Is Homeopathy truly debunked?

I think if you're interested in learning something, at least some of the responsibility should be yours.

Linda

That's what I'm doing -- asking someone who seems knowledgeable. It's a well-established approach. Not the only one, but from where I'm sitting it appears to make sense.
 
I never denied that people live longer or, in some ways, better. The question is, what caused it? And there, the answer is less clear-cut.

Medicine says 'we did' but there are strong dissenting arguments -- see Thomas McKeown and others. A lot of things have changed in the past couple of centuries, not just the rise of medicine.

I don't think medicine says "we did it all" (I was being a tiny bit silly with my earlier comment). I've been complaining for years that we are definitely at the point of diminishing returns if we try to buy additional health through the use of medical technology. But medicine and medical research isn't just about the newest drug or newest device. It just looks that way because it makes for sexier news. It's also about discovering other determinants of health, like education or socio-economic status, ways in which we harm ourselves and others, small changes in lifestyle that can make a large difference, how we are influenced by fairness and self-determination, etc., etc.

But most importantly, there's no evidence that homeopathy contributed even a speck to that change.

Linda
 
Hey, "what caused it" is a great question. We can answer this question with the scientific method. To scientifically test a medicine, you take a group of sick people and divide them in half; half of them get the medicine and half of them get something else. If one the medicated half gets better significantly more than the others we say "the medicine caused them to get better". If the medicated half gets worse, we say "this treatment has bad side effects". If the medicated half is the same as the other half we say "the medicine did not help".

What do you say if something passes such a test? Do you want a medicine to do something other than curing the disease it claims to cure?

Or do you doubt that modern medicines have passed such tests?

The question was: what are the main causes of the recent (200 years) improvements in longevity and quality of life?

Not: do medicines work?

They are related, but they are not the same.

I like that second question too, but I won't discuss it with you tonight.
 
The enhancement of public health is part and parcel of allopathy as it informs civil engineering.

The germ theory of disease, which classical Homeopathy rejects utterly, lead to Pasteurization, Chlorination, and modern waste disposal.

The ancient art of Surgery was TRANSFORMED by access to allopathic medicine. Can you imagine a limb being re-attached without Dr. Lister's antiseptic environment and without the many miracle drugs for anesthesia? And without antibiotics to suppress postoperative infection? This progressed to the point where Surgeons now are allopaths FIRST.

Add to that the ability to conduct surgery in the chest cavity without killing the patient though blood oxygenating machinery, hypothermia, and etc.

Add to that the pacemaker, the defibrillator, kidney dialysis, etc.

All a Homeopathetic can offer you is a few drops of alcohol (if you are lucky) or stale tapwater.
 
Last edited:
Not intended as a metaphor! I literally believe that Homepathic "Doctors" routinely murder their patients. And should be treated as murderers.

Another misunderstanding. I was talking about YOUR wishes to 'squash' them, cull excess population, etc.

Also, what you describe is usually called homicide by negligence. The word murder has a narrower definition, both in law and in everyday English. In my opinion, the hyperbole doesn't help your argument *because* part of your argument makes sense. When you turn it into a tirade, it becomes harder to listen to you and examine the evidence.

But that's just me.
 
It stops being negligence when 90% of the people on the planet have been telling you for decades that its bunkum. Then it become premeditated and intentional. It must be a JOY for these Homeopathetics! They are the only Serial Killers who can constantly get away with it.
 
Well.

Mslxl seems to have successfully diverted us away from asking him to defend his original comment about allopathic medicine.

My only request....can we stop using "allopathic"? It's a made up term that is meaningless. Plain old "medicine" should be sufficient, since anything else we've been referring to in this thread isn't medicine.

Linda
 
OK, I'll bite. What is your assessment of the reliability of medical research in view of the economic determinants affecting it?

Vague question.

Vague answer: overall good. I work in medical research, and there's no conflict of interest in my field (immune system research). My employer is the ministry of health, and they also pay for healthcare. They're motivated to reduce illness because they pay when people get sick both financially and politically. Their bias is to get the straightest route to understanding these illnesses, and curing them.

Almost all of the important medical research investment is funded by governments or non-profits. Private funding is really just directed toward what I'd call "product development", and of course profitability is a factor in what gets developed.

In terms of private research, the quality of research itself is not very affected, although money influences the quantity of publications on certain topics. For example, there's a guy at UBC who has published papers claiming that there is a "powerful" placebo effect for twenty years now, because he has a sugar daddy writing cheques. It's just the same thing over and over: case studies. The weakness of the first batch would have dried up conventional research funding, but there's always a few true believers out there willing to pony up to evangelize their new age belief system, and he's tapped into this community. Private interests probably don't influence the outcome of his studies, but they do provide a market and therefore economic incentive for ongoing publication that scientific merit does not justify.

What is also affected is what industry does with the research, which is to say: will they replace a good drug with a better one in the middle of the patent cycle? But this doesn't stop the College from establishing guidelines to prescribe the better drug off-label.

In any case, there are objective, independent, reviewers of medical research who attack the whole body of knowledge, such as Cochrane, and the regional medical authorities tend to consider their conclusions very highly when they make policy.

So, my impression is that the research situation is overall good.



It's nevertheless unrelated to the question of whether homeopathy works or not, though.

This is why I regard homeopathy a religion: they feel there is no obligation to actually demonstrate that they're telling the truth. It's enough to cast doubt on others, and suggest that reality is just a choice. It's *exactly* the same doubtcasting tactic that the Discovery Institute uses when they argue that intelligent design or creation science could be sciences. They just have to redefine science, of course.
 
So, my impression is that the research situation is overall good.

That's really interesting to me because we hear so much about corruption in that field.

I think I figured it out: UBC, Cochrane... you = Canadian, yes? Me = not very smart. Patience required.
 
Yes, tell us, what are the main causes?

Contrary to a number of 'skeptics' I don't claim to know the answer beyond any doubt. How do they do it?

I can tell you this. About a generation ago, the work of Thomas McKeown created a lot of stir. He was a demographer who studied a lot of 19th and early 20th century statistics and said those improvements were out of sync with the medical advances that were usually assumed to be their cause, e.g. life expectancy went up and infant mortality went down *before* large numbers of people got to see doctors. Other researchers followed in his fray, then there was a backlash from other scientists who put his results in question.

I am totally unqualified to read and evaluate the work myself. However it looks like the 'antis' come from a mainstream, 'public health policy' background while McKeown was just a geek. This is where what 'medicine says' becomes relevant, Linda. To me, there is an official story that needs defending, so I tend to be, yes, skeptical and side with the underdog.

Again, I haven't read the original work, but I remember one of the findings that were most unexpected to McKeown himself was the price of glass! Somewhere in the mid-19th century, poor people in Western Europe started being able to afford glass windows in their dwellings. As a result, they did not have to spend most of their winters in darkness, ergo vitamin D, ergo bone toughness, etc. They became healthier. He got that from studying records. He was a demographer. Again, I have no idea how such research works.

There were other factors, food, sanitation, etc.

I hope that helps. You can look him up for more info.
 
Well.

Mslxl seems to have successfully diverted us away from asking him to defend his original comment about allopathic medicine.

Linda

Well, that's a legitimate criticism.

Here is a copy of my first intervention on this thread:

"Homeopathy doesn't do anything except by virtue of a placebo effect. However it is vastly superior to allopathic medicine, simply because it refrains from its many harmful practices."

Now: I do not intend to 'defend' this. I wrote it as a provocation, so I plead guilty to trolling. I was trolling, in a sense.

If I wanted to start a discussion of it, it would need a new thread, but anyway, I won't.

I will say the following which is my excuse for not starting the discussion and perhaps also can be understood as the first step of a 'defense' of what I wrote.

I use a different epistemology of health. I know what I know about it from direct perception, not from scientific consensus. So arguing with people who know what they know about health in a completely different way from the way I know what I know about health would be just two ships passing in the night -- frustration on both sides and not much accomplished.
 
Contrary to a number of 'skeptics' I don't claim to know the answer beyond any doubt. How do they do it?

I can tell you this. About a generation ago, the work of Thomas McKeown created a lot of stir. He was a demographer who studied a lot of 19th and early 20th century statistics and said those improvements were out of sync with the medical advances that were usually assumed to be their cause, e.g. life expectancy went up and infant mortality went down *before* large numbers of people got to see doctors. Other researchers followed in his fray, then there was a backlash from other scientists who put his results in question.

I am totally unqualified to read and evaluate the work myself. However it looks like the 'antis' come from a mainstream, 'public health policy' background while McKeown was just a geek. This is where what 'medicine says' becomes relevant, Linda. To me, there is an official story that needs defending, so I tend to be, yes, skeptical and side with the underdog.

Again, I haven't read the original work, but I remember one of the findings that were most unexpected to McKeown himself was the price of glass! Somewhere in the mid-19th century, poor people in Western Europe started being able to afford glass windows in their dwellings. As a result, they did not have to spend most of their winters in darkness, ergo vitamin D, ergo bone toughness, etc. They became healthier. He got that from studying records. He was a demographer. Again, I have no idea how such research works.

There were other factors, food, sanitation, etc.

I hope that helps. You can look him up for more info.

You may be surprised to discover that a 60-year-old argument is now old news.

Linda
 
I use a different epistemology of health. I know what I know about it from direct perception, not from scientific consensus. So arguing with people who know what they know about health in a completely different way from the way I know what I know about health would be just two ships passing in the night -- frustration on both sides and not much accomplished.

I generally follow the WHO definition of health:

"a state of complete physical, mental and social well-being and not merely the absence of disease or infirmity".

What do you use?

This is cool. Self-rated health (i.e. the answer to the question, "for your age would you say, in general, your health is excellent, good, fair, poor or bad?") is a much better predictor of mortality than objective measures of health by a physician.

Linda
 
That's really interesting to me because we hear so much about corruption in that field.

I hear a lot of things about a lot of things. The key is to know the difference between reality and altmedders' sales patter.

Like I said: if you don't have the goods, change the subject and knock the competitor. FUD. It's Marketing 101.
 
Contrary to a number of 'skeptics' I don't claim to know the answer beyond any doubt. How do they do it?

I can tell you this.

...snip...

I hope that helps. You can look him up for more info.

Well, my question to you would be "do you think any of the improvements we have seen can in any way be attributed to unproven advances, or are they all necessarily attributed to proven advances?"

Or in other words, why could common people afford windows? Was it because window-magicians claimed to alchemize glass from truffles, or was it because additional knowledge, from reproducible events, led to cheaper glass?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom