Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

Mslxl, try to argue for your point rather than other random points.

You weren't saying that "allopathic medicine has grown in expensive directions", nor "allopathic medicine is not cost-effective", nor "allopathic medicine doesn't have inexpensive cures for some things I wish it did". You were arguing that you are better off not going to a doctor.

Correct, correct and correct.

But I don't think there is a realistic possibility to convince you that *you* are better off not going to the doctor.

There might be, however, a remote possibility to undermine your faith in medicine in the face of mountains of evidence pointing to serious fundamental problems in its approach. That slim hope -- perhaps an illusion on my part -- hinges on an appeal to the values of skepticism and critical thinking, which I assume you hold, at least nominally. So I concentrate on that.

Small guerrilla actions, if you will, rather than an all-out war. My original statement remains true for me, but I do not intend to mount a complete, logical argument for it in this forum. I can point you to some sources, if you're interested.
 
Here is the deal; We have all advocates of Homeopathy put that on their driver's licenses.

Then when they are severely injured in an accident, or have a heart attack or hepatitis or cancer we allow only Homeopaths to treat them.

Sounds fair to me!

It will nicely decrease the "surplus population." ;)
 
No. We should read what the poster wrote and either answer that or not answer at all.

Look the polio vaccine is about the most specialized treatment you can possibly get. It only does one thing for one disease. It is the hight of being highly specialized as it is of no use to for anything else.
 
Here is the deal; We have all advocates of Homeopathy put that on their driver's licenses.

Then when they are severely injured in an accident, or have a heart attack or hepatitis or cancer we allow only Homeopaths to treat them.

Sounds fair to me!

It will nicely decrease the "surplus population." ;)

I would agree with that.

Except for the last line. You add hate and it makes the cleverness less tasty.
 
Look the polio vaccine is about the most specialized treatment you can possibly get. It only does one thing for one disease. It is the hight of being highly specialized as it is of no use to for anything else.

Look, I was referring to what has happened to the industry in recent years.

US "health" expenditures in 1970: 352 billion
US "health" expenditures in 2003: 5,711 billion (inflation adjusted)

Where did most of that 1,500% increase go? I was talking about that.
 
You realizing in calling it very old, and lumping it with treatment many thousands of years old that you are certainly giving an impression of it at least predating antibiotics.

It's also a bad comparison, because medical professionals routinely question the value of CPR and its mechanism. Research in CPR technique is ongoing and the results of this research translate into changes in technique.

The conditions for which CPR can be applied have changed over the years (we now include choking situations - abdominal thrusts have proven to be too dangerous) and the details of the technique have changed. For example, we no longer stack breaths.

The most recent changes in CPR level C were six months ago. Any professional who is not using the current CPR technique could be charged with negligence.

When was the last time a homeopathic technique was overhauled due to scientific research, and what happens when an homeopath is not up to date on the approved standard? (Is there an approved standard?) Does he lose his job?



Another confusing question: mslxl uses the term 'allopathy' to only include conventional medicine. Most herbal medicine is allopathy, so is mslxl explicitly saying that herbal medicine is much worse than homeopathy?
 
Look, I was referring to what has happened to the industry in recent years.

US "health" expenditures in 1970: 352 billion
US "health" expenditures in 2003: 5,711 billion (inflation adjusted)

Where did most of that 1,500% increase go? I was talking about that.

It seems to have paid for an additional 7 years of life. The purchase price was cheaper for other countries, though.

Linda
 
It seems to have paid for an additional 7 years of life. The purchase price was cheaper for other countries, though.

Linda

Good point, but in truth, we don't know. It could also be nutrition, exercise, water, etc. Also, assuming you are referring to life expectancy at birth, there are serious clouds on the future of life for all of us. I don't know if demographers take into account global trends like pollution of air, water, soil and other resources, deforestation, desertification, violence, effects of global warming, cosmic radiation from holes in the atmosphere, and so on. Maybe you can enlighten me on how life expectancy figures are arrived at.
 
Another confusing question: mslxl uses the term 'allopathy' to only include conventional medicine. Most herbal medicine is allopathy, so is mslxl explicitly saying that herbal medicine is much worse than homeopathy?

No, I meant "modern, scientific medicine." Thank you for pointing that out.
 
It seems to have paid for an additional 7 years of life. The purchase price was cheaper for other countries, though.

The other thing is the increase in what are called 'quality years'. This is different than just life extension - it's a measure of how many years a person lives without having to reduce expectations due to health.

Just an example is my great grandmother, who went deaf and blind in her 30s, but lived to her '90s. Sounds like she had diabetes, which is manageable today with medications, which would be part of that overall increase in medical costs. Even though there was no increase to her lifespan, there is clearly a value attached to what could have been an improved quality of life for her remaining 55 years.

This is what the west has been experiencing for about a century: a slow improvement in average lifespan, coupled with a huge improvement in quality of life.
 
(although the official CPR technique keeps evolving every couple of years, so it's clearly not an exact science).

Actually, it's the fact that it changes that proves it's a science.

Homeopathy doesn't change, which strongly suggests it's a religion.
 
Estimated yearly deaths from homeopathy? You tell me.

Nobody actually knows. My assumption is that homeopaths don't care enough about whether their patients die from their treatments to actually study it. They treat ignorance as a virtue.

No news is not good news: it's evidence of wilful ignorance.

Medicine, on the other hand, wants to know if what they do actually works, has no assumption of perfection, and performs research to guide improvement.
 
Good point, but in truth, we don't know. It could also be nutrition, exercise, water, etc. Also, assuming you are referring to life expectancy at birth, there are serious clouds on the future of life for all of us. I don't know if demographers take into account global trends like pollution of air, water, soil and other resources, deforestation, desertification, violence, effects of global warming, cosmic radiation from holes in the atmosphere, and so on. Maybe you can enlighten me on how life expectancy figures are arrived at.

OK, ok, I think I've seen enough. Mslxl, you don't know anything about modern medicine except that it's "modern". You don't like modern things because there is a lot wrong with the world today. Therefore, you don't like modern medicine. Since you don't like it on principle, you don't care what the lifespan, cause-of-death, etc., data say. So there's no point arguing with you.

For example, there is no point whatsover to your reading this:
http://www.rootsweb.com/~ohjackso/1850mort.htm

There but for the grace of Pasteur, Lister, and Fleming go we all.
 
Medicine, on the other hand, wants to know if what they do actually works, has no assumption of perfection, and performs research to guide improvement.

OK, I'll bite. What is your assessment of the reliability of medical research in view of the economic determinants affecting it?
 
OK, ok, I think I've seen enough. Mslxl, you don't know anything about modern medicine except that it's "modern". You don't like modern things because there is a lot wrong with the world today. Therefore, you don't like modern medicine. Since you don't like it on principle, you don't care what the lifespan, cause-of-death, etc., data say. So there's no point arguing with you.

For example, there is no point whatsover to your reading this:
http://www.rootsweb.com/~ohjackso/1850mort.htm

There but for the grace of Pasteur, Lister, and Fleming go we all.

I never denied that people live longer or, in some ways, better. The question is, what caused it? And there, the answer is less clear-cut.

Medicine says 'we did' but there are strong dissenting arguments -- see Thomas McKeown and others. A lot of things have changed in the past couple of centuries, not just the rise of medicine.
 
I never denied that people live longer or, in some ways, better. The question is, what caused it? And there, the answer is less clear-cut.

Medicine says 'we did' but there are strong dissenting arguments -- see Thomas McKeown and others. A lot of things have changed in the past couple of centuries, not just the rise of medicine.

Just out of curiosity, what else do you propose might be responsible?
 
I never denied that people live longer or, in some ways, better. The question is, what caused it? And there, the answer is less clear-cut.

Hey, "what caused it" is a great question. We can answer this question with the scientific method. To scientifically test a medicine, you take a group of sick people and divide them in half; half of them get the medicine and half of them get something else. If one the medicated half gets better significantly more than the others we say "the medicine caused them to get better". If the medicated half gets worse, we say "this treatment has bad side effects". If the medicated half is the same as the other half we say "the medicine did not help".

What do you say if something passes such a test? Do you want a medicine to do something other than curing the disease it claims to cure?

Or do you doubt that modern medicines have passed such tests?
 
Last edited:
Maybe you can enlighten me on how life expectancy figures are arrived at.

I think if you're interested in learning something, at least some of the responsibility should be yours.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom