OK, I'll bite. What is your assessment of the reliability of medical research in view of the economic determinants affecting it?
Vague question.
Vague answer: overall good. I work in medical research, and there's no conflict of interest in my field (immune system research). My employer is the ministry of health, and they also pay for healthcare. They're motivated to reduce illness because they pay when people get sick both financially and politically. Their bias is to get the straightest route to understanding these illnesses, and curing them.
Almost all of the important medical research investment is funded by governments or non-profits. Private funding is really just directed toward what I'd call "product development", and of course profitability is a factor in what gets developed.
In terms of private research, the quality of research itself is not very affected, although money influences the
quantity of publications on certain topics. For example, there's a guy at UBC who has published papers claiming that there is a "powerful" placebo effect for twenty years now, because he has a sugar daddy writing cheques. It's just the same thing over and over: case studies. The weakness of the first batch would have dried up conventional research funding, but there's always a few true believers out there willing to pony up to evangelize their new age belief system, and he's tapped into this community. Private interests probably don't influence the outcome of his studies, but they do provide a market and therefore economic incentive for ongoing publication that scientific merit does not justify.
What is also affected is what industry does with the research, which is to say: will they replace a good drug with a better one in the middle of the patent cycle? But this doesn't stop the College from establishing guidelines to prescribe the better drug off-label.
In any case, there are objective, independent, reviewers of medical research who attack the whole body of knowledge, such as Cochrane, and the regional medical authorities tend to consider their conclusions very highly when they make policy.
So, my impression is that the research situation is overall good.
It's nevertheless unrelated to the question of whether homeopathy works or not, though.
This is why I regard homeopathy a religion: they feel there is no obligation to actually demonstrate that they're telling the truth. It's enough to cast doubt on others, and suggest that reality is just a choice. It's *exactly* the same doubtcasting tactic that the Discovery Institute uses when they argue that intelligent design or creation science could be sciences. They just have to redefine science, of course.