Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

its practitioners should be tried for capital murder on a regular basis

100% of all seriously ill patients "treated" by Homeopathy can be expected to die.

So they should be tried for murder (what's 'non-capital' murder?) preemptively, before they have a chance to commit it, as in 'Minority Report'?

Or do you have information about actual, not 'expected' deaths due to homeopathy?
 
So they should be tried for murder (what's 'non-capital' murder?) preemptively, before they have a chance to commit it, as in 'Minority Report'?

Or do you have information about actual, not 'expected' deaths due to homeopathy?

If they treat a patient who expires and who clearly would have been saved by real medical treatment I support hanging. But then I'm a bloodthirsty SOB. Jail terms and lawsuits are probably more realistic. I would not of course punish it in advance, but I would ban the advertisement and practice of Homeopathy with stiff prison sentences.

Homeopathy, because it does literally nothing causes deaths only through diversion from sound medical treatment; Much as do some religions. So 100% of all deaths of those under Homeopathic treatment have to be investigated as manslaughter.

If you were about to die and you go to a Homeopath, you die.

If you were about to die and you go to an Allopath, you might not die.

The difference is murder.
 
Last edited:
Talking about lung function, can I have some help for my friend with emphysema?

Oh, sorry. The thing that works best is a chamomile tea with a tablespoon of bioactive honey and---this is key---a teaspoon of sea salt. You use sea salt because it's loaded with natural minerals. What you do with the tea is inhale the vapors for 5 minutes, then spill it on your computer, so that you stop asking for help from strangers on the Web and go to a doctor instead.

The NIH has studied the effectiveness of emphysema treatments; read about these studies, but only your friend's doctor knows which ones apply to him or her:
http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/prof/lung/nett/lvrsweb.htm#results
http://www.hsc.wvu.edu/sop/wvcdhi/New Drug Monographs/tiotropium.htm
New England Journal of Medicine 2000 Dec 28;343(26):1902-09.
American Thoracic Society (2007, September 20). COPD Report: New Understandings In Diagnosis, Treatment And Prevention.
 
If you were about to die and you go to a Homeopath, you die.

If you were about to die and you go to an Allopath, you might not die.

The difference is murder.

"If you were about to die and you go to an Allopath, you might not die."

And if you did, that would be an unfortunate accident.

This is fascinating knowledge, no doubt a result of the application of healthy 'skepticism.'

But seriously (sorry to bring you back from Woulda-Land), do you have information about actual, not 'expected' deaths due to homeopathy?
 
The NIH has studied the effectiveness of emphysema treatments; read about these studies, but only your friend's doctor knows which ones apply to him or her:
http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/prof/lung/nett/lvrsweb.htm#results
http://www.hsc.wvu.edu/sop/wvcdhi/New Drug Monographs/tiotropium.htm
New England Journal of Medicine 2000 Dec 28;343(26):1902-09.
American Thoracic Society (2007, September 20). COPD Report: New Understandings In Diagnosis, Treatment And Prevention.

Thank you.
 
... But seriously (sorry to bring you back from Woulda-Land), do you have information about actual, not 'expected' deaths due to homeopathy?

100% of all seriously ill Homeopathic patients, who would die without treatment, and who do not abandon it and seek allopathic care, die of whatever it was that was killing them when they arrive at the Homeopath. The actual numbers depend on the number of patients treated who do not abandon care when they realize the the Homeopath is killing them.

Homeopaths are killers. Period.
 
Last edited:

Thank you. As far as I can tell (yes, some of it is restricted), none of these papers provide support for your claim that:

"Only a small portion of iatrogenic deaths are found to be preventable (i.e. preventable in that particular individual)."
 
..."You are assuming that iatrogenic death and disability are something to be avoided, but they are not. I know this seems crazy so I will explain. You need to ask, "how could I have prevented this iatrogenic death and what would the consequences be?" For example, the largest cause, by far, of iatrogenic problems is adverse drug events. And within that category, the use of blood thinners accounts for a large portion. It may be that the only way to prevent a specific death from the use of a blood thinner would be to avoid the use of blood thinners in general. And the consequences of avoiding blood thinners in general would be increased death and disability among those people whose use of the blood thinner prevented death and disability. So it may be that in order to prevent one death from blood thinners, ten people would die who otherwise would not. Most people would find this trade-off unacceptable, so we have to accept that iatrogenic problems cannot and should not be entirely avoided....

A slight derail... Last summer I went to a lecture that specifically addressed that issue. It seems there are genetic clues as to how much warfarin would be suitable:
http://www.gs.washington.edu/wednesdays/speakers/nickerson.html
 
CPR is not an old technique.

Late 50s.

The point was: most of the growth in the "health" "care" field is not in inexpensive things with broad applications that can help people a lot, but in expensive things that help in highly specialized situations.


I read somewhere -- wish I could find that reference -- that every other "health" "care" dollar in the US is spent on the last month of life.
 
Late 50s.

You realizing in calling it very old, and lumping it with treatment many thousands of years old that you are certainly giving an impression of it at least predating antibiotics.
The point was: most of the growth in the "health" "care" field is not in inexpensive things with broad applications that can help people a lot, but in expensive things that help in highly specialized situations.

So we really should bring back say polio as the polio vaccine only protects against polio and is too highly specialized?

I read somewhere -- wish I could find that reference -- that every other "health" "care" dollar in the US is spent on the last month of life.

And how do you determine if it really is that? What say 3 month survival rate for a condition do you need to use a treatment for that condition?
 
Thank you. As far as I can tell (yes, some of it is restricted), none of these papers provide support for your claim that:

"Only a small portion of iatrogenic deaths are found to be preventable (i.e. preventable in that particular individual)."

Yes, they all do.

If there is some part you don't understand, or you want more information in a specific area, just ask. If you don't have online access to medical journals, I'll try to summarize some info for you (keeping in mind I may get lazy about it so the more specific you are, the better :)).

Linda
 
Late 50s.

The point was: most of the growth in the "health" "care" field is not in inexpensive things with broad applications that can help people a lot, but in expensive things that help in highly specialized situations.

I read somewhere -- wish I could find that reference -- that every other "health" "care" dollar in the US is spent on the last month of life.

Mslxl, try to argue for your point rather than other random points.

You weren't saying that "allopathic medicine has grown in expensive directions", nor "allopathic medicine is not cost-effective", nor "allopathic medicine doesn't have inexpensive cures for some things I wish it did". You were arguing that you are better off not going to a doctor.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom