe as possible. This isn't about my desire to "make it legal to buy sex." This isn't about me. And it isn't about you.
 
...oh come on, you haven't posted anything in ten days, and now you are wondering why noone has responded to your cite after posting it for an hour?
Nobody posted any empirically based response to the statistics I posted 10 days earlier either. In fact it seems the whole thread just died when I didn't have time for those 10 days.

Just one final thing before I race out the door: this isn't only about the right of people to buy sex and I wish you would stop reframing the debate to suit your limited world view. I have argued from the start that this is about the right for prostitutes to take a part in shaping their own destiny. And part of doing that is to let them participate in the decision making process and to help ensure that the practice is as safe as possible. This isn't about my desire to "make it legal to buy sex." This isn't about me. And it isn't about you.
If by 'this' you mean everything anyone mentioned in the thread, then sure, you have a point. However, we are in total agreement about these other points so the discussion at hand is in fact 'only' about whether or not it should be legal to buy sex.

And let me again emphasize that I do not believe and have not claimed that the 'Swedish solution' is some kind of final, perfect solution to the problem that everyone else should just copy. I support the ban on buying sex, but there is so much more we could and should do and I would even concede that the legalization debate has in some ways been harmful because other issues have not received enough attention. I find the NZ legislation very interesting and I hope that empirical research in the coming years will provide us with better clues on what works and what doesn't. But based on current knowledge.. sorry, I have seen no serious research at all suggesting that prostitution would be 'just another job'. Only wishful thinking, anecdotal evidence, philosophical sophistry, and bald assertion.
 
But proving that he bought sex is much easier especially if the girl cooperates. This may be supported by internet messages and by physical evidence (eg fingerprints on bottles etc). Now, if they can't convict this guy for rape, and he did buy sex from her, I sure hope he's going to be convicted of that. I really would not want him to walk because of not enough evidence. Rape or not rape, if he bribes a 16-year old girl with drugs and money, he's dangerous.

Well, IF he did...perhaps.

So, it's a good law, because it allows us to nail bad guys we otherwise couldn't. What that tells me is that we need better laws. Maybe the "drugs" were marijuana joints. So it's a good argument for keeping marijuana illegal. Or he tried to get to get her drunk. So, it's also a good argument for making alcohol illegal. Completely ridiculous.

This is by far the worst argument yet.
 
Well, IF he did...perhaps.

So, it's a good law, because it allows us to nail bad guys we otherwise couldn't. What that tells me is that we need better laws. Maybe the "drugs" were marijuana joints. So it's a good argument for keeping marijuana illegal. Or he tried to get to get her drunk. So, it's also a good argument for making alcohol illegal. Completely ridiculous.

This is by far the worst argument yet.

It reminds me of the inane logic behind some laws that were enacted in the UK where possession of "extreme pornography" and so on was made illegal. Apparently if they couldn't catch the drug dealer with his stash then at least they could try him for that and other smaller offenses after snooping around his home and computer.

'Justice' done right, i guess.
 
Nobody posted any empirically based response to the statistics I posted 10 days earlier either. In fact it seems the whole thread just died when I didn't have time for those 10 days.


If by 'this' you mean everything anyone mentioned in the thread, then sure, you have a point. However, we are in total agreement about these other points so the discussion at hand is in fact 'only' about whether or not it should be legal to buy sex.

And let me again emphasize that I do not believe and have not claimed that the 'Swedish solution' is some kind of final, perfect solution to the problem that everyone else should just copy. I support the ban on buying sex, but there is so much more we could and should do and I would even concede that the legalization debate has in some ways been harmful because other issues have not received enough attention. I find the NZ legislation very interesting and I hope that empirical research in the coming years will provide us with better clues on what works and what doesn't. But based on current knowledge.. sorry, I have seen no serious research at all suggesting that prostitution would be 'just another job'. Only wishful thinking, anecdotal evidence, philosophical sophistry, and bald assertion.

You seem to start from the position that any given activity should be illegal and that good arguments need to be presented to make it legal.

I believe things should start legal and be made illegal when there is sufficent reason to do so. I believe you have your logic arse about face.

I'm glad you're not in charge.
 
But based on current knowledge.. sorry, I have seen no serious research at all suggesting that prostitution would be 'just another job'. Only wishful thinking, anecdotal evidence, philosophical sophistry, and bald assertion.

Well, in the whole of this thread, you are the one who has been making unsupported assertions. You don't back them up, and the assertions that others make that are backed up you readily dismiss, to again ask them to back it up.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom